When governments and bureaucracies fail to listen to the average of the people
In 1906, the scientist Francis Galton visited a livestock fair in Plymouth and accidentally stumbled on something that explains why central planning fails.
Around 800 visitors had paid sixpence each to guess the weight of a slaughtered ox. Galton collected the tickets and analysed them, expecting the crowd to do badly. Individual guesses were all over the place, but their average was 1,197 pounds - the ox weighed 1,198. While supposed experts - butchers and farmers - guessed poorly on their won, taken together, ordinary fairgoers had come within a pound of the truth.
Nearly a century later, in 2004, the journalist James Surowiecki popularised this effect in The Wisdom of Crowds. His argument was that in large, diverse and independent groups, individual errors cancel each other out, and the collective estimate moves towards the truth.
This helps explain why government bureaucracies so rarely match the efficiency of free markets. Friedrich Hayek called this the “knowledge problem.” The information an economy runs on is scattered across millions of people, each knowing their own circumstances, preferences and opportunities. No planner can gather it all. Markets don’t need to: through prices, they condense that dispersed knowledge into a single number that anyone can act on. The result is what Hayek called “spontaneous order”, complex coordination that no one designed.
Markets condense dispersed information into a market price. When planners abolish markets and try to design an economy and fix prices, they replace the judgement of millions with the guesses of a small group working from incomplete information. As Galton’s ox shows, no committee of experts, however clever, knows as much as all of us together. Central planning fails because bureaucrats fail to guess what the market could have told them.
5
969
dave trott retweeted
"The difference between art and design is that art doesn't have to have a function, design has to have a function" - Paula Scher
dave trott retweeted
After a long break, virtual @davetrott strikes again. How do you like it Dave? I love it.
dave trott retweeted
.@davetrott wrote about this event in Campaign. Article entitled "What influences the influencers?" As Dave writes, "Payless got fantastic advertising for next to nothing." More here: campaignme.com/a-view-from-d…
dave trott retweeted
“Don't Mess with Texas” sounds like something a Texan would actually say. “Please Don't Mess with Texas” sounds like something a delusional government committee would like Texans to say.
An anti-littering campaign became a defining piece of Texan identity all because someone figured out that appealing to a Texan's pride works better than telling them to fall in line. @rorysutherland
dave trott retweeted
A story of reframing on steroids, told by @davetrott:
buff.ly/bozPuQr
dave trott retweeted
Replying to @davetrott
A thought born from your excellent blog post. Thanks Dave!
dave trott retweeted
DON’T REGRET WHAT YOU DIDN’T DO
davetrott.co.uk/2026/11/dont…
@davetrott
dave trott retweeted
Great advice: "To cheer himself up, every day he went to the same pastry shop and ate a delicious chocolate pastry. Eventually it became clear to him: I don’t like margarine, I love chocolate: I’m in the wrong game. Doing what you love is usually the best idea..."
And nice story:
dave trott retweeted
Funny ads, often dismissed by our industry as silly, populist or lowbrow, might actually be the most commercially effective. Making people laugh (not just smile), can make them willing to pay more.
via James Hurman
'The Funny Thing About Profit' report: lnkd.in/emx32Zfq
DON'T REGRET WHAT YOU DIDN'T DO davetrott.co.uk/2026/11/dont…
When purity is weakness and messiness is strength -
facebook.com/reel/1147367467…
1
2
1,715
























