Jill Rutter (@jillongovt) header
Jill Rutter (@jillongovt) profile picture

Jill Rutter, Brexit at UK in a Changing Europe. Any other stuff at Institute for Government. Full Fact fan. Very ex-civil servant. My views not theirs.

Joined March 2010
Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)Photo by Jill Rutter (@jillongovt)
My quick take on 2nd 🇪🇺🇬🇧 summit over. No surprises on substance (deals on food, ETS linking, youth mobility). Negotiations ongoing on tuition fees & whether UK wd qualify under made in Europe provisions. 1/3
1
2
12
4,090
Jill Rutter retweeted
Pie. Sky.
Exclusive: Ministers are considering a new flexible EU membership that would let Britain pick which parts of the bloc to join, limit free movement to people with job offers and pay according to its level of involvement. The proposal for “lower-tier” alignment, seen by The i Paper, is set out in a new policy paper shared with senior Government figures, which is understood to be gaining traction in Westminster. It offers a potential long-term way for Britain to rebuild ties with Brussels without rejoining the EU on its current terms. The blueprint comes after senior EU figures warned the Prime Minister that Britain cannot continue striking individual dealsto move closer to Brussels without eventually making bigger choices about its relationship with the bloc, including whether to rejoin the single market or customs union, as reported by The i Paper on Wednesday. The difficult negotiations ahead of today’s UK-EU summit illustrate how challenging even a limited Brexit reset remain as Andy Burnham weighs up the options for Britain’s future relationship with Europe. The new document - written by the Good Growth Foundation think-tank – proposes a two-stage approach. This would start with an enhanced economic and security partnership in the near term and moving towards a new, more flexible form of membership in the longer term. The first phase would involve a new UK-EU customs union, mutual recognition of product standards and professional qualifications, and a defence and migration pact covering defence procurement and an asylum returns agreement. The second phase would be more ambitious and would involve the EU creating a more flexible “outer-tier” membership, allowing countries on its periphery, including Britain, to opt into different areas of integration, with corresponding rights and obligations. It says this should happen if the EU reforms its treaties, and argues that treaty change is both necessary and likely within the next 10 years.The report argues that eurosceptic leaders who could emerge from elections in France and Germany may push the bloc towards a looser model of integration – “exactly the kind that would suit Britain”. Story 👇 inews.co.uk/news/politics/pl…
11
15
3
164
11,319
Jill Rutter retweeted
🚨 OUT NOW 🚨 🇪🇺What does Andy Burnham want from his EU reset? Labour MP and Keir Starmer's lead negotiator on the reset with Brussels @NickTorfaen, Institute for Government's @jillongovt, and Theresa May's former adviser @RaoulRuparel join @Alain_Tolhurst to discuss how our relationship with the EU may evolve 🎧pod.fo/e/77cd0d
3
4
1,466
Jill Rutter retweeted
No legal texts of UK-EU agreements have been published. In the decade of covering Brexit/UK-EU, this is the first time. Highly unusual and infuriating.
5
8
1
46
5,283
Jill Rutter retweeted
With the UK-EU summit coming up, @UKandEU have put out their final report on what to expect and what the implications of the meeting might be. It's going to be tough, the UK will struggle to achieve all its wants, and the road ahead is hugely uncertain. 1/2
8
14
1
39
7,882
Jill Rutter retweeted
I get the charge of green hypocrisy, but the British media of all political persuasions really must stop hounding PMs about their travel. Britain is a consequential power. Turkey is an important NATO partner. The PM held productive bilats beyond climate. Let's be serious.
NEW Prime Minister Andy Burnham flew 1,800 miles from London to Antalya yesterday, and then 2,140 miles from Antalya to Dublin today - for the COP31 climate change conference. This morning he delivered a 764 word speech at Cop 31, on his 3,940 mile round trip. It works out at 5 miles per word. He was scheduled to be in Antalya for 14 hours, arriving last night at about 9.30pm local, staying the night and were due to fly about 10.50am local. Asked why Mr Burnham did not deliver the speech by zoom, his spokesman told us he was "determined to lead from the front to tackle the climate crisis". Number 10 says Mr Burnham went to Turkey because it was "right to meet world leaders". His spokesman will not tell us which world leaders he met. The PM told his audience today: "The climate crisis is not a distant threat. It is upon us all now, devastating lives and livelihoods everywhere." More at @GBNEWS.
4
8
1
113
4,086
Replying to @jillongovt
@jillongovt with @deirdreheenan @SJAMcBride Anne Watt @pivotalpolicy and @DavidSterling7 former head of NICS on the politics and upcoming election in Northern Ireland
STARTING SOON 🚨 Northern Ireland with six months to go to Assembly elections 📺 Join us at 13:00 with an expert panel from Northern Ireland to explore the most recent developments and how they affect the prospects for the next elections instituteforgovernment.org.u…
1
744
“I regard most of the problems in this country as being laid at the door of Jeremy Hunt.” Ex-BoE deputy Howard Davies says Hunt’s “unfundable” NI cuts trapped Labour, and have boxed in every budget since. Fair or unfair? #PoliticsUnleashed
56
147
29
446
98,177
Jill Rutter retweeted
Now pretending petrol duty will rise in July. Was supposed to rise in September. Then January. Who really believes it'll ever happen?
6
13
2
110
15,348
Jill Rutter retweeted
The answer: keep it simple. Don’t add special allowances and exceptions. Resist the urge to be clever. No more complexification.
25
37
2
754
28,883
Jill Rutter retweeted
Basing eligibility for energy support on council tax band does mean that whether or not Andy Burnham sends you £100 depends on what your house was worth in 1991. Not ideal.
Choice of £100 payments into bank accounts based on council tax band, rather than via Warm Home Discount for benefit recipients, is interesting. It shows a desire for (1) more households to benefit and (2) more households to notice. Burnham understands salience.
2
4
19
2,180
Jill Rutter retweeted
It is so disappointing that four years after the last energy crisis led to a badly-targeted, expensive bill for taxpayers, we are basically in the same position. Health data would be a much better way of targeting help to those who most need it (and who are expensive to treat).
NEWS ENERGY PAYMENT: £100 payment to all households in Council Tax bands A to D for England (and funding for same in other nations). That's 20m homes. Translation: This is the support for the huge rise due in January price cap. Its expected to be 27% up. Which equates to roughly £100 from Jan to March alone.
4
2
12
1,311
Just look at the policy measures table in the budget --- it's huge. Runs over many pages. Lots and lots of really small things
fees like lots of fiddling, short-term things, new complications - a 'young entrepreneurs allowance', 'starter ISA', different business rates exemption threshold for retail, leisure & hospitality ... etc . I don't hear a clear, coherent vision or a simplification of tax system
2
13
53
6,028
Jill Rutter retweeted
Great news! Labour is cutting the tax on carers who earn more than the carer’s allowance earning limit. The new rate is 100%. That’s a big tax cut, and to be welcomed (If you think I’m on drugs, please read Paul’s tweet:)
Burnham announces a 100% tax rate on carers who work and earn over the limit allowed. Better than the current rule but worse than the 55% tax when people on UC work and higher than the highest marginal rate on high earners (except loss of child care help at £100,000).
30
31
1
530
102,945
Jill Rutter retweeted
It is striking that moving away from the triple lock appears to have done absolutely nothing to dent Labour's rise in the polls.
51
26
9
430
29,011
Jill Rutter retweeted
The way plunging us into six months of darkness, which is bad for mental and physical health, and women’s safety, is somehow presented as a win.
The clocks go back by one hour on 25 October at 2am, which means you’ll gain an hour ⏰ What will you do with the extra time? Let us know below 👇
265
68
35
1,502
233,795
Jill Rutter retweeted
PM announced at PMQs that the Government will consult on ending standing charges on gas bills … Chancellor and energy secretary will review. Unexpected. Would be a significant shift.
126
89
19
772
74,359
Jill Rutter retweeted
Horrible decision from Welsh ministers not to go ahead with a much-needed update of property valuations for council tax in 2028, having previously voted for the legislation. Inexcusable. 1/3 bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6ly…
11
17
43
13,121
Good news for Olly Robbins and the govt. But the JR would have been really interesting.
FDA statement on settlement agreement for Sir Oliver Robbins.
8
5
2
28
13,028