IRD retweeted
My @theird weekly email: Post MAGA Christian Nationalism, Anglican Growth, Methodist Exit, Catholics & Antisemitism, etc mailchi.mp/indefenseofchrist…
IRD retweeted
“The key issue is that this megachurch no longer finds it useful to be attached to its denomination,” said Mark Tooley, president of the Institute on Religion and Democracy and an advocate of United Methodist renewal. “It finds its denomination to be seemingly irrelevant to its ministries, so that’s revealing of overall trends in American Christianity, which is increasingly post-denominational.”
Religious liberty and the waning influence of Christian denominations in America are at the heart of a Dallas megachurch’s dispute with the United Methodist Church (UMC), Methodist theologians say.
baptistpress.com/resource-li…
IRD retweeted
“Adam Hamilton is very much a via media person and obviously identifies as a centrist who wants to keep people altogether,” Mark Tooley, president of the Institute on Religion and Democracy, a leading traditionalist group, told Sojourners. “And I think that’s part of what made him a very effective and successful politician. But I don’t think it works in the church very well.” @liamsadams
sojo.net/articles/news/headi…
IRD retweeted
Hypothesis: There are podcasters with more influence over Christians & within wider society than entire Protestant denominations, Mainline & otherwise.
IRD retweeted
To be a Christian is to prioritize a universal multiracial body that is eternal. To be a nationalist is theoretically support for the nation, which includes many tribes bound to common purpose. How “Christian Nationalism” prioritizes white people is a conundrum.
I defy anybody to listen to my talk at the NXR conference and continue to slander us as swaggering men driven by arrogance and malice in our defense of our White kinsmen and heritage.
This charge—repeated again and again—is vacuous, slanderous, and calculated to deceive those who will not listen to our actual words.
I simply believe that I have a moral duty before God to respond to the great gifts he has given my people with both gratitude and the taking up of the mantle of responsibility that always attends good gifts from God.
To do anything less would be to shirk the duties God has given along with these gifts. Anything less would make me the worst kind of ingrate.
IRD retweeted
Their event offers a window into post MAGA Christian Nationalism without answering the question: has Christian Nationalism peaked or is it morphing into a new dimension? @TheIRD
juicyecumenism.com/2026/11/1…
IRD retweeted
Join @theird Thurs Nov 19 to hear Pam Nadell of American University on her new book "Antisemitism, An American Tradition." Reception 6pm, talk 6:30pm, Pls RSVP. theird.org/events/antisemiti…
IRD retweeted
Planting a Wesleyan/Methodist church in a city likely requires “borrowing” young ambitious clergy from other traditions such as Pentecostal or nondenominational. But they’ll have to be willing to baptize babies! 👶
IRD retweeted
Check out the latest from me:
Antisemitism in Canada: Remembering Is Not Enough juicyecumenism.com/2026/11/1… via @theird
IRD retweeted
71 percent of police-reported religion-motivated hate crimes in Canada in 2025 were against Jews.
Antisemitism is an evil that is without borders. Our Jewish friends are suffering around the world, and Canada, a place known for its kindness, is no different, writes Keira Shaw. juicyecumenism.com/2026/11/1…
Martin Luther King dreamed that in America people “would be judged not by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.” But people are now judged by the identity group to which they belong, whether considered “oppressors” or “oppressed.”juicyecumenism.com/2026/11/1…
1
196
IRD retweeted
Met today with doughty Methodist friends who drove many hours to pray in DC for a church plant. But there are almost no Wesleyan urban church planters in any denomination. Evangelical Methodists will go to Africa & South America but aren’t interested in USA cities. Grateful for the persevering prayers of this group that meets monthly. 😑🤔
IRD retweeted
Answer: almost everybody but Wesleyans.
Replying to @markdtooley
I remember reading 15 years ago about megacities and wondering: is anyone planting in those megacities?
IRD retweeted
The large & wealthy church is exiting the denomination because it wants to control its own property & deems the denomination irrelevant to its work.
After 110 years, Highland Park United Methodist Church in Dallas, Texas, withdrew from the denomination and removed “United” from their name because of issues including the ordination of LGBTQ+ clergy and the performance of same-sex marriages. They chose to stand up against the unbiblical progressive movement that has hijacked the United Methodist denomination. And I was glad to read in the @NYTimes that former President George W. Bush and his wife Laura participated in the vote and supported their longtime church’s stand. Of the 4,775 votes cast at the church last month, over 90 percent voted to do what thousands of other congregations have done and leave the United Methodist Church denomination. Thank you Highland Park Methodist Church and President Bush for doing the right thing and standing with the Word of God. nytimes.com/2026/11/06/us/ge…
Thursday: Pamela Nadell of @AmericanU speaks on her new book Antisemitism, An American Tradition, which recounts story of animus towards Jews across our nation’s history. The story is important to recall as antisemitism reemerges in many quarters. RSVP: theird.org/events/antisemiti…
Antisemitism is an evil that is without borders. Our Jewish friends are suffering around the world, and Canada, a place known for its kindness, is no different, writes Keira Shaw. juicyecumenism.com/2026/11/1…
IRD retweeted
1/2 @MarkDTooley is president of @TheIRD and editor of its foreign policy and national security journal, @ProvMagazine. He is also a @FreeConTalk signatory.
In a post-election piece for @TheDispatch, Tooley discussed the possibilities of “post-MAGA Christian activism and identity.”
“While evangelical voters were just as supportive of MAGA and the GOP in this year’s midterm elections,” he wrote, “their falling from 23 to 17 percent of the electorate implies an ebbing enthusiasm. Whether evangelical support for Trump stays level or declines over the next two years, MAGA Christianity will have to adapt to a post-Trump era. Will its indifference to personal faith and morals in favor of a strong, dramatic personality continue and attach to a new leader?”
“Arguably, evangelicals have never been demographically stronger or more influential politically,” Tooley continued. “Yet, by aligning enthusiastically with MAGA, they subordinated their identity to a wider, mostly secular movement that relied on their votes and allowed them Oval Office meetings but that did not substantively advance evangelical concerns.”
He advised evangelicals to have more confidence in their theological identity and divine providence, to embrace Christian realism rather than utopianism, to recover their “stewardship of liberty, both political and economic,” and to “steadfastly reject Christian nationalism and postliberal authoritarianisms that often include unsavory stances toward non-whites and Jews.”
“Christian nationalists fantasize about an American confessional state that punishes blasphemy and apostasy while legally restricting non-Christians, consigning Jews and others to their social ghettoes. These fantasies are not just implausible; they are dangerous and corrupting even to contemplate. They are also off-putting to nearly all wider society, fulfilling the worst stereotypes about evangelicals.”
“MAGA Christianity will end,” he concluded. “Historians, and God, will judge whether it had constructive accomplishments that compensate for the dangers to which it contributed. Evangelicals who supported it will decide what replaces it. If they are wise, they will side with historical patience, liberty for all, limited expectations of politics, providential hope, and Christian realism. How they choose will help decide the fate of the nation.” #FreeCon


















