Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics) header
Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics) profile picture

Writer @TotalAnalysis |📊 Tactical insights | “Football is the most important of the least important things.”—Sacchi | đź’Ľ [email protected] | John 3:16

Joined August 2024
Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)Photo by Aaron's Analytics (@Aaronsanalytics)
Bryan Mbeumo to Man United is as close to a sure-thing signing as you’ll get. PL-proven, physical, smart — and fits exactly what Amorim wants from his #10s. Let’s break down: 🔺Some of his goals from last season 🔺Why he’s a natural fit in Amorim’s system 🔴THREAD🔴
34
390
25
8,806
663,118
The biggest issue with this is that Iraola will know exactly how to press this situation, with clear patterns and pressing triggers in place for Sunday. That will get Anfield bouncing and put this United team under serious psychological pressure, something we know they’re not dealing with particularly well at the moment.
🚨OFFICAL: Mauricio Pochettino FIRST training session WITH Manchester United. #MUFC | 🎬@CCOveriew
10
2
4
107
23,863
Mentality 🔝 🇮🇪
🚨🇮🇪 Troy Parrott: "Professional football is one of the HARDEST professions to make it in. So many people want to be a professional footballer and if I did not have a stronger mentality, I could have failed." "Now I am at the level that I always knew I could get to and there are more levels to come. I am really excited for it." 👏 (@rte via @BBCSport)
18
1,372
Aaron's Analytics retweeted
It's been an absolute disgrace how Michael Carrick's sacking has been handled. The fact that it was leaked he was getting sacked, with seemingly everyone knowing while he was still taking training at the club, is shocking. But it goes hand in hand with how INEOS have treated staff, season ticket holders, fans and the football club as a whole since they arrived. Pure incompetence. Don't even get me started on the Glazers, but the way INEOS have operated deserves serious scrutiny. And look, I'm not suggesting for a minute that Carrick didn't deserve to go. He did. His game model was flawed and far too reliant on individual players performing. When those players weren't at it, 18th in the table is what you got. Ultimately, there was only going to be one outcome. But where is the accountability for the people above him? Jason Wilcox, Omar Berrada and INEOS have made bad decision after bad decision. Where are the consequences for them? Why does the manager continually pay the price while the people responsible for the wider direction of the football club seem to escape accountability? And that brings me to Mauricio Pochettino. One thing I will say is that I'm finding it incredibly difficult to get excited about Manchester United at the moment. Even from an analysis perspective, I feel numb towards the club. It just feels like we're going through the exact same cycle again. Another manager. Another supposedly fresh direction. Another set of questions about whether the squad actually suits what the manager wants to do. When I look at Pochettino, the first thing I think about is his background and the influence of Marcelo Bielsa. Think Bielsa and you think intensity, fitness, aggressive pressing, repeatable high-intensity running and players who can cover huge distances. Now look at this Manchester United squad. Do I see a squad full of players capable of producing those repeatable high-intensity sprints? No. And that's where I have concerns about the fit. Carrick wanted to build a team that could control matches through possession. He favoured technical players who were comfortable operating in smaller spaces, combining and controlling the rhythm of games. The problem was that when the technical quality dropped, or the players simply weren't performing, United couldn't sustain that control. The game became stretched, the distances between players increased and suddenly you had players being asked to defend huge spaces. That's the exact scenario where some of these profiles struggle massively (Mainoo, Tielemans, Santos). You could even see it against Leeds, when Carrick had to move Tielemans into the number 10 position because of the amount of ground he was being asked to cover in midfield. Now you're bringing in a manager whose football is built around enormous physical demands, aggressive pressing and intensity. So my question is simple. Does this squad actually have the physical profiles to execute what Pochettino wants consistently? I have no doubt Pochettino will get a tune out of this group. For me, Manchester United should be competing for the top five with the quality they have. Yes, the squad lacks depth in certain areas, but there is some serious talent there. Far too much talent to be sitting in the relegation places. And there are aspects of Pochettino's football that I really like. I loved watching his Tottenham side. The pressing intensity, the aggression, the energy and the way they could overwhelm opponents physically. That's the type of football I can absolutely see Old Trafford getting behind. Winning the ball high, sustaining pressure, forcing opponents into mistakes and getting the crowd involved. Old Trafford should be an intimidating place to play football, and an aggressive pressing game can play a huge part in creating that atmosphere. I was underwhelmed by his spell at Chelsea, but I can still see the appeal of appointing him. However, liking a manager's football and believing he's the right fit for the current squad are two completely different things. And that's my concern. Will Pochettino have the players capable of meeting his physical demands? Will United recruit the player profiles to make his game model work? Will he receive adequate backing in the transfer market? Because if INEOS's track record tells us anything, I have serious doubts. And that's why I struggle to get excited. It's not that I don't rate Pochettino. I do. It's not that I don't believe this squad has quality. It absolutely does. It's that I have very little confidence in the people making the decisions above the manager. We can talk about pressing structures, game models, player profiles and tactical fit all day long, but if the people responsible for building the squad keep making the wrong decisions, what actually changes? Another manager walks through the door, inherits a squad built around a different way of playing and is expected to make everything work. Then when it doesn't, we start the cycle all over again. I genuinely hope Pochettino succeeds. I'd love nothing more than to see an aggressive, high-intensity Manchester United side getting Old Trafford bouncing again. But until there is genuine accountability and a clear, direction from the people running this football club, it's difficult to believe anything will fundamentally change. That's where I am with United right now. Just numb. Time will tell.
4
6
38
18,137
It's been an absolute disgrace how Michael Carrick's sacking has been handled. The fact that it was leaked he was getting sacked, with seemingly everyone knowing while he was still taking training at the club, is shocking. But it goes hand in hand with how INEOS have treated staff, season ticket holders, fans and the football club as a whole since they arrived. Pure incompetence. Don't even get me started on the Glazers, but the way INEOS have operated deserves serious scrutiny. And look, I'm not suggesting for a minute that Carrick didn't deserve to go. He did. His game model was flawed and far too reliant on individual players performing. When those players weren't at it, 18th in the table is what you got. Ultimately, there was only going to be one outcome. But where is the accountability for the people above him? Jason Wilcox, Omar Berrada and INEOS have made bad decision after bad decision. Where are the consequences for them? Why does the manager continually pay the price while the people responsible for the wider direction of the football club seem to escape accountability? And that brings me to Mauricio Pochettino. One thing I will say is that I'm finding it incredibly difficult to get excited about Manchester United at the moment. Even from an analysis perspective, I feel numb towards the club. It just feels like we're going through the exact same cycle again. Another manager. Another supposedly fresh direction. Another set of questions about whether the squad actually suits what the manager wants to do. When I look at Pochettino, the first thing I think about is his background and the influence of Marcelo Bielsa. Think Bielsa and you think intensity, fitness, aggressive pressing, repeatable high-intensity running and players who can cover huge distances. Now look at this Manchester United squad. Do I see a squad full of players capable of producing those repeatable high-intensity sprints? No. And that's where I have concerns about the fit. Carrick wanted to build a team that could control matches through possession. He favoured technical players who were comfortable operating in smaller spaces, combining and controlling the rhythm of games. The problem was that when the technical quality dropped, or the players simply weren't performing, United couldn't sustain that control. The game became stretched, the distances between players increased and suddenly you had players being asked to defend huge spaces. That's the exact scenario where some of these profiles struggle massively (Mainoo, Tielemans, Santos). You could even see it against Leeds, when Carrick had to move Tielemans into the number 10 position because of the amount of ground he was being asked to cover in midfield. Now you're bringing in a manager whose football is built around enormous physical demands, aggressive pressing and intensity. So my question is simple. Does this squad actually have the physical profiles to execute what Pochettino wants consistently? I have no doubt Pochettino will get a tune out of this group. For me, Manchester United should be competing for the top five with the quality they have. Yes, the squad lacks depth in certain areas, but there is some serious talent there. Far too much talent to be sitting in the relegation places. And there are aspects of Pochettino's football that I really like. I loved watching his Tottenham side. The pressing intensity, the aggression, the energy and the way they could overwhelm opponents physically. That's the type of football I can absolutely see Old Trafford getting behind. Winning the ball high, sustaining pressure, forcing opponents into mistakes and getting the crowd involved. Old Trafford should be an intimidating place to play football, and an aggressive pressing game can play a huge part in creating that atmosphere. I was underwhelmed by his spell at Chelsea, but I can still see the appeal of appointing him. However, liking a manager's football and believing he's the right fit for the current squad are two completely different things. And that's my concern. Will Pochettino have the players capable of meeting his physical demands? Will United recruit the player profiles to make his game model work? Will he receive adequate backing in the transfer market? Because if INEOS's track record tells us anything, I have serious doubts. And that's why I struggle to get excited. It's not that I don't rate Pochettino. I do. It's not that I don't believe this squad has quality. It absolutely does. It's that I have very little confidence in the people making the decisions above the manager. We can talk about pressing structures, game models, player profiles and tactical fit all day long, but if the people responsible for building the squad keep making the wrong decisions, what actually changes? Another manager walks through the door, inherits a squad built around a different way of playing and is expected to make everything work. Then when it doesn't, we start the cycle all over again. I genuinely hope Pochettino succeeds. I'd love nothing more than to see an aggressive, high-intensity Manchester United side getting Old Trafford bouncing again. But until there is genuine accountability and a clear, direction from the people running this football club, it's difficult to believe anything will fundamentally change. That's where I am with United right now. Just numb. Time will tell.
4
6
38
18,137
Correct decision. It just couldn’t continue. A manager can change a lot, but at Manchester United, it feels like the problems go far beyond just the manager. INEOS have got so many footballing decisions wrong. They simply cannot afford to get this appointment wrong.
🚨 Manchester United intend to relieve Michael Carrick of duties. #MUFC say no final decision & nothing set in stone but work undertaken on replacements + multiple sources anticipate change before Liverpool. W/ @lauriewhitwell @AdamCrafton_ @TheAthleticFC nytimes.com/athletic/7768165…
1
27
1,543
Aaron's Analytics retweeted
Everton should’ve won at the weekend with the quality of chances they created. Three gilt-edged chances all fell to Thierno Barry and he failed to convert. It’s no coincidence they fell to him though. His movement is 🔝 . 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻
1
1
10
1,703
Aaron's Analytics retweeted
Thierno Barry scored a hat-trick against Preston last night in an impressive Carabao Cup win for Everton. Preston were poor, but having watched the game back, there were real signs of Barry’s potential. His movement was exceptional. A mini-thread on his performance 🧵
1
2
1
9
3,091
Red flag after red flag with INEOS.
Before the FA Cup final win against Man City, Ten Hag was under major pressure and Jason Wilcox and others involved put forward several candidates as possible replacements. One person Wilcox spoke highly of was Russell Martin, whom he had appointed the previous summer in his role as Southampton’s director of football. Martin led Southampton to promotion to the PL in 2023-24 via the Championship play-offs [@TheAthleticFC]
3
25
1,605
🔵👇🏻👇🏻
Thierno Barry scored a hat-trick against Preston last night in an impressive Carabao Cup win for Everton. Preston were poor, but having watched the game back, there were real signs of Barry’s potential. His movement was exceptional. A mini-thread on his performance 🧵
1
663
Played decent football in the first 45 minutes, but then came the typical drop-off. Had enough chances to get ourselves ahead. But INEOS need to end this. They haven’t even been competent enough to bring new defenders into the club. I mean, look at Maguire, Martinez and Dalot today. I don’t even blame them. They simply shouldn’t be starting for Manchester United in 2026. Simple as that. Now INEOS are putting out briefings about investing in defenders next summer. Next summer is too late. Carrick should’ve been gone on Monday. This cant continue.
1
25
1,699
I like that United XI, outside of Dalot at left-back, which is a microcosm of the club’s poor squad planning. Dalot has been playing LWB under Amorim and now finds himself at LB. It just doesn’t work. But beyond tactics, the question today is simple: will these players actually work hard? That’s how sad the situation has become at Manchester United.
1
32
2,193
Absolutely brilliant piece!!! 👏🏼👏🏼
A synopsis of Manchester United over the last 13 years. I wanted to go tactical but honestly there's no point.
4
1
25
2,668
Aaron's Analytics retweeted
A very in-depth thread on Man United's woes after that Como thrashing, auto-RT'd by my bot account @aftertheftw .. It's brilliant to discover new accounts featured by my bot. Check out this thread & @Aaronsanalytics and his work! Do drop @aftertheftw a follow a well. Cheers! ⚽️📊
My thoughts on Manchester United, Michael Carrick and Bruno Fernandes after the 4–1 defeat to Como. I can talk about tactics all day, but what I watched last night went far beyond a tactical problem. There is something seriously wrong at Manchester United. 🔴THREAD 🧵
1
1
448
Powerful statement from Michael Carrick in his Manchester United press conference today. "I'm not entitled to be here. Entitlement cannot be at this football club. We're not entitled to win. We've won in the past, we've got an incredible history, but that doesn't mean that you're entitled to just win. I'm fully aware of that. It takes hard work. It takes a lot of sacrifice." This embodies what Manchester United should be about. Whether it's enough to keep Carrick in the job remains to be seen. More than likely not, but he's really laid down a challenge to the players ahead of Sunday's game against Bournemouth. Let's see how they respond.
1
32
1,876
Aaron's Analytics retweeted
My thoughts on Manchester United, Michael Carrick and Bruno Fernandes after the 4–1 defeat to Como. I can talk about tactics all day, but what I watched last night went far beyond a tactical problem. There is something seriously wrong at Manchester United. 🔴THREAD 🧵
5
17
1
120
77,534
My thoughts on Manchester United, Michael Carrick and Bruno Fernandes after the 4–1 defeat to Como. I can talk about tactics all day, but what I watched last night went far beyond a tactical problem. There is something seriously wrong at Manchester United. 🔴THREAD 🧵
5
17
1
120
77,534
INEOS haven’t helped matters. For all the positive messaging about the rebuild, United still have serious issues with squad balance and defensive depth. Talking about signing defenders next summer doesn’t solve the problems Carrick is dealing with now. The recruitment strategy deserves serious scrutiny.
1
3
725
FINAL THOUGHTS Bruno’s comments were the final straw for me. Carrick deserves criticism for aspects of his game model. INEOS deserve criticism for recruitment and squad planning. But these players haven’t earned the right to publicly question the manager while failing to deliver the basics on the pitch. You can talk tactics all day. But without intensity, urgency, work rate and collective responsibility, tactics mean absolutely nothing. Manchester United didn’t lose 4–1 because of a tactical system alone. They lost because of a lack of intensity, character and collective responsibility. And that is a far bigger problem.
1
1
12
728