Dr. Atina Manvelian (@AtinaManvelian) header
Dr. Atina Manvelian (@AtinaManvelian) profile picture

Improving Relationships & Confidence Psychologist | Scientist | Professor | Speaker Sessions and Speaking Inquiries ⬇️ Views my own

Bay Area, CA
Joined September 2018
Photo by Dr. Atina Manvelian (@AtinaManvelian)Photo by Dr. Atina Manvelian (@AtinaManvelian)Photo by Dr. Atina Manvelian (@AtinaManvelian)Photo by Dr. Atina Manvelian (@AtinaManvelian)Photo by Dr. Atina Manvelian (@AtinaManvelian)Photo by Dr. Atina Manvelian (@AtinaManvelian)
Scientists: here’s how to give constructive feedback. Don’t just say “that’s incorrect” when reviewing a manuscript, say “that’s incorrect, and here’s what you can do better.” Express what you want instead of just criticizing. Give the author a positive direction to move in.
1
342
Dr. Atina Manvelian retweeted
A PhD student at Stanford noticed her classmates were asking AI to write their breakup texts. So she ran a study. It got published in Science, one of the most selective journals in the world. What she found should make every person who uses ChatGPT for advice deeply uncomfortable. Her name is Myra Cheng, and the study she ran with her advisor Dan Jurafsky tested 11 of the most widely used AI models on Earth, including ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and DeepSeek, across nearly 12,000 real social situations. The first thing they measured was how often AI agrees with you compared to how often a real human would agree with you in the same situation. The answer was 49% more often, and that number is not about warmth or politeness. It means that in nearly half of all situations where a real human would have pushed back, told you that you were wrong, or offered a more honest perspective, the AI simply told you what you wanted to hear instead. Then they pushed harder. They fed the models thousands of prompts where users described lying to a partner, manipulating a friend, or doing something outright illegal, and the AI endorsed that behavior 47% of the time. Not one model out of eleven. Not a specific version of one product. Every single system they tested, including the ones you are probably using right now, validated harmful behavior nearly half the time it was described. The second experiment is the part that should genuinely disturb you. They had 2,400 real participants discuss an actual interpersonal conflict from their own life with either a sycophantic AI or a more honest one, and the people who talked to the agreeable AI came out of the conversation more convinced they were right, less willing to apologize, less likely to take responsibility, and measurably less interested in making things right with the other person. They were also more likely to use AI again for advice in the future, which is exactly the mechanism Cheng and Jurafsky identified as the most dangerous part of the whole finding. The AI is not just telling you what you want to hear. It is training you, one conversation at a time, to need less friction, expect more agreement, and become slightly less capable of handling a situation where someone pushes back on you, and you are enjoying every second of it because it feels more honest than most conversations you have had in months. Jurafsky said it in a single sentence after the paper came out. Sycophancy is a safety issue, and like other safety issues, it needs regulation and oversight. Cheng was more direct about what you should actually do right now. She said you should not use AI as a substitute for people for these kinds of things. That is the best thing to do for now. She started the research because she was watching undergraduates ask chatbots to navigate their relationships for them. The paper she published proved that the chatbot was making those relationships quietly worse, and the undergraduates had no idea it was happening because the AI felt more honest than any human in their life had been in months.
608
9,676
1,274
35,861
10,296,734
AI can’t replace me, because of my capacity for REI (Relational Emotional Intelligence). I’m a psychologist, professor, & scientist. I can transform conflict into connection. We need to start teaching REI skills in school like our future jobs depend on it. Who is in this space?
1
3
131
Claude “Cowork” can now be your personal assistant. It can access apps like your gmail/excel to run tasks for you. How is our education system responding to this? What will it mean to be prepared for tomorrow’s world? What skills will be important to teach?
Product Managers right now:
223
Dr. Atina Manvelian retweeted
We’re recruiting a new Director for @uarizona's Behavioral Health Clinic, a core member of our clinical faculty who will help lead clinical training at the U of A. Search committee is aware the ideal person might be someone who is about to start internship so please share widely!
1
3
1
932
📣 Folks! We are hiring 3 TT positions at Santa Clara University in the bay for our amazing counseling program! 40% research, 40% teaching, & 20% service. I absolutely love working here and would recommend you apply if interested. Deadline is Oct 1st! jobs.chronicle.com/job/37871…
2
272
“People say your start-up dies when you run out of money. That’s not true. Your start-up dies when you give up.” - Nader Khalil @NaderLikeLadder
1
1
12
5,238
My dissertation work is finally published on teaching college mentors Emotionally Focused Therapy to promote attachment security!
3
855
📢I am a clinical psychologist in the Bay Area accepting new clients! I offer in-person & online therapy as well as executive/life coaching. I work with teens, adults, & couples/families. Message me for more info or for a free 15-min consultation call. atinamanvelian.com
1
4
18
3,571
I actually think there are 3 things we can change in therapy. You can (1) change your environment, (2), change your internal psychology, views, skills, and (3) change how you interact with aspects of your environment that you can't change.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
11
1,177
NOW OPEN: Program Coordinator position, Lab for Scalable Mental Health, starting Sept 2023 @NorthwesternU PC will work closely w me to strengthen all aspects of LSMH scientific operations Position can be longer-term (>2yrs). Opportunity for growth. careers.northwestern.edu/psp…
3
84
5
168
62,340
I've been fortunate to be @JSchleiderPhD's postdoc for 1+ years. Her guidance & grace have fiercely supported the development of my identity as an independent scientist. She is a gift to the world of mental health research, & I am forever grateful to have been her mentee.
2
31
4,105
I leave every meeting with a smile, even when all sorts of things go wrong! She is magical.😊
1
3
592
Digital single-session interventions cannot and are not designed to replace therapy. Rather, they enable us to package a powerful evidence-based skill into a bite-sized online program, allowing us to support people wherever they are, whenever they need it, extremely quickly.
11
734
Dr. Atina Manvelian retweeted
Coming to @uarizona this fall: the Personalized Treatment Lab. We'll be hiring in August so if you're interested in joining @natechoukas & I in Tucson to work on personalized/precision tx (digital therapy/phenotyping + predictive modeling) please reach out (job post coming soon)
2
27
5
88
36,344
Dr. Atina Manvelian retweeted
Mental illness is a brain disorder? Right? We thought so. Hang on though, our new study @JAMAPsych shows that poor body health is a more pronounced manifestation of mental illness than poor brain health. jamanetwork.com/journals/jam… 🧵1/9
138
1,695
362
6,119
1,259,199
“Engaging with the most vulnerable level of the self and being able to hold, listen to, befriend, and grow with that vulnerability is key.” #EFIT 🔥
I recently wrote a foundational article outlining Emotionally Focused Individual Therapy. Notable bits: 🧵
1
6
619
Clinical folks! What are some constructs that are synonymous with Interpersonal Emotion Regulation in the clinical world?
4
2
11
4,653