Brian Householder (@BHouse50) header
Brian Householder (@BHouse50) profile picture

Life long @Pirates fan. Waiting for that 'New Pirates Generation' #LetsGoBucs

Pittsburgh, PA
Joined November 2015
Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)Photo by Brian Householder (@BHouse50)
The MLBPA is walking into a trap they set for themselves 32 years ago. A salary cap is almost certainly guaranteed at this point ------------------------------------------ In 1994, the owners claimed a good-faith impasse and in turn implemented their own CBA. In August of that year, the players union went on strike and challenged this ruling in court. The judge (Sonia Sotomayor) ruled in March '95 in favor of the union, stating that it was in fact the owners who were bargaining in bad-faith and reinstated the old CBA for 1 year. A new deal was eventually reached in 1996 which included the newly introduced luxury tax ------------------------------------------ The crux of the case was this...The players refused any hard salary cap but offered an alternate economic framework centered around a luxury tax and an overhaul of the industry's financial layout. In their counterproposals to the team owners, the MLBPA offered the following specific concessions: - A Luxury Tax - Expanded revenue sharing - Maintaining the Status Quo Over Aggressive Gains Because the players had consistently stayed at the negotiating table and offered counterproposals (like the luxury tax, rev sharing, etc), they were legally recognized as bargaining in good faith. The owners, however, were not. They proposed a salary cap and a reduction in the players' share of revenues to curb rising player salaries, while eliminating salary arbitration and altering free agency. And then unilaterally implemented it after the claimed impasse ------------------------------------------ Fast forward 32 years...which side is consistently coming to the table with proposals that include multiple concessions such as increased minimums, reduced club control time, and increasingly higher floors? In the legal realm have judges stayed pro labor as they were in the 90s or swung more pro business? An impasse will be called, the players will strike and then they will lose in court. The owners are just following the same playbook the players used 32 years ago
35
13
3
71
36,164
At this point the MLBPA has to play the game that's being laid out Say "Ok, we'll do a cap. 200 floor, 300 ceiling. Now let's talk other points and we'll circle back to final numbers" Then the proverbial ball is in owners court. Whether it's true or not, the PA looks like the unreasonable strong armers to the gen pop. If they play the owners game, you can flip that script
48
I absolutely love all the CNA talk. Highly spirited, solid points on both sides, so many different angles to attack How bout this for an idea... - No cap or floor but increase the luxury penalties, and implement a tax penalty on the low end (let's call it 125) - Split 80% of TV revenue equally - Team bonuses for playoff appearances, paid for by rest of the 20% of TV money - 1 less year of team control and higher league minimums Put me in the room, I'll get something done!!
36
But...but...don't ALLLL players ever say the cap is evil?!? Votto gets it. Most of the others do too. Just can't piss off their other bosses (agents)
This quoted post is unavailable.
49
Soooo, still wanna tell me it'll "supress salaries"? The players will be getting an initial bonus (more money in the pool from the jump) and a better long term outlook But no, let's make sure and save those agent's bacon! The psyop on baseball players needs to be studied
I get MLBPA lackeys will spout the "salaries will decrease" line to fool their own membership but here in the public, that doesn't fly. The NHL players went from $690M-$1.17B salary pool in '05-06 to $2.46B/$3.328B this season. The same thing will happen for MLB players.
90
Brian Householder retweeted
The league minimum is too low in MLB. It’s the lowest among major N. American sports. Yet, the majority of players perform at that rate or near it. Anyone who steps on a major league field has reached the pinnacle of their profession. (I’ve written about this dynamic for years, btw.) Good for Kyle Tucker, but making 77x the minimum isn’t a healthy system. The median outcome, the median career, ought to be in focus. The reality is most players need second careers after playing MLB.
34
9
5
114
20,646
Somebody please show me the players good faith proposal against this Absolute slam dunk in the courts. I personally want baseball next year so I would hate it if it went there But if it does...MLBPA loses in a landslide
Baseball fans have repeatedly told us they have two issues with the game today: blackouts and fairness We’re proposing to make three major changes to baseball: 1. Entering into a partnership with players where all revenues that are generated are split 50/50 between the teams and the players 2. Implementing a salary cap and floor that will regulate what each team can spend 3. Revenues from media generated in baseball are shared equally by the clubs This will reduce the revenue disparity in baseball and help us address local blackouts Major League players’ total compensation would go up and fans would get a more competitive game It’s a win for everybody
57
Brian Householder retweeted
Who’s bargaining in bad faith? The MLBPA may be walking into a trap that was set 32 years ago. In 1994, the owners declared an impasse, unilaterally implemented a salary cap and eliminated key player rights. The players took them to court. The ruling changed everything… 🧵
6
5
4
71
34,208
This is what sports fans have become. Absolute pansies Akin to a toddler kicking and screaming cause he got a red popsicle instead of a blue one How far we have fallen as a society. Dudes just absolutely castrated all over, it's not just Pirates fans
Yankees deadline has @JoezMcfLy in shambles
3
556
😆😆😆 $33 is price gouging. What, mommy stop bank rolling you, Jim? Now do average price. What's the cost for 1st deck comparatively? They're taking the quality over quantity route since their market has such low volume thanks to the malcontents
Once again, a weekday day game and the Pirates are the 2nd highest "get-in" price behind only the Dodgers. In fact, they are over 100% more expensive than eight of the 14 other games being played throughout MLB today. Pittsburghers are being price gouged. Plain and simple.
1
707
Raising the floor does 2 things. 1) discourages the riff raff and 2) encourages more of the lower bowl ticket sales. Without such a wide gap between the two, ppl are more willing to upgrade. It's a quality over quantity argument. Tried doing quantity and it hasn't worked so why not try the other. And if you can keep out the blubbering idiots that ruin the experience by booing and crying and being generally soft for real baseball fans and kids, double win
1
134
My son and I were at last night's game...he NEVER leaves early. We did yesterday cause a group sitting in front of us made it an unbearable experience for him by being so incredibly soft and whining and booing for 7 straight innings GTFOH you sad pathetic losers
2
1
719
Mayyybe this is a bed you made yourself, DK and the rest of the Pittsburgh media? Can't assume you can slander someone for decades and get any type of preferential treatment The cash cow of shit on the Bucs is on its way out but not without the vampires kicking and screaming!
Replying to @Dejan_Kovacevic
Man, be grateful you've still got two major-league teams in town who know how to carry themselves professionally. We have decisions to make, in turn. We're not about to participate in a game that's rigged. Never seen something like this in 25-plus years. 3/3 @MLB @MLB_PR
2
292
Finally, the team's getting creative to avoid the constant smear campaigns You think maybe, Noah, this is in response to 30 years of abuse by the local media? But no, sure, point fingers right at them as per usual
Zero disrespect to Jason, but it’s absolute nonsense the team went out of its way to control the narrative here. Carmen was set to speak with reporters tomorrow. The team ensured he spoke with their own writer before hand. That’s wrong. Full stop. Period.
230
Absolutely he was disappointed about the move, but this was largely much to do about nothing Also out of these 2, who you starting? 51% hard hit rate and a .285 xBA is a disaster waiting to happen And no way am I bringing Walks McGee in with anyone on base
242
The agent mouth pieces in full force Why don't they touch on the fact that the BASELINE proposed cap puts significantly more money in players pockets in totality? Somehow that's bad for all players? The @MLBPA is a joke only serving agents and the top 5% of who they represent
The MLBPA's response, in part, to today's proposal: "The owners responded today with a demand for a salary cap system, something generations of players have fought against. The last time the owners made such an explicit push for a cap—over 30 years ago—it led to the longest work stoppage in MLB history. For generations, our members have fought against cap systems because they harm players at all levels, erode or eliminate contractual guarantees, pit player against player, lead to more work stoppages, not less, and get worse for players over time. Caps don’t lower ticket prices for fans, eliminate tanking or ensure teams are run with equal competence. They suffocate competition by offering owners an all-purpose excuse for inaction and mediocrity."
1
145
We have actual numbers now 245 cap and 171 floor (seems my estimates were pretty spot on, conservatively) And that's the owners FIRST offer Again, the cap/floor system is PRO players! Don't let the agent mouth pieces and big market easy button hoarders tell you any different
So let's actually do the math on this "supress salary" argument The current payroll of all teams combined is 5,430M The proposed cap and floor is $160M - $240M Assuming everyone above lowers to 240 and all below raise to 160, the total would become 5,700M!! Almost 300M more in payout, even including the current hyper inflated Dodgers total coming down 150+! So who's suppressing whose salary, Chris Bassitt and "executive subcommittee"? The top 5% of PLAYERS are suppressing salary for the other 95%! And for what?! For a small elite's super privilege. That's the ACTUAL purpose of a union, to AVOID that. The fans want it, the owners want it, most players want it (remember executive subcommittee voted 0-8 against last CBA, while the players rep group voted 20-8), but the super douche subcommittee wants to gaslight us into being the victim
70
The BASE proposal would put $40M dollars into players pockets Could easily double that in negotiations AND get your super 2 and club control asks But sure, the @MLBPA is looking out for all their members 🙄
MLB proposed a hard salary cap of $245.3 million and a salary floor of $171.2 million for 2027 as part of the next CBA, per @JesseRogersESPN
2
7
1,189