Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng) header
Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng) profile picture

We oppose attempts to criminalise parents who smack their children.

England
Joined November 2022
Photo by Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng)Photo by Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng)Photo by Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng)Photo by Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng)Photo by Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng)Photo by Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng)
On Wednesday, Peers debated an amendment to the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill calling for a review of the Welsh smacking ban – an attempt to pressure the Westminster Government into outlawing smacking in England. Here are some highlights from the debate.
1
2
293
.@Fox_Claire warned that hundreds of parents in Wales have been sent for ‘re-education’ under the ban. Because this can appear on enhanced DBS checks, a mum who smacks her child to stop them running into the road could be barred from working as a care assistant or childminder.
2
3
9
1,119
Be Reasonable’s Ciarán Kelly goes head to head with smacking ban campaigner Rosey Davidson on @SkyNews. He warns that putting loving parents in the same camp as abusers is going to make it even harder for children in real danger to be helped. youtu.be/-69ppEKJV7A
107
Sociologist Dr @AshleyAFrawley responds to celebrity calls for an English smacking ban @TalkTV She argues that a mum should be able to tap her toddler on the hand to make a point without her life being ruined by being convicted of criminal assault youtu.be/w7ugO_1GBFA
1
79
A smacking ban “does a grave injustice to good parents by making them out to be abusers when they're not”. Be Reasonable's Simon Calvert speaks to @TalkTV's @iancollinsuk about the NSPCC's latest calls for an English smacking ban. youtube.com/watch?v=WSI93IWL…
109
Our spokesman Simon Calvert warns Radio 2 listeners that a smacking ban will put thousands of parents each year in the cross-hairs of the criminal justice system for nothing more than tapping a child on the back of the hand.
53
“Measures such as smacking bans... come wrapped in the language of ‘safeguarding,’ yet they erode parental autonomy while sidestepping the real crises” conservativewoman.co.uk/brav…
1
1
1
70
1⃣“Current legislation already provides statutory safeguards that protect children from physical harm. 2⃣“Banning reasonable chastisement would criminalise ordinary mums and dads while squandering scarce frontline resources.”
50
A mum who taps their tot on the back of the hand—that is the kind of reasonable parental discipline that smacking ban campaigners want to criminalise, warns Be Reasonable’s Simon Calvert. @BBCLookNorth
4
3
261
The headline takeaway from the NSPCC is that a majority of what they call “safeguarding professionals” think the law should change. But that appears quite different from what the wider public thinks.
1
4
‘Reality Will Be Less Help For Children Who Need It’ Be Reasonable's Simon Calvert on @TalkTV with @Iromg, explaining why an English smacking ban would only divert police and social work resources away from protecting abused children. youtube.com/watch?v=vWrMScXT…
2
115
An amendment to criminalise smacking in England failed to get Government support yesterday. The Government said it has “no plans to legislate at this stage”, but intends to wait for the Welsh Government to publish its assessment of its 2022 smacking ban.
MPs are expected to debate an amendment today to criminalise smacking in England. (1/3) youtu.be/hPCvoWM7qzI
79
MPs are expected to debate an amendment today to criminalise smacking in England. (1/3) youtu.be/hPCvoWM7qzI
8
2
3
6
6,710
The amendment would only serve to outlaw the mildest tap on the hand or a gentle smack on the back of the legs. Anything which leaves more than a transitory reddening of the skin is already illegal. (2/3)
1
1
96
‘Calls for a smacking ban are motivated by ideology, not scientific evidence’ Sociologist Dr @AshleyAFrawley on @BBCRadio4 youtu.be/xeJshPEDNMs
5
11
1,037
“Rather than the law focusing on parents who are actually abusing their children we’re forcing the police and social services to invest time in families where… mum has done nothing more than tap the tot on the back of the hand” @bbc5live youtu.be/UYTZJFRguAY
3
3
604
The Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health has today called for an English smacking ban. Its officer for child protection said it’s “time for this Victorian-era punishment to go”. Speaking on @LBC, Simon Calvert responded to the claims... 🧵(1/4)
1
4
2
409
(2/4) Be Reasonable’s Simon Calvert told @NickFerrariLBC, “the reasonable chastisement defence is what they want to repeal”. The “defence, by definition, only protects parents when they do something that is reasonable”, e.g. the mum who taps the tot on the back of the hand.
1
1
33
Social Work Scotland “are talking about how difficult” Scotland's smacking “law is making it for them to engage constructively with families because minor trivial incidents… get escalated” “That’s bad news because it means families aren’t getting the support they need”
Asked why ‘if an adult can't smack another adult, parents should be able to lightly smack their children’, Simon Calvert said: “If we try & say that parents have to treat their children from birth like adults in every respect, I mean that’s crazy” @bbcmtd youtube.com/watch?v=tc8q-9hj…
1
1
93
Asked why ‘if an adult can't smack another adult, parents should be able to lightly smack their children’, Simon Calvert said: “If we try & say that parents have to treat their children from birth like adults in every respect, I mean that’s crazy” @bbcmtd youtube.com/watch?v=tc8q-9hj…
1
1
1
2
476
He added: “It’s not a wise way of thinking about the criminal law to make those comparisons.”
35
(2/2) Responding to claims that a smacking ban is needed to prevent parental abuse, Minister for School Standards Catherine McKinnell said: “any suggestion that reasonable punishment could be used as a defence to serious harm to a child... is completely wrong & frankly absurd"
38