Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada) profile picture

सं‌ श्रु॒तेन॑ गमेमहि

भारत
Joined April 2022
Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)Photo by Kumārila Bhaṭṭa (@Bhattapada)
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
"Fauatian spirit of Hindus paved the way sothat the man Krsna can defeat the god Indra" because I have to bigbrain infront of goras that my heresy regarding my texts is better than the heresy they can do regarding mine. As I said, the opposite camps are more same than different.
1
3
19
505
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
A kṛṣņayajurvedic simple homa procedure deployed to acquire lost wealth typically. Also used when one is in a contest and surrounded by enemies or for victory when one undertakes an enterprise. This just uses the jaya mantras.
1
5
31
540
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
Yes. Just as it is Karpatriji in the north, it is Paramacharya in South. Other than that they were strictly shastraic, they also showed that it is possible to live per the shastras - that galls them even more because it disproves their position that shastras are invalid today.
The growing animus against Swami Karpatri aming sections of Hindutvaites is a reflection of the schizophrenic trauma of modern Hindus that pulls them in two opposite directions: 1. The obligation to represent Hindus in modern politics informs their polemic against Islam. 2. The polemic against Islam compels them to turn against similar ideas in Hindu tradition and deny their validity. Traditional institutions and paramparik acharyas like Karpatri ji simply stand in the way of this cancelling of shastras. The only options available to them are: make the effort to understand and rationalise the traditions in a respectful manner or discredit them. The latter is easy and rewarding, therefore prevalent.
2
14
341
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
The growing animus against Swami Karpatri aming sections of Hindutvaites is a reflection of the schizophrenic trauma of modern Hindus that pulls them in two opposite directions: 1. The obligation to represent Hindus in modern politics informs their polemic against Islam. 2. The polemic against Islam compels them to turn against similar ideas in Hindu tradition and deny their validity. Traditional institutions and paramparik acharyas like Karpatri ji simply stand in the way of this cancelling of shastras. The only options available to them are: make the effort to understand and rationalise the traditions in a respectful manner or discredit them. The latter is easy and rewarding, therefore prevalent.
Amongst all shades of opinion and strategizing, the urge to show Swami Karpatri ji as a plagarist is the lowest in my view. Agreeing or disagreeing with views is everyone's prerogative but to judge a guru-shishya relationship with modern academic blinkers is not useful let alone being Dharmic. Traditional knowledge transmission mechanisms are distinct. Learnt from Paturi sir recently about how Bhagavatpada Adi Shankara wrote bhaashya to his síshya Hastaamalakaachaarya's book. Might be unfathomable for a modern brain seeped in Western academic discourse Beyond everything, the purpose of studying our knowledge is to understand the subtleties of Dharma and Karma and bring it into behavior. The inability to factor karmic consequences is the main concern and the real education we need to advance.
9
39
2
151
3,282
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
Replying to @Anviksiki
A good essay or article pertaining to this topic. @infinitchy do see it. Though it's written in context of poetry, but logic is transposable poetryfoundation.org/article…
1
8
212
Amongst all shades of opinion and strategizing, the urge to show Swami Karpatri ji as a plagarist is the lowest in my view. Agreeing or disagreeing with views is everyone's prerogative but to judge a guru-shishya relationship with modern academic blinkers is not useful let alone being Dharmic. Traditional knowledge transmission mechanisms are distinct. Learnt from Paturi sir recently about how Bhagavatpada Adi Shankara wrote bhaashya to his síshya Hastaamalakaachaarya's book. Might be unfathomable for a modern brain seeped in Western academic discourse Beyond everything, the purpose of studying our knowledge is to understand the subtleties of Dharma and Karma and bring it into behavior. The inability to factor karmic consequences is the main concern and the real education we need to advance.
5
22
1
83
3,980
This dunderhead thinks ꣳ [which is pronounced like गुँ] means गूंगा [mute]. Can't even get started on how badly he has botched the meaning of other parts of this mantra.
शादी में पंडित जब सिंदूर दान के टाइम मंत्र पढ़ता है तो वो गंदी गंदी गाली देता है पूरा सुने इस वीडियो जानकर पंडितलोग समझा भी सकते है @grok तू भी बता सकता है
1
8
170
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
श्री गुरूभ्यो नमः #sringeri
6
17
281
2,176
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
The Brahmanical order has always been the real enemy of Indra.
1
12
224
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
Yajur Veda Ghana Parayanam by HH Jagadguru Shankaracharya Sri Satya Chandrasekarendra Saraswati Mahaswamigal. HH completed Rig Veda, Yajur Veda, Sama Veda, Shadangas, and Dashopanishat by HIS early 20s, a remarkable feat achieved by very few, let alone at such young age! 🙏🙏
11
93
5
516
13,421
वेदाध्ययनपूर्वकब्रह्मविद्याऽधिकारविषये ब्रह्ममीमांसासूत्रस्य कौण्डिन्न्यायनवृत्तौ
2
5
351
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
छठ की महिमा
22
101
1,257
अपारकारुण्यसुधातरंगैः अपांगपातैरवलोकयंतं । कठोरसंसारनिदाघतप्तान् मुनीनहं नौमि गुरुं गुरूणां।।🌸
2
16
76
862
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
What is Āstikya and Nāstikya? Patañjali's Mahābhāṣyam (on Aṣṭādhyāyi 4.4.60): अस्तीत्यस्य मतिः -आस्तिकः। नास्तीत्यस्य मतिः -नास्तिकः One whose mati is asti ('it exists') is an āstika, one whose mati is nāsti ('it doesn't exist') is a nāstika. Vāmana-Jayāditya's Kāśikāvṛtti (on Aṣṭādhyāyi 4.4.60): अस्ति मतिरस्य आस्तिकः। नास्ति मतिरस्य नास्तिकः।..न च मतिसत्तामात्रे प्रत्यय इष्यते। किं तर्हि? परलोकोऽस्तीति यस्य मतिरस्ति, स आस्तिकः। तद्विपरीतो नास्तिकः। One whose mati is asti ('it exists') is an āstika. One whose mati is nāsti ('it doesn't exist') is a nāstika. And the pratyaya (ṭhak, which has ādeśa of ika) is not merely iṣṭa for sattā. What then? He whose mati is that paraloka exists, is an āstika. The one viparīta to that is a nāstika. This is followed by Kaiyaṭa's Bhāṣyapradīpa, Nāgeśa's Bhāṣyapradīpoddyota, Jinendrabuddhi's Nyāsa, Bhaṭṭoji's Siddhāntakaumudī, etc. [1/4]
3
14
2
40
2,367
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
The goosebumps of remembering the tapasya of Dharmasamrat Swami Karpatri Ji Maharaj, and the disappointment of hearing how Maharaj is spoken of now! Watch this beautiful video by Sri Ashish Dhar It puts us firmly in place. In a time when ANYONE casually abuse Mahatmas and Shankaracharyas, this is a much-needed reminder of the reverence, restraint, and basic dignity that Sanatana Dharma demands. Listen. Reflect. And speak with awareness. @infinitchy @upword_ Full Video: youtube.com/watch?v=8gbQDpBs… #SanatanaDharma #HinduDharma #Shankaracharya #GuruBhakti #Tapasvi #Vedanta #TraditionalWisdom #RespectTheGuru #Dharmacharya #Yati #Shraddha #Parampara #HinduDiscourse #Adhikara #SpiritualHeritage #Jagadguru #ShastricKnowledge #DharmaOverPolitics #HonourTheAcharya #SanatanaValues #Swami #Karapatri #Maharaj
15
30
658
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
'छठ महापर्व' पर श्रीमज्जगद्गुरु पुरिपीठाधीश्वर शङ्कराचार्यजी महाभाग की दैनिक भास्कर (आर्काइव-2019) से विशेष बातचीत।
2
65
1
227
1,792
Additionally, clear evidence exists that Swami Karpatri Ji was fully aware of the correct dates of Pythagoras’s life. Screenshots from two different editions of his work Mārksvād aur Rāmrājya (Chapter 1) explicitly record Pythagoras’s birth and death years in accordance with the standard historical chronology (sixth century BCE). This further confirms that the isolated phrasing in Vedārtha Pārijāta cannot be read as a genuine chronological error on his part.
1
3
17
372
I have come across an allegation made by Nityananda Misra against Swami Karpatri Ji in a 2024 Medium article (medium.com/@nmisra/when-kara…). The relevant portion reads: “The same Karapātra Svāmī who would astonish and inspire readers by writing on topics he specialised in would almost always reduce himself to a laughing stock by writing tomes with supreme confidence on topics outside his expertise. For example, he would confidently date Pythagoras, who lived in the sixth century BCE, to the thirteenth century CE.” His main allegation here is that Swami Karpatri Ji wrongly (and confidently) dated Pythagoras to be from 13th century CE rather than the sixth century BC. The allegation rests on the following passage from Swami Karpatri Ji’s Vedārtha Pārijāta (p. 1294): Sanskrit: “त्रयोदशी शतीमारम्य पैथागोरास-केप्लर-न्यूटनप्रभृतिभिर्भूभ्रमणसिद्धान्त उत्थापित” Hindi rendering given in the book: “ईसा का तेरहवीं शताब्दी के बाद पैथागोरस, केप्लर, न्यूटन प्रभृति पाश्चात्य विद्वानों ने पृथिवी के भ्रमण का सिद्धान्त माना।” Read in isolation, this sentence does appear to place Pythagoras in the thirteenth century CE and would therefore support Misra’s charge. However, the very next passage in the same work reads: Sanskrit: “भारते आर्यनभट्टेनार्यभट्टया पृथिव्या अचलत्वं सूर्यादिग्रहाणा च भ्रमणमुक्तम् । लल्ल-वराहमिहिराहीना समक्षे तस्य प्रतिष्ठा नाभूत्, ततस्तेन प्रतिष्ठार्थमेवार्यभट्टिनाम्नैव ग्रन्थान्तरं लिखितम् । तत्र पैथागोरसादिरीत्या भूभ्रमण साधितम् ।” Hindi rendering given in the book: “भारत में आर्यभट ने अपने ग्रन्थ आर्यभटी में पृथिवी को अचल और सूर्य प्रभृति ग्रहो को चल माना है। लल्ल, वराहमिहिर प्रभृति के सामने जब उसकी प्रतिष्ठा न जमी तो उसने दूसरा ग्रन्थ लिखा, जिसमे कि पैथागोरस की पद्धति से ही पृथ्वी के भ्रमण का सिद्धान्त सिद्ध किया है।” This second passage is decisive. Swami Karpatri Ji states that Āryabhaṭa, after failing to gain acceptance for his original view, composed another work in which he demonstrated the rotation of the Earth “in the manner of Pythagoras” (पैथागोरसादिरीत्या). Āryabhaṭa flourished in the late fifth to early sixth century CE (c. 476–550 CE). Lalla and Varāhamihira belong to the sixth century CE. For Āryabhaṭa to have followed a “Pythagorean method,” Pythagoras must necessarily have lived centuries earlier—i.e., in the pre-Common-Era period. It is chronologically impossible for a fifth-century Indian astronomer to have adopted the methods of a thirteenth-century European thinker. Thus the isolated sentence that appears to date Pythagoras to the thirteenth century CE is either a slip, an imprecise formulation, or a reference only to the later Western revival and popularisation of the idea of terrestrial motion. The immediately following discussion makes it clear that Swami Karpatri Ji regarded Pythagoras as an ancient authority who preceded Āryabhaṭa by a considerable margin. In short, the charge that he “confidently dated Pythagoras to the thirteenth century CE” does not withstand scrutiny once the full context is taken into account.
5
26
1
63
3,886
Kumārila Bhaṭṭa retweeted
Sāmba Purāṇa (38.32-33): चित्रभानुर्विचित्रैश्च कुसुमैस्तु सुगन्धिभिः | पूजयेत् सोपवासो यः स कामिनीप्सितांल्लभेत् || घृतेन दीपं प्रज्वाल्य तिलतैलेन वा पुनः | दीर्घायुर्वपुषा युक्तश्चक्षुषा न च हीयते | दीपदानान्नरो नित्यं ज्ञानदीपेन दीप्यते | स च बुद्धीन्द्रियैश्चापि न कदाचिद्विमुह्यति || One, who upon upavāsa, does pūjana of Citrabhānu with vicitra and sugandhī kusuma-s (puṣpa-s) attains his īpsita kāmanā-s. One who does (Sūrya-hetu) prajvalana of dīpa with ghṛta or tila-taila, he becomes dīrghāyu, yukta with vapus (sundara-deha), and is never vihīna of cakṣus (eyesight). Through dīpadāna (to Sūrya), a nara is nityataḥ dīpta with jñāna dīpa and he is never at any time vimohita by his buddhi & indriya-s. Sāmba Purāṇa (38.40-41): यः सदाऽर्चयते सूर्यं चन्दनागुरुकुङ्कुमैः | स पूज्यते नरो नित्यं धनेन यशसा श्रिया || रक्तचन्दनमिश्रैस्तु रक्तपुष्पैः शुचिर्नरः | उदयेऽर्घ्यं सदा दत्वा सिद्धिं संवत्सराल्लभेत् || One who always does arcanā of Sūrya with candana, aguru, and kuṅkuma, that nara is nitya pūjita with dhana, yaśa, and śrī. A śuci nara who always offers arghya with rakta-puṣpa-s miśrita with rakta-candana at sūryodaya attains siddhi within a saṁvatsara. [3/7]
1
2
10
191