
prev and future @terraformindies - Where I work on us winning
Vancouver, British Columbia
Joined September 2019
- Tweets3.2K
- Following951
- Followers1.9K
- Likes355K
Pinned Tweet
Another two weeks, and the next blog post is finally done:
How Starlink Will Conquer The Earth's Telecommunications Layer
The most important insight of this blog post is that Starlink V3 launched on Starship will reach a cost that is competitive enough for SpaceX to be price competitive with every ISP on Earth, irrespective of population density.
A Starlink V3 costs, SpaceX reaches $352/Gbps/year. This means that they can serve customers at broadband speeds (100 Mbps) for just $29/year, $2.4/month.
This is more than enough to cover the entire world in Starlink terminals and subscriptions cheap enough to compete with legacy telco's.
The limiting factor to Starlink's success is not economic, it's entirely achieving the required scale.
That's the headline of the analysis, aside from the conclusion there is tons of fun modelling that was required to come to such conclusions.
I started with the global distribution of population, overlaid the distribution of Starlink satellites onto it, and created a capacity allocation model that models the elasticity of connectivity in every country.
This elasticity-derived model allowed me to simulate SpaceX bringing online every unconnected person in every country on Earth with declining as the customer base increases.
Get all the info about the model and conclusions in the post:
ckalitin.github.io/posts/sta…
As expected, extremely low safety factors
This will take some redesign
First step is to delete all 8020 aluminum extrusion because I am a man of god.
Once again keeping up the tradition of starting a new modelling project on every flight.
This time solid mech, finally an application of 6 months of classes.
Bonus photo of the outskirts of Mount Olympus in Washington.
2
19
1,477
Once again keeping up the tradition of starting a new modelling project on every flight.
This time solid mech, finally an application of 6 months of classes.
Bonus photo of the outskirts of Mount Olympus in Washington.
I actually quite like this reply to Elon, which in attempting to expound why capital allocation is the limiting factor to progress, in fact makes the case for visionary technical leadership being the limiting factor.
The first paragraph shows why Elon won. Extreme focus on the most important problem and not falling for rent seeking games.
Part of the reason we got so much R&D funding and innovation at little companies in WW2 is that Vannevar Bush built the systems in government required to give them capital and have competent military organizations to work with (as Kelly Johnson describes in his 14 rules). The limiting factor to progress is talent.
There is enough capital being thrown everywhere that it obviously isn’t being squandered by Bezos and his yacht. Exceptionally competent teams, leaders, and engineer are the limiting factor:
ckalitin.github.io/posts/man…
@matthewstoller I’d like to see your reading list, too many primary production methods mentioned for it to be a coincidence. The origins of efficiency? Smil? Yergin?
First of all, I'll agree with you that Jeff Bezos was good at monopolizing e-commerce and is not particularly focused or hungry when it comes to space. And throw all the strays you want at Lockheed and Boeing. Their leadership is skilled at corruption and financial engineering, not production. I always like it when you go after corporate monopolies.
That out of the way, I didn't say *anyone* can shove capital at an engineering problem and solve it easily. That's obviously untrue, and I'm not going to stand behind something I didn't say. I said that applying capital and engineering to a problem leads to improvement. It does. I don't think it's easy, but it's a clear and replicable model Americans have followed for hundreds of years. There's nothing unique about the path SpaceX took to make certain launches more efficient. But just because it's not unique doesn't mean it's not a real accomplishment. Good for your team, the pride you guys feel is well-deserved.
There's also nothing unique about Boeing or Lockheed being shitty; financial engineering leads to poor results and limited learning. It's downright shocking that for many years we relied on the Russians for launches, and that was a straight-up policy failure. NASA's funding of SpaceX to break that cartel was a good choice.
What is historically unusual today in the U.S. is two things. One, we as a society have dramatically narrowed the set of people who can marshal capital, and most of that set are not capable of hiring and running large engineering projects.
It used to be the case that capable and interested leadership was necessary to raise capital, now the qualification is simply being part of a narrow set of monopolists. Bezos spends his time on a mega-yacht staring at his wife's boob job. And hey, that's fine for him, but it's weird that such a character would have control over a space company on which he's not focused. It's a waste of large amounts of capital and a society that allows it is quite Soviet. Same with Zuckerberg dumping $80 billion into the Metaverse, Boeing and its Jack Welch-inspired mess from the 1990s onward, or Microsoft's endless attempts to make corporate America pay for variants of Clippy.
We've always know the rich and famous mostly don't innovate to challenge the status quo - why would they? As Woodrow Wilson put it in 1913, "The treasury of America... depends upon the inventions of unknown men, upon the originations of unknown men, upon the ambitions of unknown men. Every country is renewed out of the ranks of the unknown, not out of the ranks of those already famous and powerful and in control."
It's not, therefore, a surprise, to see stagnation in America, which is a problem you've actually highlighted.
You're a bit different than the rest of the Silicon Valley set. You are interested the technology work for which you fundraise, and you can inspire engineers to do great work. And that matters. There are downsides to your choices, and I won't go into them here, but the innovation is real.
My question is why innovation is not more widespread, as it used to be. It's not just the narrow set of people who can marshal capital, the other gating factor is that we have de facto limited the structure in which one can organize capital to shareholder driven financial institutions. Such corporations have their place, and always have. But to only allow that kind of structure is weird, and would have meant we never would have created the original NASA that built the foundations of our space capacity.
We had a far more innovative era and much more productive set of industries from the 1930s to the 1970s, when we built most of the foundational digital and aerospace technologies. With our financier-driven model today, for instance, we never would have the free universal GPS system that we take for granted, or the nuclear submarine developed by Admiral Rickover. We may not even have the semiconductor or the laser, or perhaps those would be bottled up in some large firm, protected by a thousand IP attorneys. All of those deployments of innovative scientific and engineering capacity are a result not just of engineering prowess, but of government policy to limit the power of dominant firms who had captured the control of those technologies, or to simply empower good leadership within public bureaucracies.
I'll be a bit more specific. I once got a list of antitrust cases in 1952, and here are some of the industries where the DOJ antitrust division forced an end to anti-competitive uses of patents:
Electric lamps, glass bulbs, tubing, argon gas, machinery, electrical equipment, fluorescent lamps, soap and synthetic detergents, variable condensers (the tubing devices used on radios to select broadcasting stations), chlorinating equipment, braking systems, electrical equipment, powder, and paste for the detection of defects in metal parts, wrinkle finishes for paint, enamel, and varnish, latex, prismatic glassware and illuminating appliances, peach pitting machinery, fluorescent materials, metal abrasives industry, machine tools, dental impression powder, telescope grocery carts, sheet chargers used to feed sheets of metal materials to rolling mills, etc.
During WWII, we also basically had the government pay to replace pretty much all of the nation's machine tools. The government also financed R&D, and was the key customer for smaller firms building out the semiconductor industry, like Texas instruments and Motorola. Those companies licensed AT&T's tech because of the 1952 antitrust consent decree that forced the telecom firm to offer nondiscriminatory licenses to all comers of all Bell Lab innovations. The result of these policy choices was a ton of innovation.
We are in a very different world now. Our current policy choices on who can raise capital to control technologies and within what structures they can do so represent an ideologically blinkered approach that kneecaps innovation. Many on the right see these policy choices as virtuous and inherent. They imagine that only great men can transcend what are actually just self-imposed traps that drown the talents of most Americans.
You don't see that as much in China, which has plenty of innovation. That country has many policies the U.S. used to have, such as highly competitive markets, a financial system geared to production, weaker IP, and an export-oriented currency regime. They are predatory, but very capable, precisely because they control their financiers, as America did until the 1970s. Obviously I don't endorse the Chinese state's aims or totalitarian goals, but they have learned from us what works, and we should similarly learn from them. You understand my argument, you have a lot of investments in China and have commented on the capabilities of the Chinese government and people.
Today, in the West, you are one of the small number of people who can access large amounts of capital in our dysfunctional and corrupt political order, and use it to actually bend metal. Why you can do so is a separate and perhaps not as charitable a discussion, but I will leave that aside. You can also hire capable engineers and empower them. Good for you. That's hard. It's also not genius. When you had a task in which you didn't control the context - DOGE - the results were different.
The actual disagreement here is the nature of how leadership happens. Many find comfort in thinking they need great men to protect them and innovate, my own view is that ordinary people, when free, can do extraordinary things. So I think we should focus on undoing the shackles - whether monopolies, excessive patent thickets, corruption, poor financial regulation - confining the American people. To put it differently, I don't think we should make it extremely difficult for competent people to raise money to do innovative things just so Zuckerberg can waste money on his dork metaverse.
I'll offer one other observation. You built your career starting in the 1990s, when there was a consensus that broadly technology was a force for good. That consensus existed precisely because of the old American policies I am discussing here, and the ones currently at work in China. We didn't confine the deployment of technology to a narrow extractive set of monopolists, but broadened it and ensured that it did offer public benefits through a certain legal framework.
That framework collapsed, and there are now few protections for consumers, workers, or suppliers anymore. You know this directly too, you sued Apple for its misuse of its app store monopoly power. The result of this legal collapse is that there's too much innovation around harming people and extraction, too much investment in predatory gambling systems and surveillance pricing bullshit. There are too many monopolies and too much enshittification.
So the consensus that technology is a force for good is fracturing. People don't think innovation is helping them anymore. Look at the anger at data centers, no one believes AI is going to benefit them. It's a very bad thing that people think this, but it's also rational. They see how it's used for pricing bullshit and surveillance and layoffs, on the vague promise from the financiers behind it that it *might* cure cancer one day. They see the narrow control of technology as all about extraction for a dominant few. It's not the Jetson's anymore. Some neat launch innovations don't change that.
Maybe the collapse of that consensus doesn't bother you, or maybe you think it can be reconstituted via the same path used to destroy it. But you should think about it, because on this consensus rests your empire. And that's not even factoring in the reality that if we regulated our systems competently, AI might actually cure cancer instead of raising the price to treat it.
At any rate, my view is what makes America awesome is that we set up our institutions so ordinary people can do extraordinary things. We are all, in the end, quite ordinary, but also touched with the divine. And that includes you. So good job to your team for what they accomplished. Most of them likely know they stood on the shoulders of giants, and that they contributed to the great flow of human knowledge that goes back thousands of years.
The AST / Blacklift blog post is up!
Like @astrorahul_ has noted, every launch and satellite company converges in the end because the way to capture the most value is by vertically integrating, partly due to very high launch gross margins.
When a Falcon 9 costs $15M and sells for $70M, the obvious incentive for constellations is to build their own launch vehicles and for launch companies to build their own internal payloads.
I added a section at the bottom analyzing AST's business with MNOs in contrast to Starlink Mobile, and the MNO strategy is obviously paying off with ~3 billion users available and $1.2B in commited revenue.
Internalizing launch is the right call for AST from a strategic perspective. They'll likely be years behind schedule and spend far more than expected, but given expected future revenue (if they survive) this is a relatively small price to pay vs the gross margins of launch.
@daveginvesting, as promised
ckalitin.github.io/posts/ast…
I've seen a critical number of posts about ASTS's LV that I now must write a blog post.
Building a launch vehicle is the rational decision of any player in market that will be launch-constrained for the foreseeable future, and it allows you to internalize a critical capability that unlocks more markets for you in the future.
The CEO of @StarpathSpace made this point on @ti_morse's podcast a couple of weeks ago:
"We have a date in the back of our heads where if the launch market doesn’t fix itself we are going to go build a launch company and the reason that we have to do it is because um we want our customers to be successful."
(15:22)
The reason Starpath has to consider doing this is because they'll be supplying solar arrays and other components to megaconstellations, and if none of their customers have launch, they have no customers.
Now, the limiting assumption is how long you expect there to be a launch constraint.
SpaceX isn't going to sell you launch, Blue is booked up with Kuiper and internal payloads, Relativity may not sell to you due to eg. Google compute sats, Firefly doesn't seem competent, etc.
That leaves Neutron and Stoke, and you'll have to compete with every other customer for their launch.
Building your own launch vehicle is a hedge against the launch constraint lasting 5-10 years.
Internalizing launch also takes in one of your biggests risks, which has the potential to unlock new markets for you (5x cheaper launch (price vs cost) is a great thing!).
I've seen a critical number of posts about ASTS's LV that I now must write a blog post.
Building a launch vehicle is the rational decision of any player in market that will be launch-constrained for the foreseeable future, and it allows you to internalize a critical capability that unlocks more markets for you in the future.
The CEO of @StarpathSpace made this point on @ti_morse's podcast a couple of weeks ago:
"We have a date in the back of our heads where if the launch market doesn’t fix itself we are going to go build a launch company and the reason that we have to do it is because um we want our customers to be successful."
(15:22)
The reason Starpath has to consider doing this is because they'll be supplying solar arrays and other components to megaconstellations, and if none of their customers have launch, they have no customers.
Now, the limiting assumption is how long you expect there to be a launch constraint.
SpaceX isn't going to sell you launch, Blue is booked up with Kuiper and internal payloads, Relativity may not sell to you due to eg. Google compute sats, Firefly doesn't seem competent, etc.
That leaves Neutron and Stoke, and you'll have to compete with every other customer for their launch.
Building your own launch vehicle is a hedge against the launch constraint lasting 5-10 years.
Internalizing launch also takes in one of your biggests risks, which has the potential to unlock new markets for you (5x cheaper launch (price vs cost) is a great thing!).
Successful day. Two failure modes identified.
I melted about 3-4 kg of brass today, about a fourth of my cannon.
One heating element melted through and the rest of that string sagged down into the main kiln body. No over current or ground fault triggered.
Interestingly, the kiln made a different hum after the fact. The kiln hums due to the current though the coils generating an oscillating magnetic field, which changed after the melt through.
The other failure mode is that the piece of wood below the kiln started smouldering. Very quick heart rate ensued.
I got a spray bottle and splashed the wood, this solved the issue.
Interestingly thid kiln fired for pottery for many decades (presumably decades) with that wood below it without issue. I’m getting to the hottest temperatures this kiln has experienced, right at the end of is life (I’m not playing with it a second after a get my cannon).
Next steps to my cannon:
- replace the two old heating elements (one of which burned through)
- delete wood. (Duh)
On demand software is amazing because I can Claude Code a custom debugging interface in 5 minutes that acts as a specialty oscilloscope for a rotary encoder.
We are so rich
Looks like Nord Space's Titan (5t class) is out and Tempest (10t class) is in
I wonder what trade happened at Nord Space to make this change. Something customer (or internal customer) driven, or realizing a 5t partially reusable vehicle is too small and scaling isn't as difficult as imagined.
NordSpace welcomes Budget 2026 and congratulates the Department of National Defence for making sovereign medium-lift launch a national priority! We have been relentlessly building up to Tempest, our reusable 10,000+ kg medium-lift vehicle, powered by our scalable patent-pending Hadfield engine technology, and dedicated medium-lift launch pads at SLC-01 at our Atlantic Spaceport Complex (ASX) in Newfoundland and Labrador.
Backed by a national rocket propulsion ecosystem and dedicated launch and test infrastructure, this budget is the right call for Canada’s sovereignty, security and economy. The budget names three key pillars, and NordSpace has been building all three with cadence, focus and efficiency:
🚀 Launch Vehicles: Our launch program was architected from day one to reach medium lift by 2032. Taiga, launching from the ASX, will be the first commercial liquid rocket to launch from Canadian soil in the coming weeks. Tundra follows with a 1,100 kg to orbit capability, and both pave the way for Tempest, our reusable medium-lift vehicle designed to deliver more than 10,000 kg to orbit. This stepwise approach balances economic and technical risk for Canada and NordSpace, and is the way the most successful companies, from SpaceX to Rocket Lab, have built medium-lift launch.
🔥 Propulsion: Our patent-pending 3D-printed Hadfield liquid rocket propulsion system is built to scale to medium-lift. Critical aspects of it will be proven in flight on Taiga and Tundra before it powers Tempest. Every launch of Taiga and Tundra will retire risk on the path to medium-lift for Tempest, while opening new markets and serving critical commercial and government missions.
🏗️ Infrastructure: ASX, supported by DND through a recent $20M contract, is Canada’s largest spaceport and uniquely selected, designed and built to be a sovereign site that can support medium-lift launch safely and reliably, with over 6,000 acres of necessary safety clearances and environmental approvals in place. Area 66 is Canada’s largest propulsion test centre where multiple engine test cells are being commissioned and our Hadfield engines have been tested countless times for years. Together, the ASX and Area 66 form the backbone of the national launch and test infrastructure this budget calls for.
Milestone-based, competitive support rewards companies that build hardware and test it. For a company focused on cadence and execution, this is exactly what we needed to hear. Canada is the only G7 nation without its own launch capability, and we intend to change that. We are ready to work with the Government of Canada to get it done, and launch the North!
Ad astra per aspera 🚀🇨🇦
@NationalDefence @DRDC_RDDC @csa_asc @Transport_gc
@DavidMcGuinty @SeanFraserMP @stevenmackinnon @TonyWakehamNL
1
20
1,317
EVEN MORE PROGRESS!
Claude one-shotted building the schematic for the Tesla shunt resistor just from multimeter continuity and resistance probes and a picture of it.
Amazing work
Great Progress Tonight!
The unknown differential amplifier is a Texas Instruments LM2903! I misread "Q" as "G" and wasted at least half an hour, such is life.
I've got most of an annotated picture with net labels done.
Found the SPI lines, differential amplifier circuit, clock lines going from STM8 to the ADC IC, and lots more.
Interestingly, one of the shunt terminals seems to be tied to VSS - unfortunate, I wanted this not to require an isolated power supply.
I have not yet gone past where others have before me, but I'm well on my way. This will at the very least be the most well documented exploration of the 2012 Tesla Model S Shunt.
Interestingly, the 3-wire "SPI-like" communication protocol between the STM8 and the ADC uses the STM's TIM2 / ADC pin for data communication.
Could it be an ADC reading a digital bus? Or is this far too silly to even suggest? Maybe it's just used as a GPIO.
I unfortunately wasn't able to to figure out the connection between the op-amp and ADC, tomorrow I'll review diff amp circuit to get a better idea of what's going on.
Another amazing thing, I managed to scrape off the plastic coating on top of all the ICs and get very good looks at their markings! This is how I figured out the G vs Q issue.
Next time I find the connection between the op-amp and the ADC and finally start talking to it over SPI!
It'd also be interesting to probe UART to see if anything is going on. The RX pin doesn't have a test pad while TX does, so I'm guessing it's outputting something.
































