The road map of Fannie and Freddie.
$FNMA $FMCC
@SecScottBessent
@StephenM
@pulte
@realDonaldTrump
docs.google.com/presentation…
Citizen retweeted
Is keeping Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac trapped in an 18-year conservatorship actually protecting homeowners, or is the status quo masking the real drivers of today’s mortgage rates?
The prevailing Washington narrative claims that ending the conservatorship and returning $FNMA and $FMCC to private shareholders will inevitably widen mortgage spreads and push borrowing costs even higher. It sounds plausible on the surface, which is why trade groups and status quo defenders repeat it constantly.
Empirical evidence tells a different story.
Prior to the 2008 conservatorship, when Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac operated as private corporations with an implicit backstop, the mortgage spread to the 10-year treasury averaged roughly 140 to 170 bps. Over the past several years under full federal conservatorship, that same spread blew out to 230 to 300+ bps, only recently compressing back toward ~200 bps. Government control did not produce tighter spreads, and private ownership never prevented them.
Second, today’s elevated mortgage spreads have almost nothing to do with Fannie and Freddie’s ownership structure. The bulk of the spread is driven by negative convexity, extension risk, and the historic lock-in effect. Because millions of homeowners are sitting on sub-4% mortgages with zero incentive to refinance or move, prepayment speeds collapsed while interest rate volatility surged. The combination of these factors has forced MBS investors to demand wider spreads to compensate for duration risk. Fannie and Freddie did not cause that rate volatility. Those distortions are the consequence of years of unsustainable debt issuance, poor fiscal and monetary policy choices, and geopolitical instability.
Third, the mechanism to preserve market stability during an exit already exists; even better is that it requires zero Congressional action! Under Section 2 of the Senior Preferred Stock Purchase Agreements, Treasury still holds $254 billion in undrawn funding commitment ($113.9 billion for Fannie Mae and $140.2 billion for Freddie Mac) that can survive a release from conservatorship. Treasury and the FHFA can restructure or deem the existing Senior Preferred Stock satisfied, leave that $254 billion line intact as a pseudo-explicit guarantee for catastrophic tail/black swan risk, and reinstate the Periodic Commitment Fee so taxpayers are paid ongoing compensation for standing behind it. Even a 25 bps commitment fee on that $254 billion line generates roughly $635 million a year in direct revenue for Treasury. This is a very nominal expense easily absorbed by the GSEs' net income while formalizing the backstop.
@SecScottBessent plays chess, and he understands the value of asymmetric information and controlling the key squares before making a move. Bond desks react to headlines long before they examine the details, so telegraphing an exit before the backstop and bank capital rules are locked in only invites unnecessary volatility and political noise.
If that $254 billion line is paired with a paid commitment fee, the fear over widening spreads evaporates. At that point, keeping Fannie and Freddie in conservatorship isn't protecting the borrower - it's protecting the status quo!
Citizen retweeted
Full deep-dive presentation on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac stress test results; with implications for capital requirements
Happy Veterans 🇺🇸( Armistice) Day to all our soldiers. 🫡
Fun fact: $FNMA
206
Citizen retweeted
$FNMA $FMCC
Um...
Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac shareholders should find this highly encouraging.
@DavidShafer is an F2 friend we’re happy to see in the White House.
Great question from @dragonstoscale last week!
Great catch, @realJoshuaRich, on the previous posts from David & making the connection with @pulte's repost this evening!
Big wheels keep on turnin'!
GLTA.
xitter.gq/pulte/status/212032438…
Citizen retweeted
Replying to @SecretaryTurner @POTUS
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac need to exit the conservatorship for this Administration to be truly "Housing First"!
It’s Miller Time.
Mr. President, enjoy the High Life.
@realDonaldTrump
@StephenM $fnma
@pulte
@SecScottBessent
@howardlutnick
@BillAckman
@HorsemanCountry
@nicosintichakis @Wize_Markets @TylerEHand @usnavycmdr
@DoNotLose @World_21m
27
Citizen retweeted
Replying to @SecScottBessent @POTUS
@SecScottBessent you have the perfect vehicle to fund Trump Accounts by monetizing warrants in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac!
Citizen retweeted
$FNMA $FMCC
If anything, the midterm results accelerate DJT's plans for Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac.
He knows the existential threat to the U.S. economy if the Democrats regain control of this massive, ever-growing piggy bank.
247wallst.com/investing/2026…
Citizen retweeted
An important read on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and the political implications of Democratic Party control of the two companies.
These comments deserve far more attention. The 18 year old conservatorship of $FNMA and $FMCC poses a long term risk to the housing market. @BillAckman highlighted these issues recently. He warned that leaving the GSEs in limbo leaves them vulnerable to inefficiency and political weaponization.
At the risk of going into too much detail here is a synopsis or his talking points and perhaps a few of my own:
Political Weaponization: F2 have a very large war chest and an indefinite conservatorship leaves trillions of dollars in cash generating mortgage capacity under absolute bureaucratic control. A change in administration can instantly weaponize this control to push social and political agendas, shifting the GSEs from neutral market utilities to partisan tools.
Distorting credit allocations: When the federal government controls the flow of capital, mortgage access can be manipulated based on political favoritism rather than merit. It has been pointed out that using Fannie and Freddie to grant mortgages on highly favorable, non-economic terms creates massive structural instability.
The spectre of the GFC: This exact dynamic precipitated the original 2007–2008 financial crisis. Prior to the crash, HUD progressively raised affordable housing quotas for the GSEs, forcing them to absorb toxic, unqualified loans to satisfy political homeownership agendas. Keeping them in conservatorship preserves the exact mechanism that allowed that crisis to happen.
Spreads are historically wide: Currently, the spread between the 30 year mortgage rate and the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield is highly elevated; sitting near 215 to 217 basis points, well above the historical average of ~150 basis points. This massive gap heavily penalizes everyday homebuyers with higher borrowing costs. The fact that spreads are wider than before the GFC dispels the notion that conservatorship suppresses the spreads. An explicit line of credit backstop may be more effective.
Government overreach widens the gap: Policy interventions such as mandates that alter mortgage callability or complicate refinancing rules increase risk premiums for MBS investors. This added policy uncertainty drives up the yields investors demand, directly widening mortgage spreads. Separately, nonpecuniary aspects like eleveated rates/duration risk up this demand and have nothing to do with F2.
Privatization can actually remove uncertainty: Formalizing privatization, acknowledging the GSEs' massive capital buffers, and executing a structured exit would eliminate the "political risk premium" hanging over the MBS market. Restoring the GSEs to the private market under fixed capital guidelines is the most direct path to compressing today’s bloated spreads.
The bailout is repaid: The narrative that Fannie and Freddie are a liability to the taxpayer is completely false. While the government injected $191 billion during the crisis, the GSEs have paid back over $301 billion to the Treasury.
Unlocking 100s of billions in value: Rather than a rushed IPO that risks destabilizing the market, the administration can immediately exercise its warrants for a 79.9% common stock stake (Subject to the SPS/LP repayment stated above) and relist the companies on the New York Stock Exchange. This "walk before you run" strategy would safely remove roughly $8 trillion in liabilities from the federal balance sheet while netting taxpayers a massive "mark-to-market" windfall.


























