Considering the state of GTA VI and all the media coverage around it, I'm going against my principles and voting for OoT despite it being a remake.
I want more games like OoT and not like GTA VI.
These are the only categories that had any interesting picks for me.
I'd either not played enough of the games in other categories, or the selection was actual ass.
While I did like the Zelda OoT remake, I'm not picking it for GOTY. 90% of that game came out in 1998, not 2026.
14
Because Emily stops breathing/dies, mutates into a giant monster which Leon shoots, then gets cured with a macguffin and is just fine? The macguffin even cures her cataracts.
It's just outright stupid, even in context. The game breaks its back to make Emily live.
9
These are the only categories that had any interesting picks for me.
I'd either not played enough of the games in other categories, or the selection was actual ass.
While I did like the Zelda OoT remake, I'm not picking it for GOTY. 90% of that game came out in 1998, not 2026.
Played through most of Queens Domain, a game inspired by (not a copy of) Kings Field and a bunch of other old school games. However, I've decided not to 100% it/get the best ending.
Personally I found the game to have a very strong start, but peter out as it goes along.
It has some neat twists and turns, especially mid game, and the freedom in the exploration is very well done which is why I'm being very general/vague.
Though I personally didn't like how the end game is essentially a scavenger hunt, and I found re-running old areas to be quite boring, hence why I'm dropping it.
I do recommend it however, it is a great game for players who enjoy old-school adventure/RPG games, even if I didn't enjoy the late game.
47
Decided to bite the bullet and get TotK.
I will admit the reason I didn't get it earlier was because I didn't want the series to go in its/BotW's direction, and it looked way too similar to BotW as well.
With the OoT remake coming out putting me in a Zelda mood, and it's been long enough since I played BotW, I'm more receptive to giving TotK a fair go.
6
Ah fuck it. My Zelda Tier List (and the version I played).
None of these games are bad. I still enjoyed the games in C tier.
I regard the OG OoT higher than the remake, but they are close (a lot of give and takes, and cba to make an A+ for it). I'm mainly disappointed the remake didn't add anything new dungeon wise.
I've tried LttP multiple times but it never grabs me.
Yes I like Zelda 2 more than Zelda 1.
52






















