John Derbyshire (@DissidentRight) profile picture

Writer, podcaster

Long Island
Joined January 2015
Photo by John Derbyshire (@DissidentRight)Photo by John Derbyshire (@DissidentRight)Photo by John Derbyshire (@DissidentRight)Photo by John Derbyshire (@DissidentRight)Photo by John Derbyshire (@DissidentRight)Photo by John Derbyshire (@DissidentRight)Photo by John Derbyshire (@DissidentRight)
Scientific American current headline: "Anthropic mathematician claims to prove Riemann hypothesis, most famous problem in all of math." scientificamerican.com/ If you don't know what the Riemann hypothesis is, I can recommend a most excellent book that explains it in a way anyone can understand. johnderbyshire.com/Books/Pri… Every household should have a copy!
10
31
2
127
4,852
Is philocaption johnderbyshire.com/Reviews/C… still a thing? Just wondering: I keep reading articles about the Dating Recession georgetownvoice.com/2026/02/…
2
1
12
785
The air traffic shutdown brought to mind E.M. Forster's 1909 short story THE MACHINE STOPS, a classic of early sci-fi. Closing lines: "Oh, tomorrow—some fool will start the Machine again, tomorrow." "Never," said Kuno, "never. Humanity has learnt its lesson." As he spoke, the whole city was broken like a honeycomb. An air-ship had sailed in through the vomitory into a ruined wharf. It crashed downwards, exploding as it went, rending gallery after gallery with its wings of steel. For a moment they saw the nations of the dead, and, before they joined them, scraps of the untainted sky.
5
12
131
3,985
My suggestion on Monday xitter.gq/DissidentRight/status/… that Stephen Miller should run for President in 2028 got a surprising number of comments, mostly negative. For as far through them as I could be bothered to read, the chief grounds for the negativity were (1) Miller's a Jew, and (2) Miller's a Nazi. Hoo-kay. So here we have a patriotic 41-year-old male U.S. citizen by birth, presentable-looking and extremely articulate in speech, well-educated and obviously very intelligent, with a photogenic family (wife, four kids), 20 years in politics and no record of malfeasance that I'm aware of. Why is it preposterous that he should run for office? Just six years ago 80 million Americans voted into office as President a mumbling, stumbling 78-year-old congressional time-server with a junkie son who had parlayed his father's position into dubious deals with Chinese and Ukrainian counterparties. Were any of my commenters who think Stephen Miller is unfit for office among those 80 million? Whatever. I shall go ahead anyway to order the printing of T-shirts, baseball caps, and coffee mugs. It's never too soon to prepare. MILLER '28!
Am I really the first person to suggest this? Is it really so far-fetched? STEPHEN MILLER FOR 2028!
55
24
272
5,665
Am I really the first person to suggest this? Is it really so far-fetched? STEPHEN MILLER FOR 2028!
389
19
16
276
25,806
* September 2001: Radical Muslims fly planes into the World Trade Center, killing 3,000 people. * 2001-2026: Successive U.S. governments open up the country to settlement by unprecidentedly great numbers of Muslims. The number of mosques goes from dozens to thousands. * November 2026: Muslims -- including outspoken radical Muslims -- are voted into positions of legislative and judicial power all over the U.S.A. ------------- Make it make sense.
59
98
5
540
8,170
The 2026 Nobel Prize in literature went to Canadian poet Anne Carson. If you want to sample her verse, fans of REAL poetry have been tossing and goring it on X xitter.gq/ProfGrewal/status/2108… My own reaction is the common one: If this is poetry, what is NOT poetry? You want poetry? I got poetry. How about a sestina? You're welcome. johnderbyshire.com/Readings/…
I honestly just don’t get poetry. Why is this good?
6
7
1
61
2,028
My kids are in their thirties now, so I'm out of touch with the high-school curriculum. Do today's students hear anything about the horrors of 20th-century socialism? About 1970s Cambodia, for example? Back in 2000 I reviewed David Chandler's book about the Tuol Sleng interrogation center. Here is the closing paragraph of my review. "Professor Chandler has done his work well, with the frank objectivity that is the only possible approach to such a catalog of madness. This is a necessary book, but a profoundly dismaying and depressing one. Its message is simple: never, ever let middle-class revolutionary intellectuals take control of your country. If by mischance they do, run like hell." johnderbyshire.com/Reviews/C…
16
18
153
4,533
I'm just reading Dennis Duncan's 2021 book INDEX, A HISTORY OF THE amazon.com/Index-History-Adv… No typo there: that's the name of the book. It's a history of indexes in books. And yes, before you ask, it has an index itself. Lots of curious facts here. I've chugged along these past few decades assuming that the only work of fiction that includes an index as part of itself (I mean, not added by an editor for some study edition) was Nabokov's PALE FIRE. Nah-uh, there are lots of them. Lewis Carroll wrote one. Lewis Carroll! (Although, as Dennis Duncan observes, "entries in the SYLVIE AND BRUNO index lean determinedly towards the whimsical.") Duncan's book caught my eye because I myself once compiled a book index. The book I was indexing was neither fiction nor nonfiction but a humongous two-volume catalogue. My index covered 42 pages in different languages and alphabets. Sample page here johnderbyshire.com/Miscellan… Back story to my indexing adventure here johnderbyshire.com/FamilyAlb…
3
3
27
1,413
I agree with Niall Ferguson: this Bill Maher item is a gem xitter.gq/billmaher/status/21138… The original communists told us we were heading for class warfare. What we're speeding towards right now looks more like age warfare. Might it get ugly -- uglier than in France today? In Aldous Huxley's novel BRAVE NEW WORLD (if I remember it right), citizens who reached the age of 60 were hustled off to a euthanasia facility. Might that policy soon be a vote-getter? (NB: I'm 81.)
One reason young people want socialism so much is that they're jealous that older people have it and they don't.
11
11
1
83
4,121
What's my take on the Russia-Ukraine War? My primary take remains the one I voiced in April 2022, when the war was new. This was, I pointed out -- with supporting statistics -- a war between the world's two most corrupt white nations. johnderbyshire.com/Opinions/… That's likely still true, but I haven't checked the stats recently. I liked that descriptor so much I went on using it in my weekly podcast until I hung up my mike in June 2025.
21
7
132
4,273
If the woke biases in Wikipedia annoy you, be aware (if you're not already -- I always come late to these parties) that Elon Musk has given us an alternative: Grokipedia. Here's the entry for me: grokipedia.com/page/John_Der…
16
16
1
148
4,309
Blimey! My post exposing the awfulness of Greyhound buses xitter.gq/DissidentRight/status/… has gathered 85 comments. That's more than Desikishu's video clip about the mermaid whose tail came off. xitter.gq/desikishu/status/21054… (and most of HIS comments were from himself). It's way more than my usual low-single-digits score. I don't think I shall ever get the hang of social media.
एक बड़े मॉल के अंदर एक विशाल एक्वेरियम बना हुआ था, जहाँ एक लड़की जलपरी की रंग-बिरंगी पोशाक पहनकर पानी में शो कर रही थी। बच्चे और बड़े सभी शीशे के बाहर से उसे देखकर खुश हो रहे थे और वीडियो बना रहे थे। लड़की पानी में तैरते हुए सबका हाथ हिलाकर अभिवादन कर रही थी। तभी...Read news
5
1
43
4,671
Very sorry to see my President pandering to the parasites and crooks at Hesperophobia Hall johnderbyshire.com/Opinions/…
1
4
1
31
3,466
The news about recent advances in Artificial Intelligence has mathematicians slitting their wrists all over. AI is impressively good at math. Do we still need human mathematicians? Most recently, earlier this month, OpenAI claimed that one of their models had cracked the Navier-Stokes equation. (All right: "equations," if you want to be fussy.) As much as a lay person needs to know about Navier-Stokes was covered in my Straggler No. 117 column last year: johnderbyshire.com/Opinions/… (The relevant paragraph is the one beginning "So: turbulence ahead.") Has OpenAI really cracked Navier-Stokes? My buddy Sergiu Klainerman, writing on the Heterodox STEM substack, says not: "In truth, what the machine did was to settle a much weaker version of the problem." hxstem.substack.com/p/ai-wil… So: impressive? certainly, but not final. Sergiu again: "There are many risks associated with the uses and misuses of AI. The extinction of mathematics as a human endeavor is not among them." Math geeks, put away those razor blades.
9
10
2
82
4,293
Peter Brimelow reports that "The VDARE Foundation just got yet MORE bad news in its lawfare hell, which has now lasted nearly four and a half years." This latest bad news is a ruling by a federal judge (Biden appointee, natch) essentially pushing VDARE's claims that their Free Speech rights have been violated back to New York State for judgment. A senior officer in that state's judiciary has already boasted -- in public! (Peter supplies the video) -- of using lawfare to suppress opinions the state Attorney General disapproves of. peterbrimelow.com/p/do-feder…
2
22
3
104
9,565