Eric E retweeted
I'm tired, guys.
I'm tired of the gaslighting. I'm tired of the bullshit. I'm tired of people falling for really stupid propaganda and damaging our country in the process.
The American right deserves better than another grifting influencer constantly mewling about why everything is hopeless.
I'm also tired of watching people who built their audiences on the right all of the sudden spend their time convincing those same Americans that everything they supported was a lie.
Trump made a mistake, thus the whole agenda was now a scam. He struck Iran, thus tiny Israel somehow owns our government. If someone mentions an accomplishment, instead of acknowledging it, it's met with whataboutism and 'you're an Epstien elite, a pedo protector, or whatever conspiracy theory is trending that week.'
But Trump also delivered on a lot with a major thin margin in Congress full of people who shows little interest in helping.
CPB reported 8,288 southwest border apprehensions in October 2026, which is 95 percent below Biden's monthly average. DHS and BP are reporting over 3 million deportations and 800k illegals arrested in under two years. Those are significant numbers that are being completely ignored by Podcastistan and the American left.
Substantial changes happened at the border, which Trump 100% kept his promise one.
Trump also signed tax deductions for tips and overtime. He promised working Americans tax relief and followed through on it.
NATO allies agreed at The Hague to spend 5% of their GDP on defense and related security needs. Trump pushed them to that agreement.
Trump also brought in $11+ trillion in new U.S. investment commitments, bringing back industry, energy, and SI to America. There are now 111 billion barrels of proven oil reserves under US control thanks to our actions in Venezuela. We have exported over 100 million metric tons of LNG. We are drilling like never before and Trump oversaw $1.3 trillion in deregulatory actions, which is the most in history.
Oh, and he significantly shrunk the federal workforce.
Those are all promises that Donald Trump made and kept, yet people that supposedly voted for him but now claim he betrayed them love to say he did nothing that he promised.
Tucker Carlson said that the election was a punishment for Trump doing the opposite of what he promised. Apparently the border, tax change, and the rest of the accomplishments I just listed were just nothing burgers, right?
In June 2025, Candace Owens told Piers Morgan that the decison to strike Iran belonged to Netanyahu: "This was not Trump's decision, it was Bibi Netanyahu's decision."
Was there any proof behind this accusation? Of course not.
In March 2026, Tucker Carlson presented the conflict as Israel's war. He cited Democratic Senator Mark Warner's assessment that Iran posed no imminent threat to America, then declared that Americans were fighting Israel's battle. You know, normal right wing stuff to propagate left wing Democratic talking points and push them as fact, right?
The Hodge twins' March episode with Alex Jones used chapter labels announcing that Americans would "DIE for Israel" and that "MAGA left Us" as they jumped fully into doomer Podcastistan mode.
Jimmy Dore and Owen Shroyer also did a show in March and argued that Trump had made an arrangement with the Israeli lobby (you know the boogeyman lobby controlling America, despite not being in the top 10 in either domestic nor foreign lobbies) and technology interests to pursue regime change in Iran. They posed it all as hypothesis, of course, because there was no proof of any of it actually happening.
Shawn Ryan asked Michael Lester on March 19th whether America was going to war with Iran for Israel, building the entire episode around a question that has only ever been a question, never anything answered with any semblance of truth. You can guess how that episode went, as it became a staple of Shawn's embrace of the Podcastistan doomer narrative.
Then Matt Walsh joined in and started pushing the same nonsense. Everyone that understood the reasonings behind attacking Iran was all of the sudden a neocon and a foreign shill. It was Israel's war. All of the lefty talking points that the right so gullibly embraced.
But what they all did was repeat the message that Trump betrayed his voters, that Israel controlled all of his decisions, and that Americans had been taken for fools.
So, let's talk about the Iran war without the fan fiction.
The State Department attributed at least 603 American deaths in Iraq to the Iranian regime. In January 2024, three more Americans were killed by an Iran backed drone attack in Jordan, under Biden. In November 2024, DOJ exposed an IRGC linked plot that included a plan to kill Trump.
Those families have a much better reason to care about Tehran than whatever Netanyahu wanted.
And that doesn't even consider all of the terrorist proxies Iran funds and directs to harm American interests throughout the Middle East and Northern Africa.
I absolutely supported hitting the regime's ability to kill Americans and choke off the region. The public intel on the nuclear program was messy, and no one ever established an imminent Iranian nuke (not that such intelligence would actually reach the public under any situation), but as of November 18, the US and three European governments were still warning that the IAEA couldn't account for Iran's nuclear material and inspectors were being kept out of the one place the world needed them.
Calling it a war of choice never explains the alternative. More sanctions? Another deal? Walk away? Every option has a price tag that most of you are unwilling to talk about.
Look at the map.
The “pivot to China” crowd should probably start by checking China’s fuel gauge. Before this war, roughly one-fifth of the planet’s petroleum liquids squeezed through Hormuz, and in early 2025, 89% of the crude transiting there was bound for Asia. The Gulf and the Indo-Pacific aren’t separate theaters—they’re stitched together by the tankers running the route and our actions in Iran showed them that not only can we run theater level operations, but we can also shut down any choke point on earth that we see fit and there is nothing anyone else can do about it.
That is an unmatched power that the US possesses, yet Podcastistan will never admit it.
Oh, and Iran also arms Russia, and though Russia, China, Iran, and North Korea aren't a formal bloc, ignoring their cooperation in our planning is stupid.
Oil is part of the argument as well. Brent dropped from $107.03 on November 3 to $91.84 on November 4. Trouble in those lanes reaches American wallets fast and then magically disappeared after the midterms, but did anything actually change in Iran from a month ago? No.
So why the price change? Because it was all setup on speculation and on punishing the Trump administration for acting so that propagandists could blame it all on the admin.
And of course we have to discuss the Israel alliance that so many idiots love to trash while knowing absolutely nothing about it.
How about we judge it by what Americans get from it. The Trophy active protection system on our Abrams tanks came out of a joint US-Israeli effort. The Marine Corps' Medium Range Intercept Capability pairs Tamir interceptors and Iron Dome components with American radar to protect Marines from aerial threats.
Anyone calling the whole relationship a one way giveaway has to explain those massive benefits we receive, not to mention the trade, tech, and other strategic reasons for the alliance.
Sure, you can scrutinize the aid and even scrutinize the conditions. That's how an alliance works. But two countries wanting the same enemy capability destroyed doesn't prove Israel controls America, and neither do fairy tales created over a hundred years ago.
Trump owns his decisions. Congress owns what it funds. Blaming a hidden foreign hand lets them off the hook and makes the entire problem undiagnosable, which is actually the entire point of the propaganda in the first place.
Then there's the antisemitism, and it's right there.
Criticizing aid, lobbying, airstrikes, or Netanyahu is normal politics. Claiming Jews control everything is something else, and that is exactly where 99% of the anti-Israel sentiment really comes from.
The Hodge twins' March 30 episode with Stew Peters had chapters titled "We Are Israel's B****! and The Talmudists Want EVERYTHING!" Owens promoted Der Talmudjude, a nineteenth century antisemitic polemic. Carlson gave Nick Fuentes an extended interview and a bigger audience, and Fuentes's views were already notorious.
The Protocols of the Elders of Zion sold the same story: a hidden Jewish power pulling every string. It was a forgery. It survives because it hands angry people an easy target. And yes, it was absolutely created to confuse and control illiterate peasants in Tsarist Russia.
But that's the woke right: Collective guilt, permanent grievance, and a secret system behind everything. Disagree with them and you're part of the system. Slapping a conservative label or some Christian language on it doesn't change what it really is, guys.
Treating American Jews as agents of a foreign government is disgraceful. If you claim to defend Western civilization, learn where this garbage came from.
And to the people who say my service was for Israel: I swore an oath to the United States of America's Constitution and none other.
I expect the people who send Americans into combat to explain the mission and own the results, but I'm sick of hearing our service reduced to working for Israel. It writes off the American interests involved and treats those who served like props in somebody else's conspiracy.
The Air Force says Operation Epic Fury flew about 10,000 sorties and hit more than 13,000 objectives in 38 days. Those American service members deserve appropriate credit for these monumental feats in an otherwise denied theater. They also deserve leaders with a strategy that turns military results into something lasting, because the June agreement collapsed, limited strikes resumed, and the regime is still standing.
Veterans disagree about this war, and we've earned the right to argue about it. But every time someone uses our service to sell a Jewish control conspiracy, I'm going to object. Show the evidence, or shut the hell up.
We have to stop buying permanent defeat.
Foreign governments love a grievance they can exploit. In July 2024, the DNI said Iranian actors were posing as activists, encouraging protests, and funding them, sometimes without Americans knowing who they were dealing with.
Remember, this was always the plan of Democrats and the left, and they did not even have to push it on their own thanks to Podcastistan: Dismiss every accomplishment, turn every mistake into betrayal, and call every alliance foreign control, and people stop expecting anything from their own country.
Meanwhile, there's always another episode to sell.
I want the right back to using its convictions. Name the failing policy. Explain the fix. Hold officials to their promises and give them credit when they deliver.
Trump and his administration should answer for his failures and the people who built audiences supporting him should answer for what part they played in destroying the right's momentum and handing a massive victory to Democrats in the midterms.
I refuse to outsource my thinking to a president, a party, or a podcaster.
The American right should refuse too.
Eric E retweeted
Oh yes… it’s happening. 👀
🚨 Judy Shelton, the GOLD Standard Lady, says she’s not allowed to discuss her new secret role w/ Scott Bessent at the U.S. Treasury
“I think me be given this new position as counselor to the Treasury Secretary is good news— the bad news though is that I’m not supposed to discuss my work. That was the stipulation I was given— I needed to get permission to give this speech— I was given approval and told I could offer my thoughts, but I could not say anything that encompasses my official duties.”
rumble.com/v7ioug0-judy-shel…
Eric E retweeted
What really was Yalta? This week, the lamestream media called the Big Three meeting in China, Yalta 2.0. They were stunned when President Putin asked, "what was wrong with Yalta? " It has been portrayed as the leaders of Britain, the U.S., and Russia carving up the world and sacrificing eastern Europe to communism. But that is a false history. Franklin Roosevelt had a different idea--dismantle the British colonial empire after the war and conspire with Stalin to do so. Roosevelt was not dewy eyed about Stalin. But he knew that the British Empire was even more evil and that Russia had lost 27 million people in securing an end to the fascism which British and American elites had initiated. Go back and read the correspondence between Stalin and Roosevelt here. larouchepub.com/other/book_r… It will open your eyes to how power in history actually operates.
Eric E retweeted
Democrats: "I miss when our presidents didn't cozy up to dictators."
Reality: Obama cozying up to Cuban dictator Raúl Castro at a baseball game in Havana 👇
Eric E retweeted
To all the pussies saying grown men shouldn't be playing video games:
We were playing Call of Duty between combat missions in Iraq and Afghanistan.
We carried rifles, wore body armor, and went outside the wire into actual war zones. Then we'd come back, grab a controller, and play video games.
If combat veterans can enjoy gaming after a day of fighting a war, I'm pretty sure grown men can enjoy it after a day at work.
Being a man isn't defined by your hobbies. Grow the fuck up.
Eric E retweeted
🚨 NOW: President Trump just put Mexico AND Canada on notice in the same breath.
Trump says he told Mexico's Claudia Sheinbaum they're close to a trade deal, but America WILL NOT ACCEPT a big trade surplus against us.
He told her straight: "THE CARTELS ARE RUNNING MEXICO," and we cannot let that happen next door.
On Canada, Trump says Prime Minister Carney wants to build the Keystone pipeline. Trump says that's good, but Canada has to do A LOT MORE.
He says Canada has been ripping us off for 50 years.
No more free rides from our neighbors. America First.
Eric E retweeted
This is how tariffs work. A foreign steel company realized that the best way to access the US market was to invest and build inside it instead of exporting to it. Tariffs created a price premium, which attracted investment and new capacity - allowing the price to come back down.
A year after its takeover of U.S. Steel, Nippon Steel is revitalizing the Edgar Thomson steel mill, making preparations for a new plant, and is expected to generate thousands of jobs and more than $1.7 billion in economic activity for Pennsylvania.
"Whether it's for reindustrialization or to compete against Chinese overproduction, the US and Japan are very structurally compatible," @WillRevenge told @riverakiradavis.
Nippon Steel-U.S. Steel-style investments show how "Japanese expertise, capital, and technology can reinvigorate US manufacturing," Chou said.
Read more in @nytimes: nytimes.com/2026/11/18/busin…
Why is this so important?
Dialogue helps prevent conflict.
In the past, the EU cabal puppets, would dictate who was acceptable and who was excluded.
They would determine who was invited to all the important meetings involving world leaders.
The EU would purposely “isolate” particular world leaders and paint them as “enemies.”
Recently Putin has been excluded, even though Russia is a super power and one of the biggest energy suppliers and economies in the world.
Why?
Because Putin got rid of the Rothschilds controlled central bank and doesn’t take orders from the EU.
Putin protects his people and the SOVEREIGNTY of Russia.
That goes completely against the globalists agenda.
The globalists promote WAR.
And in order to start WARS, you need to promote “enemies.”
“Enemies” like Russia, North Korea and Venezuela.
Trump is now “publicly” allied with all three and has completely ended any prospect of WAR with them.
And Trump is making deals with them to replace antagonism with economic prosperity and cooperation.
Globalism is dead.
SOVEREIGNTY is being made great again.
Now who is isolated?
The EU and the very puppets who promote WAR for profit, are now left out of the world changing events.
.@POTUS at the trilateral meeting with President Xi and President Putin: "We have a special responsibility to maintain open, respectful, and productive dialogue on issues impacting not just our people, but the entire planet. Too often past leaders avoided talking to nations with whom they had disagreements — and we feel the opposite."
Eric E retweeted
"Affordability"
Y'all need to shut your yaps and realize you were suckered by an Information Operation.
Life under Trump is more "affordable" than it was under Biden. Don't believe me? Look at Grok's analysis below.
The problem is that Biden caused so much damage, and that damage cannot be instantly reversed. However, Donald Trump has done as good a job as any human being could have done to improve things in two short years.
Not good enough though, right? We have an "affordability crisis" thanks to Trump, right?
Lies. All lies.
But lies that were believed by so many MAGAs that they stayed home on Election Day, did not vote, and HANDED THE FREAKING CONGRESS TO THE VERY PEOPLE WHO ACTUALLY DID CREATE AN AFFORDABILITY CRISIS IN THE FIRST PLACE.
I weep for the way it is so easy to manipulate the minds of Americans to believe lies.
xitter.gq/i/grok/share/c2hhcmQtM…
Eric E retweeted
Just a friendly reminder that Nick Fuentes was outside the Capitol on January 6, encouraging protesters to break through police barriers.
He was never arrested.
Eric E retweeted
EVERY CHILD DESERVES AN UNCLE WHO IS A
QUESTIONABLE INFLUENCE
BUT AN EXCEPTIONAL EMERGENCY CONTACT
Eric E retweeted
These reporters all wrote articles declaring that PizzaGate was fake news.
All of these same reporters were arrested and charged for being pedos.
Probably not a coincidence.
Having coffee with a friend this morning when he suddenly, nervously admitted that he has become particularly racist over the past 2 years
I paused in shock and calmly replied...."why didn't you tell me sooner, I could have been sending you all the funny memes and clips"
☕
Eric E retweeted
What do firearms, drones, and LLMs have in common?
All three are enabling technologies that are so dangerous when exclusively in the hands of potential tyrants that they can never be left to centralized control.
There happens to be a lot of talk about the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis this morning. I say we need a Generalized Second Amendment - that the right to bear arms must include any instruments that can tilt the balance of power between the individual and the state.
Eric E retweeted
Wow. Scott Bessent just reverses his entire line of attack from the last 2 weeks, declaring HE is responsible for China trade policy, not Commerce, and that he now agrees with the President and doesn’t believe it’s wise to blacklist China “we don’t want to decouple, we want to derisk”, endorsing Lutnick’s approach of pushing NVIDIA to self-police chip sales without tipping off the targets with a blacklist in the middle of a clandestine DOJ investigation.
This is a complete 180 from what he’d been pitching to media outlets in recent weeks, blaming Lutnick for China policy and criticizing Commerce for not decoupling from China. Very odd flip flop here…wonder what conversations were had during that China trip for him to change course like this?
Eric E retweeted
跟几个行业里的高管聊了聊,我听到几个让人坐不住的消息:
1. 老黄再不回来,NVDA 可能要迎来一波大辞职潮。
数据不会说谎:英伟达员工2026财年的流失率已从2.5%升至3.7%。78%的员工身家超百万,近一半超2500万美元——想退休随时能退。他们还在干,就是为了老黄。
现在临时CEO(原CFO)上任,大家“再撑一下”的借口没了。管理层承诺加薪、增发股票,但钱解决不了信仰问题。更麻烦的是,董事会已启动新CEO遴选,头号目标是Arm CEO雷内·哈斯——他在英伟达干过7年,算“老熟人”,但空降能补上老黄的窟窿吗?
2. 市场对NVDA未来增长的信心在松动——老黄本身就是护城河。
媒体很少提:老黄特别擅长自上而下的架构设计,关键决策靠他“玄学级”的判断力。CUDA、网络业务、内部团队吵架,最后拍板的永远是老黄。这些决定没法写进流程手册,但每次都决定了Nvidia+整个AI生态往哪儿走。
然后供应链跟着走、资金跟着走、协议跟着走、信心也跟着走。
空降CEO或提拔内部高管,都补不上这个窟窿——台湾代工厂跟老黄攒了十几年的信任,不是换人就能无缝衔接的。老黄一次次押上改变行业的重注,硬是把Nvidia干到5万亿市值。
3. 供应链已经开始松动了——这才是最要命的。
台积电、SK海力士这些伙伴,态度都在变。以前老黄在,都是抢着配合;现在要求英伟达先付预付款才肯排产。
数据更吓人:英伟达的供应与产能承诺达2790亿美元,比上季度暴增1600亿。这些钱是用来锁HBM内存和台积电先进封装产能的。信任没了,合作就要付出真金白银的代价——老黄在时从没这样过。
4. 技术领先度没想象中大。
说领先5年?想多了。其实是不同领域领先几个月到一年不等,是老黄踩油门把节奏拉起来的。
更扎心的是,Anthropic最新路演显示:用AI agent把模型迁移到AMD GPU,只需3天,而以前要6-12个月。CUDA护城河正被AI coding agent动摇——老黄离开越久,衰退来得越快。
一句话总结:NVDA最大的护城河,就是老黄敢做高风险的架构决策,并能把资金、供应商、整个行业的信心拧到他那套愿景上。 现在连台积电、海力士都开始要求先付钱了——信心一旦松动,掉得比股价还快。
$NVDA
@JensenHuang
Eric E retweeted
《中期刚输完,参议院62比33就给懂王送了个大礼:1.8万亿的项目终于能动了》
昨晚参议院62比33,直接把话说清楚了:懂王没跛脚,跛脚的是那帮以为赢了中期就能为所欲为的民主党。
你看投票,14个民主党参议员投了赞成票,连 Schumer 都投了赞成票。Schumer 是谁?民主党在参议院的头头,刚赢了中期,转头就得跟着投这个法案。你说他心里乐意吗?他不乐意也得投,因为这法案是真东西,不投就是跟美国老百姓过不去。
这法案是干嘛的?一句话:把卡了几十年的许可,给捅开了。
1.8万亿美元的项目卡在联邦许可里,管道建不了,矿山开不了,电厂盖不了,输电线拉不了,数据中心想用电都没电。这不是钱的问题,这是美国自己把自己绑住了手脚,绑了几十年,没人敢解。
现在懂王把它解开了,还不是靠行政令解开的,是写进法律里解开的。行政令下任总统一个签字就能撕,法律撕不了,下任总统想推翻,得再过国会那一关。这就是为什么这法案值钱:它把懂王的能源议程钉死了,钉进法律里了。
最解气的是哪一条?数据中心自己建电、自己付电费,不准摊到你家电费单上。
以前那套玩法是什么?数据中心一来,用电暴涨,电网要升级,升级的钱全摊到普通家庭头上。你家电费涨了,你都不知道为什么涨。现在法案写明白了:你数据中心要用那么多电,你自己建,你自己付,别让老百姓给你买单。这条一出,谁还敢说这法案不是为老百姓写的?
再看另一条:给联邦机构设硬期限,环评不能再拖几年,批了的许可不能再被什么激进机构、什么诉讼随便撤掉。以前一个项目,环评拖三年,诉讼拖五年,拖到投资人跑了,工人散了,项目黄了。现在不行了,时间到了就得批,批了就得认。
这对美国意味着什么?意味着美国终于能建东西了。管道、矿山、电厂、输电线,建起来就是高薪工作,能源、采矿、建筑,全是美国人干的活。能源供应上来了,油、气、电都多起来了,老百姓的能源账单才有往下走的可能。不是明天就降,是路终于通了。
对懂王意味着什么?意味着中期输了两院,他手里还是有牌。
民主党赢了中期,赢的是席位,赢不了人心。席位能让你开调查、发传票,席位不能让你建电厂、降电费。懂王这一手,直接把“谁能干实事”这个问题摆到台面上了:你们赢了选举,你们建了什么?他输了选举,他建了什么?62比33,这个数字就是答案,连你们自己人都要投他。
所以众议院赶紧过,Johnson 说有票,那就别墨迹。拖到1月,新国会一来,民主党众议院接手,这法案就可能被改、被拖、被毙。现在是跛脚鸭会期,是最后的窗口,过了这个村就没这个店了。
一句话:中期输了是输了,但这一仗,懂王赢得漂漂亮亮。62比33,14个民主党人跟着投,这不是妥协,这是认输。认的是:美国要建东西,美国要便宜能源,美国要有人干实事。而干实事的人,现在还是懂王。
Eric E retweeted
It feels demeaning to even have to explain this, but:
Amazon is *valued by investors* at about $2.8 trillion, which means they’re willing to buy, say, a 1% ownership share for $28 billion. It does not mean they have a $2.8 trillion pile of gold coins. It’s based on the value of expected future profits. It’s a prediction, not a tangible thing.
Amazon’s *profit margins* are extremely low. The consumer marketplace (how most people interact with amazon) has margins around 4%. (Amazon Web Services has a much higher margin, but almost all their customers are other giant corporations that Mamdani also hates). Furthermore, much of that marketplace revenue is advertising. Stripping this out, direct, conventional margins on Amazon sold products are essentially zero. Think about what that means: Amazon found a way to run a business delivering goods to consumer’s doors at cost. They’ve already achieved the communist dream for regular consumers: giving you what you want, overnight, at cost. And they make a profit at the same time!
How can they be worth so much on margins that thin? Scale! They serve hundreds of millions of consumers, so making even small amounts per consumer translates into a giant total figure.
But that also means that any reduction in their tiny margins tanks the entire business overnight. If government regulation turns the tiny fraction of profit they skim off their huge gross revenue from positive to negative (which, again, would require only a couple-percent tax) then suddenly that entire fraction of their business becomes worthless overnight. Investors leave, amazon shrinks to being just a cloud services provider, and Americans can no longer get overnight delivery of literally anything on Earth - AT COST - overnight. The reason for the investor valuations -expected future profits - collapses, and their is no dragon hoard of gold coins to loot anymore. Poof. You won’t have redistributed trillions. You’ll have deleted it from existence.
It’s not that Mamdani doesn’t understand this, or that he does. He doesn’t have a worldview at all. He is a rhetoric machine designed to optimize his personal power. He doesn’t know or care about the concepts of “outcomes” or “consequences”. The final form of a politician in a mass democracy.
Eric E retweeted
Most climate change debate today treats atmospheric CO₂ as a threat, and modern temperatures as a dangerous anomaly.
But a far more resilent Earth emerges once you step back into deep geological time and see basic plant biology. CO₂ is still the foundational carbon source of all terrestrial life, on a planet still locked in a long-term ice age.
CO₂ comprises roughly 0.04% of Earth's atmosphere. It's not a toxic pollutant though, it's a vital trace gas. Through photosynthesis, plants draw in CO₂ and water to build carbohydrates and release the oxygen every animal and human depends on. Higher atmospheric CO₂ directly stimulates plant growth, improves water-use efficiency in crops and lifts global agricultural yields.
NASA's satellite observations confirm that rising CO₂ over recent decades has driven record global greening. This resulted in expanding leaf cover over arid and temperate regions - an area twice the continental United States.
Viewed across geological time, CO₂ levels are unusually 'low' - not dangerously high. Throughout the Phanerozoic Eon spanning 539 million years, atmospheric CO₂ was routinely several times higher. Before the first vascular plants colonised the land in the Cambrian, CO₂ sat between 4,000 and 7,000 ppm while marine biodiversity was ready to explode.
Over hundreds of millions of years, rock weathering and carbon burial steadily drew that carbon down. By the time of the Last Glacial Maximum 20,000 years ago, CO₂ had fallen to roughly 180 ppm — close to the 150 ppm threshold below which many land plants cannot survive. The modern rise above 400 ppm is a bounceback from historic depletion, not an unprecedented spike.
Earth's temperature tells a similar story when placed in a broader context. Our planet is still in the Late Cenozoic Ice Age, which began 34 million years ago, when permanent ice sheets formed on Antarctica. More specifically, we live in the Quaternary glaciation (begun 2.58 million years ago), experiencing a temporary warm interglacial — the Holocene — between major glacial advances.
Across hundreds of millions of years, Earth's average temperature has frequently been far warmer than today, by as much as 9°C during prolonged greenhouse eras when polar ice caps did not exist.
During the most recent Eemian interglacial 125,000 years ago, temperatures ran roughly 2°C warmer than today. This warming was driven primarily by natural orbital shifts, solar variations and ocean circulation, not from rising CO₂.
If natural or human-driven processes warm the planet further within today's Holocene interglacial, the geological record points to ecological expansion rather than biological collapse.
These are not a crisis. Warmer temperatures paired with higher CO₂ reduce cold-weather deaths. They lengthen the growing seasons and push arable land and forests northward into the vast empty expanses of the Siberian taiga and boreal belt.
This extends a miraculous planetary greening, which is already well underway.






























