At the end of today’s sitting, Ratha pressed Col. Selematsela to admit he knows or "knows of" Const. Zungu, before tossing a parting jab about Stephen Hawking and Albert Einstein on his way out. Let’s unpack why that moment matters. 🧵
@OCJ_RSA
#SenzoMeyiwaTrial
Col. Selematsela handled it with composure by simply asking him to explain this "knowledge" .
He never got an answer only a backwards historical quip at the door. Justice must not only be done; it must manifestly be seen to be done.
@OCJ_RSA your judge.
#SenzoMeyiwaTrial
Earlier, during his exchange with Colonel Selematsela, Judge Ratha condescendingly remarked that "some people don't know English" right before the Hawking and Einstein jab. This pattern of belittling witnesses from the bench is unacceptable.
@OCJ_RSA
#SenzoMeyiwaTrial
🧵 The dispute over Constable Sizwe Zungu’s movements starts with two dates: Sunday, 26 October 2014, and Monday, 27 October 2014. His account of reporting for duty before visiting Basotho Hostel must be tested against SAPS records. #SenzoMeyiwaTrial
1
14
1,171
Bottom line: the state faces a huge mountain to climb here. The central evidentiary question remains can any reliable record or witness corroborate Zungu’s specific account of signing in and receiving a vehicle on Sunday, 26 October?
#SenzoMeyiwaTrial
1
7
698
The absence of records isn’t automatic proof of perjury. However, if the registers were complete and entries were mandatory, that discrepancy becomes material to Zungu’s credibility—making any reliance on his testimony deeply questionable. #SenzoMeyiwaTrial
2
9
614
