Geoff Baker retweeted
El Sistema at 50: the rise and fall (and rise again?) of Venezuela’s controversial music programme
Geoff Baker charts the Venezuelan youth music programme's turbulent reputation across recent years @Geoffjbaker
classical-music.uk/features/…
Geoff Baker retweeted
Valid and true points from @Geoffjbaker. Most of you won't know that he is the Director of Research at Agrigento Music, author of Rethinking Social Action Through Music and has lived in Venezuela and other Latin American countries. He has worked with many musicians and community projects in Colombia, Mexico, Brazil and has contributed his expertise and passion for real social transformation through music in programs like Red de Escuelas de Música de Medellín (Colombia) and Vientos Musicales (Mexico). He also has family in Venezuela. He writes and speaks with in-depth experience and knowledge on the subject and is an unflinching advocate for truth, justice and music education. Please read. @marshallmarcus
El Sistema at 50: a response to Marshall Marcus
geoffbakermusic.co.uk/2025/0…
@marshallmarcus @monterogabriela @jessicaduchen
Geoff Baker retweeted
#Artículo: "EL SISTEMA EN SU 50° ANIVERSARIO Y LA BALANZA PESADA", por Luis Palacios R.
"En Venezuela existe una balanza en la que un millar de instituciones no perciben todo lo que deberían y unas pocas sí que reciben". #Venezuela #ElSistema #Dudamel
facebook.com/photo/?fbid=114…
Geoff Baker retweeted
THE SOUND OF SILENCE:
There are times for making music and there are times when silence should be the most powerful musical protest.
January 11th, the day after Maduro is illegitimately re-inagurated, is a day for mourning and not for making music. The days before and during the tour is due to take place, Maduro will kidnap, torture and murder innocent Venezuelans fighting to defend the will of a proven majority of the country. We voted. We won. Please stand with us.
Thank you to @jessicaduchen for having the courage to write this piece for @thetimes. The Times has kindly given free access to the article, so you should be able to read it with this link. thetimes.com/article/7dc3c4a…
Geoff Baker retweeted
@Geoffjbaker text digs down on the deeper moral story: “Very little of my long interview made its way into today's Guardian article, but that's normal for media articles. A point that I made was that this actually goes beyond Saudi Arabia’s support for football, which presents a value-free image to the world. It’s more distraction than hypocrisy. In the case of El Sistema, the Venezuelan government presents a value-laden image to the world – and the values are the precise opposite of the reality that it is creating back at home. Think of a youth orchestra playing great music: there are few more powerful symbols of peace, harmony, and hope for the future – precisely what Maduro’s government is undermining within Venezuelan society.
And it’s not just symbolism. These values are explicit as well as implicit. The rhetoric around El Sistema is a big part of its global appeal and are at the forefront in all its performances and activities (and its official responses to journalists). It’s a discourse about citizenship and peace and social change, and again, this is the opposite of Venezuelan reality. So this is a more extreme form of “washing” than many others, because it’s actively inverting reality. It’s as though Saudi Arabia sponsored a gay men’s chorus.
For example, Dudamel and El Sistema’s Venezuelan National Children’s Orchestra headlined a festival in LA entitled “Citizens of the World” on July 28-29, 2024. These were the very days on which their compatriots back home were deprived of a fundamental right of democratic citizenship – to cast a meaningful vote.
It’s not just the music industry that is complicit in this music-washing: it’s also the music education sector and major funders. Post-2007, there was a wave of enthusiasm for El Sistema around the world and many programs were created in its image, including Sistema Scotland and Sistema England and many in the US, such as Dudamel’s YOLA. Most of these programs, too, have been sticking their heads in the sand and refusing to recognise or discuss the issues raised in this article, instead continuing to adulate and showcase El Sistema. The same is true of international funders like the UN and the IDB, which have given El Sistema large sums of money over many years and amplified its utopian rhetoric, and have thereby supported the music-washing of Venezuela’s increasingly harsh realities. In short, there is a huge array of institutions around the world that need to take a long, hard look at themselves and consider the political dimensions of their support for El Sistema.
Finally, it’s striking that Askonas Holt denies not only the political dimensions of El Sistema – which is ridiculous, considering who runs it – but also the problematic realities of the Venezuelan program, which have been revealed repeatedly over the last decade. El Sistema is not “a beacon for education through the medium of classical music,” as the agency claims, but a corrupt and scandal-ridden organisation that has permitted the darkest sides of music education to flourish and has had a deleterious effect on this field internationally, propagating regressive ideas and practices. @AskonasHolt steadfast promotion of this organisation in the face of mounting evidence of its problems is just as reprehensible as its complicity in art-washing the Venezuelan regime.”amp.theguardian.com/world/20…
Geoff Baker retweeted
Happy 2025 to all!
Reality imposes itself on the festivities for us Venezuelans who, in just 9 days, will be forced to watch the re-inauguration of Nicolás Maduro, widely accused - even by fellow leftists in South America - to have stolen the presidency yet again.
The very next day, Venezuela’s flagship youth orchestra - owned and funded by the regime - will begin a European tour, welcomed in Europe’s major concert halls. Where artists who support Maduro’s close ally Vladimir Putin are banished from making music, Venezuela’s propaganda mission continues unchallenged.
Thank you to @tomphillipsin and The Guardian for giving voice to the less palatable propaganda mission of El Sistema under, first, Chavez and now Maduro.
Music can not transform society as long as it serves tyranny. amp.theguardian.com/world/20…
Geoff Baker retweeted
In which I probably upset yet another set of people with my musings about music education! drfautley.wordpress.com/2023…
Geoff Baker retweeted
¿Por qué los músicos colombianos no están de acuerdo con un Sistema de Orquestas como el venezolano? diariocriterio.com/musicos-c… via @diariocriterio
Geoff Baker retweeted
Hace unas semanas tuvimos la visita de Geoff Baker en Valparaíso y nos compartió su más reciente investigación con una charla magistral en @Arte_UPLA
Si se lo perdió, lo puede ver aquí youtu.be/o0MpB48tiaE
@Geoffjbaker
Geoff Baker retweeted
En el marco de la visita del #etnomusicólogo Geoff Baker a #Valparaíso este jueves tenemos una Mesa redonda sobre #musicascomunitarias y cambio social y el viernrs la charla Replanteando la acción social por la música ¡Acompáñennos!
Geoff Baker retweeted
THREAD: ‘The power of music to change lives’ #NPME2 #NPME #PowerOfMusic. Whilst I get the sentiment, we @youthmusic take a different angle: It’s the power of young people to change their lives through music. There’s a difference here. 1/7
Geoff Baker retweeted
Music Education twitter: our final version of the Youth Voice toolkit with @SConnections @JennRaven @isabella_mayne and Lewisham Music is now available. Thanks to our wonderful funder @AgrigentoMusic @Geoffjbaker
issuu.com/soundconnections/d…
Geoff Baker retweeted
“La romantización del poder de la música europea en América Latina se remonta a los relatos de los misioneros españoles del siglo XVI, que escribían sobre sus propios esfuerzos supuestamente gloriosos para pacificar y convertir a la población indígena.˝ tropicoabsoluto.com/2022/03/…
Geoff Baker retweeted
#ElSistemaDesafina | El Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo dice que El Sistema fue el que decidió la construcción de un solo centro de música de los siete que se habían prometido en el contrato inicial #TalCual #ClaroyRaspao #AlianzaRebeldeInvestiga
https://xitter.gq/t.co/QjhVqiLWqj
Geoff Baker retweeted
#ElSistemaDesafina |Autoridades regionales de El Sistema cuentan que desconocen por qué no se han comenzado a construir los centros de música prometidos por El Sistema y el BID. Conoce más detalles aquí: https://xitter.gq/t.co/LSii8dmSg0
Geoff Baker retweeted
Te invitamos a visitar, en el siguiente enlace, el especial multimedia "Las notas desafinadas de El Sistema". Conoce los detalles de esta investigación y a compartirla con tu RT🔁
#ElSistemaDesafina🎻📈 alianza.shorthandstories.com…
Geoff Baker retweeted
21.900 instrumentos se comprarían para El Sistema con el financiamiento aprobado por el Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo en el año 2007. Entérate este #15Mar en el especial #ElSistemaDesafina qué pasó con esa promesa
Geoff Baker retweeted
Our most accessed book this month was 'Replanteando la #acción #social por la #música: la búsqueda de la #convivencia y la #ciudadanía en la Red de Escuelas de Música de #Medellín' by Geoffrey Baker!
Read & download for free or buy a hard copy at doi.org/10.11647/OBP.0263
Geoff Baker retweeted
✍️NEW #BLOG: Read now 'Replanteando la #acción #social por la #música: la búsqueda de la #convivencia y la #ciudadanía en la Red de #Escuelas de #Música de #Medellín' by OBP author Geoffrey Baker.
Click below 👇 to access
doi.org/10.11647/OBP.0173.01…






















