Motion to dismiss design patent infringement denied - district court declined to apply ordinary observer test on its own without a properly construed patent claim to provide the backdrop for the application of the test
Flipsi, Ltd. v. TOMY Int'l, Inc., N.D. Ill., 1-23-cv-00745
78
Big news for US design patents today - Federal Circuit has granted rehearing en banc to reconsider longstanding obviousness analysis, first requiring a primary reference with basically the same design characteristics, now challenged as too stringent
cafc.uscourts.gov/opinions-o…
Pleased to share that @aipla's Innovate Magazine includes an article on IP protection related to Augmented and Virtual Reality, including a section I contributed on design patent protection.
aipla.org/innovate/2022-pape…
Federal Circuit affirms IPR finding design patent valid, declines to depart from obviousness precedent requiring a "primary" reference with basically the same design characteristics before turning to secondary references.
cafc.uscourts.gov/opinions-o…
New post Fielding and Labelling Designs explores the significance of identifying the article(s) of manufacture for a design patent
altdesignpatent.com/posts/fi…
1
67
N.D. Il. judge concludes computer-generated design patent illustrations depict opaque; ordinary observer would not find translucent accused design substantially the same; opaque and translucent objects are categorically different, plainly dissimilar
shorturl.at/oQT34
E.D. Pa. judge concludes actual baseball bats are not relevant prior art for design patent anticipation or obviousness analysis of a "drinking vessel" (article of manufacture identified in the design patent title and claim) which resembles a baseball bat
shorturl.at/fjsZ6
1
4
422
George Raynal retweeted
Attending #aiplaAM22?
Don't miss our Andrea Soldatini speaking about Global Design Protection on Friday afternoon, and Elisabetta Papa, coordinator of the discussion on UPC and Unitary Patent on Saturday morning.
Looking forward to seeing you there!
https://xitter.gq/t.co/agvM1Y2mo2 @aipla
Next #designlaw2022 panel explores symmetry with respect to inventorship (again based on obviousness, basically the same)
Next, @ChrisCarani discusses identical forms for different products and claim scope - is a design patent claim agnostic or specific to article of manufacture?
#designlaw2022
Obviousness is determined from ordinary designer perspective, but there is no infringement symmetry
#designlaw2022
Replying to @MarkJanisIU
@MarkJanisIU explains, when Gorham chose the ordinary observer standard for infringement over skilled observer utility standard, Court adopted an infringement test from outside of utility law, and didn't go on to adjust anticipation standard, enshrining asymmetry
#designlaw2022
George Raynal retweeted
Replying to @MarkJanisIU
@MarkJanisIU explains, when Gorham chose the ordinary observer standard for infringement over skilled observer utility standard, Court adopted an infringement test from outside of utility law, and didn't go on to adjust anticipation standard, enshrining asymmetry
#designlaw2022
Next, @MarkJanisIU picks up to expand on Perry's criticism of International Seaway to argue there is a more systemic problem with the court's rationale - the notion of symmetry between anticipation and infringement is a fallacy
#designlaw2022
next, @IvyEstoesta discusses anticipation outcomes in ex parts appeals, inter pares review, and district court litigation #designlaw2022
Yet Examiners aren't taking into consideration the prior art as it would be considered in infringement analysis #designlaw2022
Perry Saidman explains how after Int'l Seaway, USPTO design patent examiners can sidestep the more rigorous analysis of obviousness (103) and apply art which is substantially the same, as opposed to identical, for anticipation (102) #designlaw2022
Perry Saidman explains how after Int'l Seaway, USPTO design patent examiners can sidestep the more rigorous analysis of obviousness (103) and apply art which is substantially the same, as opposed to identical, for anticipation (102) #designlaw2022
I'm proud to help coordinate a panel to explore this issue at the upcoming @abaipl Virtual Fall Institute
With @CLMauro @PulseUX, @IvyEstoesta @SterneKessler, Courtney Stopp (USPTO) and Beth Ferrill @FinneganIPLaw
October 12
Register here:
lnkd.in/eskDzkWd
As the importance of design rights for innovators and brand owners and the prominence virtual worlds continue expand, the question arises: can design rights be obtained and enforced against virtual infringement?
As the importance of design rights for innovators and brand owners and the prominence virtual worlds continue expand, the question arises: can design rights be obtained and enforced against virtual infringement?










