Independent analysis of and commentary about philanthropy and giving

Joined July 2019
The Giving Review retweeted
Good take on the small donor factor by @jsscppr with excellent data. The larger backdrop here is that the top 20% of voters by income now lean heavily Democratic. share.google/VJdalDyXbsoY4qJ…
2
2
85
The Giving Review retweeted
thegivingreview.com/the-ford… As the @FordFoundation’s new grantmaking strategy shifts its central focus to democracy, @GivingReview co-editor @mhartmannmke considers what the change might mean—and what the foundation isn't saying about why it made it … “A more-interesting and -helpful insight on the shift’s explanation might be to leave what remains to be seen to the future and wonder about what just plain isn’t seen as of this ‘moment,’ but must have occurred in Ford’s consideration and preparation of it.” After all, Ford says its new strategy was informed by extensive internal deliberations, outside reviews, and critical perspectives. “What did these private conversations, reviews, and critical perspectives conclude was ‘wrong,’ or maybe even just wrong-headed, about the old strategy, in the previous ‘moment’? What has Ford learned from it?” And as Ford promises broader coalitions and greater openness to disagreement, another question arises: “Just how pluralist the new, humbler, more democracy-protecting Ford’s promised democratic pluralism will actually be” does remain to be seen.
4
1
2
290
The Giving Review retweeted
Kremlinologists looking for insight into the Ford Foundation's recent shift in strategies should check this out
thegivingreview.com/the-ford… As the @FordFoundation’s new grantmaking strategy shifts its central focus to democracy, @GivingReview co-editor @mhartmannmke considers what the change might mean—and what the foundation isn't saying about why it made it … “A more-interesting and -helpful insight on the shift’s explanation might be to leave what remains to be seen to the future and wonder about what just plain isn’t seen as of this ‘moment,’ but must have occurred in Ford’s consideration and preparation of it.” After all, Ford says its new strategy was informed by extensive internal deliberations, outside reviews, and critical perspectives. “What did these private conversations, reviews, and critical perspectives conclude was ‘wrong,’ or maybe even just wrong-headed, about the old strategy, in the previous ‘moment’? What has Ford learned from it?” And as Ford promises broader coalitions and greater openness to disagreement, another question arises: “Just how pluralist the new, humbler, more democracy-protecting Ford’s promised democratic pluralism will actually be” does remain to be seen.
2
3
198
The Giving Review retweeted
It’s No Joke. Nonprofit Hospitals Are More Profitable than For-Profit Hospitals Studies find that nonprofit hospitals achieve greater profits with higher average prices than for-profit hospitals. On average, nonprofits have 29% greater profits than for-profits. scottahodge.substack.com/p/i…
7
31
9
110
7,324
thegivingreview.com/the-ford… As the @FordFoundation’s new grantmaking strategy shifts its central focus to democracy, @GivingReview co-editor @mhartmannmke considers what the change might mean—and what the foundation isn't saying about why it made it … “A more-interesting and -helpful insight on the shift’s explanation might be to leave what remains to be seen to the future and wonder about what just plain isn’t seen as of this ‘moment,’ but must have occurred in Ford’s consideration and preparation of it.” After all, Ford says its new strategy was informed by extensive internal deliberations, outside reviews, and critical perspectives. “What did these private conversations, reviews, and critical perspectives conclude was ‘wrong,’ or maybe even just wrong-headed, about the old strategy, in the previous ‘moment’? What has Ford learned from it?” And as Ford promises broader coalitions and greater openness to disagreement, another question arises: “Just how pluralist the new, humbler, more democracy-protecting Ford’s promised democratic pluralism will actually be” does remain to be seen.
4
1
2
290
The Giving Review retweeted
Reading…
thegivingreview.com/if-the-n… @GivingReview co-editor @mhartmannmke considers @IUPhilanthropy’s new What Americans Think of Nonprofits & Philanthropy 2026, and what it might reveal about the nonprofit sector … The report finds what it calls “a substantial recognition gap: Americans may interact with nonprofits regularly while not identifying those interactions as nonprofit service use. “More broadly,” it continues, “many people may associate nonprofit services primarily with direct assistance or basic needs, while overlooking the broader range of nonprofit institutions they encounter.” According to Hartmann: “The nonprofit sector has developed an academic-professional infrastructure sophisticated enough to discover that most Americans don’t know there is a nonprofit sector. “Perhaps the public doesn’t need the ‘nonprofit sector,’” he writes, “nearly as much as the nonprofit sector needs the nonprofit sector.”
2
2
24
The Giving Review retweeted
NEW: Anthropic’s filing appears to partly walk back—or at least massage—the co-founders’ pledge to commit 80 percent of their personal equity holdings in the AI startup to philanthropic causes, a commitment made when the startup was founded. Those acts of philanthropy, the filing suggests, are “voluntary, revocable expressions” that “do not constitute binding obligations.” motherjones.com/politics/202…
1
15
3
17
3,276
The Giving Review retweeted
Anthropic's S-1 explicitly makes clear that the founders' commitment to donate 80% of their personal equity is revocable / non-binding.
6
45
8
214
35,093
The Giving Review retweeted
thegivingreview.com/in-the-a… @GivingReview co-editor @WilliamSchambra sees opportunity for nonprofit sector after midterms to confront waste, fraud, and abuse … “If such self-examination has been postponed because it might seem to give aid and comfort to the enemy,” he writes, “that excuse will have been removed.”
4
1
1
141
No doubt there are plenty of journalism scholarships on the left and right. But $10 million in funding to bash progress? That hurts, writes @andykessler on.wsj.com/4BpLK9L
2
2
1,548
The Giving Review retweeted
Nearly half of all hospitals are exempt from paying US corporate income taxes. As healthcare spending rises, lawmakers have questioned whether hospitals are providing as much in community benefits as they derive from tax exemptions. Read more: hubs.ly/Q04C2Ps00
1
2
735
The Giving Review retweeted
The Ford Foundation on Thursday laid out a new strategy that reorients the 90-year-old grantmaker around what it calls the “preconditions for thriving democracies,” from the rule of law to trustworthy information and inclusive economies. bit.ly/4dYgAMx
2
2
2,418
The Giving Review retweeted
DOL Clarifies When a Nonprofit's "Employee" Can Sometimes Be A "Volunteer," Too fplglaw.com/insights/dol-cla…
1
2
61