Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR) header
Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR) profile picture

Strategy | innovation | knowledge creation in science, engineering, and technology | organization | cognitive science | AI

San Francisco
Joined July 2011
Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)Photo by Brian Gordon (@GordonBrianR)
Let me try and articulate what is see is a genuine tension between Bayesian subjective credences across theories of the world and what constitutes a probability calculus within a possible world bundle.
1
1
4
862
More niche than ‘the brain is not a computer’ or ‘intelligence is compression’ or ‘consciousness is computational’ but sure to generate the same intensity of partisan debate. #makeneuroaigreatagain
The free energy principle is free because it’s not that useful.
79
This needs to be a national priority. Great to see YC making an explicit call for startups in this space.
Replying to @ycombinator
Robots Made in America @sdianahu Robot foundation models are starting to transfer skills from one machine to another, which means the bottleneck is shifting to hardware. The U.S. still imports much of its robots and their critical components. We want to see founders rebuild that supply chain here, from magnets, motors, gears, and sensors to chips, batteries, and the machines that make them.
75
This is a (another) great piece, breaking down VC, as an industry, by the underwriting logics used to assemble portfolios. Underwriting logic is as core as stage, focus, strategy, or thesis when it comes to understanding what the firm is doing.
2
175
Brian Gordon retweeted
That's awful. If you don't fight the status quo when you're young, what are you going to do once you're old?
I think those paying attention will eventually identify this as the most toxic dynamic of Effective Altruism: It is a machine that uses tech money to divert smart young people into a pseudointellectual bubble that supports the status quo, away from actual critical thinking.
1
1
3
60
Brian Gordon retweeted
1/ In February, we argued that the cost of execution would fall much faster than the cost of verification. As agents scale, human attention and expertise become the binding constraint. @AnthropicAI just put experimental evidence behind our warning... xitter.gq/AlexTamkin/status/2115…
New Anthropic research: How AI agents shape experts' judgment calls When experts delegate work to an agent, do they still make the key decisions? We tested this in a randomized trial with 50 professional data analysts.
5
5
1
45
3,725
Probably a bunch of people vibe coding will come up have even more appreciation for the wildness of industrial scale technology. Maintaining is a full time job
4
1
7
303
This feels like a variant of @erikphoel theory of dreaming applied to modern AI models. Maybe the extrema of it, where the model is actually frozen and dreaming relaxes this architectural (vs ‘mere’ overfitting) constraint?
at some point we’ll just accept that the alien-ghosts can use a lot of mechanisms that we use
1
3
369
Brian Gordon retweeted
at some point we’ll just accept that the alien-ghosts can use a lot of mechanisms that we use
Today on the blog, learn about our new instance of a “sleep” phase in continual learning, which enables LLMs to continuously integrate new facts and enhance reasoning while mitigating catastrophic forgetting or static knowledge cutoffs. More →goo.gle/4iICkyD
16
9
3
267
24,748
Don’t put AI between yourself and someone in any coaching/teaching/mentoring or meaningful partnership role. The raw material is what allows the form to be seen. I wouldn’t let my robot show my golf coach my swing.
1
4
214
Brian Gordon retweeted
i think people will be surprised how stupid AIs are considered in a decade after they get the low hanging fruit from the literature and have to actually work in the world
14
2
78
7,124
There is no reason to suppose humans/cultural progress has saturated either the extensive (combinatorial search) or intensive (domain insight) margins when it comes to scientific inquiry and we are just now probing what machine, human, & hybrid architectures can do.
there was a point before deep blue, before alphago, before navier stokes, where you could argue, if not entirely convincingly, that maybe some areas of human endeavor were already skill saturated enough that more intelligence wouldn't help much I think there is basically no shred of credibility left for this kind of thinking now on anything where a primary input is intelligence. we know too much, we have seen too much. the universe has a high skill cap
1
2
209
The scientific project of AI, originally, for many at least, can be understood as a ‘makers knowledge’ quest — an attempt to understand the mind by building minds. It’s notable that right at the exact moment we seem to have cracked (forms of) intelligence, we started on agency.
What I think Henry is pointing to can perhaps be understood as a kind of agency that is ‘world constructing’ and transcending in a sense, rooting what it is to be human in the demiurgic imperative more than intellection simpliciter.
1
3
147
What I think Henry is pointing to can perhaps be understood as a kind of agency that is ‘world constructing’ and transcending in a sense, rooting what it is to be human in the demiurgic imperative more than intellection simpliciter.
I think the natural retreat is romanticism, specifically to intangible capacities like yearning, wonder, authenticity, ambition, and so on. Maybe not a bad outlook, but one that survives more on the vagueness and illegibility of these virtues than true human exceptionalism.
2
1
2
251
I’m sure this over-simplifies romanticism (and Henry’s views).
33
I don’t think it’s as simple as supposing there is a basal and higher level(s) to these processes. Machines are already contributing to the construction of World3. It’s more of a mangle than a hierarchy.
In nature, the machine is continuous with the animal, from the lever to the lion--causal, wild. Culture makes the difference. Imagination separates the concept from the emotion, the intellect from the will, reason from the passions. It imposes discipline and grants our freedom.
1
89
Renegotiating (with ourselves) just what it is to be human is the project of modernity, stretching from the beginnings of the mechanical philosophy of nature to Darwinism and now AI.
2
114
Brian Gordon retweeted
In nature, the machine is continuous with the animal, from the lever to the lion--causal, wild. Culture makes the difference. Imagination separates the concept from the emotion, the intellect from the will, reason from the passions. It imposes discipline and grants our freedom.
I lean on intellection *and* volition, reason *and* passion, and I don't think you can have one in any recognizable sense without the other. Animals are continuous with machines; that's nature, from lever to lion. Human culture (concept *and* emotion) makes the difference.
1
2
2
3
346
A piece of advice Hubert Dreyfus gave the grad class: “The important thing is to ask a sincere question. Otherwise, you won’t know when you’ve got your answer.”
2
7
1
27
1,035
Brian Gordon retweeted
What people call intelligence can be seen as two distinct things 1. how much scale you have 2. how much ability to scale you have Most peole think of intelligence in terms of (1). Someone like Francois Chollet thinks of intelligence mostly in terms of (2) The models are weakly good at (2) on their own but not there yet. Labs themselves (and the entire ecosystem that feeds them scaling inputs) remain critical for (2), where the input and output is a thing called “Claude” or “GPT” Many are implicitly building for a world where (2) doesn’t itself have scaling laws leading to automation, where models remain relatively static objects only capable of a bit of extra test time logical depth. Status quo bias and cope imo The Models Will Eat Their Harnesses
3
4
31
2,305