Hamlet (@IACTwo) header
Hamlet (@IACTwo) profile picture

India's To Be or Not to Be Aircraft Carrier

Joined August 2022
Carrier critics: Aircraft Carriers (which move) are "sitting ducks" in today's ISR saturated, precision strike environment Also carrier critics: Shore-based air (which operates from static airfields) is the solution. youtube.com/watch?v=bAnhSkHR…
2
3
1
14
We have written to the @ECISVEEP and CEOs of 7 states regarding the shocking and flagrant non-compliance with Supreme Court’s directions and ECI’s own instructions. On Oct 28, SC had said that it was an ERROR to use Form 6, with its declaration of being a first time voter, to re-enroll deleted voters on the ASDD (Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate) list. Following this, on Nov 6, the ECI issued instructions that such voters can fill enumeration form instead of Form 6 and their old EPIC number would be restored. Despite passage of more than 10 days, there is NO implementation on the ground. CEO Delhi website continues to require deleted voters to fill Form 6 to re-enroll.
8
176
2
313
4,772
Raja Mohan's pro-US bias is well known and his flawed analysis has been called out multiple times. But India has screwed up not bcos of any alleged overreliance on US Also it's cute when "independent" PRC scholars talk about a 2nd rate power like Russia in " a hierarchy".
Its argument has a basic flaw. Similar diplomatic moves do not imply similar strategic standing. Everyone can balance and bargain. Far fewer can set the terms. 1) Keeping the Quad alive tells us little about what Washington will sacrifice for it. America can bring its partners together to strengthen its bargaining position, then negotiate with Beijing over their heads. India risks mistaking America’s current need to counterbalance China for a lasting commitment to Indian interests. 2) Benefiting from differences among major powers makes sense. Building a strategy around those benefits leaves a harder question unanswered. How much of that advantage does India control? Washington may offer India better terms because it needs Indian cooperation against China. But Washington also decides how much that cooperation is worth. India must turn such openings into capabilities that others will need even when their priorities change. After decades of diplomatic manoeuvring, how much independent strength has it accumulated? 3) The three-way summit matters even without a major agreement. The meeting itself signals a hierarchy. These powers have to deal directly with one another because each can obstruct the others’ major goals. India celebrates its ability to maintain relations with all sides. Yet those sides can negotiate directly and change the conditions under which India has been benefiting. Being welcome in several forums does not guarantee a say when the biggest decisions are made. Mohan mentions strengthening India at home. That should be the starting point. India needs power that others cannot ignore, even when they strike a deal. You cannot build strategic autonomy on differences that others are free to settle.
29
Let the meltdown begin...
Robert Pattinson is James Bond
27
Godi media. And then there is just plain lazy Desi media. Mostly incompetent but sometimes too clever by half.
1
74
Hamlet retweeted
Protesters led by AISA President Neha Bora tried marching towards the Environment Ministry building in New Delhi, demanding accountability over Delhi’s toxic air. They were stopped by the Delhi Police.
22
121
5
450
5,089
Credit for giving Kallis his due. But AB, assuming this is a test team? Nope. 5 - Steve Waugh - c 6 - Kapil Dev Also, like all lists only works on paper. Neither Lara nor Tendulkar opening in Tests works. Hayden and SunnyG. And then this whole thing stops working😃
Who will be your number 6?
127
The US still does, but not with the 4477, which was wound up years back. Mig 21 in the 60s vs Mig-21 in the 80s. Some differences. Also, since we don't know the exact nature of the "secrets", one shouldn't assume it was about the hardware alone. There are other facets of ops.
I’ve long wondered: The US acquired its first Yak23 in 1953, MiG21 in 1966, and MiG23M in 1977. The USAF 4477th exposed thousands of US pilots to combat against real Soviet aircraft. Possibly, it still does. What MiG secrets would the Larkins have had to sell to the CIA?
30
On November 19, President Xi Jinping will hold the China-Russia-U.S. Summit with President Vladimir Putin and President Donald J. Trump in Shenzhen.
52
354
57
1,854
101,979
Manila, May 2007 - First Quad "dialog" Manila, November 2017 -Quad 2.0 reincarnation Manila, November 2026- Quad clinically dead, but won't pull the plug.
Replying to @suhasinih
Actually Philippines is a good venue. Squad. Which some believe has supplanted Quad.
34
Ironically Manila, Nov 2017 that Quad was reborn. a. DJT1.0 had a neocon-ish NatSec team. Not now. b. It was Biden that skipped Quad summits in Aus 2023 and India 2024 But, it is India that killed the Quad in both avatars. Lack of both rigor and intellectual honesty to deny this
The Manila meeting will be the first Quad Summit to be held in a non-Quad country and indicates the challenges that India has faced as the Chair of the Summit of the four-country grouping that revived its cooperation in the Indo-Pacific in 2017, upgrading it during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2021 to leader-level meetings. Since then, the government has been unable to host the Quad Summit in India even once, mainly due to the U.S. President’s unavailability. New Delhi is unwilling to hand over the Chairship of the summit without hosting it here either, which may yet happen in Delhi next year, the sources told The Hindu.
24
In Desi military WhatsApp groups it is fashionable for many BTDTs to post dialog from either Col Jessep or Brig Rudra Pratap Singh (Jessep in Desi remake) showing them in a "positive" light. A reminder that in a Republic you keep your military on a very tight leash. Or else...
Hegseth is too dumb to realize that the line he paraphrases (from Plutarch’s Life of Pompey) has since become a shorthand warning about how republics decline when powerful men stop feeling bound by law.
3
172
Are you thinking of leaving Delhi-NCR because of the air pollution? Six professionals and founders already did. Here's what they gained, and what it cost them. In today's @IndianExpress 🧵
12
65
9
186
18,241
RAF Sea King pilot and his wife to visit India for environmental award ceremony while NCR AQI...
Packed week -PM Modi's Manila visit -India Asean, East Asia, Quad Summit -Trump, Xi, Putin meet in China -Prince William and Princess Kate on India visit
36
Hamlet retweeted
#Delhi: This morning as per aqi.in. If this isn’t a public health emergency, I don’t know what is. Is anyone accountable?
21
57
10
179
5,179
The AUKUS inquiry fails in invoking the lessons from the Collins class program. Which don't seem to have been learned. WHEN not IF AUKUS fails, we will see how many "experts" who failed to heed the red flags raised at the outset, admit their mistake.
34
BZ!
We are thrilled to announce that the joint team of @reporters_co, @investigate_eu , & @_infoLibre has won the Human Rights & Religious Freedom Journalism Awards 2026 in the Best Text Reporting on Human Rights & Religious Freedom (English) category. 1/3 instagram.com/reel/Dfv3zkdTu…
26
Bad editing by ToI. But Lanba's answer on why 3 carriers also unconvincing. a. Are you only deploying in IOR? Or beyond it? b. Is IOR only SL/Maldives? Why haven't current carriers deployed beyond? c. France has one carrier. It deploys worldwide Increasingly, a vanity project.
'Every landing is a controlled crash': ex-Navy chief Lanba on why India needs three carriers A carrier pilot lands on a strip barely 100 metres long, at night with no moon and no backup airfield. Lanba explains why that skill takes over a year to build, why it is lost when there is no carrier to fly from, and why India needs three of them. Watch the full conversation with @PrasadScribe 🔗 youtu.be/NR8TFCTC0FI?si=koX9…
2
64
Hamlet retweeted
60 Minutes analysis of satellite imagery and new video shows the scale of destruction the Pentagon has never fully disclosed. Since the start of the war, Iran has hit at least 31 U.S. military and diplomatic sites across eight countries. cbsn.ws/4zP7T04
457
3,703
233
8,939
633,705
התנהלות ראש הממשלה היוצא נתניהו וסביבתו היא איום מוחשי, ישיר ומידי על הדמוקרטיה הישראלית. לא נותרה בישראל חלקה שלא הושחתה, עוותה והוכפפה למען הישרדותו הפוליטית האישית של נתניהו. אין רסן שלא איבד, ואין גבול שלא נחצה. אסור בשום פנים ואופן שנתניהו ימשיך לאחוז בהגה השלטון ולו דקה אחת נוספת. אסור בשום פנים ואופן שישראל תיגרר לסבב בחירות נוסף כשהוא ראש ממשלה. מובן שכל עוד הוא בתפקיד - לא יתקיימו יותר בחירות הוגנות וכשרות בישראל. זה השיקול המרכזי שמנחה אותי בכל משא ומתן קואליציוני שאני מנהל בימים אלו. לאחר שהכניס ללשכת ראש הממשלה סוכנים קטארים בפרשת "קטארגייט", עכשיו נחשפת פרשיה חדשה וחמורה עוד יותר - ניסיון שיבוש בחירות לכאורה תוך השתלת ראיות, הפעלת המשטרה נגד אזרחי ישראל הערבים בלי צו חיפוש או צו מעצר בתוקף. אני קורא לפתיחת חקירה מידית של הפרשה ולהבהרה מידית של המשטרה והשב״כ בדבר הפרטים שפורסמו. אפעל להקים ועדת חקירה לחקר מעורבות והתערבות לשכת ראש הממשלה ביום הבחירות והתנהלות גופי הביטחון לקראתו ובמהלכו.
2,169
3,328
439
16,390
1,171,649
Bcos the military cannot simultaneously claim to have the highest standards of integrity and professionalism and then trot out the trite "angry young man" defense from 70s Bollywood movies. The message even from those movies was that it was self defeating.
Replying to @IACTwo
Why should only faujis bear this cross? No other Gormint service ever thinks of effectiveness efficiency or modernization. Only ghus khori. This expectation only of faujis? Why? To get dhapped by thullas and thekedars?
58