Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate) profile picture

Moderate libertarian, Teacher (MS Science, HS Biology, HS CTE Health Occupations), Mom. Gen X-er.

Indiana, USA
Joined September 2019
Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)Photo by Indiana Moderate (@IndianaModerate)
Replying to @Ezra4Liberty
Look at that. Moderate libertarian. Who would have expected that?
9
1
23
7,554
Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% for voluntary communes and co-ops and federations or whatever. But these are always going to be fringe groups because modern economies are more productive and workers have higher standards of living.
4
I mean, you're not actually considering the way humans or non-human organisms interact. You're just imagining something completely detached from reality and saying your imaginary world is better than reality. That's not really helpful.
1
7
I don't think that's accurate economically or ecologically. You're not comparing economic systems or building on current systems. You're just imagining something and saying "that would be cool." it's philosophical, not scientific or historical.
5
Yes, I think anarchy-type communes can work on the very small scale, like other intentional communities. But it doesn't seem practical for larger communities, complex economic systems, that rely on infrastructure, standardization, laws, etc.
2
14
That's not a good analogy at all. Anarchy relies on people behaving differently than people have ever behaved. Liberal democracies and constitutional republics don't do that.
1
13
Is there any example of this kind of society or is it all imaginary?
4
14
Yeah, I get that, but I'd rather live in a place with good laws than any sort of majority-rule type of deal. Half of humans are below average ethically and intellectually ;)
2
13
But there is a wide spectrum between anarchy and authoritarian collectivism. And I agree with you (I think) that any alternative to what we have now has to be more voluntary than what we have now to be more sustainable than what we have now.
1
17
I don't think laws and law enforcement are the same as central planning. I agree with the gist of "voluntary" -- I think it should be very, very difficult to pass a law -- like 70-80% of a municipality, state, country should have to vote for a municpal, state, or national law.
2
22
I'm not against local commons or worker co-ops for those who want them, but most people don't want them. Public spaces tend to be dangerous and dirty which would worsen without police. And worker co-ops have the risk of business ownership with the lack of control of employment.
1
14
I think voluntary alternatives to state reliance is win-win whether you ever achieve international narachy or not!
4
There are lots of countries that have strong property rights, strong free trade, and effective, non-corrupt government. Most of them are much smaller than the US and many are also decentralized like the US is supposed to be but isn't.
1
10
The best economies in the world and in history aren't the ones with no government. They're the ones with strong property rights, strong free trade, and effective, non-corrupt government.
1
14
I don't think any of that is logical, but can anarchists co-exist in a world, country, ro state where most people aren't anarchists? If not, it's kind of a self-defeating ideology, right?
2
12
Central government enforces property rights and free trade. That's not what you said. You said it keeps capitalism from turning into feudalism. No it doesn't. The state doesn't protect against collusion. It's the colluding power. The state should be a small and local as possible.
3
14
Nothing about that statement that makes any sense at all. Authoritarianism doesn't keep freedom from turning into authoritarianism. That's circular reasoning and completely illogical. Barriers to free markets aren't caused by freedom LOL
1
14
?? That's not true at all. You're not comparing economic systems or economic policies, you're just spouting Marxist propaganda, which isn't historical or economic or even ecologically valid.
1
16
You can't use "capitalism" to refer to property rights and free trade and also use it to refer to government barriers to property rights and free trade. Monopolies and government-corporate collusion are anti-capitalist. But I'm all for decentralizing state power!
2
18
Capitalism is strong property rights and strong trade freedoms. If that's not what you're arguing against, you're not opposing what capitalism-defenders defend, what economic indexes compare, etc. If you're against concentrated economic power, we have common ground.
1
15
Less than 1% of American businesses are large, publicly-traded corporations. More than 2/3 are sole proprietorships, 90% have fewer than 20 employees. And monopolies are least common in the most capitalist economies (strongest property rights, most free trade).
1
2
18