AJ K (@InquiringAJ) profile picture
Joined March 2022
I’m seeing so much nonsense flying around, I’m compelled to lay down some basics. 1. You don’t need a religious basis for supporting the right of the Jewish people to a national home. I’m a Catholic, so I don’t associate the modern Jewish state with any deep theological or eschatological meaning. I don’t believe the “ingathering of the Jews” in Israel portends the end times. But as a matter of secular justice, I believe that the Jews are entitled to a state. 2. Why? Because the modern world is configured along nation-state lines. And long before the Holocaust, the Jews tried every other means — converting, assimilating, becoming German or French or Russian nationalists, socialism, etc. — and they couldn’t escape persecution. The Holocaust only compounded the urgency of a Jewish state. Afterward, a Jewish state was established and internationally recognized. And here we are. 3. You can criticize the policies and conduct of said Jewish state. I did so, quite vigorously, over the summer. I will continue to criticize its drift toward intolerance, disproportionate warfare, and settler maximalism in the Palestinian Territories. 4. But if you are obsessed with the wrongdoings of one state (and one state only), or if you imbue that state with almost metaphysical evil, or claim to question all nationalisms but only focus on one — that crosses a line into animus. Fin.
193
198
39
1,523
133,798
What an insanely awful, and borderline heretical, take. Our Lord was like us in *all things*, except sin. To say he didn’t have a sense of humor borders on docetism. (Note this is a—surprise!—sedevacantist bishop.)
Bishop Sanborn: Our Lord did not have a sense of humor. He smiled, but he never laughed. What an interesting explanation here!
20
9
6
223
17,058
Sorry Tony. The issue isn’t “this is totally fine” and “every priest should do this” It’s called having a little grace for moments like these and not amplify negativity from sede accounts who’s only purpose on here is to confirm themselves in their own beliefs. Cringe. Yea. Goofy. Yea. Fr. Mike or not, they’re human. They sometimes make goofy videos. So forgive me for being the type of person who gives whatever priest a little slack for being goofy. If it’s not a terminal problem, I see now reason to feed into the negativity. Not everybody is going to be Fr. Ripperger.
Why are so many young men attracted to Orthodoxy? Because their priests don’t act like this. The only reason everyone is defending it is because it’s Father Mike. If it was a priest they didn’t know they’d be saying it’s awful. I’m sure the girls think it’s adorable, but no straight man in his right mind should think this is ok.
42
8
318
19,775
People are too lazy to do serious reading today. You’d think that, given how short a tweet is, they’d have attention span enough to read at least that carefully before responding. But no. Soon we’ll be down to grunts – into which people will still read all kinds of bizarre things
42
19
5
288
16,050
1995 years ago, a small group of fishermen in Galilee began to spread the message of the Catholic Church. In 5 years, a man born on the opposite side of the Earth on a continent no one had ever heard of will preside over its 2,000th anniversary.
27
186
7
2,331
68,218
I’m so tired of the silly political analyses of the papal candidates: “where does he stand on immigration? On climate change? On the poor?” Look, there are indeed moral implications of the Gospel, but the Gospel itself is what truly matters. And the Good News is that Jesus Christ is risen from the dead and hence the rightful Lord. What I’m looking for in a Pope is a man who firmly believes this and knows how to make it compelling to people today.
713
1,364
239
11,636
594,859
This is a warped conscience. Someone who says "not my problem" in reference to those perishing, all as a way to justify antisemitic innuendos, is someone who has lost the plot big time
This quoted post is unavailable.
486
I was speaking to a student today who is interested in becoming Catholic. I asked him what issues or barriers there were for him in getting there. Of the several issues, one was the “ultra traditionalists in the online Catholic community. They don’t seem very Christian.”
40
15
17
201
38,102
Harry complaining about why he was conceived is weird, and suggests he doesn’t understand how many children exist solely because tequila tastes good.
14
16
4
283
37,484
We are going to beat gender ideology. I am not optimistic about very many things, but this is a fight we can win. And we will.
436
1,783
97
18,009
Wow, this new Ben Stiller mockumentary on pop atheism is hilarious!
“Where is heaven exactly, given that we have multiple telescopes up there beaming back information.” - Sam Harris
28
39
2
486
Ok can Christians please stop taking a ‘middle ground’ on Roe v Wade being overturned? It stopped abortion up to birth in half the country. It is a good thing. You wouldn’t take a middle ground on other grave human rights abuses. Don’t do it here.
45
81
3
844
Dear Justices, tune out the diabolical howls and shrieks and listen to this woman and to these voices:
17
187
6
1,369
it is irresponsible to be portraying this guy as a mental health expert. He is not. Nor is he a theological expert.
"If they undergo this process ..." Click here to watch full episode: churchmilitant.com/video/epi