It's the height of bad faith to jump from observing that a foreign people, faith, and culture is incompatible with your own, to committing a second Holocaust. Why, as a historian, would you pick the Jewish expulsions and Nazi atrocities, rather than the British leaving India, as a comparison for a population exodus? Because you want to summon the spectres of the twentieth century to proscribe deportations as racist and scary. There is nothing about British traditions that demands we appease foreign people who hate us, and their foreign religion which will not reproduce our civilisation. I like Professor Starkey, but he tried the same twee comparisons to Catholicism in our debate. The denominatinal disputes between Christians in Britain were between natives, and between sects of our national faith. The presence of Islam in Britain is totally optional. We don't have to tolerate it.