Steve Bolander (@Lou_Cadia) header
Steve Bolander (@Lou_Cadia) profile picture
Joined June 2017
Nevermind. Grok says no. **No — not for Starship’s reentry tiles.** The new material is an impressive room-temperature insulator, but it fails the temperature, environment, thickness, and durability requirements of a reusable orbital heat shield. Starship uses ~18,000 hexagonal low-density silica-ceramic tiles (fibrous silica network, mostly air, with a high-emissivity borosilicate or MoSi2 coating). Surface temperatures during reentry reach ~1,400–1,650 °C. The tiles must stay attached, survive plasma, thermal shock, vibration, rain, and many flights while keeping the 304L stainless-steel hull below ~800 °C. Typical conductivity for this class of tile is ~0.06 W/m·K at 300 °C and rises with temperature. The NC State material is a 2-D hybrid organic-inorganic perovskite thin film (azobenzene ethyl ammonium lead iodide). It has very low conductivity (~0.04 W/m·K at room temperature) and is unusually stiff for that conductivity. It can be printed as a scalable coating. Those properties are real and useful for electronics, cookware, or moderate-temperature insulation. They do not transfer to Starship TPS: - **Temperature limit.** Hybrid lead-halide perovskites (including 2-D layered versions with organic spacers like azobenzene or phenethylammonium) typically lose the organic components and collapse between ~150–300 °C. Even the more stable compositions used in solar cells degrade under prolonged 85 °C stress. Reentry is an order of magnitude hotter. The leftover PbI₂ would not function as a reusable high-temperature insulator. - **Form factor.** It is a thin film. Starship tiles are ~3 cm thick so that the temperature drop and thermal mass keep heat from reaching the steel. A coating a few microns or tens of microns thick cannot do that job. - **Environment.** The material contains organics and lead iodide. It is sensitive to moisture, oxygen, UV, vacuum outgassing, and radiation — all present on the windward side of Starship. Existing tiles use a glassy coating specifically to resist atomic oxygen and plasma. - **Other mismatches.** Density is higher than silica foam tiles. Coefficient of thermal expansion, plasma erosion resistance, rain/erosion durability, and high-temperature emissivity are unproven and almost certainly inadequate. Lead content is also undesirable on a reusable vehicle. A thin coating of this perovskite on the *back* of existing tiles or as an internal layer in a multi-layer stack is theoretically possible for extra insulation at lower temperatures, but that is not what the tiles themselves do. SpaceX is still iterating on silica-ceramic formulations, attachment (“crunch wrap”), and coatings because those materials already operate in the required temperature regime. This perovskite does not. The paper’s mention of “space travel” is generic; it does not claim reentry-capable TPS.
48
Travelers to Texas. Welcome y'all. One favor to ask please. Try the brisket without any sauce first. Not against sauces, but yeah it's kind of a thing.
2
56
Steve Bolander retweeted
some photos from Patagonia Spring 1998 catalog so interesting to see the contrast with the modern outdoors recreation editorial style
21
95
8
3,874
354,431
Interesting flight path, but nothing to worry about SATX. Just tax dollars at work with an FAA flight check to verify radar coverage at KSAT approaches/departures. Beautiful bird too.
180
Temperature scale I use in parenthesis. What is yours ? -18°C to 0°C: 0°F to 32°F (Freezing) 1°C to 11°C: 33°F to 52°F (Chilly) 12°C to 22°C: 53°F to 72°F (Cool comfort) 23°C to 33°C: 73°F to 92°F (Warm) 34°C to 43°C: 93°F to 110°F (Hot)
41
AN 124 at YYZ 17/6/26 18:40
1
65