
California’s #1 HOA homeowner-side law firm representing homeowners in disputes with their California HOAs. The Firm also handles corporate and business law.
Aliso Viejo, California
Joined November 2025
- Tweets321
- Following6
- Followers34
- Likes311
Pinned Tweet
When it comes to relying on martial arts training in a real-world situation, when the pressure’s on, you’ll never rise to the occasion; instead, you’ll fall to your training. The same is true in HOA litigation.
Homeowners facing a bad HOA are at an automatic disadvantage because the HOA’s lawyer does nothing but represent associations. You deserve that same level of focused expertise. As the pioneer in homeowner-side HOA law in California with nearly 30 years of experience, I’ve built MBK Chapman to be the black belt in your corner.
Watch MBK Chapman’s new video to see why our experience, discipline, and a deep knowledge of the Davis-Stirling Act are the only ways to flip the script on a bully board.
#HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #DavisStirlingAct #CaliforniaHOA #badHOA #HOAhell #MBKChapman #MichaelKushner
I’ve built my career fighting bad HOAs. But AB 130 has yet another unintended loophole that hurts conscientious homeowners.
When AB 130 went into effect, it amended Civil Code § 5855 to give homeowners the right to avoid discipline if they fix a violation before the disciplinary hearing. But the law makes no exception for repeat offenders. A resident can consistently park in someone else’s space or leave their trash bins at the curb, stop right before each hearing, and start again once it passes. And it appears as if the HOA can’t ever fine them for it.
Towing and lawsuits still exist, but few HOAs or homeowners will spend thousands of dollars suing a neighbor over trash bins.
The Legislature should take the cure protection away from anyone who repeats the same violation, say, 3 times in 12 months.
What do you think? Should repeat offenders lose the right to cure, or would that hand bad HOAs a new weapon?
Link to Fact Sheet in the first comment.
#AB130 #HOACure #HOAfines #HOAviolation #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
1
2
22
Every year, your HOA has to provide you with mandatory financial and policy-related documents
California HOAs have to send homeowners two sets of documents every year, 30 to 90 days before the fiscal year ends.
The annual budget report has to tell you how much money is in reserves and how far short it falls, whether the board is putting off major repairs, whether a special assessment is coming, what the HOA owes on loans, and what it will charge you for documents when you sell.
The annual policy statement has to tell you how the HOA collects assessments and handles foreclosures, what it fines for, and how dispute resolution works when you want to fight back.
And if the budget report leaves out required items, the HOA can’t raise your regular dues without a secret ballot vote of the homeowners.
When did your HOA last send you these, and what did you find in them?
Link to a 90-second video from HOA HELL podcast in the first comment.
#HOAbudget #HOAdisclosures #HOAannualbudgetreport #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
1
3
47
A jury awarded the family of an autistic boy $8 million after a neighbor sued to have the boy declared a “public nuisance.”
A woman in a Santa Clara neighborhood sued the family of a nonverbal 11-year-old autistic boy, called him a “public nuisance,” and asked the court to stop his noise. According to the family, the sounds came from vocal stimming while he chased bubbles in his own backyard on weekend afternoons.
The court threw out her nuisance case. The family had filed a cross complaint, and the jury sided with them, awarding $8 million on their claims, including intentional infliction of emotional distress.
No HOA was involved in the San Jose case. But inside an HOA, a neighbor doesn’t need a lawsuit. They can keep filing complaints and demand the HOA enforce its nuisance rule against the family. Under California law, the ordinary sounds a disabled child makes don’t constitute a nuisance, as long as they aren’t made at unreasonable times like 2 a.m. If the HOA fines or threatens the family over those sounds, it faces fair housing liability. And once the HOA knows a neighbor is harassing a family over a child’s disability, it has to act against that neighbor.
Has a neighbor or your HOA ever gone after your family over your child’s disability?
Link to my Fact Sheet about the news story in the first comment.
#autismacceptance #publicnuisance #fairhousing #disabilityrights #HOAnuisance #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
1
5
46
A Texas HOA fought a backyard office for 6 years and now owes the homeowner $153,000. Could that happen in California?
A Texas homeowner wanted to build a 160-square-foot office in her backyard. The HOA’s architectural committee said no, so she sued.
The courts ruled the committee never had the authority to reject it. The HOA didn’t even appeal that part. It appealed only the attorney’s fees, and lost. With court costs and interest, it now owes her about $153,000.
California law points the same direction. HOAs have to decide architectural requests in good faith, and their decisions can’t be unreasonable, arbitrary, or capricious. Whoever wins a lawsuit to enforce the governing documents gets their attorney’s fees paid. That cuts both ways, though. If the HOA wins, the homeowner pays the HOA’s fees.
Wherever you live, has your HOA ever rejected a project you were sure it had no right to block?
Link to the news story in the first comment.
#HOAarchitectural #ADUcalifornia #HOAlawsuit #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
2
4
24
Got a violation hearing notice from your HOA?
In California, you have the right to fix the violation before the hearing. If you do, the board can’t fine you or impose any other discipline. Period.
If the fix will take longer than the time you have before the hearing, giving the HOA a financial commitment to cure, like a signed contractor agreement, works too.
If the board does fine you, it can’t go over $100 per violation unless it finds in writing, at an open meeting, that the violation threatens health or safety.
And if a board member is also the neighbor who complained about you, that director has to leave the room and can’t vote.
If your HOA skips any required step, it can’t enforce the discipline.
Link to Fact Sheet in the first comment.
#HOAviolation #AB130 #HOAhearing #HOAfines #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
1
5
20
Is your HOA trying to stop your kids from playing outside?
One redditor said their HOA keeps sending violation notices and threatening fines because their 5-year-old and 3-year-old ride Power Wheels in front of the garage, while teens zoom around on e-bikes at 20 mph the whole time. Another said their HOA told them their 5-year-old couldn’t ride a bike with training wheels, a helmet, and pads.
In California, HOAs can’t ban casual play in the common area. Kids riding bikes, playing catch, and making up games are exactly what the common area is for. A rule banning that is never going to be deemed reasonable, so an HOA can’t enforce that kind of idiotic blanket rule.
And when a rule targets only kids, or the HOA enforces it only against families with kids, the HOA is walking into serious fair housing problems too.
Has your HOA ever gone after your kids for just being kids? What did they try to pull?
Links to two Fact Sheets are in the first comment.
#HOAkids #HOAcommonarea #fairhousing #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
2
5
26
Bought a home and now your HOA wants you to pay the last owner’s fines?
If you live in California, you’re not responsible for the last owner’s fines.
Any fines the HOA charged the last owner belong to the last owner. Under the Davis-Stirling Act, you’re not responsible for unpaid fines imposed by your HOA.
The physical stuff is different. The overgrown yard, the peeling paint, and the shed the seller built without approval all became yours when you bought the house. The HOA can even demand that you tear out an improvement you paid for.
So before you buy into an HOA, ask the seller in writing whether they got HOA approval for every improvement the governing documents required approval for. If they say yes and it turns out they didn’t, you can hold them responsible for failing to disclose.
Link to Fact Sheet in the first comment.
#HOAfines #buyingahome #HOAviolations #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
1
5
19
RIP to Captain Jean Luc Picard.
Right now, Patrick Stewart is performing Shakespeare in heaven.
#PatrickStewart #JeanLucPicard #STTNG #TheNextGeneration #StarTrek #Picard
3
115
Can your HOA’s lawyers accuse you of harassment for filming a vendor or complaining about the board? They’re trying.
It takes violence, a credible threat of violence, or a pattern of conduct that serves no legitimate purpose and causes substantial emotional distress to constitute harassment under California law. Filming people from a place you have a right to be, questioning a contractor, or criticizing the board all serve a legitimate purpose. None of that is harassment, and the HOA-side lawyers who send these letters know it.
HOA-side law firms in California are sending more and more of these cease and desist letters for a calculated and pathetic purpose, which is to scare and intimidate “difficult” homeowners into silence. Bad HOAs understand that a cease and desist letter on law firm letterhead, no matter how bogus, can accomplish the board’s goal of silencing its harshest critics.
Usually the homeowner filmed a vendor violating the CC&Rs, asked workers why they were on the homeowner’s property, or just asked difficult questions. Many of these letters accuse homeowners of civil harassment. Some go further and accuse them of assault, or even, incredibly, of creating a hostile workplace for the HOA’s vendors, as if the homeowner were an employer covered by California’s labor laws.
If you got one, what did it accuse you of, and what did you do?
Link to the Fact Sheet, “Can My California HOA Accuse Me of Harassment for Filming or Complaining?” in the first comment.
#HOAharassment #ceaseanddesist #HOAfreespeech #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
1
4
88
A commenter called HOA boards “a fraternity of sociopaths” that must be replaced.
OK. Replaced with what?
One rule: “Abolish HOAs” doesn’t count. Homeowners keep choosing them for a reason.
Best ideas may end up on the podcast. Who’s first?
5
91
Who pays when your HOA’s contractor or vendor damages your home or your stuff?
If your HOA is in California, the answer could be the HOA, the contractor, or both.
An HOA HELL podcast listener is living this right now. Their HOA’s pest control company treated the lawn, then ignored its own posted instructions to keep it dry. The crew left the sprinklers running, and tens of thousands of fire ants moved into the listener’s condo.
When this happens, some HOAs tell you to take it up with the contractor. Others say you maintain your own home, so the repairs are yours. Both answers are wrong. The HOA has to maintain the common area, and hiring a pest control company, landscaper, plumber, or roofer to do that work doesn’t get it off the hook when that contractor damages your property. You can sue the contractor directly too. You don’t have to pick one.
Who pays for what depends on what got wrecked. Damage to the home itself, the walls, ceilings, floors, or built-in cabinets, is on the HOA. Your belongings are different. The contractor owes you for your furniture, electronics, or your grandmother’s antique armoire, but the HOA pays for those only if the contractor was acting as its agent, or if the HOA was careless itself, like keeping a company it knew did sloppy work.
I break it all down in my Fact Sheet, “Is My California HOA Responsible When Its Contractor Damages My Home?” Link in the first comment.
Has an HOA contractor ever damaged your home or your belongings? Who paid?
#HOArepairs #HOAmaintenance #HOAcontractors #HOAliability #HOAlawyer #HOAattorney #CaliforniaHOA #DavisStirlingAct #badHOA #HOAHell
1
5
59