Muhammad Raza retweeted
Last night, in my teams meeting, I took a deep dive into the Home Secretary's proposal to extend the qualifying period for Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) from five to ten years, subject to limited exceptions.
The more I examined the proposal, the more questions I found myself asking.
First, the issue of legitimate expectations and the changing terms of the immigration pathway.
Many of the visa routes affected are employment-based and what we term commercial visas.
People enter the UK under a framework that sets out the conditions of their stay and provides a recognised pathway to settlement.
In doing so, they make significant commitments. They pay visa fees, accept sponsored employment, relocate their families, invest in accommodation and build their lives around the immigration framework in place at the time. Most of these conditions are below reasonableness or what should be widely regarded as fair.
It is therefore reasonable to argue that the five-year ILR pathway formed a significant part of the basis upon which many people made these life-changing decisions.
Yet, halfway through that journey, the Government is proposing to change the qualifying period to ten years.
The problem is not simply that immigration policy can change. Governments must retain the ability to review and amend policies.
The real issue is changing the terms for people who have already entered the system and made substantial commitments in reliance on the previous framework.
Even more concerning is the absence of any meaningful assurance that future governments will not move the goalposts again.
We are effectively being told that the immigration rules in force at the time an individual applies for ILR will determine their eligibility, rather than the rules that existed when they entered the UK.
What guarantee, then, does anyone have that today's ten-year pathway will not become fifteen years under a future government?
Where do we draw the line ?
Lack of certainty is not what UK is known for
I’m on a Skilled Worker visa and was due to qualify for permanent residency in March 2027 — just over 4 months away under the previous rules.
@ShabanaMahmood
@ukhomeoffice
@andyburnham
#ilr #skilledworker #Immigration
5/
People say “the government can change the rules whenever they like.”
Okay… so where does it stop? What’s stopping the next government from saying no permanent residency at all?
What security do any of us actually have?
Muhammad Raza retweeted
Dear @SohailAshrafGor, I am an overseas Pakistani and I need you and Chairman CDA @CDAthecapital to hear this.
I own a house in Islamabad. I came back to rebuild it, ready to spend my life savings in precious foreign exchange in Pakistan instead of anywhere else in the world.
Instead, I have spent the last 2 months inside CDA offices. Three hours every single day. Meeting after meeting with directors and members. Every visit ends with the same empty promise: "your file will move tomorrow."
Why is it stuck? Because someone bribed their way into CDA and got a letter affixed to MY file that clearly belongs to a completely different property three streets away. The plot number on it was changed from 449 to 499 , and a handsome amount was paid to make that forgery stick. Anyone who opens the file can see it in 30 seconds. Yet no officer is willing to remove it on the pretext of following the course of law.
Think about what this means. An overseas Pakistani, with clean papers and money ready to invest, can be held hostage for months by one forged letter and one bribe. Meanwhile the person who paid the bribe faces no questions at all.
Chairman CDA, I ask you directly: how does an average Pakistani get justice in this system? The one who cannot sit in your office for 2 months? The one who has no contacts, no camera, no journalist to tag?
You appeal to overseas Pakistanis to send remittances and invest back home. I did exactly that. This is what I got in return.
I am asking for one thing only: open my file, remove the forged letter that belongs to plot 449, and hold accountable whoever inserted it. That is it. Basic honesty from a public institution.
@CDAthecapital @KlasraRauf @DrTariqFazal @MohsinnaqviC42 @CMShehbaz @FIA_Agency #Islamabad #CDA #OverseasPakistanis #Corruption


