Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis) header
Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis) profile picture

Philosophy professor. 'Thinking Critically About Abortion'; 'Animals & Ethics 101'; Lead Editor @1000WordPhil ; some writings at @Salon ; https://xitter.gq/t.co/o1LpDJOKti

Atlanta / City of Decatur, GA
Joined March 2014
Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)Photo by Nathan Nobis . com (@NathanNobis)
I wrote a short book for college students: The College Success Rulebook: Practical Advice for College and Beyond. It’s free and openly licensed for instructors to use and share: CollegeSuccessRulebook.blogs… #CollegeSuccess #StudentSuccess #HigherEd #CollegeStudents #OER
1
6
1,236
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
FROM SOMEONE WHO ACTUALLY TEACHES COLLEGE: Lots of people seem to think the crisis in evaluating students can be solved by "just using in class blue book tests, duh!" You think professors haven't thought of this? It is galactically ignorant, for so many reasons: 1. In many disciplines, the thing being tested requires a computer to produce. What, are you going to have your students write complicated code or statistical analysis by hand? 2. It is — shocker! — possible to cheat on Blue Book exams. There are many large 100+ student classes. What's to stop someone from taking a screenshot of the exam questions and having their phone generate an essay answer? Enforcing no-cheating in this context is really hard. 3. Narrowing evaluations to only in-class handwritten material highly constrains the type of evaluations you can give. No long research papers, for example. No short answer reflections written at home. It also means TONS more labor, deciphering the writing. 4. Enforcing the conditions necessary to prevent cheating now compromises the student-teacher relationship in huge ways. 5. Students may still use AI to read and summarize sources, then write essays about those summaries (SparkNotes for everything). If the skill that's being built is the ability to process information for yourself, there's no test for it. What are you going to do, have students read an entire novel in class, then grade their Blue Book answer?
106
39
30
412
85,547
Yes the "far left" hates all longstanding traditions. Hating longstanding traditions is one of their traditions, and that hate it too! (Why are people who should be smart so dumb too often?)
Nothing the far left hates more than a longstanding tradition!
4
104
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
Sometimes on this and similar apps, people claim that they don't understand why being conscious is important. This is, of course, very hard to believe. For one, would these folks mind if they became permanently unconscious? (Yes). A new book on this: global.oup.com/academic/prod…
2
3
8
378
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
Replying to @Womp_Tomp
Your question then is, "What if there were a big embryo that looked like a baby?" The answer here is that should think about this case what you should think about embryos. abortionarguments.com/2021/0…
2
1
174
This is the place that proves this!
Malcolm Gladwell, five-time New York Times bestselling author, says influence used to mean expertise. Now it can come from anyone relatable. Six lessons on building influence: success.com/malcolm-gladwell…
76
Sometimes on this and similar apps, people claim that they don't understand why being conscious is important. This is, of course, very hard to believe. For one, would these folks mind if they became permanently unconscious? (Yes). A new book on this: global.oup.com/academic/prod…
2
3
8
378
Another issue they have apparently never thought of is whether a world that had no conscious beings in it would have (moral) value. Or, if had some kind of value, how would that value compare to a world with conscious beings.
1
72
Also all major ethical theories appeal the to value of being conscious: e.g., utilitarianism, etc. focuses on pleasure and pain, and only conscious beings are like that; Kant focused on having a will, rationality, consistency, etc. and only conscious beings can do that. And more.
1
56
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
Replying to @PAHoyeck
They are often needlessly long-winded: most books could have been an article.
1
1
7
159
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
You do not appear to have anything interesting to say on these issues. No accomplishments, no substantive writings, no videos .. nothing, you don't teach classes on these topics .. right?
2
1
1
85
Moral progress. Depravity, art, & GTA Six. Coffee & the advance of science. Why the world seems so beautiful. Aristotle & Nathan Fielder. Karl Marx & Richard Scarry. What makes your life worth continuing? dailynous.com/2026/11/18/min…
1
3
912
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
On this app, people talk about things being "objective" and various contraries (e.g., "subjective") and almost never explain what they mean or think about different meaning. (Same with "correct"). Maybe some researchers don't do much better.
1
1
4
143
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
Right. This response maybe got lost: Here's a case: ICE kills some innocent, non-threatening person. Group A says it's wrong (and has many reasons why). Group B says it is not. Here almost nobody in Group A is going to think this is only wrong "for" group A or whatever.
1
1
4
126
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
Replying to @PAHoyeck
"What do you mean?" and "Why think that?" are key, core critical thinking questions.
2
4
507
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
Replying to @_akpiper
Totally agree. So much academic writing is needlessly long-winded and convoluted. No need for that, then or now, and AI can help people with that, if and when they are unable or willing to edit themselves.
1
72
Tough luck, babies! No rights for you!
“Health care is a human right” is factually untrue and an idiotic statement …that’s not an opinion…it’s an iron clad fact. No one has a natural right to someone else’s labor. Stop saying it…you sound dumb..also, it gets in the way of trying to figure out a good and affordable solution to the actual problem.
3
4
258
If you want to see many people reason and respond poorly, ask them (1) if they would like to work in a slaughterhouse, (2) why, and (3) if - given what they said - they think other people should have (or have to have) that job, and why.
2
3
228
Nathan Nobis . com retweeted
Replying to @NathanNobis
I have a few papers etc. in the works that deal with similar questions. Would the average human's offloading most thinking to AI: (1) ... significantly reduce their own critical-thinking activity? (2) ... fail to significantly increase the quality of the critical thinking?
1
1
103
Are there people worried about people "outsourcing" their significant thinking and decisions to AI? If so, I don't see why that would happen, since many people apparently rarely have a thought like, "I should learn from someone who really understands this topic." Given that...
3
3
458
why would these same people consult AI and then defer to it? And if they did, wouldn't that often produce a better result anyway than their current "zero input" thinking?
1
2
61