
The garden of rejections. Use #ManuscriptRejected to share your story. Retweet ≠ endorsement.
Joined May 2020
- Tweets2.2K
- Following413
- Followers1.3K
- Likes513
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
#manuscriptrejected —> submitted to a higher impact journal anyway and woke up to an acceptance email this morning. Woohoo! Happy 02.02.22! #phdlife #phdchat @PhDVoice @AcademicChatter #AcademicChatter @PhD_fail
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Reviewing is a funny game. As authors we've all received a snarky review at some point and know how harsh it feels. So why would any author give reviews like this? Is it a case of the bullied becoming the bullies? Predator-prey reversal? @PhDVoice @PhD_fail
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Unpopular opinion: If you’re a white person who “loved graduate school” then you didn’t make enough good trouble with/for your marginalized colleagues. And if your response to that is that there was no trouble to be made, you just weren’t trusted enough to know about it.
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Personally, anytime my paper is rejected in a particular journal I move to the next.
Don’t take journal rejections personally.
A rejection doesn’t guarantee that your paper is bad.
There are even Nobel prize winning papers that were rejected.💪
#PhDVoice @PostdocVoice
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Replying to @PhDVoice @PostdocVoice
My paper was rejected by a journal without giving reasons. I submitted it to another journal of the same ranking as the first one and it was published after minor revisions.
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
The 1st time my paper was rejected, I cried. I did few editing and submitted to another journal which was accepted. Since then I don’t even stress it. We moveee✌️✌️
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
I got one paper accepted and one paper rejected today (different journals). Already heard back from all coauthors. Including the editors, that’s 7 academics that were working on a Sunday.
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Resubmitted a brutally reviewed and rejected paper coauthored with @annekearymonas1 & Prof. Kostogriz to a new journal after making some changes.
What doesn't kill you makes you stronger. #Academia
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
My first paper on ML in chemistry was rejected from every damn possible journal! But now... all of them want to publish ML
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Don’t take journal rejections personally.
A rejection doesn’t guarantee that your paper is bad.
There are even Nobel prize winning papers that were rejected.💪
#PhDVoice @PostdocVoice
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Replying to @NeNe_LaShaun
Unfortunately, manuscript rejection happens after R&R… a lot… I recently had one paper rejected after revision and another paper I coauthored was rejected after R&R as well and I have heard a couple cases of rejections after R&R…luckily there are many journals so to the next! – at Manhattan, NY
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
A few months ago, I submitted a paper to a journal & after the first round of R, the paper was rejected. Knowing the quality of the work we had done, I resubmitted it to an older & higher journal (IF wise) & it was accepted with minor revision.
St Rejection could be a blessing
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
To help those who are getting rejections from PhD programs:
Current PhD students, how many rejections did you get before getting into your PhD program?
(And too many to remember is a valid answer as well)
#PhDVoice @PostdocVoice
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
According to reviews I received the paper is rejected because it is not novel and unique enough, but also because it shows results that don't match the previous literature. Yay, academia.
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Asking for a friend: if a replication study (which fails to replicate an important paper) is rejected at a journal, should you 1) drop it and move on; 2) appeal; or 3) submit to a related journal?
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
I don't know about the rest of y'all but maybe my very favourite academia thing is when your paper gets rejected because it's about the question you wanted to consider, instead of the question the referee wanted you to consider—that makes me feel all warm inside, very warm indeed
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
“Come join us” says professor at Ivy League institution that will receive 800 applications for one position.
Manuscript Rejected retweeted
Question for academic peeps - have you ever successfully argued against a paper rejection? Been in review process 1yr, 1st reviewer happy with all changes, says it’s important & should be published. 2nd has issues with it. Editor rejected. Do I bother stating a case? Or leave it?























