Doug Garber (@PitchThePM) header
Doug Garber (@PitchThePM) profile picture

Ex-Citadel / Millennium PM breaking down high-conviction ideas, buy-side process, and variant views

Joined September 2024
Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)Photo by Doug Garber (@PitchThePM)
EP. 60: $ANT Anthropic’s Path to $350 Billion Revenue? with @_SeanDavid, CIO, @AvoryCo "We're all focused on the $1.4 Trillion, but you need $2.8 Trillion." “$350 M Revenue is to justify 1.4., if they continue to execute, they could they possibly get to $350. But if you want to double your money, I wanna go from $1.4 Trillion to $2.8 Trillion.” "Eighty percent of Anthropic's revenue comes from models they've created in the last six months." "In some of the AI products we use, we're one click away from going from this model to that model." Sean Emory is the founder and CIO of Avory & Co, the Miami firm he has run for more than ten years. Avory runs concentrated, long-only separately managed accounts and AVRY, the Avory Foundational ETF, a 20–30 name active ETF built on one idea: invest forward, with valuation discipline. Anthropic prices its IPO this week at up to $1.4 trillion, and it backed its way into Sean's portfolio for nothing: Zoom's early stake, which Sean puts at $4–8 billion, against a Zoom market cap approaching $30 billion. We do the work on Anthropic itself. At a reasonable 20x FCF, $1.4 trillion needs $70 billion of free cash flow, which at 20% margins means $350 billion of revenue against an $81 billion October run rate. To double your money you need $700 billion of revenue, more than the roughly $500 billion all the big clouds generate today. We also get into the ~$900 billion compute bill against thin contracted revenue, the risk with 80% of revenue coming from models less than six months old, the ease of trading down to open-weight models, the importance of the harness and orchestration layer and the importance of owning the customer. *Not Investment Advice *Disclosure: Doug Garber is invested in the AVRY ETF. Avory & Co holds $ZM , $XYZ and $NOW , as discussed on the episode. 💡 This episode is presented by: @AlphaSenseInc –Decision Grade AI. Complimentary trial at the link : alpha-sense.com/Pitch/ @Fiscal_ai – Delivering Modern Financial Data Infrastructure. 15% discount with code PITCH: fiscal.ai/?via=pitch
1
1
6
822
Ex-@Citadel & Millennium PM Doug Garber (@PitchThePM) on the real cost of becoming a portfolio manager and why curiosity and drive beat pedigree. Doug Garber hosts Pitch the PM and previously ranked as a top analyst at Citadel’s Surveyor Capital before running a multi-sector book at Millennium (Katahdin Capital). He is now CIO of Westport Alpha Group. “Why are you in on the weekends? Why are you there doing 12, 14 hour days? You got to love it. You got to be curious, but you got to put in that time. Someone else will. Is it worth it?” We cover: - The fire in the belly test: a decade of Sundays, 12 to 14 hour days, and the relationships that take the hit. - Mentorship over brand names. The right boss beats being number 7 on a top team. - Citadel’s structured process machine versus Millennium’s entrepreneurial pods. - Alpha capture, backbooks, and the poorly kept secrets of multi-manager economics. - Why going outside your lane is how even top PMs blow up. - AI as a useful tool you still have to own. You can’t walk into the MD’s office and blame the model. - From SPVs to media company: the unexpected business development grind behind Pitch the PM. - Why great analysts don’t all need to become PMs, and why finding work you actually enjoy matters more than the starting salary. Highlights: 00:00 How Doug got into investing and the early foundation from Tulane programs 15:38 Alpha capture, backbooks, and why the industry is less opaque than it used to be 25:13 The intensity of hedge fund culture and the fire in the belly required to win 40:04 Advice for young people aiming to become portfolio managers 44:49 Where the biggest opportunities lie and why staying in your lane matters 50:28 The real sacrifice of becoming a PM and whether it is ultimately worth it 53:31 Balancing success with purpose and finding work that does not feel like work 01:01:26 One takeaway: find a career you really enjoy This content is for informational and entertainment purposes only and is not financial advice. Always consult a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions. Investing involves risks, and past performance is not indicative of future results.
2
5
1
49
8,804
Short Sellers Are Guaranteed Buyers Generating alpha on the short side of the book is a key to having a long, profitable career in long-short investing for most investors. There were four takeaways from the episode with my former colleague from Citadel's Surveyor Capital, Jack Woodruff about short selling: 1) Jack commented that, "Short selling isn’t inherently destructive. It’s an important part of an efficient market." 2) He explained that when companies try to control meetings and access, it can be a clue they might be hiding something. That behavior motivated Jack to dig deeper, to find what they might be hiding. 3) One of my favorite CEOs would regularly comment that, “Short sellers are guaranteed buyers at some point.” Showing his confidence in his company. (Note: They eventually cut the dividend.) 4) My classic comment is, "A bad short is a great long" Jack agreed, "100%". -->Top 10 Takeaways from my conversation with Jack: HERE
10
1,568
Ex-Citadel and Millennium PM Doug Garber (@PitchThePM) on why he walked away from running a book at Citadel: "You're a weekend parent at best. Even if you're home, your mind's always there." "When I was climbing the ladder, you have tunnel vision. You make a lot of trade-offs and sacrifices and you prioritize your work and you're climbing the ladder and not your relationship." "It doesn't grow my bank account the same way, but there are some other objectives as well." "He was at BAM and then Millennium and he just gave back a very large book. And to go be a teacher." "He's like, I feel fulfilled."
7
13
1
268
162,472
Having @_SeanDavid on @PitchThePM tomorrow. Here are the prep questions: Comment to add a question for me and Sean. 1.) What’s ANT worth?  2.) How’d you value it? DCF? 10x ‘27 EV/Revenue? 3.) Did you talk to any underwriters, what’s their message?  4.) Where is consensus in this name for 2027 vs where are your estimates? Per reports, Goldman has 2027 / 2028 revenue estimates of $130 / $442 billion, yielding a forward revenue multiple of 10.2x / 3.0x. (Note: we pulled the GS estimates from an FT article and cannot verify them ourselves)... 5.) Are you concerned about the lack of pricing power?  6.) How does the operating efficiency work?  7.) Is this Wework with the mismatch in operating liabilities and revenue visibility?  8.) Is this winner take all on models? Or will people trade down? Will Anthropic go vertical to hardware and applications?  9.) Where do you want to be invested in the AI stack long-term?  10.) Are you putting in for the deal? 11.) Where do you think it closes in day 1?
1
9
2,200
EP 59. "The Only Risk Is Not Being Big Enough”. Meet JACK: Citadel's Top Stock Picker with Jack Woodruff, exCitadel Partner & CIO of Candlestick Capital “I got an email from Ken Griffin, and he said, 'Don't you think you're a little big?' And I said, 'The only risk is not being big enough.'“ "It's not the best idea at the top of the book, it's the idea I could lose the least in." Jack Woodruff came into the industry looking for shorts through deep accounting analysis. He built a simple and scalable investment process with Gabe Plotkin at Point72, and then ran the biggest team on Citadel's Surveyor platform for nearly a decade, becoming a Citadel partner. In 2019 he spun-out with his team to found Candlestick Capital, where he ran 30-plus stock pickers using a simple investment framework and standard model to create time efficiency. Doug and Jack worked together at Surveyor. They talk about what went on behind the scenes of the Citadel spin-out, the research behind Jack's team catching the top in Lululemon when everyone's credit card data said fine, why a reverse-engineered DCF is still the best tool an analyst has, why process is the edge, and how he hired (never from the buy side) and sized (the idea he could lose the least in goes on top). "I spend no time on me being right. I spend all of my time on me being wrong, because that's what could hurt me." "We never had arguments about a stock. We had arguments about inputs to the model." “There's nothing like getting a good short. There's nothing more satisfying in my eyes." 💡 This episode is presented by: AlphaSense–Decision Grade AI Oxford Data Plan–The Home of Alternative Data *Not Investment Advice (01:38) The peak of Melvin, investors calling, and the Surveyor contract that allowed a spin-out (03:22) Taking the team, the infrastructure and the track record for a revenue share (04:05) How "Jack be nimble" became Candlestick Capital (06:08) "Jack's only 1%": the PR response to his exit (08:37) Why Citadel wanted him picking stocks, not running Surveyor (12:43) An accountant who wanted to be a short seller: Big Six, M&A diligence, Trivium (16:08) Why short selling is the most important role in an efficient market (18:31) "I don't mind the shorts. They're guaranteed buyers" (23:14) The formal preview process and the reverse-engineered DCF (26:59) What AI changes for analysts, and rebuilding Candlestick with Claude (31:53) How Candlestick was organized: PMs, analysts, associates, data science (39:57) Nailing the top in Lululemon: Vuori, Alo and the belt bag (42:49) Tell me what it will be in six months, not what the data says (46:17) The brick-and-mortar shorts: JCPenney and Macy's (49:41) Ken's email: "Don't you think you're a little big in JCPenney?" (51:40) Always in the model: running scenarios on how you can be wrong (56:04) Hiring: never from the buy side, live-round interviews, model tests (65:20) Right 52% of the time: sizing is everything (66:03) Using the risk model without being defined by it (69:40) Four consumer teams at SAC then, 70-plus now (73:28) What's next for Jack
7
44
11
568
179,364
Top 10 takeaways from my coversation with Jack Woodruff. pitchthepm.substack.com/p/me…
1
1
283
“The only risk is not being big enough.” That was Jack Woodruff’s response when Ken Griffin emailed him asking whether his JCPenney short had gotten a little too large. At the time, this was far from an obvious trade. Bill Ackman, Glenview and Mark Cuban were publicly making the other case, and Jack watched well-known personalities pump JCPenney on TV while he remained negative. Eventually the stock cracked and fell 80–90%. Ken followed up: "I’m glad it’s finally going your way." It's one "analytical skill" to have a thesis right, it's an entirely different "mental skill" to have the conviction to stick with the position when it's going against you and you're against Ackman, Glenview, etc...and Ken's asking questions. 💡 This episode is presented by: AlphaSense–Decision Grade AI : alpha-sense.com/pitch/ Oxford Data Plan–The Home of Alternative Data: oxford-dp.com/demo?utm_sourc… Watch the full episode: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1F…
1
2
16
2,115
Doug Garber retweeted
H100 rents +40% in a year, but capital is getting pickier. Strong borrowers raise easily; others face high spreads and strict conditions. Contracted demand ≠ funded capacity. The compute market can stay hot while certain players get consolidated. Thank you @dee_bosa and @YahooFinance for having me on! youtube.com/live/tN8AKvBg2I0…
9
30
4,537
3/n and 2/2 with @PitchThePM Fmr BAM TMT with a deep dive on how agents will reshape the internet (winners and losers both agents and providers) $META $ETSY $PINS $SHOP and more podcasts.apple.com/us/podcas…
1
2
14
3,585
💡 This episode is presented by: @AlphaSenseInc Decision Grade AI : alpha-sense.com/pitch/ @OxfordDataPlan –The Home of Alternative Data: oxford-dp.com/demo?utm_sourc…
1
1
513
Jack’s Lessons from Gabe Plotkin Jack Woodruff’s biggest lessons from his first teammate, Gabe Plotkin: If you can’t explain the investment simply, you may not understand it well enough. Jack described Gabe’s ability to take something extremely complicated and make it understandable to a fifth grader. Simplicity was the edge. Because investing is ultimately a supply-and-demand business. You need other investors to eventually reach the same conclusion. If the thesis is so complicated that nobody can ever get there, what’s the point? Jack and Gabe built their investment and research process around a few basic questions: ➡️What exactly are we underwriting? ➡️Can we explain it clearly? ➡️What is going to change? ➡️What happens when it does? The other lesson was more personal. Gabe had a photographic memory. Jack didn’t. So Jack built procedures and systems around the way he processed information. There is no one-size-fits-all investment process. The goal is to build one that works for you and continue to iterate. 💡 This episode is presented by: @AlphaSenseInc Decision Grade AI : alpha-sense.com/pitch/ @OxfordDataPlan –The Home of Alternative Data: oxford-dp.com/demo?utm_sourc… xitter.gq/PitchThePM/status/2120…
🤖 Made with AI
EP 59. "The Only Risk Is Not Being Big Enough”. Meet JACK: Citadel's Top Stock Picker with Jack Woodruff, exCitadel Partner & CIO of Candlestick Capital “I got an email from Ken Griffin, and he said, 'Don't you think you're a little big?' And I said, 'The only risk is not being big enough.'“ "It's not the best idea at the top of the book, it's the idea I could lose the least in." Jack Woodruff came into the industry looking for shorts through deep accounting analysis. He built a simple and scalable investment process with Gabe Plotkin at Point72, and then ran the biggest team on Citadel's Surveyor platform for nearly a decade, becoming a Citadel partner. In 2019 he spun-out with his team to found Candlestick Capital, where he ran 30-plus stock pickers using a simple investment framework and standard model to create time efficiency. Doug and Jack worked together at Surveyor. They talk about what went on behind the scenes of the Citadel spin-out, the research behind Jack's team catching the top in Lululemon when everyone's credit card data said fine, why a reverse-engineered DCF is still the best tool an analyst has, why process is the edge, and how he hired (never from the buy side) and sized (the idea he could lose the least in goes on top). "I spend no time on me being right. I spend all of my time on me being wrong, because that's what could hurt me." "We never had arguments about a stock. We had arguments about inputs to the model." “There's nothing like getting a good short. There's nothing more satisfying in my eyes." 💡 This episode is presented by: AlphaSense–Decision Grade AI Oxford Data Plan–The Home of Alternative Data *Not Investment Advice (01:38) The peak of Melvin, investors calling, and the Surveyor contract that allowed a spin-out (03:22) Taking the team, the infrastructure and the track record for a revenue share (04:05) How "Jack be nimble" became Candlestick Capital (06:08) "Jack's only 1%": the PR response to his exit (08:37) Why Citadel wanted him picking stocks, not running Surveyor (12:43) An accountant who wanted to be a short seller: Big Six, M&A diligence, Trivium (16:08) Why short selling is the most important role in an efficient market (18:31) "I don't mind the shorts. They're guaranteed buyers" (23:14) The formal preview process and the reverse-engineered DCF (26:59) What AI changes for analysts, and rebuilding Candlestick with Claude (31:53) How Candlestick was organized: PMs, analysts, associates, data science (39:57) Nailing the top in Lululemon: Vuori, Alo and the belt bag (42:49) Tell me what it will be in six months, not what the data says (46:17) The brick-and-mortar shorts: JCPenney and Macy's (49:41) Ken's email: "Don't you think you're a little big in JCPenney?" (51:40) Always in the model: running scenarios on how you can be wrong (56:04) Hiring: never from the buy side, live-round interviews, model tests (65:20) Right 52% of the time: sizing is everything (66:03) Using the risk model without being defined by it (69:40) Four consumer teams at SAC then, 70-plus now (73:28) What's next for Jack
4
1
40
7,149
Doug Garber retweeted
V100 came out in 2017. It’s still renting at ~ $0.50/hour in 2026. Thank you @MichaelDell for citing our data.
We started shipping the Nvidia H100 in 2022. A year ago it rented for $1.96/hour. Today: $3.10. +58%, on a chip that was supposed to be obsolete by now. So much for GPU depreciation.
2
1
2
21
3,174
When two smart investors reach completely different conclusions on the same company, the disagreement may be simpler than it looks. Jack Woodruff put it this way: “You’re using two sets of numbers.” His JCPenney short was a perfect example. He spoke with investors like Glenview and Ackman, on the other side of the trade and realized they weren’t necessarily seeing a completely different business. They had completely different financial assumptions. Their view: +$2 billion of EBITDA. Jack’s view: −$2 billion of EBITDA. That’s not a small disagreement. And it’s a useful reminder when researching the other side of a position. Before debating the narrative, figure out exactly which assumptions are producing the opposing valuation. Sometimes the entire disagreement is sitting inside the model. xitter.gq/PitchThePM/status/2120… 💡 This episode is presented by: @AlphaSenseInc Decision Grade AI : alpha-sense.com/pitch/ @OxfordDataPlan The Data Plan–The Home of Alternative Data: oxford-dp.com/demo?utm_sourc… Not Investment Advice.
EP 59. "The Only Risk Is Not Being Big Enough”. Meet JACK: Citadel's Top Stock Picker with Jack Woodruff, exCitadel Partner & CIO of Candlestick Capital “I got an email from Ken Griffin, and he said, 'Don't you think you're a little big?' And I said, 'The only risk is not being big enough.'“ "It's not the best idea at the top of the book, it's the idea I could lose the least in." Jack Woodruff came into the industry looking for shorts through deep accounting analysis. He built a simple and scalable investment process with Gabe Plotkin at Point72, and then ran the biggest team on Citadel's Surveyor platform for nearly a decade, becoming a Citadel partner. In 2019 he spun-out with his team to found Candlestick Capital, where he ran 30-plus stock pickers using a simple investment framework and standard model to create time efficiency. Doug and Jack worked together at Surveyor. They talk about what went on behind the scenes of the Citadel spin-out, the research behind Jack's team catching the top in Lululemon when everyone's credit card data said fine, why a reverse-engineered DCF is still the best tool an analyst has, why process is the edge, and how he hired (never from the buy side) and sized (the idea he could lose the least in goes on top). "I spend no time on me being right. I spend all of my time on me being wrong, because that's what could hurt me." "We never had arguments about a stock. We had arguments about inputs to the model." “There's nothing like getting a good short. There's nothing more satisfying in my eyes." 💡 This episode is presented by: AlphaSense–Decision Grade AI Oxford Data Plan–The Home of Alternative Data *Not Investment Advice (01:38) The peak of Melvin, investors calling, and the Surveyor contract that allowed a spin-out (03:22) Taking the team, the infrastructure and the track record for a revenue share (04:05) How "Jack be nimble" became Candlestick Capital (06:08) "Jack's only 1%": the PR response to his exit (08:37) Why Citadel wanted him picking stocks, not running Surveyor (12:43) An accountant who wanted to be a short seller: Big Six, M&A diligence, Trivium (16:08) Why short selling is the most important role in an efficient market (18:31) "I don't mind the shorts. They're guaranteed buyers" (23:14) The formal preview process and the reverse-engineered DCF (26:59) What AI changes for analysts, and rebuilding Candlestick with Claude (31:53) How Candlestick was organized: PMs, analysts, associates, data science (39:57) Nailing the top in Lululemon: Vuori, Alo and the belt bag (42:49) Tell me what it will be in six months, not what the data says (46:17) The brick-and-mortar shorts: JCPenney and Macy's (49:41) Ken's email: "Don't you think you're a little big in JCPenney?" (51:40) Always in the model: running scenarios on how you can be wrong (56:04) Hiring: never from the buy side, live-round interviews, model tests (65:20) Right 52% of the time: sizing is everything (66:03) Using the risk model without being defined by it (69:40) Four consumer teams at SAC then, 70-plus now (73:28) What's next for Jack
1
1
13
3,886
In a Good Year, You’re Right 53% of the time. “The only risk is not being big enough.” That was Jack Woodruff’s response when Ken Griffin emailed him asking whether his JCPenney short had gotten too large. With slim odds of winning big on "hit rate," Jack focused on "slugging" or winning big when he had high conviction. In the full episode, Jack’s shares his learnings for crushing it for the past two decades in one of the most competitive games in the world, long-short investment management. ➡️ "to me, it's all about slugging. It's all I ever really cared about" ➡️"make it so easy that a fifth grader could understand" ➡️"I will forever say, that investment management is a time management exercise." ➡️"We never had arguments about a stock. We had arguments about inputs to the model." ➡️ "All I did was be in a model." On Risk Management, he wasn't guided by a complicated quantitative risk model (which he viewed as a distraction to deep research); instead, his process was guided by: ➡️"I spend no time on me being right. I spend all of my time on me being wrong" ➡️"It's not the best idea at the top of the book, it's the idea I could lose the least in." xitter.gq/PitchThePM/status/2120… 💡 This episode is presented by: @AlphaSenseInc Decision Grade AI @OxfordDataPlan The Home of Alternative Data Happy Hunting
🤖 Made with AI
EP 59. "The Only Risk Is Not Being Big Enough”. Meet JACK: Citadel's Top Stock Picker with Jack Woodruff, exCitadel Partner & CIO of Candlestick Capital “I got an email from Ken Griffin, and he said, 'Don't you think you're a little big?' And I said, 'The only risk is not being big enough.'“ "It's not the best idea at the top of the book, it's the idea I could lose the least in." Jack Woodruff came into the industry looking for shorts through deep accounting analysis. He built a simple and scalable investment process with Gabe Plotkin at Point72, and then ran the biggest team on Citadel's Surveyor platform for nearly a decade, becoming a Citadel partner. In 2019 he spun-out with his team to found Candlestick Capital, where he ran 30-plus stock pickers using a simple investment framework and standard model to create time efficiency. Doug and Jack worked together at Surveyor. They talk about what went on behind the scenes of the Citadel spin-out, the research behind Jack's team catching the top in Lululemon when everyone's credit card data said fine, why a reverse-engineered DCF is still the best tool an analyst has, why process is the edge, and how he hired (never from the buy side) and sized (the idea he could lose the least in goes on top). "I spend no time on me being right. I spend all of my time on me being wrong, because that's what could hurt me." "We never had arguments about a stock. We had arguments about inputs to the model." “There's nothing like getting a good short. There's nothing more satisfying in my eyes." 💡 This episode is presented by: AlphaSense–Decision Grade AI Oxford Data Plan–The Home of Alternative Data *Not Investment Advice (01:38) The peak of Melvin, investors calling, and the Surveyor contract that allowed a spin-out (03:22) Taking the team, the infrastructure and the track record for a revenue share (04:05) How "Jack be nimble" became Candlestick Capital (06:08) "Jack's only 1%": the PR response to his exit (08:37) Why Citadel wanted him picking stocks, not running Surveyor (12:43) An accountant who wanted to be a short seller: Big Six, M&A diligence, Trivium (16:08) Why short selling is the most important role in an efficient market (18:31) "I don't mind the shorts. They're guaranteed buyers" (23:14) The formal preview process and the reverse-engineered DCF (26:59) What AI changes for analysts, and rebuilding Candlestick with Claude (31:53) How Candlestick was organized: PMs, analysts, associates, data science (39:57) Nailing the top in Lululemon: Vuori, Alo and the belt bag (42:49) Tell me what it will be in six months, not what the data says (46:17) The brick-and-mortar shorts: JCPenney and Macy's (49:41) Ken's email: "Don't you think you're a little big in JCPenney?" (51:40) Always in the model: running scenarios on how you can be wrong (56:04) Hiring: never from the buy side, live-round interviews, model tests (65:20) Right 52% of the time: sizing is everything (66:03) Using the risk model without being defined by it (69:40) Four consumer teams at SAC then, 70-plus now (73:28) What's next for Jack
1
15
2,405
Doug Garber retweeted
i have to convince my parents that i don’t look like any of them
I have one question… actually, a LOT of questions. 😭
8
1
1
56
6,718
Jack Woodruff is the former founder & CIO of Candlestick Capital and an exCitadel Partner. He is the best investor I personally know. When he spun-out of Citadel, the media called him Citadel’s Top Stock Picker. My top 10 takeaways from our recent conversation are in the latest Substack Newsletter. 👉 pitchthepm.substack.com/p/me… 1. Jack had a solid FOUNDATION. He started as an accountant, the... 2. Jack worked for TRAINING, not money initially. During his MBA, he worked for free with... 3. Jack had a great MENTOR. He worked with legendary investor... 4. Jack had CONVICTION. He attributes his outsized success to... 5. Jack’s RISK MANAGEMENT. His… 6. Jack had WORK ETHIC. His team worked… 7.Jack had PASSION. There was some… 8. Jack had a great PROCESS. He simplified every stock to one of… When he shared this, everyone I know started to write as fast as they could! 9. Jack attracted, TRAINED, and retained top talent. His secret was to... 10. Jack be nimble, Jack be quick, Jack jump over the CANDLESTICK. He was one of two… 👉 Full Newsletter: pitchthepm.substack.com/p/me… Full episode dropping soon 😎
1
2
45
78,387