The Jem. retweeted
“We’re not against sex workers, guys! Just because we want to strip you of your livelihoods, make you homeless and put you in dangerous abusive situations, that doesn’t mean we’re against you!”
The Jem. retweeted
i visited my uncle's wife recently. she used to be full of life, we used to talk & laugh together. She became a mother. She pees herself anytime she laughs and she became so quiet. Motherhood stole her soul. Nothing changed for my uncle tho, it is not fair to women.
Replying to @PsychMove @ai_prime10
The difference between eating/breathing and having a kid is that breathing only affects you. Nobody else has to suffer the consequences of you eating lunch. When you act on a desire to create a new person, you're passing the bill—onto someone else who never agreed to the deal.
1
9
Replying to @ai_prime10
I appreciate the honesty even tho' you're pivoting to pure moral egoism ("I do whatever I want because I desire it")which actually proves my exact point. Reproduction isn't done for the child; it's done entirely to satisfy the parents' desires.
1
9
Replying to @PsychMove @ai_prime10
@ai_prime10 If the goal is purely selfless nurturing, adopting an existing child who actually needs a home achieves that without creating brand-new risks for someone who didn't ask to be here.
1
12
Replying to @PsychMove @ai_prime10
You are essentially creating a set of needs and vulnerabilities that didn't exist before, and then calling it selfless to fulfill them.
2
12
Replying to @ai_prime10
As an antinatalist my point isn't that parenting is easy or selfish; it's that creating the child in the first place is done for the parents' desires(selfish), not the child's. Before they are conceived, a child has no need to be fed, taught, or nurtured.
1
13
Once a baby is born, they are already a sentient, feeling being capable of experiencing pain and distress. Letting an existing newborn die causes real harm to a living being. Preventing a conception, on the other hand, harms nobody.
14
they can't want to be born, and they can't feel deprived of happiness if they never exist. You cannot harm someone who doesn't exist, which is why erring on the side of caution means not creating the risk in the first place.
The newborn example is a fair question, though.
1
8
doctors use in emergencies—which is why a valid DNR (Do Not Resuscitate) order legally forces doctors to let a patient die. Autonomy and consent literally come first.
As for the nonexistent child: I'm not saying they 'want' not to be born. A nonexistent person has zero desires,
1
8
if they aren't created. Saving someone from losing a life they already want is completely different from forcing a brand-new person into existence to gamble with suffering they didn't ask for.
1
25
The unconscious patient already exists—they have a history, relationships, and a vested interest in staying alive, so doctors act on 'presumed consent' to protect what they already have. A nonexistent child has zero desire to be born and misses out on nothing
1
25
You are making a classic category error by conflating a life already in progress with a life that has not yet been created but to answer you,That’s the exact difference between a life worth continuing and a life worth starting.
1
24
with the worst-case scenario.
Anyway as for the asymmetrical argument,a mutual of mine explained it in details. Read up.
Interestingly, The philosopher David Benatar provided a strong argument that it’s actually morally wrong to have children…
he said that when you carefully examine the value of pain and pleasure, there is an important imbalance…that the presence of pain is bad and the presence of pleasure is good, but the absence of pain is good even if there is no one to experience that good, while the absence of pleasure is not bad unless there is someone who is deprived of it.
From this, he concludes that bringing a person into existence always introduces harm, because every human life inevitably contains suffering, whereas not bringing a person into existence avoids that harm without depriving anyone of pleasure, since there is no person who exists to miss it.
On this basis, he argues that procreation is morally problematic because it imposes unavoidable harm on someone who did not need to exist in the first place. Even the best lives include pain, loss, and death, and these harms are guaranteed once a person is created.
Benatar also argues that humans are biased in how they evaluate their lives, tending to underestimate suffering and overestimate well being due to psychological adaptation and optimism. When these biases are set aside, the conclusion follows more clearly, creating a new person exposes them to harm for no necessary reason, while not creating them avoids harm without wronging anyone.
Therefore, he concludes that choosing not to have children is the more morally defensible position. 😅
7
Replying to @emifuckingbobby @mr_orero
To clarify,the analogy isn't that the car is guaranteed to crash, just that it might, and you're buckling someone else into the passenger seat without asking them first. Even when life has plenty of good, the person taking the gamble isn't the one who has to live
1
10
Replying to @ai_prime10
Because all reasons is rooted in me,me,me,me,....and none of it has anything to do with the said child.
1
14







