Roger Pilon (@Roger_Pilon) header
Roger Pilon (@Roger_Pilon) profile picture

Philosopher, Lawyer; Sr. Fellow, Cato Institute; Cato VP Emeritus; Founding Dir. Emeritus, Cato Ctr. for Constitutional Studies; Founder, Cato Sup. Ct. Rev.

Joined March 2013
Photo by Roger Pilon (@Roger_Pilon)Photo by Roger Pilon (@Roger_Pilon)Photo by Roger Pilon (@Roger_Pilon)Photo by Roger Pilon (@Roger_Pilon)
Readers might enjoy my Chapter 1, "The Purpose and Limits of Government."
In the Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson recounted, succinctly and methodically, “a history of repeated injuries and usurpations” at the hands of King George III. The Declaration lists, point by point, “a long train of abuses and usurpations.” Jefferson aimed to establish a pattern, demonstrating that Great Britain had “a design to reduce” the residents of the American colonies “under absolute Despotism.” Put plainly, the king had the “direct object” of “the establishment of an absolute Tyranny over these States.” Of course, the story has a happy ending. Two hundred fifty years later, America is still independent and no longer under the control of any king. We live under a Constitution, written just 11 years after the Declaration, that was designed purposefully to avoid many of the worst tyrannies that the colonies suffered. In @CatoInstitute's new book "A History of Repeated Injuries," we explore simple, yet profound questions: 250 years later, how successful have we been? Are we entirely free of the “injuries and usurpations” of which the Framers complained? Or have modern analogues of old tyrannies crept into our own government, leading to losses of liberty akin to those suffered by the colonists? Each chapter in this volume is centered around one of the injuries listed in the Declaration. The authors of each chapter connect the history of the Founding era with modern times, framed around one or more passages from the Declaration’s list of grievances. The aim is to put the language of the Declaration in greater context, looking both backward and forward. What led Thomas Jefferson to include a particular line in the Declaration, and what challenges do we face now that most closely echo that history? For example, Jefferson complained of the king “obstructing the Laws for Naturalization of Foreigners.” As @David_J_Bier explains, “Free immigration was a central principle for the Founders.” Yet today, “all immigrants are presumed ineligible unless they prove they fall into an exception.” The Declaration also famously decries “imposing Taxes on us without our Consent.” @adamnmichel and @JoshLoucks27 recount that the American Revolution “was a rebellion against a system of taxation that was punitive, discriminatory, and enriching special interests on the other side of the Atlantic.” Today, once again, the “tax system has become a tool of political favoritism.” “He has kept among us, in times of peace, Standing Armies without the Consent of our legislatures.” @brandan_buck's chapter begins with this grievance, and he describes a long tradition of “opponents to American militarism” who “believed that the creation of a large standing army, particularly via conscription, fundamentally altered the individual’s relationship to the state.” But as Buck explains, America has indeed kept an enormous standing army since World War II and many of the concerns the Framers raised have proved prescient. The Declaration also excoriates the king “for depriving us in many cases, of the benefits of Trial by Jury.” The Framers enshrined the jury trial right in the Constitution because they were well aware of how easily criminal law can be abused. As @ConLawWarrior writes, “British kings and queens generally preferred to operate within the ambit of formal law by enlisting the legislative authority of parliament and creating special adjudicative bodies like the Star Chamber to provide legal cover for their predations.” And in my chapter, I note that “English colonial administrators attempted to subvert the right to a civil jury trial by trying cases in specialized courts called ‘vice-admiralty’ courts.” Further chapters by @Roger_Pilon, @bskorup, and @D_A_Irwin explore the Declaration’s lessons for political philosophy, executive orders, and trade, respectively. We hope that this new edited volume will give a broad overview of where we started as a nation, where we’ve come, and where we still have to go to achieve the visions of liberty and good government envisioned by those who bravely signed the Declaration of Independence 250 years ago.
1
2
4
327
This clip needs to be widely circulated -- not that the credulous will be move by it, but others will be. The truth about the Gaza War needs to come out, one step at a time, and this is one such step.
Former AP journalist Matti Friedman admits that they had no choice but to be complicit with Hamas, and NOT admit that many of their dead were in civilian clothes. I’m certain that ALL networks had no choice but to do this for fear of Hamas in Gaza.
1
2
2
747
Worth your four minutes.
218
Antisemitism explained as envy on steroids.
Gad Saad gave the best explanation of antisemitism I ever heard!
1
114
Roger Pilon retweeted
Holy shit. Wow. This is HANDS DOWN the best take I’ve heard. If there is one video you listen to today it’s this one. Every single word of this and it’s a huge “f*ck you” to @antonioguterres for propping up the barbaric terrorist Islamic Regime in Iran. Must be shared everywhere in my opinion. Unfortunately I have no idea who this young British woman is to credit her, if you know who it is feel free to tag below.
1,481
14,933
1,647
36,451
905,543
Ed Crane, cofounder of the Cato Institute in 1977, died on Feb. 10. Yesterday, Cato posted brief tributes from several of Ed's long-standing colleagues, including me. bit.ly/3MF0xJ8 Ed was a masterful organizer, steeped in libertarianism, and inspired by America’s founding principles. Cato is his legacy.
1
2
126
Those were the days.
Margaret Thatcher on the socialist ideology hating freedom. “Socialists just don't like ordinary people choosing, for they might NOT choose Socialism." BOOM 💥 and here we are AGAIN!
1
136
Love it! How far we've come from those days.
Socialism refuted in 60 seconds 🤣
2
514
See my brief critique of this piece in the context of an Inst. for Free Speech symposium on Buckley v. Valeo at 50. @DuncanHosie's real target is Marbury v. Madison. He's a post-New Deal zealot who would democratize a Constitution that protects his speech. bit.ly/4ti14RK
The increasing divide between Congress and the Supreme Court raises critical questions about our democratic system. How can we foster a responsive government in this landscape? Insightful thoughts from @DuncanHosie, SLS ConLaw Fellow, in @TheAtlantic. brnw.ch/21wZ4VS
199
Been away from X for a bit, but last night I saw Brad Smith's post lauding my piece in the Buckley v. Valeo at 50 symposium his Inst. for Free Speech recently hosted. Rereading my piece this morning, not bad! See esp. my take on a Stanford/Atlantic chap bit.ly/4ti14RK.
"James L. Buckley: The Man & His Principles" is the 9th essay in @InstFreeSpeech series on 50th anniversary of Buckley v. Valeo, the most important campaign case ever before the Supreme Court. It's from @Roger_Pilon, founding publisher of the Cato Supreme Court Review. ifs.org/blog/james-l-buckley…. "Jim noted that what they [he & fellow plaintiffs suing to block the law] had in common was that they were all outsiders... Just to get their campaigns started—to say nothing of the country’s need for healthy political competition—outside candidates needed not only money but big money, especially from major donors, precisely what campaign finance “reform” denied them. . . ." In addition to a great contribution to understanding the Buckley decision and its important, Roger's piece is a warm tribute to Jim Buckley, the man.
1
2
2
281
Brad, Thank you for those kind words, That was a great symposium that you and David Keating put together to mark the 50th anniversary of Buckley V. Valeo, and good of Eugene Volokh to promote it at his Reason blog. Your own summation hit all the right spots. Well done!
"James L. Buckley: The Man & His Principles" is the 9th essay in @InstFreeSpeech series on 50th anniversary of Buckley v. Valeo, the most important campaign case ever before the Supreme Court. It's from @Roger_Pilon, founding publisher of the Cato Supreme Court Review. ifs.org/blog/james-l-buckley…. "Jim noted that what they [he & fellow plaintiffs suing to block the law] had in common was that they were all outsiders... Just to get their campaigns started—to say nothing of the country’s need for healthy political competition—outside candidates needed not only money but big money, especially from major donors, precisely what campaign finance “reform” denied them. . . ." In addition to a great contribution to understanding the Buckley decision and its important, Roger's piece is a warm tribute to Jim Buckley, the man.
3
3
575
Wonderful! Congratulations, John.
It is an honor to run an Institute that bears his name!
1
3
293
Amen.
Ed Meese is one of the kindest and most generous men I have ever met. I am glad we will be able to help ameliorate the damage that has been done to the reputation of the center that bears his name at Heritage, by doing outstanding work under the banner of the Meese Institute for the Rule of Law at Advancing American Freedom. Exciting times ahead! As Ed Feulner used to say, “Onward.”
1
2
212
Merry Christmas to you and Susan!
Folks are asking me what I am going to do next. I’m enjoying Christmas w/my wonderful family, as I hope all of you are doing. When that’s over, I’ll think about the future & how I can continue to contribute to this great country we all call home.
1
5
374
Josh's statement at Reason is worth reading.
I so admire Josh as an honest and forceful analyst, and the Guide is on my desk because a week doesn’t go by that I don’t use and learn from it.
2
7
4,241
It is an honor to run an Institute that bears his name!
Wow. It's not just that the staffers from Heritage's Meese Center are moving to @AmericanFreedom. They're taking the name with them, with Edwin Meese himself in support of it.
1
9
1
120
7,022
My wife Juliana has a nice piece this morning at Civitas, "A National Day of Gratitude," drawing on her first Thanksgiving in America after her family had left communist Romania some six decades ago: bit.ly/4837eg2
1
1
104
Roger Pilon retweeted
Who am I to gainsay this?
Btw, this is from a brand new book edited by my professor, Jan Laitos from @SturmCOL. It features some great pieces on property rights from @Roger_Pilon, @IlyaSomin, @RichardAEpstein, and many more. Get you a copy! e-elgar.com/shop/usd/rethink…
2
3
356
I enjoyed this exchange with @Cato’s legendary Constitutional law scholar @Roger_Pilon — on why I believe the American system will prevail in 21st-century competition with China.
1
13
1,778