Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters) header
Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters) profile picture

Ex-Golden Hippo. Now @mailerprofit. Sharing 14+ years of retention marketing knowledge

Joined May 2026
Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)Photo by Sarah Saturday (@Saturdaymatters)
Sarah Saturday retweeted
The biggest winner in DTC is usually the business that's willing to take on the most legal risk in their ads. It always plays out that way. Brand scales using relatively normal ads. Then a competitor pops up and starts running ads that are 10% more aggressive. The original brand sees CAC go up because there's a new competitor bidding with better ads. In order to cope with the increased CAC, the original brand has a few options. Option 1: one-up the competitor by running ads that are more aggressive, which creates a never ending spiral of out-lying and out-risking. Option 2: switch to MRR/focus on LTV. Option 3: do both. That's why the market is playing out the way it is right now. Creative strategists are in higher demand than ever. And eCom businesses are switching over to MRR en masse, desperate for retention experts who know how to build and optimise a retention program - because the edge is now in retention economics. And if you're a brand owner running subscriptions without understanding cohort analytics, zero day churn, split testing on your subscription cohorts and beating controls, not knowing what good/bad metrics look like; you are going to lose to the brands who do (ie the clients at Mailer Profit)
27
7
4
294
15,857
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Should emails be image based or text? For a while, I believed the hype. We switched Truvani emails to those nice image based emails… Deep down I thought it was a mistake. But everyone else was doing it. And brand. And looks so pretty. Yea, well. They also don’t perform. Text based emails beat image based emails and that’s that. We went back and email is now a channel that’s growing. Found the right agency - which is rare - to run it. But man. Looking back at our image email performance is gross.
22
4
2
93
11,025
Sarah Saturday retweeted
HIDDEN AGENDA I'M PUSHING: - Shrink your attribution window. Every other agency wants to widen it - Subscription orders are not campaign revenue. (Most ESPs let agencies count them twice anyway) - Ask your agency to show you campaign revenue with subscription orders stripped out. Watch what happens - Wide attribution windows aren't a Klaviyo default. They're a retainer protection strategy - Your agency's win rate goes up every time their attribution window does - Your attribution ain't shit. Your agency just doesn't want to admit it.
2
3
24
1,461
Sarah Saturday retweeted
We have a wellness brand pulling $1.14M/month from email & SMS alone. - 23% of total store revenue attributed directly to email & SMS - $136K generated from SMS abandoned checkout in the last 30 days - 17% click rate on SMS flows - 64K net-new subscribers added in a single month - from flows alone - Two flows (welcome + checkout abandonment) driving the majority of revenue - AOV climbing toward $100 without discounting deeper - just smarter bundling - List is still compounding while attribution holds steady
6
2
24
1,513
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Wrote as a fake man for a probiotics brand > The owner wanted something legitimate > Started auditioning people to be the face of the brand > Brought in a bunch of candidates to test > Found one guy where you’d let your kid sit on his lap > Called him Skinny Santa > Advocated hard to sign him and test him > He is the only guru for the brand… but one of the top converting gurus in the wellness space
3
17
951
Sarah Saturday retweeted
We have yet another supplement client making $1.8M/month but was struggling during Chinese New Year. Every year, the factory shuts down. So they either overstock or run out. The fix was moving the entire customer base onto subscriptions. A retention channel solving a manufacturing problem.
1
2
19
1,214
Sarah Saturday retweeted
We have a seller in the beauty device space. 70% of customers renew after month one. $226 LTV by month six. Their goal is $1M MRR in the next 3 months. This is what happens when a great product has marketing that matches it.
3
3
20
2,382
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Our manufacturer shit the bed on a cosmetics order > Wrong color, couldn't ship it under the original SKU > The plan was to make them eat the cost > Instead, we relabeled it a seasonal limited edition > Got the units at a discount for the trouble > Charged a premium because it was “limited” > Sold through 5,000 in 3 days > Limited drops have been in the plan ever since
1
2
22
1,700
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Client wanted their emails to look more premium - Built them a beautifully designed campaign - Plain text email beat it - Tried a fancier popup (spin-to-win, mystery discount, the works) - Plain scratch-and-win beat that too - Pulled a plain text winner from 3 months ago and just resent it - It beat the new stuff again - Now the ugliest email in the account is the highest converting one
2
3
24
1,726
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Brands pulling $1.6M/month from their flows are constantly optimizing them. Set them and forget them, and yours quietly die while you sleep.
5
1
24
1,603
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Underrated founder hacks: - Buy from your own brand every month - Timing matters just as much as the offer - Read your own reviews before you read another marketing book - Hire operators you'd hand the master password to, then actually hand it over - Half your “we need a new strategy” meetings are “we quit too early” meetings - Every dollar spent acquiring a customer you can't keep is a dollar you lit on fire - Pour money into what already works before you spend it learning something new
2
3
25
1,692
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Someone asked @zzarakkk recently why he’s been so “quiet” lately. My read: he’s not quiet. He’s maturing. And he’s only going to speak when it matters. I’ve watched that happen in real time over this past year. And I think it only happens when someone has peace. When they know the people next to them will catch whatever they throw. There’s a version of you that’s loud because you’re filling space. And a version of you that’s quiet because you’ve found the people worth saving your words for. If your absence is being noticed by people who were wasting your time anyway - good.
2
15
1,023
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Subject line: “Please don't forward this” One send = $40,236.29 … Pretty sure some of them forwarded it.
2
4
25
2,244
Sarah Saturday retweeted
First half of 2026: 📧 A perfume brand launched a subscription program - it's now the majority of their business 📧 A wellness founder offloaded email and had the bandwidth to launch an entirely new beauty brand 📧 A music marketing company crossed revenue milestones we don't talk about publicly - in a vertical most agencies won't touch 📧 $1M+ Klaviyo month. $777K Klaviyo month. Both in the same industry. Same month. 7 active pods. Multiple verticals. Zero clients that look the same. The best retention work gives founders their time back. It changes their business model. It opens doors they didn't know were there. That's what we're building.
1
2
20
2,383
Sarah Saturday retweeted
COPYWRITERS DON’T WANT YOU TO KNOW THIS: 01) Plain text → outperforms your $5k designed template every time 02) The email that reads like a text from a friend → converts more than the one that looks like an ad 03) Concision → if you can cut it and nothing changes, cut it 04) Copy built from your customer's exact language → always outperforms copy built from a brief 05) Hand copying great emails → teaches more about persuasion than any copywriting course 06) Copy is psychology on paper → most copywriters study writing, not people 07) The customer reading an obvious AI email → feels it, assumes the product's the same quality 08) A list built on real connection → will outlive your ad account, your platform, and your agency
8
29
1,738
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Underrated life advice: Be as intentional about your business partners as you are about choosing a spouse. Real work-life balance is not 50/50. It is built with people who have your back so completely that the line stops mattering. You do not clock out to recover from them. You root for each other. Most people never find this because they never took the partnership seriously enough to look for it.
1
2
23
962
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Grew about 1K followers in WEEKS But I’m not just documenting a journey to “X followers in Y days.” Here's what I'm actually doing: - Pulling value straight from real client audits and calls - Refusing to gatekeep wins that could help someone else - Giving playbooks freely… no one's executing it as we do anyway - Only trying to reach the founders who are ready to hear it My follower count is like a body count: None of my business.
1
3
19
1,039
Sarah Saturday retweeted
We had a women's supplement brand that nearly 2x’d revenue in 6 months. $1.93M/mo in December → $3.87M/mo today. Store revenue up 90% Email revenue up 173% The business scaled. The email program scaled faster.
2
1
20
2,556
Sarah Saturday retweeted
Got on an onboarding call with a founder two weeks ago. Before I could finish my intake questions, he stopped me. He wanted to know who I was. Whether I'd actually be involved or just hand off the brief. He'd been burned before. Last agency gave him copy that could've been written for anyone selling anything. Here's what this guy had already done before he ever hired us: > Spent a full month researching his avatar before he built the product > Compiled every word, phrase, and complaint his customers use on Reddit and Amazon into a document > Built the product around a gap (everyone else is selling gummies with sugar and food dye to kids who react to sugar and food dye) > Migrated subscription platforms specifically because the old ones' dunning system was producing bad churn data and he couldn't trust the numbers > Fulfills out of his home with his family because he trusts them most He didn't ask how our process worked. He asked whether the right person would be touching his brand. Most founders never think to ask that. They hire the agency, let whoever gets assigned do the work, then complain three months later that the copy doesn't sound like them. This guy treated the partnership like a hire. That level of intentionality doesn't just show up in how he vets vendors. It shows up in everything he's built.
3
1
1
25
1,620
Sarah Saturday retweeted
If you've spent your late 20s-30s in ecom, you'll notice this: - Some left a broken system the moment they saw it for what it was. - Others stayed inside it, arguing they could fix it from the bottom. - Some bet they could do more good upstream than fighting downstream. - Others kept treating symptoms and called it a career. - Some moved across the country on a maybe. - Others waited for a sure thing that never came. - Some said yes to learning a whole new craft at 27. - Others decided what they already knew was enough. - Some built things nobody asked them to build. - Others ran the playbook they were handed and stopped there. - Some walked when the terms stopped fitting their life. - Others complied and resented it quietly. - Some trusted one introduction that broke their own rule. - Others let an old bias make the decision for them. Same decade. The difference was never timing. It was who chose.
1
3
21
1,500