Replying to @ElGatoPartners
Let me help you understand this here… after all, I do wish to offer some insight.
The company holds $157 million in cash. The stock now trades at $0.33, giving the company a market capitalization of roughly $104 million… that’s more than $50 million below the cash on its balance sheet, or about $0.50 of cash behind every $0.33 share.
The market is valuing the operating business at less than zero, and that is a direct verdict on how this company is being run.
Now, we are in the second Nasdaq compliance period, which expires March 1. There will be no further extension… under current Nasdaq rules, failure to comply at the end of the second period means immediate suspension, with trading moving to the OTC market while any appeal is pending.
To show 10 consecutive business days at $1.00 or above, action must be effective no later than February 12, and realistically by late January.
Now, let’s add insult to injury. Shareholders granted the Board broad authority this summer. That authority carries an obligation to use it for all shareholders, not to treat them as hostages.
No one other than I has asked the Board to commit to anything.
Here are my thoughts:
i. Buyback: Repurchase at least 200 million shares. At current prices that is roughly $66 million, buying back stock at about two-thirds of the cash behind it. Given the stock's trading volume, this should be done through a tender offer launched no later than mid-December, not left to open-market purchases that cannot reach this size in time.
ii. Digital asset fund: Seed a fund with 1,000 BTC, with a Solana allocation added to it, funded from the cash balance remaining after the buyback.
iii. ETPs and tokenized Reg A bonds: Use the company's ETP platform and distribution to monetize public/private partnerships, financed through tokenized bonds issued under Regulation A.
iv. No reverse split on its own: If the Board uses its authority to do a reverse split, it must be announced together with the buyback and a written commitment of no equity issuance (including ATM sales) below a stated price for 12 months, and no insider selling during the buyback. A reverse split by itself, followed by dilution, would confirm what shareholders already suspect.
Just my .02…
1
1
65
Replying to @ElGatoPartners
I don't care what they confirmed or said... I got on a video call with them awhile back - Johan, Andrew, Curtis and another shareholder... and they promised this and said that and they said that they hoped I didn't sell my shares - and at that time market structure was changing and I couldn't dump shares the way Van Eck did.... The J. Gunnar deal was BS and all of the discussed "possibilities" with the company have done crap. Management is unaccountable, leaves too many gaps in what is done, what is said and what is in writing, I find them to be self serving, conflicted by and with the appearance of self dealing and counsel skates on a very thin line of ethical misconduct and if he were here in the US I'd have both a legal and non - legal investigator after him to try and pull his license. I hold millions of shares, from the beginning, I'm not a trader and will certainly be one of the ones involved in future litigation. I mean the balls on these guys... they told shareholders how they were investigating short sellers and market manipulation with. digital forensics team and then in a conversation I'm told they're shopping for a party to fund the litigation and then my character is assassinated for giving them the benefit of doubt... No... fu*ck them.
1
45
Replying to @ElGatoPartners
They're self-serving... and yes, that's a type of intelligence. Now differentiate what kind of intelligence you want to trust with your money. No one bought the shares at $4.95 USD... $4.50... $4... $3... $2... or 1... and there's no guarantee that after a RS anyone is going to buy the shares... the market doesn't trust management.
1
45
$DEFT My issue with the company and its management is that shareholders are being asked to trust both the business story and the people overseeing it, without enough information to independently assess either.
The quarterly release gives combined figures, but doesn’t show which products attract money, which markets generate revenue, or whether expansion into places such as Brazil justifies its cost. That leaves shareholders unable to distinguish productive investment from activity that keeps consuming capital.
Then comes the compliance deadline. Management acknowledged that a reverse split may be necessary, but offered no specific decision or implementation timetable. March 1 is the deadline to regain compliance.
A ten-session run beginning February 12 would finish February 26, assuming every closing bid qualifies. Notices and any necessary approvals come earlier. February 16 could begin a ten-session run ending on March 1 itself, but that leaves no cushion.
That creates an imbalance: shareholders face a dated consequence while management describes business opportunities without comparable dates or commitments.
And this is where independent oversight matters. Someone should be pressing management on both sides: Which initiatives are producing results? How long do we fund the others? When do we act to protect the listing? What happens if the plan fails?
Lucet’s overlapping roles do not establish wrongdoing. But they make it reasonable to ask who provides independent advice when the interests or conduct of connected executives come under scrutiny. His position as counsel does not itself answer that question; the board needs to explain its safeguards. Then again, the Board is problematic as well.
Then again, I told Andrew and Curtis and they told Kenny this over a year ago. Since then I’ve told everyone that there’s an issue, or the appearance of an issue, with Governance.
We should keep one distinction precise: I verified these disclosure gaps in the earnings release filed on EDGAR, not yet throughout every quarterly statement and note.
I cannot establish why management omitted a detailed split timetable.
Please... someone step in and buy the company... and get rid of management.
Max
@jhnwtt @Forson @CSchlauf @DeFiTechGlobal @ValourFunds @reflexivityres @novogratz @matthew_sigel @Russ_N_Starr @Frank_Giustra @bulldogholmes @olivierfrancois @CoinDesk @ElGatoPartners @martypartymusic @BaltiTrades @etiennecol @fishfishjump @IGasU22Up
Replying to @ElGatoPartners
Management hasn’t given shareholders enough detail to judge where their money is working or a clear timetable for handling a deadline that could force a reverse split. That makes independent board scrutiny especially important. Yet shareholders have also been given little explanation of how that scrutiny operates when counsel and executives have overlapping relationships. They are being asked to supply the trust that better disclosure and demonstrably independent oversight should earn. Most of the company's management believes they're very intelligent... shareholders like me think they're seriously disconnected from reality.
1
72
Replying to @GauravA62820706
Thanks for the invaluable insight, and for the masterclass in how not to use the internet or the English language.
1
1
126
The message from the $DEFT call and transcript… Shareholders need to be patient. Again.
“Look at the earnings potential.” Where is it? “In the new funds.”
Where are the investors? “Waiting for a track record.”
What about the stock? “Institutions might buy after a reverse split.”
Each answer points somewhere else. You never quite arrive at a result someone is responsible for delivering.
The problem isn’t that everything takes time. It’s that every explanation ends with another condition… and no clear point where management runs out of explanations and owes shareholders an outcome.
The funds are coming… Approvals are coming… Clients are interested… Deals could happen when the market improves… And apparently, investors might buy the stock once a reverse split makes the price look more respectable.
Wonderful. Everyone has something to look forward to except the people already holding the shares.
That’s the point everyone needs to pay attention to.
There was progress. Customers put more money into Valour’s products, and Stillman’s business has grown. But the big profit needs context: a large part came from investments going up in value. That helps the balance sheet. It doesn’t tell us the business can consistently earn enough to cover its costs.
That was the question I wanted answered: can this company make dependable money for its shareholders?
Instead, we heard about more things being built.
The new fund is open, but so far the company supplied all the money. That’s a start. It isn’t proof that outside investors will commit money. Interest may exist; commitments are what matter.
Alpha has relationships, but the counterparties would prefer better prices before doing deals. Fair enough. They can afford to wait. Shareholders would probably enjoy that luxury too (sarcastic).
Custody is delayed because people were moved to other important projects. We can’t hear much about those projects yet, but naturally, they’re important. We’ll have to take that on trust as well. LMAO (sarcastic)
Then there’s the reverse split.
Management says it will do one if needed to keep the Nasdaq listing. I understand why. But fewer shares at a higher price won’t undo anyone’s losses. And saying institutions might buy afterward is a pretty thin comfort to the shareholders who bought beforehand.
Some funds may genuinely be unable to buy below a certain price. Fine. But being allowed to buy and actually wanting to buy are two different things.
Shareholders are being asked to take comfort in buyers who haven’t bought.
What bothers me most is how little management has offered in exchange for more patience. On a personal level, I don't find management believable or trustworthy.
What spending gets cut if the new funds don’t attract customers? What happens if approvals take longer? How is management’s pay affected if shareholders keep losing ground? At what point does the board say, “This hasn’t delivered, and we need to change course”?
And where is the board in all this? And a question for Philippe Lucet, If it’s holding management accountable, shareholders deserve to hear how. What targets were or have been set? What happens when they’re missed? Because from this call, it’s hard to tell where management’s assurances end and the board’s oversight begins... and if counsel, a member from another founders BoD is capable of walking the tightrope.
Nobody can promise a stock price. But management can make commitments about how it spends shareholders’ money and what it will do when plans fall short.
Instead, we got another version of, “I’ll gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today.”
Shareholders already bought the hamburger. They’ve been waiting. And now they’re being told that changing how the bill is divided might attract a better class of customer.
Before asking for more patience, management needs to tell us, the shareholders, what they’re putting on the line... and what changes if Tuesday comes and goes again.
... then again, its a perfect takeover target for a company that can deliver...
Max
@jhnwtt @Forson @CSchlauf @DeFiTechGlobal @ValourFunds @reflexivityres @novogratz @matthew_sigel @Russ_N_Starr @Frank_Giustra @bulldogholmes @olivierfrancois @CoinDesk @ElGatoPartners @martypartymusic @BaltiTrades @etiennecol @fishfishjump @IGasU22Up
Replying to @FattyFatty12352
... the Q3 earnings release issued yesterday, November 12, doesn't discuss or quantify legal costs.... it reports total operating expenses of US$11.3 million, without breaking out legal fees. Its only mention of legal proceedings is in the general risk disclosure.
34
Replying to @FattyFatty12352
Ahh... thank you... providing a detail like that would take away an appearance of material concealment... everyone's aware already.
4
141
I was an early retail investor in $DEFT. I understood that expansion would cost money. I expected management to remember whose money it was spending.
Brazil, new markets, new products... fine. Show us what they cost, what they earn, and when shareholders can expect a return.
Then explain why key management short-term benefits rose 89% while core revenue fell 29%.
Expansion can justify investment in the business. It isn’t a blank cheque for the people running it.
What justified the increase? Why now? Where is the restraint shareholders have been expected to exercise through a bear market?
YTD compensation, consulting and professional fees alone exceeded core revenue. In Q3, professional fees practically matched Valour’s entire management fee and staking/lending income.
I’m tired of being sold tomorrow’s potential while paying today’s bills. The shareholder proposition is starting to sound like Wimpy from Popeye: “I’ll gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today.”
Except management’s meal appears to have been paid for already.
If expansion justifies these costs, publish the budgets, the milestones and the consequences for missing them. Tie management’s rewards to delivering returns, rather than asking shareholders to keep financing the promise.
We invested early. We took the risk. Why are we still waiting for a payoff that management appears to have awarded itself?
Final thought… Miami… was in South Beach at the Ritz for Cantor and will be at Loews in the Gables for more… you’ve missed the boat… not sure if there’ll be another…
@DeFiTechGlobal @jhnwtt @Forson @olivierfrancois @ElGatoPartners @CSchlauf @Russ_N_Starr @etiennecol @fishfishjump @IGasU22Up
Replying to @Russ_N_Starr @Shasershas @WaGon90392895 @calilocosi @himshouse @VectorSciPAIN @DeFiTechGlobal
...a little birdie had once said you resigned originally because of another little birdie's personality and their unwillingness to share a few extra bread crumbs...
1
123
I've been a shareholder in DeFi Technologies since the beginning. I believed in what this company could have become, and I've watched it grow, and then change, and then change again.
That's precisely why what's happening now is so disappointing.
I don't think shareholders should have to sit quietly when they have legitimate questions about management, transparency, governance and the direction of the company.
I think there's value in the underlying portfolio and that's what makes this particularly frustrating.
Then again, maybe it's time to stop asking how the existing structure can be preserved and start asking what would actually be best for shareholders…
There's an earnings call on Friday.
I’ve attached a few names to this post - the emails will go out privately and perhaps a well-funded US group will recognize the opportunity, acquire the portfolio, put the businesses under new leadership, give the flag a fresh identity and build something exceptional.
… and here's my concern: whether earnings come in slightly above expectations, break even or disappoint, shareholder value will continue to suffer because management isn't prepared to address the bigger issues.
In my view, that includes the failure to adequately confront concerns around short selling, wash trading and fundamental changes in market structure that increasingly allow AI-driven strategies and exceptionally well-funded participants to put retail investors at a disadvantage.
These are issues that deserved serious attention and a meaningful response.
It also includes the appearance of some serious self interests run awry.
Now, I'm not suggesting any of this because I want to see the company fail. Quite the opposite. I believe the assets, the underlying businesses and the people doing the actual work deserve an opportunity to succeed.
But I also believe management needs to change.
Whether that happens through the market finally recognizing the underlying value or through a sale to someone with a better vision, shareholders deserve an outcome that reflects what they've invested in.
This isn't about management protecting management.
It's about the people who put their money, trust and expectations into this company and the investment thesis that so many retail shareholders believed in and supported.
I think it's time that conversation happened openly… Then again, maybe not.
I'll enjoy the fireworks or the demolition either way.
@DeFiTechGlobal @CSchlauf @jhnwtt @Forson @olivierfrancois @Russ_N_Starr @matthew_sigel @martypartymusic @reflexivityres @SECPaulSAtkins @lathamwatkins @SkaddenArps @sullcrom @NelsonMullins @BakerHostetler @FinCENnews @FT @novogratz @fishfishjump @etiennecol @IGasU22Up
Replying to @DeFiTechGlobal
@DeFiTechGlobal @DEFTIndex @Forson @jhnwtt You may need to publish the dollar flows, product AUM, and evidence these signals predict subsequent returns (for the most recent DVIO... Otherwise, it reads like a weekly sales dashboard dressed up as investment intelligence... but you know that.
1
124
