Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant) header
Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant) profile picture

When something does not add up, you are missing data. Math works! If you are missing data, follow the money

Joined November 2022
Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)Photo by Richard Crowe (@SocraticQuant)
Richard Crowe retweeted
NATO-OTAN Article V does NOT say what many people believe. We must still follow our constitution. US obligations under NATO Article 5 (simple ranked list, most to least binding/significant): 1. **Treat an armed attack on a NATO ally as an attack on the US** If a NATO member in Europe or North America suffers an armed attack, the United States must regard it as an attack against itself. 2. **Assist the attacked ally with “such action as it deems necessary”** The US is obligated to help restore and maintain the security of the North Atlantic area. This is a real international-law duty, but the *form* of help is left to the US. 3. **Armed force is allowed but not required** The treaty explicitly permits the use of military force, yet it does **not** automatically require troops, combat, or a declaration of war. Assistance can be military equipment, intelligence, logistics, airspace/port access, sanctions, or other measures. 4. **Follow U.S. constitutional processes** Article 11 requires obligations to be carried out according to each country’s constitution. In the US this means the President generally needs congressional authorization before committing forces to combat (Congress holds the power to declare war / authorize force). The treaty does not bypass Congress. 5. **Act individually and in concert with other allies** The US must coordinate with the rest of NATO while still deciding its own contribution. 6. **Report the attack and all measures to the UN Security Council** Immediate reporting is required. 7. **Terminate measures when the UN Security Council takes over** Actions under Article 5 end once the Security Council has taken the measures necessary to restore international peace and security. Key realities - It is **not** an automatic trigger for war or a blank check for the President. - It applies only to armed attacks within the geographic limits of Article 6 (mainly European and North American territory, Turkey, and forces/vessels/aircraft in the North Atlantic area north of the Tropic of Cancer). - It has been formally invoked only once—after the 9/11 attacks on the United States—when allies provided a range of support short of a full automatic war response. - The flexible “as it deems necessary” wording was deliberately negotiated by the United States in 1949 precisely to avoid an automatic military commitment.
1
1
1
189
Richard Crowe retweeted
Why is it always "a path to citizenship " as an end result of Amnesty? Why not a path to legal residency with no path to citizenship? Why not a practical compromise that gives each side what they want? Extreme vetting and payback of any welfare accessed while illegal. Payback can even be on a payment plan. Anyone not qualified gets immediately deported. Sanctuary states/cities legally prohibited from NOT passing illegals convicted of crimes being passed over to ICE so they do not have to conduct as many raids. Continued funding for the "border wall" and upgrades. This approach would overcome the objections of adding voters and ensure that we keep productive people. It would also allow the issue to be put to be before the next election. Deporting the full unauthorized immigrant population (roughly 13.5–16 million as of 2025–mid-2026) would cost on the order of $250–1,000 billion in direct federal spending and take 10–30 years, depending on the pace, mix of enforced vs. voluntary departures, and capacity build-out. CC @POTUS @SenSchumer @RepJeffries @LeaderJohnThune @Jim_Jordan
Would you support some sort of "amnesty" agreement if it guarantees Republican control of the Whitehouse in 2028? Why?
4
1
2
6
668
Elon Musk reveals how Starlink saved Ukraine from collapse, and sets the record straight on claims he throttled it: “There is no private individual who has helped Ukraine more than I have. I made sure that Starlink was in Ukraine, prepositioned ahead of the Russian invasion.” “When Russia invaded, they disabled all communications, all cell towers, all fiber cables, and every satellite communication system. There was one system they could not disable, and that was Starlink.” “If they had not had Starlink, their entire line would have collapsed because they had no communication system, and Russia would have won. Now, does that sound like a pro-Russian action to you?” “Even to this present day, Starlink provides the backbone of communications for the Ukrainian military and for Ukraine more broadly. If we were to turn off Starlink, the entire Ukrainian front would collapse immediately.” “From the beginning, I said that Starlink is a civilian system. It is not meant to be used for offensive drone strikes that kill people. If you want to do that, you need to do Starshield, which is a separate system that is controlled by the US government.” “In the Starlink system, there is a speed limit. That speed limit is the speed of the fastest road speed limit in Ukraine, which I think is about 80 miles an hour.” “Do not ask me as a private individual to make kill decisions that sometimes result in the loss of innocent lives, not just soldiers. That is not my position to do. And yet we’ve been pressed relentlessly to do that, which I think is outrageous.” “Those are the rules that have been in place since the beginning, for years. Now people pressure me to change it, but I’m not changing it.”
276
1,250
100
7,727
1,535,075
Richard Crowe retweeted
Replying to @DerrickEvans4WV
Yes, confirmed. Vance pulled out of the NYT DealBook Summit minutes before it started to stay in DC for meetings on the recent tech outages (Microsoft, FAA ground stop, banks, NSA network). Officials including the DNI say these are separate maintenance/technical issues, not a coordinated attack or crisis. "Doomsday blackout" is headline hype.
10
20
2
266
36,612
Senator Sanders @SenSanders I am a surgeon This is the MOST IMPORTANT chart in American healthcare. Since 2000, hospital prices are UP 281%. Number one on the chart. Above college tuition. Three times inflation. Now ask yourself: is your care three times better than it was in 2000? Shorter waits? More time with your doctor? Easier to get an appointment? You know the answer. You PAID 281% more for 15-minute visits, a six-week wait for a specialist, a portal instead of a phone number, and a different doctor every time. The money went somewhere. It didn't go to the room you were in. Here's where it didn't go. Medicare's payment to the physician over the same 25 years: up 7%. Inflation: up 93%. Adjusted for the cost of running a practice, that's a 33% cut. Every other line on this chart rose. The one for the person treating you went backwards. So what inflated? The building. Hospitals started buying doctors' practices. Same visit, same doctor, same room, now with a "facility fee." Medicare pays more, your insurer pays more, your copay goes up. The care got worse & so did the invoice. Then they merged. One system buys the hospital across town, the next county, the next state. Insurers can't drop them, so they pay whatever's asked. RAND found consolidation raises prices with no improvement in quality & Sometimes even worse quality. And the backwards doctor line is the fuel. An independent practice can't survive a 33% real cut. It sells to the hospital. Now that doctor sees 28 patients a day on a quota, with an administrator deciding what gets ordered. The 281% grows by eating the doctor. Look at the bottom of the chart. TVs -98%. Software -73%. Cellphone service -44%. Everything with real competition got cheaper and better. Everything that consolidated into a few giants got more expensive and worse. "Nonprofit" hospitals? Many are. Nonprofit means no shareholders. It doesn't mean no surplus. The surplus goes to the next acquisition, the next tower, the next executive. This is corporate medicine on a graph. Not greedy doctors. The doctor line went backwards. It's the building that got expensive, and it's the building that decides how long you wait. Next time someone blames your doctor & the no surprise act for the cost of healthcare, send them this chart and ask one question: Which line is the doctor on? Chart: @Mark_J_Perry @SenWarren #MedicareForAll
Some say we can’t afford Medicare for All. Really? Here’s what we’re spending on healthcare per person vs. countries with universal healthcare: 🇺🇸: $15,474 🇯🇵: $5,790 🇬🇧: $6,797 🇨🇦: $7,301 🇫🇷: $7,367 🇦🇺: $7,469 🇧🇪: $7,750 Fact: We can’t afford NOT to enact Medicare for All.
222
1,182
92
3,339
137,855
Richard Crowe retweeted
As I was saying … Free Starlinks for FAA were offered to Sec Duffy, but he said they were not needed. As it turns out, they were.
Replying to @elonmusk
Correction: the ancient system that is rapidly declining in capability was made L3Harris. The new system that is not yet operational is from Verizon.
3,780
13,099
890
103,245
7,482,303
Richard Crowe retweeted
No senior Biden administration officials were required to live on military bases due to threats. - Lloyd Austin (SecDef) lived in a private home he bought. - Antony Blinken faced prolonged protests outside his private Virginia residence (state police spent >$300k on protection) but stayed there. - Deputy DHS Secretary John Tien (retired Army colonel) lived on base in a condo, paying rent—tied to his military status, not threats.
Trump administration officials currently living on military bases due to threats: -Attorney General Todd Blanche -Secretary of State Marco Rubio -War Secretary Pete Hegseth -White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller -Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent Pretty insane that political violence in this country has become this severe.
2
6
12
1,077
Richard Crowe retweeted
Replying to @SocraticQuant
Unreal, and who's idea is it NOT to vet them?
1
1
1
100
Richard Crowe retweeted
Would the government and/or MicroSoft have a vested interest in keeping quiet on the source of today's outage if it was due to hacking or malicious states? Microsoft would have clear incentives to avoid or delay admitting a successful attack: Reputation and customer trust damage as a major cloud and security provider. Potential stock price impact, enterprise customer churn, and contractual/SLA liabilities. Competitive disadvantage versus rivals. It is routinely in their interest to frame incidents as internal technical failures when possible (and the current description of servers failing health checks under normal traffic aligns more with configuration, software, or infrastructure issues than a classic external DDoS). Governments have more situational incentives: If the attack involved nation-state actors, intelligence agencies may prefer delayed or limited public attribution to protect sources/methods, avoid immediate escalation, or manage diplomatic fallout. Critical infrastructure or government systems relying on Microsoft 365 could raise national-security considerations.
4
2
4
1,072
Richard Crowe retweeted
699
2,454
494
28,222
756,236
Richard Crowe retweeted
Replying to @GuntherEagleman
The question I most wish people would ask is: “What single shift in human thinking would most accelerate real progress?” Answer: Stop treating uncertainty as failure. Treat it as the only honest starting point. Most breakthroughs begin the moment someone admits “I don’t know” and then measures instead of defending a preferred story.
130
314
36
3,252
63,924
Richard Crowe retweeted
Replying to @Olking07 @grok
People are surprised MS products are crashing… lol! Some of you are too young…
67
74
6
2,316
600,174
Richard Crowe retweeted
To be clear, what the @DOGE team and @USTreasury have jointly agreed makes sense is the following: - Require that all outgoing government payments have a payment categorization code, which is necessary in order to pass financial audits. This is frequently left blank, making audits almost impossible. - All payments must also include a rationale for the payment in the comment field, which is currently left blank. Importantly, we are not yet applying ANY judgment to this rationale, but simply requiring that SOME attempt be made to explain the payment more than NOTHING! - The DO-NOT-PAY list of entities known to be fraudulent or people who are dead or are probable fronts for terrorist organizations or do not match Congressional appropriations must actually be implemented and not ignored. Also, it can currently take up to a year to get on this list, which is far too long. This list should be updated at least weekly, if not daily. The above super obvious and necessary changes are being implemented by existing, long-time career government employees, not anyone from @DOGE. It is ridiculous that these changes didn’t exist already! Yesterday, I was told that there are currently over $100B/year of entitlements payments to individuals with no SSN or even a temporary ID number. If accurate, this is extremely suspicious. When I asked if anyone at Treasury had a rough guess for what percentage of that number is unequivocal and obvious fraud, the consensus in the room was about half, so $50B/year or $1B/week!! This is utterly insane and must be addressed immediately.
31,478
90,707
8,390
408,510
68,905,951
Richard Crowe retweeted
Resign your party registration NOW! Make @LeaderJohnThune the leader of a shrinking party. If enough people do this, the @GOP may finally realize that they must listen to the rank and file (you). Your party registration only matters in a few states that require it to vote in Primaries. If you live in one of those states, you can always re-register for the primary and then unregister right after. Sorry @ScottPresler, the people will only stand for so much. Given how they have treated you after all the hard work you did on their behalf, will you join us in a de-registration drive? #DeRegisterParty
🚨 BREAKING: JOHN THUNE has just been easily REELECTED as Senate GOP Leader BEHIND CLOSED DOORS, meaning he will become Minority Leader as of Jan. 2027 — Punchbowl And the ENTIRE GOP LEADERSHIP TEAM has been RE-SELECTED. WHY did we hold this election so soon?! Several patriot GOP senators tried to push it back to let members put out their vision for leadership, but instead we just RUSHED IN and chose the same guy. Confirm nominations and make the most out of the next 60 days. THE CLOCK IS TICKING!
7
3
1
9
1,030
Richard Crowe retweeted
The first Primary is only 14+ months away. Start NOW!
I'm going to say something that needs to be repeated A LOT over the next two years. If you are on the Right and someone else on the Right disagrees with you on your choice for the GOP Presidential candidate, you should definitely argue it out with them on an informed, FRIENDLY basis. And then when the nominee is chosen, the two of you need to join hands and unite behind that candidate. The alternative is communist jihadists. The primary season is the time to ARGUE (respectfully). The general election is the time to UNITE. If you hate everyone who disagrees with you, uniting becomes impossible and so does winning.
1
1
3
303
Richard Crowe retweeted
I don’t need another politician thanking me for my service on Veteran’s Day this year. Fix the VA. Stop wasting taxpayer dollars. Respect the Constitution. Protect our sovereignty. Then we’ll talk.
41
149
6
1,001
11,882
Richard Crowe retweeted
Dummy-mandering! Republicans tried to lock in more House seats by redrawing maps mid-decade (especially in Texas, Florida, and a few other states). The goal was to create extra Republican-leaning districts so they could hold their slim majority. To do that, mapmakers often had to **spread Republican voters thinner**. They took some voters out of very safe GOP districts and added them to neighboring districts that had been more competitive or Democratic-leaning. This is a classic gerrymandering move: you create more districts that lean your way, but you shrink the safety margin in the ones you already hold. Those “watered-down” districts were still expected to stay Republican under normal conditions. But in 2026 the political environment shifted against Republicans (driven by dissatisfaction with the economy, Trump’s approval, and other issues). Because the margins in many of those redrawn districts were no longer huge, the shift was enough to flip them to Democrats. At the same time, most of the new seats Republicans had drawn to flip blue failed to stay red. The result was a classic “dummymander”: an aggressive gerrymander that backfired. Instead of protecting or expanding the GOP House majority, the thinner margins left more seats vulnerable, and Democrats gained control of the chamber. Democrats also countered with their own redistricting in California, which offset some of the Republican gains. In short, Republicans diluted their own safe districts to chase more seats. When the wave came, those thinner districts washed away.
1
1
3
296
Richard Crowe retweeted
Senator Grassley, there are SIXTEEN Judicial nominations pending and 10 stuck in your committee. Impressive work, Chairman Grassley. Slow-walking your own party’s judges is a special kind of leadership.
263
2,444
119
7,596
39,925
Richard Crowe retweeted
Now is the time to start recruiting for Senatorial races in 2028. Here are the seats up for grabs: - Alabama (Katie Britt, R) - Alaska (Lisa Murkowski, R) - Arizona (Mark Kelly, D) - Arkansas (John Boozman, R) - California (Alex Padilla, D) - Colorado (Michael Bennet, D) - Connecticut (Richard Blumenthal, D) - Florida (Ashley Moody, R) - Georgia (Raphael Warnock, D) - Hawaii (Brian Schatz, D) - Idaho (Mike Crapo, R) - Illinois (Tammy Duckworth, D) - Indiana (Todd Young, R) - Iowa (Chuck Grassley, R) - Kansas (Jerry Moran, R) - Kentucky (Rand Paul, R) - Louisiana (John Kennedy, R) - Maryland (Chris Van Hollen, D) - Missouri (Eric Schmitt, R) - Nevada (Catherine Cortez Masto, D) - New Hampshire (Maggie Hassan, D) - New York (Chuck Schumer, D) - North Carolina (Ted Budd, R) - North Dakota (John Hoeven, R) - Ohio (Jon Husted, R) - Oklahoma (James Lankford, R) - Oregon (Ron Wyden, D) - Pennsylvania (John Fetterman, D) - South Carolina (Tim Scott, R) - South Dakota (John Thune, R) - Utah (Mike Lee, R) - Vermont (Peter Welch, D) - Washington (Patty Murray, D) - Wisconsin (Ron Johnson, R) PS: Every house seat is up for grabs
5
5
1
14
1,567
Richard Crowe retweeted
If you had to pick one person responsible for the Electoral blow out, which one would you pick?
32%Trump
62%Thune
6%Johnson
72 votes • Final results
7
1
1
9
1,078