Surprising God (@SurprisingGod) header
Surprising God (@SurprisingGod) profile picture

Can we surprise God? I’m on a journey to answer this question because I think how we answer it radically shapes every moment of our lives. Join me! @thatdankent

Here, facing an open future…
Joined June 2010
Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)Photo by Surprising God (@SurprisingGod)
RT @thatdankent: Are you familiar with the writing maxim KILL YOUR DARLINGS? Writers obey this maxim when they revise their work. They toss…
This quoted post is unavailable.
2
1
Behold! I've started working on Chapter 5 (of 7) of my book "Surprising God." The Chapter is called: God is One. It's actually about Trinity, covenant bonding, and agape love. Right now I'm slogging through Trinity research (pray for me). While it's true that I've now come to a place in life where I find great joy in the reality of the triune God, the topic of Trinity darkens my humors. I wouldn't doubt it if several layers of hell involve intensive academic reading about God's triune nature. My negative tingle is well justified. I'm reading this "Introduction to Trinity." At some point I approach a landmark—60 pages in—where the writers are finally getting to their definition. My eyes have already gone numb from endless logical indicators (indeed, therefore, moreover, however, thus), countless nominalizations (simplicity, spiration[!], consummation, filiation[!]), and an all-you-can-eat-buffet of other sour forms of academic jargon. But now, finally, I come to their answer! How to understand the Trinity. My eyes awaken, just a bit, eager for the long awaited light. First, I read their setup: "The Father is not the Son. The Son is not the Father. The Spirit is not the Father or the Son." Okay, fine. So far, so good. And then I read (I kid you not): "While these distinct personal ways of being the one God require absolutely no distinction between the persons of the Trinity and the one God, thus preserving divine simplicity, they also exhibit how the persons of the Trinity are truly distinct from each other—by the manner in which they communicate God's simple essence to each other." Ugh! Think of all the money spent on college, and the hours spent in classrooms, all to come out with this trainwreck of a sentence—at the book's apex! To write this poorly, you need advanced training. If you can unpack this "Introduction to Trinity" sentence—maybe by breaking the sentence up, diagramming it, then soaking it in holy water—what do you find? You'd hope to find a cogent understanding of what the Triune God is. But, no. You find little clarity at all. My first question is this. If there are three "distinct personal ways of being the one God," how is that simplicity? How is that not variation? Maybe there's an answer to this basic, rudimentary question, but the writers give no such answer. Then there's "the manner in which they communicate God's simple essence to each other." What does that even mean, to communicate one's simple essence to another? If it's so simple, what is there to communicate? If the communication is echoing within the Godhead, what could be communicated that the interlocutor doesn't already know? The writers go one to suggest that "the Father eternally communicates his simple essence to the person of the Son..." Why does it take so long (eternity) to communicate something so simple? And to a recipient who already knows the content? And what exactly is being communicated? Do the persons of the Triune God eternally face one another, then twitter compliments to one another, like some old lady mammering to her poodle? "You're so perfect, aren't you? Yes you are! Perfect in every way! Look at you! Who's my perfect begotten Son? You are!" What these writers will say is that, when it comes to God, all talk is analogous, and "analogies are partial," and "all analogies break down at some point." Okay, fine. But that doesn't mean that every broken analogy is good. Or true. Here's a secret I've learned in reading theology and philosophy for the last 30 years: SOME THINKERS ADORE PARADOX. I don't want to go so far as to say they make paradox an idol. But they seem to defend paradox with great fervor (while pursuing clarity with much less fervor). Many are the roads that end in fog when seeking God. Sure. But I think God's triune nature is not one of those roads. I say this because, while God doesn't promise humans omnipotence, or omniscience, God does invite us to share in his triune oneness. In Jesus's final prayer to God, he pleads that we believers "may be one, Father, just as you are in me and I am in you. May they also be in us . . . that they may be one as we are one" (John 17:21-22). Many foggy paradoxes might reside in God. But, God's simultaneous plural nature and monistic nature cannot be one of those paradoxes. Not if we—mere humans—can partake in the same experience. What's the answer, then? What is the oneness of God? The bond? I'll let you know when the book is ready for pre-order (wink-emoji).
"The perfect analogy of the trinity doesn't exi—"
2
1
10
528
Podcaster Nick Loper once confessed: “I thought I liked cashews, until we got some unsalted ones. Turns out I just like salt.” A similar epiphany happened to me. I thought I liked theology and Bible study. I downloaded sermons, listened to lectures, and read books-too-big-for-backpacks. I even earned a master’s degree from @BethelSeminary. Many folks bound into seminary with a song on their lips, only to limp away clinging—if they’re lucky—to a fraction of the faith with which they came. I didn’t lose my faith in seminary. My faith grew. Why I found profit while others found loss, I don’t know. Even basic explanations come out sounding patronizing, or like humble-bragging. Say I point to a simple and impersonal truth, like: seeking God is hard. Notice how this implies that my success came from superior effort: I worked hard enough to overcome the challenge. And notice how this also pins failure to insufficient effort of those others: they were not up to the challenge. But none of that is true. I doubt I worked harder than anyone. Me, I blame seminary itself. I don’t mean Bethel Seminary—which I adored—I mean seminary in general. Seminary is doomed to disappoint. You pass through the doors expecting a lively journey, but instead you encounter cryptic scriptures, tedious commentaries, and abstruse debates about how the shape of an accent mark might affect translation. You Betty-Boop into the room expecting a path of rapturous light, but instead it feels like hours and hours of milking flies. I thought I liked theology. It turns out I just like finding God. I like the gust of relief when I disarm a menacing doubt. I like the swell of euphoria when I comprehend why the good news is actually good—and why it's actually news. I like the boost of conviction when I come to trust more and more the promises of God. One promise in particular stokes my levity most. Paul tells the Corinthians: “For we are the temple of the living God; as God said, 'I will make my dwelling among them and walk among them, and I will be their God, and they shall be my people’.” (2 Corinthians 6:16) I carried this charming promise with me into seminary. God will dwell with us. We’ll hear him approaching in the cool of the day. We’ll know what we know by pure perception—no Bibles, no theology. Immediate and intimate observation, little more. That charming promise kept tickling me and nudging me throughout my seminary studies. It also kept my expectations sober. A promise is a pending thing. "God will dwell with us." That moment still hangs somewhere out of reach, up in the air. We’re not yet there. For now, while we wait for that great day, our work is more constructive than observational. We build our picture of God in the workshop of our minds. We each cobble together a forensic sketch from imperfect sources. We go to the gospels and study the wild testimonies of unexceptional people, written in languages few of us know. We debate our perspectives with fallible scholars and we propound our pictures against theirs. Yes, we have the Holy Spirit, but we must strain to hear his whispers and soft guidance. And all of this we do in a world that looks far more demonic than godly. I’m surprised we find any traces of light at all. I carry on because I know this work is not the thing itself. I do not expect rapturous light or euphoric theophanies. I carry on knowing whatever we can find on a path toward a great promise will always thump dull relative to the expectations of what's to come.
🤖 Made with AI
7
4
42
12,347
Surprising God retweeted
The enemy knows how powerful our unity is. He attacks it. We don’t protect it. Our diversity is meant to be our beauty, not our breaking point. #Christianity #SpiritualAwakening #SpiritualWarfare #Christian #Faith #BodyofChrist
1
3
94
I don't see how a view like this could lead to anything but a sort of functional materialism. The determinism of this breed of Calvinism bears the same burdens as the determinism of secular materialists. Quote pulled from Horton's: "For Calvinism" p. 65.
3
1
3
370
From "The God Who Trusts." Curtis Holtzen pp. 129-130
4
6
558
Surprising God retweeted
I was re-listening to this episode of the @SurprisingGod podcast last night while driving back from Wisconsin at 1 AM so I wouldn’t fall asleep… I’m weird like that, I suppose, but it’s an excellent interview and defense of the Open view. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcas…
1
2
1
1
1,009
Several Reflections On the Challenges of Writing "Surprising God" So Far A book about God is a book about everything. No wonder books about God sprawl all over the place: the topic ‘God’ touches every other conceivable topic. Any true thing about God will echo in the fibers of all that God has created. Me, I have no interest in writing a book about everything. I just want to share how the surprising God I encountered lit up my life and rescued me from despair, and I want to help readers encounter that same God. I don’t want this book to sit on bookshelves as a compendium of Christian theology; I want this book to light readers on fire! Yes, to spread a holy fire, that’s why I'm writing this book, and to spread that fire quickly enough to keep it hot. So when I look at the piles of books, articles, and notecards stacked wobbly around my office floor, my mouth goes slack and my eyes go vacant. I look at my research and I’m pierced with a paradox: all these collected hot-takes, personal testimonies, wise insights, Bible verses, and clever arguments truly helped guide my discovery, but they are not the discovery itself. They are arrows pointing toward a light, but they are not the light. What am I saying? Maybe that I don’t want to get lost in a labyrinth of arrows. Trying to introduce people to this surprising God feels like trying to describe Michelangelo’s Pietà by carefully examining the dust and chips of marble on the sculptor’s floor. Open most academic books about God and you often find one of two toils. Open the first book and you're accosted by the exhausted jargon of a weary scholar, so entrenched in the same fruitless spirals of argument, so numbed by the same circuitous conversations, that their prose dribble across the page, dull and predictable. These books read how I imagine Israelite food critics would read in the 30th year of eating only manna and quail. Open another book and you’ll find a different woe. Perhaps antsy to escape those stagnant loops of discourse, other scholars dive deep into minutiae. They pull out their microscopes to probe new depths of nuance—way down in the neglected deep—hoping to find a new clue, a new insight, a new twist which might shine new light on the ancient debates still hammering away far up on the dark surface. These books might explore dead languages from old scrolls, questioning the gender of a preposition, or the curious placement of an accent mark on an ambiguous word. Or maybe they spatter the page with symbolic logic until the whole thing looks like some contrived hieroglyphics that only four people in the known universe can understand. While the authors are clearly smart, and they may even be right, they’re so recondite they leave the reader not knowing why any of it matters. When you write about God you can get easily stuck in the pedantic gravity of the bookshelf and never achieve orbit, never reach escape velocity. I don’t want to get stuck on those same tired intellectual roundabouts, nor do I want to get lost in the weeds of minutiae. I’m not writing this book to simply share information. I want to open a door for readers to hopefully experience the pervasive hope, purpose, and joy that I’ve experienced these past 30 years. I guess what I’m saying: I want to find the signal in the noise, the melody in the cacophony, and I want that melody to make readers dance, just as the melody has made me dance.
3
1
1
8
671
My brief review of Piper's synopsis of the Five Points of Calvinism. Here's a link, too, if the resolution of the image sucks: goodreads.com/review/show/57…
1
5
176
I'm writing a chapter on making sense of a living God. Open theism makes the most sense of a living God. Calvinism, frankly, doesn't make much sense of a living God at all. If everything unfolds according to a script, God simply plays his role like the rest of us.
“He was crucified in weakness, but lives by the power of God.” 2 Corinthians 13:4 He is alive. He is powerful. Now.
1
3
153
Is it better to be a COWARD or a FOOL?
26%a COWARD
56%a FOOL
18%Too afraid to answer
34 votes • Final results
1
1
1
2
596
We covered many topics, and the Surprising God Think Tank did not disappoint! From his time as a Calvinist, to his controversy around open theism, to his current mindset about God and free will, Greg Boyd gets to the heart of it all! Episode 23 thatdankent.com/greg-boyd-ev…
1
4
9
2,068
Greg Boyd will join the Surprising God Think Tank on May 1, 2024. You can still join in and be a part of the conversation: SurprisingGod.com
3
3
191
The podcast is now on Spotify! I had it set up for Spotify from the beginning, but I forgot to approve the terms and conditions (I am Batman, bureaucracy is my Arkham Asylum). open.spotify.com/show/3kuY4c…
1
3
3
238
Paul Eddy supports open theism, even though he is not an open theism. Here's why. To hear the entire episode, go here: thatdankent.com/paul-eddy-on…
2
1
159
As I pound away at my book, Surprising God, I want to hover at these subterranean forces that drive so many of our beliefs. Besides the cool story about John Piper, Paul captures so well the heart of how I want to engage the issues around God's sovereignty and human potential.
Beneath the arguments and the debates lies something more foundational to theology: What do you consider beautiful? My friend and mentor Paul Eddy lays this out so well. Listen to the whole episode HERE: thatdankent.com/paul-eddy-on…
1
2
6
772
Surprising God retweeted
Anyone else struggle with cynicism toward the church? Welcome to the club! But I bet you would find this tribe refreshing. Check this out.
Exciting news! Meet our featured speakers for Unite 24' - a gathering of minds, hearts, and believers committed to renewing the church with Jesus at the center. Don't miss out! Register now for an unforgettable experience. loom.ly/XYASxVk
4
2
21
6,789
New Episode of Surprising God just dropped:
Oord takes the premises: • Power = fundamentally social • Power cannot exist in absolute isolation then infers: • If God existed w/out creation, God had no power • With no power, God couldn't have created anything Does this work? Dan says "no." thatdankent.com/is-power-fun…
1
2
264