Replying to @jaxoninaction @ThoughtfulSaint
There are plenty of cool prophet figures throughout history, like Hong Xiuquan. Why spend so much time defending a guy who got the most basic of basics wrong?
1
28
Replying to @jaxoninaction @ThoughtfulSaint
Sure; not denying God’s existence is also bare minimum for a prophet.
1
45
Replying to @jaxoninaction @ThoughtfulSaint
It’s not a definition, it’s just a bare minimum; if you get the most important theological fact in history precisely wrong you’re not a prophet.
1
1
46
Replying to @jaxoninaction @ThoughtfulSaint
A person who denies that Jesus was the Savior is simply not a prophet.
2
5
74
Replying to @TomStringham @JReubenCIark
IOW, even if the Saints did not benefit much from the 1st amendment *as a constitutional instrument* pre-1900, relative to a realistic counterfactual, they probably did benefit just from holding it as an ideal they believed existed or that the country would eventually live up to.
1
15
Replying to @JReubenCIark
Nowadays, yes, I see it. In early church history not as much. But I will say that 1A gave the Saints confidence that they had religious freedom, at least until 1833 but even later as a hope, and that confidence/hope may have been necessary to do all the crazy stuff they did.
2
1
43
Replying to @nathanielcastle
I’ll share something in return. Jesus is literally God’s son. The angel said he was called that because he was conceived when God’s power overshadowed Mary. Son thus truly meant offspring, it was not merely a metaphor for shared essence.
4
42
Take away religious freedom and there’s still a chance the Saints make it out of the country earlier and survive. Take away abundant, cheap land and what can they do? Not much: they remain scattered and Zion is not built. 9/9
1
53
But the church’s success happened in spite of a political and legal environment just not quite as bad as elsewhere.
Because it wasn’t just religious freedom: it was literally the land. At every step, there had to be land for the Saints to claim and live on. 8/
1
1
51
This isn’t to say the Saints weren’t blessed with liberty; they were, and the church ultimately flourished. And it’s not to say 1A isn’t good; it is. It’s also not to say that there were better places for the church to be founded initially; there weren’t. 7/
1
1
27
dismissing the Church’s claim to protection under the First Amendment as a “sophistical plea”, saying that Saints’ religious beliefs were only a “pretense” for justifying the “nefarious doctrine” of polygamy. We never actually directly won anything under 1A until the 1980s. 6/
1
1
29
In the Utah War, a third of the US Army was sent to subdue Utah. In 1887, the Edmunds-Tucker Act disincorporated the church, seized its assets, and disenfranchised its members; some Saints fled to Canada. A few years later, the Supreme Court upheld the Act, 5/
1
1
29
The political system itself was seldom helpful and often an obstacle. The Saints were driven out of Jackson County, then Missouri. They left Illinois after a mob killed Joseph and Hyrum. Appeals by JS to the government for protection and compensation had been denied. 4/
1
1
29
Even in the early days in Kirtland, they were able to gather and set aside enough land for new, destitute arrivals to make a living. The success of the early church repeatedly depended on the incredible bounty of habitable and sparsely populated land that existed in the US. 3/
1
1
90
The Saints were able to get cheap land in Missouri and free land in unsurveyed parts. They were able to buy very cheap land in boggy Nauvoo. The Salt Lake Valley was effectively free, and still cheap when the government started charging the Saints for deeds in the late 1860s. 2/
1
1
96
Members think of religious freedom when they think of “choice land”, but when it comes to what set the land apart for the church to come forth I think the political/legal conditions are somewhat overrated relative to the material conditions; especially the land itself. 1/
There’s a fun alternate reality where the Saints settled Vancouver Island instead of the Salt Lake valley and Canada is 15% LDS instead of the US being 1-2% LDS. Even before JS died, the church was looking for places for the Saints to settle that were beyond 1/
2
5
352
Replying to @jaxoninaction @Ch_JesusChrist
It speaks well of us that we provide worship space to groups who would not do the same for us. “Interfaith” might be a stretch in these mostly one-way relationships. I lived within walking distance of four mosques in my old neighborhood; zero such events there to my knowledge.
5
169
Replying to @jkenney
Architects unfortunately claim not to like beautiful buildings if they are new! Their preferences depend on how old they believe the building is. It’s a bit of a cult and it’s very silly.
6
506
Replying to @pcrowe @Car_Free_USA
That's overstating it; as a metro area it's still more dense than every metro area in the US great plains.
15
440


