Unfortunately for JoMo, credit for coinage appears to go to a US TV host on a Fox News talk show in 2013.
foxnews.com/transcript/bipar…
1
1
3
Oh good grief, no.
The risks of Wistyism attaining a critical mass and collapsing the fabric of reality are to great to even contemplate such a venture.
1
5
I'm intrigued by the reference to expulsion from the Garden of Liberal Eden, which I would presume to be what one gets for partaking of the fruit of the Tree of Incognisance.
1
1
5
Replying to @zeno001
@zeno001 Did some sciencing with Grok and the outcome was...
...interesting.
I'm in a skeptical mood, so let's do some science.
A point that's simply not made often enough in the often intemperate debate surrounding paediatric gender medicine is just how utterly detached the entire field has become from any mainstream psychological theories and perspectives on the process of identity formation.
63
Replying to @TomMillerUK
There is apparently a church building in one of the GTA6 promo videos, although whether it made the final game and can be entered is yet to be confirmed.
9
Replying to @prof_curiosity1
@prof_curiosity1
Been playing with Grok and suspect this may be up your street. Did I miss anything/anyone major in setting the prompts?
I'm in a skeptical mood, so let's do some science.
A point that's simply not made often enough in the often intemperate debate surrounding paediatric gender medicine is just how utterly detached the entire field has become from any mainstream psychological theories and perspectives on the process of identity formation.
39
Were this a scientific paper, we'd move on to a 'discussion' offering the author's opinion of Grok's findings but as this is social media, I'll leave my own efforts there for now and open up the floor to everyone else to offer their opinions on this exercise.
24
...while the reverse process again serves to flag up serious weaknesses in the WPATH model and its fit to the current evidence base.
1
24
As regards the predictions each model makes about the other, you probably won't be surprised by now to find that the biopsychosocial model has some quite strong and well evidenced predictions to make about WPATH's model...
1
8
...the general facts without offering any predictive ability.
On the face of it, the biopsychosocial model offers a much stronger hypothesis as a foundation for formulating general clinical and therapeutic practice in this field.
1
7
Across 15 cohort characteristics, supported by evidence, the biopsychosocial model either strongly predicts or closely accounts for 14 while the WPATH model fails to register a single strong fit and appears to generate most of its moderate ratings by being vague enough to fit...
1
7
Again, Grok was left to identify which evidence to include in its assessment without any directive prompts and...
...well, see for yourself, Grok's findings are pretty stark.
1
10
Having set up our hypotheses, each of which relates to and underpins a different model of care; the biopsychosocial model is what you expect to underpin exploratory approaches, while the WPATH naturally underpins the affirmation model, let's look at how each fits the current evidence.
1
7
...potential explanatory power and stands in stark contrast to the paucity of developmental concepts and mechanisms of the WPATH model.
If nothing else, and there's plenty more to come, it readily illustrates the extent to which WPATHs model exists in almost total isolation...
1
10
Grok's Biopsychosocial developmental model, by way of contrast, weighs in at a hefty 14 stages, many of which occur contemporaneously and/or overlap, and appears, on the face of it, to offer a much greater level of...
1
10
As the footnote suggests, biological factors are treated as largely determinative, supporting a belief that gender identity can become developmentally fixed at an early age and represents an 'authentic self' that should be affirmed and supported regardless of age at presentation.
1
9
We'll start with the Grok-generated WPATH model which consists of eight stages but which, in truth, doesn't appear to offer much in terms of explanatory value or developmental underpinnings.
1
13
...against current evidence to see which is the better fit.
That's enough explanation, so let's move on to see what Grok managed to generate.
1
10















