Again, it's not about a single paper
You're looking for a Nature publication and missing the forest for the trees 😇
1
61
You can read through all of his papers 😇
BTC is about the accumulated insights rather than one or few definitive papers
Peter's work spans years, and BTC distills key findings into actionable steps for teachers
1
53
The aim of Building Thinking Classrooms is not to answer every research question
Of course, you could do more research
It's *based on research,* but it's not a PhD thesis that cites references for every statement and every number
Because here's the problem: no one other than academics reads them
If you write a popular book, you need to make it generally accessible
"I've probably known Peter for 20 years...about as long as I've been in Canada. A simple google scholar search (scholar.google.com/scholar?s…) will turn up lots of the research evidence which is 'distilled' in the BTC book."
open.substack.com/pub/pershm…
1
43
Peaked into all the comments 🫡
Check out this one in particular:
open.substack.com/pub/pershm…
1
48
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
#reviewer2 up at 3am trying to find that one citation that will help to destroy and reject the manuscript.
#AcademicTwitter @AcademicChatter
1
49
For what it’s worth it, other scientific fields, such as computer science and deep learning, publish predominantly at conferences
1
23
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
It's a different kind of research
And yes, it is documented in peer-reviewed (book and conference) publications
xitter.gq/VisualInkPub/status/18…
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
You're looking for a different kind of research
Peter isn't doing randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies 😅
As described in the introduction of the book, his approach is more like field research, going into classrooms, observing students
1
43
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
You're looking for a different kind of research
Peter isn't doing randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies 😅
As described in the introduction of the book, his approach is more like field research, going into classrooms, observing students
Yes, it's a great article because it analyzes the sources of the book objectively
– it doesn't say there's no evidence
It spurs a debate about how much evidence there is (which is a fair debate to have!)
Did you read the comments by SK?
Too long; didn't read:
"BTC is not a research text. It is a popular text, meant for a popular audience."
It's based on research by Peter, but it doesn't claim to be a scientific publication
– it's not a PhD thesis 😇
2
71
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
No, that's not a bijective relation
Solid research should be published in journals – agree
But that doesn't imply research published outside of journals isn't solid
That is a false logical conclusion
1
32
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
Agree.
But it doesn't mean book and conference publications aren't peer-reviewed or ain't research 😇
2
143
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
"no paper => no research" as a claim is wrong
Just because your research ain't published in an academic paper doesn't mean it ain't research 😇
And, by the way, book and conference publications are peer-reviewed too
1
54
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
You should try the chocolate cake and read the book
It's delicious 😇
2
1
63
Replying to @DanielBorowsk13 @pgliljedahl
"no paper => no research" as a claim is wrong
Just because your research ain't published in an academic paper doesn't mean it ain't research 😇
And, by the way, book and conference publications are peer-reviewed too




