Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
Court of Appeal Speaks
In Fikah Acres Limited v Robert Kinuthia Mungai, Kenya Planters Co-operative Union Ltd (In Liquidation) & the Chief Land Registrar [2026] KECA 2586 (KLR), the Court of Appeal at Nyeri affirmed the cancellation of 16 titles, consolidating five binding principles for Kenyan conveyancing and land litigation:
1. Root of Title Over the Register:
Under Munyu Maina v Hiram Gathiha Maina [2013] eKLR, dangling a certificate of title is insufficient once challenged; the proprietor must prove the legality of every link in the chain of acquisition.
2. Strict Compliance with Conditions Precedent.
Where a settlement agreement stipulates conditions precedent (such as independent valuations and surveys) to determine acreage, transferring land without fulfilling them renders the transfer invalid.
3. Mandatory Land Control Board Consent.
Under Section 6(1) of the Land Control Act, lack of consent renders agricultural land transactions void ab initio. Equity will not rescue a transaction tainted by forgery or an unproved root.
4. Sequential Inquiry for Bona Fide Purchasers.
Following Dina Management and Sehmi v Tarabana, courts apply a two-step test;
(a) whether the vendor held a lawful root of title capable of transmission (nemo dat quod non habet), and
(b) whether the buyer meets the traditional bona fide purchaser criteria. Good faith and payment cannot sanitize a defective root, particularly where lis pendens, status quo orders, or dual-representation red flags exist on the record.
5. Limits of Section 99 of the Land Act
Statutory protections shielding auction buyers from title cancellation apply strictly to regular exercises of a chargee’s statutory power of sale—not private debt-settlement transfers.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
The Geneva Graduate Institute, Switzerland, is accepting international applications for its 2027 Master’s and fully funded PhD programmes. Fields include international relations, international law, international economics, development studies, anthropology, sociology, and international history and politics
graduateinstitute.ch/applica…
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
"Bona fide occupant" under Section 29 of the Land Act isn't a closed list. Occupiers who got their rights from earlier adverse possessors of registered land (12+ years before their death) can count too, even if they held the land less than 12 years before the 1995 Constitution.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
🚨 A title deed alone is insufficient to establish lawful land ownership where the root of title is challenged.
In Bitange & 2 others v Tuva & 4 others [2026] KECA 2518 (KLR), the Court of Appeal at Nairobi examined whether registered proprietors could evict individuals who had purchased, occupied and developed portions of land before the proprietors obtained their titles.
The dispute concerned Kajiado/Kaputiei-Central/2305, registered in the appellants’ names.
The respondents maintained that they had purchased portions of the original parcel from Mututua Ole Sirinket between 1988 and 1995 and had occupied and developed the land for approximately 22 years.
The Environment and Land Court upheld their interests and ordered the transfer of specified portions of the property.
The registered proprietors appealed.
What did the Court of Appeal determine?
1. A title deed is evidence of ownership, but it is not conclusive in every dispute.
Sections 24–26 of the Land Registration Act protect registered proprietors and recognise certificates of title as prima facie evidence of ownership.
However, where the legality of acquisition is challenged, registration alone may not be sufficient to establish an enforceable claim.
2. Registered proprietors must demonstrate the lawful root of their title.
The appellants produced title documents and official search certificates but failed to provide the underlying sale agreements or other records explaining how they lawfully acquired the land from the deceased owner’s successors.
The Court found that this evidentiary gap undermined their claim.
A registered proprietor cannot simply rely on the existence of a title deed when the process through which the property was acquired is materially challenged.
3. Long-standing occupation may create overriding interests.
The respondents demonstrated earlier purchases, prolonged occupation and development of the disputed portions.
The Court recognised their interests under Section 28(h) of the Land Registration Act, which protects rights acquired, or being acquired, through limitation of actions or prescription.
Such interests may bind registered land even where they do not appear on the register.
However, occupation alone does not automatically confer ownership; the legal requirements for the particular interest must be established.
4. The absence of a formal counterclaim did not defeat the relief granted.
The appellants challenged the trial court’s orders directing transfer of specific portions of land despite the respondents not having filed a formal counterclaim.
The Court upheld the orders, considering that the competing ownership claims and appropriate relief had been fully canvassed during the proceedings.
The appeal was dismissed, leaving the transfer orders in place.
The broader legal and constitutional question
On one side, Article 40 of the Constitution and the Land Registration Act protect registered property rights and promote certainty in land transactions.
Purchasers and financial institutions rely on land registers to determine ownership and assess legal interests in property.
On the other side, the law recognises certain unregistered interests, including rights acquired through limitation or prescription, which may bind subsequent registered proprietors.
Protecting these interests prevents registration from automatically extinguishing legally enforceable rights that arose before the title was issued.
Key takeaway: A certificate of title is strong evidence of ownership, but it is not an absolute defence against a challenge to the legality of acquisition or established overriding interests.
Land buyers should examine both the documentary history of ownership and the actual occupation of a property before completing a transaction.
Follow @Lexken_EMSLaw for practical legal insights on property law, land transactions and civil litigation in Kenya.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
🚨🔥YOUR COUNTY GOVERNMENT ALLOCATED YOU LAND, THEN GAVE PART OF IT TO SOMEONE ELSE. CAN THEY REALLY DO THAT? THE HIGH COURT HAS ANSWERED! ⚖️
Imagine being allocated a plot by the County Council, paying rates for years, developing it and following up on your title, only to discover that part of your land has quietly been renumbered and allocated to somebody else. That is what happened in Basil Washington Achienga v Loice Stella Okaya Omollo & another, where the County Government of Kisumu had allocated Loice Plot No. 9341/19 in 1991, continued recognizing her interest and accepting her rates, but later carved out Plot No. 9341/19A and allocated it to another person. The High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the restoration of the original plot and the eviction of the subsequent allottee. The Court found that the County had never proved that Loice’s allocation had been repossessed or lawfully revoked.
The judgment delivers a serious warning to county land departments: an allocation is not a license to do as you please with land already committed to another person. Even where an allottee has no registered title, a public authority cannot simply strip away an interest it has repeatedly recognized without following due process and giving the affected person a fair hearing under Article 47 of the Constitution. The Court also made an important distinction: although the reallocation was unlawful, the evidence did not prove that the subsequent allottee personally participated in fraud. His claim to be an innocent purchaser nevertheless failed because he had no title and had applied directly to the County for land that was not available for allocation. If your plot has been subdivided, reallocated, or its records altered without your knowledge, do not assume that the County's records or a new allotment letter automatically settle the matter. The history of the allocation, the payment records and the authority's own decisions may be critical in protecting your land rights.
Kindly retweet widely🙏
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
🚨🚨The 𝐇𝐢𝐠𝐡 𝐂𝐨𝐮𝐫𝐭 𝐚𝐭 𝐕𝐢𝐡𝐢𝐠𝐚 in 𝐂𝐚𝐫 & 𝐆𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐥 (𝐓𝐫𝐚𝐝𝐢𝐧𝐠) 𝐋𝐢𝐦𝐢𝐭𝐞𝐝 𝐯 𝐒𝐢𝐥𝐚𝐬 𝐀𝐧𝐝𝐚𝐦𝐛𝐢 & 𝐑𝐨𝐛𝐞𝐫𝐭 𝐀𝐦𝐰𝐚𝐢 𝐎𝐤𝐢𝐥𝐥𝐨 [𝟐𝟎𝟐𝟔] 𝐊𝐄𝐇𝐂 𝟏𝟑𝟒𝟏𝟖 (𝐊𝐋𝐑) held that a motor vehicle dealer who has already sold and delivered a motorcycle cannot be held liable for a later accident merely because its name still appears on the NTSA register.
𝐉𝐮𝐬𝐭𝐢𝐜𝐞 𝐑. 𝐍𝐲𝐚𝐤𝐮𝐧𝐝𝐢 confirmed that 𝐒𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 𝟖 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐓𝐫𝐚𝐟𝐟𝐢𝐜 𝐀𝐜𝐭 creates only a rebuttable presumption of ownership. The person whose name appears on the logbook is presumed to be the owner “unless the contrary is proved.” In this case the dealer proved it had sold the motorcycle to a third party on 11 January 2022, 27 days before the accident on 7 February 2022 and produced a tax invoice acknowledged by the purchaser. The police abstract, the plaintiff’s own evidence and the investigating officer all showed that another person (the 1st Defendant) had possession, control and insurance of the motorcycle at the time of the accident. The Court held that this evidence fully rebutted the presumption leaving the dealer as a mere “paper owner.”
The Court further held that vicarious liability does not arise from registration alone. It requires proof of an employment or agency relationship between the registered owner and the rider. No such relationship was established. The rider named the other defendant as his employer and that defendant confirmed he had given him the motorcycle. The dealer’s employee list did not include the rider.
The decision reinforces two practical points. First, an official NTSA Copy of Records is strong evidence of registered ownership but is not conclusive where clear proof of a prior sale and change of possession exists. Second, victims and claimants should carefully identify the person who actually controlled and insured the vehicle at the time of the accident rather than relying solely on the name appearing on the register.
#law #kenya #legal #TrafficAct #NTSA #MotorVehicle #CourtOfAppeal #HighCourt #Ownership #VicariousLiability
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
The Court of Appeal has dismissed the application by the family of Tony Gachoka to stop Floriculture Limited from occupying the property bought by it in 1995. It is expected that the junior police officers in Thika who have been misused to interfere in the matter will back off and that Tony Gachoka will stop his unnecessary noise through KTN, questioning why and how Somalis bought the land.
For law students and youthful Advocates, we went through the Replying Affidavit and Submissions in this matter. See how they have been applied on the arguable case, and nugatory aspect.
See also, how the Court of Appeal has deprecated the twenty-one grounds of appeal relied upon by the Applicant. As I advised before, a maximum of seven grounds will do.
Lastly, the locus classicus in 5 2 B, Stanley Kang’ethe Kinyanjui v Tony Keter & 5 Others [2013] eKLR was argued by yours truly, thirteen years ago.
Someone asked why I do not teach at Kenya School of Law. I do not need to. I teach in Court everyday, and here on X and Facebook for free. Let Danstan Omari teach at the Thugulu Universities atop TuckShops on Luthuli Avenue, and the Kenya School of Law. Mwewe na Njiwa hawabishani chakula. Mmoja ala nyama na mwingine ala nafaka.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
These are sample submissions on an appeal before the Court of Appeal. I want you to pick key points. One, we have converged the legal arguments to two issues, down from the seven grounds of appeal. Two, we have used seven pages, down from the twelve given. The simpler your presentation, the easier for the Court of Appeal to decide the matter efficiently and effectively.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
ADVERSE POSSESSION: Change in land ownership. The Supreme Court of Kenya has clarified the test for adverse possession and how a change in ownership affects the 12-year limitation period. What should landowners, purchasers and lenders know? Read more lnkd.in/dFEDE46W
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
The Court of Appeal at Eldoret overturned the ELC judgment awarding Silverster K. Kaitany KShs. 50 million in damages against Nyayo Tea Zones, holding that registration cannot cure an unlawful allocation of public land.
kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment…
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
Important Supreme Court decision urban planning and limits of structural interdict orders.
In Claire Kubochi Anami & 2 Others v CECM, Nairobi City County & 20 Others (SC Petition No. E044 of 2025, 30 October 2026), the Supreme Court of Kenya held that courts cannot use an unapproved draft policy to fill a planning vacuum. The maxim “law abhors a vacuum” is an interpretive canon, not an independent source of legislative power.
Residents along Rhapta Road challenged approvals for 17- to 22-floor developments, arguing the area was capped at four floors under the 2004 Guidelines and NIUPLAN 2016. The County had relied on the draft Nairobi City Development Control Policy, 2021, which was signed by the Governor but never approved by the County Assembly or gazetted. The Environment and Land Court used Google Maps to place the plots in Zone 4B (capping them at 16 floors), while the Court of Appeal reclassified them to Zone 3C (capping them at 20 floors) and issued supervisory structural interdicts.
The Supreme Court unanimously set aside this judicial zoning, establishing key principles:
Drafts Lack Legal Force: Planning is a constitutional county function under the Fourth Schedule and PLUPA, 2019. An operative plan requires County Assembly enactment and gazettement. Without an approved plan, a county's power to approve developments on the merits stands suspended; it cannot convert administrative inaction into unchecked discretion.
Courts Do Not Zone: Zoning requires technical, multi-factor assessments of infrastructure, sewerage, traffic, and density. Courts review the legality of planning decisions and can compel authorities to act, but they lack the mandate and competence to fix heights or redraw zoning lines.
Limits of Structural Interdicts: Applying Mitu-Bell, the Court upheld the core order directing the County to enact and gazette a lawful plan within six months. However, it struck out directives prescribing plan contents, consultations, and rolling compliance reports as judicial overreach.
Demolition Is a Last Resort: Demolition severely impacts Article 40 property rights. Where developers rely in good faith on municipal approvals, institutional state failures will not be visited punitively on private parties absent fraud, bad faith, defiance of stop orders, or imminent peril.
Noting that the County gazetted the Development Control Policy, 2026 in June 2026, the Court remitted the matter to the Court of Appeal solely to verify compliance. Approvals stand, confirming that the bench can enforce the duty to plan, but cannot draft the plan itself.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
🔴 A GIFT OF LAND CAN EXPIRE - AND 12 YEARS OF SILENCE CAN COST THE OWNER EVERYTHING
The Supreme Court has delivered a major warning to landowners and a powerful clarification for long-term occupiers. In Kakuzi PLC v Makuyu Club (Suing through Trustees) [2026] KESC 69 (KLR), the Court held that occupation which begins with permission or a donation is not automatically adverse possession - but where that permission is no longer legally binding on a subsequent owner, continued open, exclusive and uninterrupted occupation can become adverse, and the statutory clock can begin to run.
The jurisprudential holding is clear: a change of ownership can fundamentally change the legal character of occupation, and a title holder cannot simply sit back while another person openly possesses the land for decades.
Fort common mwananchi, the lesson cuts both ways. A title deed is powerful, but it is not a magic shield against the passage of time. If you buy land already occupied by another person, investigate who is on it and why, and if their occupation is inconsistent with your ownership, take effective legal or physical steps to assert your rights. On the other hand, living or using land for many years does not automatically make it yours; the requirements of adverse possession must still be strictly proved. But Makuyu Club’s victory over approximately 70 acres sends one unmistakable message across Kenya: in land law, sometimes the owner who does nothing for too long can watch the law move in favour of the person who never left.
Kindly retweet widely🙏
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
#hotoffthebench
SCORK addresses the remedy of anticipated profits for breach of contract:
1.Anticipated profits are recoverable as part of the contractual expectation interest. A claimant must establish the net profit it would have earned had the contract been performed.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
🚨 Winning a breach of contract case is not the same as proving what the breach cost you. The Supreme Court has wiped out a KSh 103 million lost-profit award for exactly that gap.
This is National Social Security Fund Board of Trustees v Micro-City Computers Limited, Supreme Court Petition No. E037 of 2025, decided on 30 October 2026. Here is what it means.
In 2011, the National Social Security Fund contracted Micro-City to install a security system at Social Security House for about KSh 244 million. The Fund never handed over the site, citing budget constraints, and later re-advertised the tender. The courts found that the Fund had breached the contract. The fight that reached the Supreme Court was not about the breach. It was about the KSh 103 million Micro-City claimed in profits it would have earned had the contract run its course.
The Court used the case to settle how anticipated profits are proved and valued, and the answer is one every business and every lawyer should note.
✅ First, what lost profits are. Damages for breach of contract aim to put the innocent party where it would have been had the contract been performed. Lost profits are part of that expectation, but they are the net profit, receipts less the cost of earning them, not the gross contract price. And they are capped by the contract's own terms. You recover the value of lawful performance, not the best outcome you can imagine. Here the contract let the Fund terminate on one month's notice, so the profit could not be valued as though years of performance were guaranteed.
✅ Second, the standard of proof. The Court clarified a point that has long caused confusion. Strict proof of special damages does not mean a higher standard of proof. The standard is the ordinary civil one, the balance of probabilities. Strict proof is about the quality and particularity of the evidence, not the level of certainty. The law asks for as much certainty as the loss reasonably allows, no more.
✅ Third, and most importantly, a two-stage test. Before a court values a lost profit, the claimant must first prove that the loss happened at all, that it was ready and able to perform, what it would have earned, what it would have spent, and over what period. These are historical facts, and they cannot be assumed from the breach.
Micro-City's claim failed at the foundation. Its expert projection was not an audit, assumed the figures it was given were accurate, mixed in company-wide expenses, left the managing director's own far lower estimate unexplained, and assumed years of maintenance the contract never guaranteed.
The legal dispute worth noting. On one side, a wrongdoer should not escape because the breach itself made the profit hypothetical. If courts demanded mathematical precision, a party could breach and then hide behind the very uncertainty it created, so the law gives the innocent claimant a fair wind and lets the court estimate once loss is shown. On the other side, damages are compensation, not a windfall, and a court cannot hand over millions on a projection built on untested assumptions and a period the contract never promised. Discipline in proof protects defendants, here a public fund, from paying for profits that were never really shown. Where the fair wind of estimation ends and the free ride of guesswork begins is the line this judgment draws.
Key takeaway: to recover lost profits, prove the fact of the loss with real, particular evidence first, and only then may the amount be estimated. Lost profits are net, not gross, and never exceed the value of what the contract actually guaranteed. An expert's arithmetic cannot prove the assumptions it rests on, and a silent opponent cannot fill the gaps in your proof.
👉 Follow @Lexken_EMSLaw for practical legal insights on commercial litigation and contract damages.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
🚨 Justice cannot be served fairly when a party is ambushed by the clock. The Court of Appeal has reset a hearing because the notice given was too short for a party to prepare.
This is Castillo & another v Nkingis Kisemei & others, Civil Application No. NAK E039 of 2021. Here is what it means.
The issue was not the merits of the dispute. It was timing. A hearing had proceeded on notice that the Court of Appeal found inadequate, too little time for the parties to get ready. The Court did not paper over it. It directed that all parties be served afresh and a new hearing date be fixed.
The principle behind that order is one of the oldest in law. A fair hearing is not only the chance to be present. It is the chance to be ready. Under Article 50 of the Constitution, every person has the right to have a dispute decided in a fair hearing, and Article 25 places that right beyond limitation. The right means little if a party learns of the hearing so late that they cannot gather their evidence, instruct an advocate and put their case properly. Adequate notice is what turns the right to be heard into a real one.
Short notice, then, is not a technicality. A decision reached after a party has been denied time to prepare is open to challenge, and will often be set aside, exactly as happened here. The cure was not to punish anyone, but to restart the step properly, with proper service and a fresh date.
The legal dispute worth noting. On one side, courts are under real pressure to move cases along. Backlogs are heavy, delay harms everyone, and firm hearing dates are one of the few tools that stop litigants from dragging a matter out, so there is a strong pull toward holding the date and getting on with it. On the other side, speed is not the same as justice, and a hearing that a party could not properly prepare for is not a fair one, however efficiently it was conducted. An ambush by the clock tends to produce a result that has to be undone later, which serves no one. Where the drive to dispose of cases quickly ends and the right to adequate notice begins is the line this ruling draws.
Key takeaway: a fair hearing requires adequate notice, enough time to prepare, instruct counsel and take part meaningfully. Where the notice falls short, the hearing can be set aside and the parties served afresh. Being heard means being given the time to be ready.
👉 Follow @Lexken_EMSLaw for practical legal insights on civil procedure and the right to a fair hearing.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
Dear Law Students,
Please take time to read the ShaKaHola judgment.
High Court Sitting in Malindi Criminal Case No E003 of 2024 found Paul Mackenzie and 28 co-accused guilty of 191 counts of murder.
drive.google.com/file/d/1tTt…
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
Assistant Legal Counsel (Recruitment)
Deadline: Dec 1
pca.int/en/about/employment/…
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
🚨 A letter of allotment is not a title deed. If the conditions attached to it are not met in time, the entitlement can lapse, and whoever later buys the land may be buying nothing.
This is Mbau & another v Kitaka [2026] KEELC 6962 (KLR).
Two parties claimed the same plot in the Kiboko "B" Settlement Scheme in Makueni. The first man was allotted the plot in 1999 by a letter of offer. The letter was not an unconditional grant. It was valid for 90 days and required him to accept it, pay a ten per cent deposit and complete the documentation within that time, and it stated that failure would lead to cancellation without further notice. He did none of those things in time.
Because the conditions were not met, the offer lapsed and, by its own terms, stood cancelled automatically. The plot was then allocated afresh to the second man, who accepted and paid in 2009, took possession and built permanent houses on it. Years later, the first man purported to sell the plot to a buyer to raise medical fees, and the buyer's agents went on to demolish those houses.
The court's reasoning followed a straight line.
✅ First, an allocation made subject to express conditions does not confer a continuing entitlement where the allottee fails to meet those conditions within the stipulated period. The first man's later payments could not revive an offer that had already lapsed.
✅ Second, once the offer had lapsed, he had nothing to sell. A person cannot pass what he does not hold, so the sale transferred no title.
✅ Third, the buyer was not protected as an innocent purchaser. The law shields a purchaser for value only where he buys in good faith and without notice of a defect, and here the warning signs were plain.
There were permanent houses on the land, which should have prompted him to ask who was in possession, and the sale agreement itself set aside six hundred thousand shillings to evict an occupant, a clear signal that the seller's title was doubtful. Real due diligence would have shown that the conditions of the original allocation were never met. The buyer was therefore not a bona fide purchaser without notice.
The court also distinguished the familiar rule that, where two titles compete, the first in time prevails. That rule is for two regularly issued titles. Where the first allocation had lapsed for non-compliance, there was no competing title to rank first, and the land was free to be allocated to someone else. The true owner was confirmed, and his proven losses, valued by a quantity surveyor at about KSh 537,354, were awarded.
The legal dispute worth noting. On one side, the buyer paid money and relied on documents the seller held, including a later certificate suggesting ownership, and it is hard to watch an apparently honest purchaser lose both the land and his money. If buyers cannot rely on the papers a seller produces, land transactions become perilous. On the other side, conditions attached to settlement land exist so that it goes to those who meet the terms and actually settle and develop it, and rewarding a lapsed allottee, or a buyer who ignored people living on the land, would defeat that purpose. The buyer was not truly without notice, and his remedy lies against the seller, not in the true owner's land. Where the security of a transaction ends and the duty to look before you buy begins is the question the case leaves.
Key takeaway: an allotment letter subject to conditions is not ownership. If the conditions lapse, so does the entitlement, nothing can be sold from it, and a buyer who overlooks occupants and red flags is not protected. Before you buy land, confirm not just that the seller holds papers, but that the allocation behind them was ever completed.
👉 Follow @Lexken_EMSLaw for practical legal insights on land law and conveyancing.
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
Find attached the link for this monumental case here:👇
kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment…
@ayagamax
Angelo M. Makuei retweeted
Justice Nabil Orina does a fantastic decision herein, not too long not too short but importantly analyses the issues so succintly
I think on judgecraft my Lord is doing very well especially decision writing
Link: kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment…

















































