Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam) profile picture

Çağımızın bir kahramanı. Düşünüyorum. Philosophy & cognitive science @cog_ist / @theanalytichub / @the_holistic_

Joined July 2026
Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)Photo by Yunus Şahin (@cogsciadam)
Bu yeni hesap. Gören eş dost takip ederse makbule geçer. Takip etmediklerim alınmasın lütfen, fırsat olmadı herkesi arayıp taramaya...
1
16
10,368
Bu sabah müthiş bir makale okudum! Felsefe, fizik ve hatta bilişsel bilimi çok iyi birleştirmiş. Fiziksel indirgemecilikten başlıyor, karmaşık sistemlere, oradan enformasyon teorisine, termodinamiğe, oradan neden "belirimin" zorunlu olduğuna uzanıyor. Yetmiyor, tüm bunların, "bellek, hatırlama, öğrenme, algı, normativite, fenomenoloji ve benlik" gibi kavramları temellendirmek için nasıl bir zemin sağladığına değiniyor. Uzun yıllardır okuduğum en sıkı felsefe işi. Hatta bana kalırsa ideal bir felsefe metninin neye benzemesi gerektiğine çok güzel bir örnek. Bilim felsefesi, metafizik, fizik ve bilişsel bilimle ilgilenen herkese şiddetle öneriyorum.
27
193
19
1,288
53,286
Tabi ki bu çalışma esasında taslak mahiyetinde ve geliştirilecek yanları mevcut. Hatta benim "katılmadığım" bazı net kısımlar da mevcut - ki Sarp benle nerede ayrıştığını aralarda açıkça belirtmiş :) - fakat hem "philosophizing" hem de yazım tarzı itibariyle mest oldum. Beni düşüncelere sevk etti ve kafamda yeni sekmeler açtı.Bir süredir felsefe okurken yaşayamadığım bir histi doğrusu...
1
1
19
3,304
Yunus Şahin retweeted
Geçen hafta Viyana'daki Erwin Schrödinger Enstitüsü'ndeki "Quantum Probes of Gravity" çalıştayında yaptığım konuşma: youtube.com/watch?v=ixBe1gdO…
1
28
1,318
You know, it's interesting how it never occurs to these guys that the supercomputer will simply say "X simply isn't possible".
Philosopher Nick Bostrom says delaying superintelligence could mean delaying breakthroughs that radically extend human life: "Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares had this book, 'If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies.' And it seemed to me that we have at least as strong evidence for the claim that if nobody builds it, everyone dies." "Successfully developing safe superintelligence, I think could lead to enormous breakthroughs in biomedicine and in anti-aging interventions that could radically extend the lifespan of currently existing people." "If you think about what our life expectancy would be if we weren't aging, it's something on the order of 1,200, maybe 1,400 years or so. And that maybe is a quite conservative lower bound because in this situation you might also have other ways of reducing other mortality risks like accidents and so forth." "You might think that if we spend more time doing AI alignment research, the existential risk from developing AI goes down at some rate. And then on the other hand, every year that we delay it, we have millions and millions of people dying." "You don't want to delay a single day longer than you really need to."
126
78
13
2,474
115,573
Edinmeyen kaldı mı? :)
1
6
531
Yunus Şahin retweeted
Bilim, akademi, üniversite... radyo, tiyatro ve opera gibi "bir şeye" dönüşecekler. Belli bir grup insanın yalnız sevdiği için yaptığı, sevdiği için ilgilendiği, kendinde kıymetli bir uğraş. Ve bilimi kalabalıklar, siyasetçiler ve mühendisler rahat bıraktığında ne müthiş bir şey olduğunu yeniden deneyimleyebileceğiz.
7
7
5
95
6,858
Yunus Şahin retweeted
If from true premisses they always yield true conclusions, what more could be desired? Yet those machines have no souls that we know of. They do not think... — Charles S. Peirce, Collected Papers (CP 2.59)
3
1
15
635
Yunus Şahin retweeted
It is by no means hopeless to expect to make a machine for really very difficult mathematical problems. But you would have to proceed step-by-step. I think electricity would be the best thing to rely on. — Charles S. Peirce, Letter to Allan Marquand (December 30, 1886)
5
1
29
697
Yunus Şahin retweeted
Nagel isn’t making some dumb mistake. No one seems to understand what “natural manifestation” means. He likely means two things, both of which are coherent. (1) consciousness comes before language, and language is an abstraction of it. (2) there is no such thing as a “purely linguistic experience” for humans, in that language does not naturally manifest in consciousness. You are conscious of language as heard words (LLMs can’t hear) or as it relates to the actions and dispositions of your embodied self (they aren’t embodied either).
This argument from Thomas Nagel is... terrible. Just bizarre. It seems pretty unambiguously to beg the question. Odd to see such a prominent philosopher make such an obvious mistake.
83
75
13
762
69,050
Yunus Şahin retweeted
It's really so funny how analytic philosophy's self image is of this rigorous pure crystal if reason but everything interesting that has come out of it in the past 50 years is footnotes on sellars's drunken but brilliant ramblings
1
2
1
10
367
Bilim, akademi, üniversite... radyo, tiyatro ve opera gibi "bir şeye" dönüşecekler. Belli bir grup insanın yalnız sevdiği için yaptığı, sevdiği için ilgilendiği, kendinde kıymetli bir uğraş. Ve bilimi kalabalıklar, siyasetçiler ve mühendisler rahat bıraktığında ne müthiş bir şey olduğunu yeniden deneyimleyebileceğiz.
7
7
5
95
6,858
Yes! Nagel weighs in on the biological naturalism side. Glad to see him around here!
Saw this Nagel quote going around and wanted to offer some more elucidation. Here's a brief thread 🧵: Let's start with a question: Why do we think that models that can chat with us are conscious but models that can recognize faces or produce images or drive cars aren’t? (1/8)
1
1
6
935
Yunus Şahin retweeted
Bertand Russell, Wittgenstein hakkında sevgilisine şöyle dedikodu yapmış: "Benim Alman eleman arıza çıktı, inatçı ve sıkıntı duruyor, ama sanırım salak değil." "Bizim Alman mühendis galiba salağın teki." "Benim şu serkeş Alman her türlü akli müdahaleye karşı zırh kuşanmış resmen. Onla konuşmak cidden bir vakit kaybı."
When people criticize you, don't despair! Here's what Bertrand Russell said about Ludwig Wittgenstein, who turned out to be the single most important philosopher of the twentieth century!
4
5
1
75
5,277
Yunus Şahin retweeted
Nagel: “There’s no mental life there in the ordinary sense. It’s not a mind. It’s not somebody that we have to care about. It’s a machine. Here are some of the smartest people on the planet being completely idiotic”
33
273
10
2,072
69,634
Yunus Şahin retweeted
people rlly dont wanna here this but. yeah most mental health diagnoses are actually problematic. They create labels and identity attachments. They also foster the expectation of additional symptoms. our treatment approach should be purely symptom based
you can say this about.. anything. there are people in their 30s still claiming they can't do basic tasks because of anxiety
17
99
25
1,249
20,698
Yunus Şahin retweeted
Hard not to notice that many of the people racing to automate humanity don’t seem very connected to the human part themselves. They're casually giving away what they've never valued.
Anthropic Researcher Tao Lin: Pretty much all humans on earth will become permanently unemployable because of AI "It's very likely that pretty much all humans on earth will become permanently unemployable" "And will need to strictly rely on government welfare to sustain themselves" "Human employment will go away."
16
88
5
872
19,764
Yunus Şahin retweeted
Paul Feyerabend: "The younger generation of physicists, the Feynmans, the Schwingers, etc., may be very bright; they may be more intelligent than their predecessors, than Bohr, Einstein, Schrödinger, Boltzmann, Mach, and so on.  But they are uncivilized savages, they lack in philosophical depth" (quoted in Lakatos and Feyerabend, For and Against Method). What Feyerabend said about that generation goes double for the current crop of pop science dorks (apart from the "may be more intelligent" bit, LOL).
Nobel prize winning physicists VS pop scientists on philosophy
50
269
17
1,778
65,081
Doğrusu, büyük dil modellerinin ve üretici yapay zekadan hemen hiçbirimizin haberi olmadığı o güzel yılları, yani şurada sadece birkaç sene öncesini, çok özlüyorum.
2
3
2
49
2,438
Çok makul bir serzeniş bu. STEMcilerin beşeri ve sosyal disiplinlerde bilgi sahibi olması "eğitsel" bir gereklilik iken, aynı şekilde, beşeri ve sosyal disiplinlerde çalışanların da temel STEM meselelerine aşinalığı "eğitsel" bir gereklilik.
I always wonder. Why do we expect STEM people to know humanities stuff? Yet humanities people would never be asked to learn basic physics. I think there's a tacit agreement that humanities people are dumber, so we shouldn't ask too much of them. But this is rude to say out loud.
1
1
8
1,200
Bertand Russell, Wittgenstein hakkında sevgilisine şöyle dedikodu yapmış: "Benim Alman eleman arıza çıktı, inatçı ve sıkıntı duruyor, ama sanırım salak değil." "Bizim Alman mühendis galiba salağın teki." "Benim şu serkeş Alman her türlü akli müdahaleye karşı zırh kuşanmış resmen. Onla konuşmak cidden bir vakit kaybı."
When people criticize you, don't despair! Here's what Bertrand Russell said about Ludwig Wittgenstein, who turned out to be the single most important philosopher of the twentieth century!
4
5
1
75
5,277