Crackpot History (@crackpothist) header
Crackpot History (@crackpothist) profile picture

The Crackpot History Podcast. Separating history from hysteria. Available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and more.

Joined April 2025
Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)Photo by Crackpot History (@crackpothist)
Still here. Working on something important. Different format. More to come. Stay tuned.
1
1
70
1,633
Some of the basic claims he gets wrong: - The Hashemites liberated Jerusalem from the Ottomans ❌ - He bastardizes quotes from Herzl, Jabotinsky, and Weizmann ❌ - He treats the King-Crane commission as a neutral body when Crane adored Hitler❌
2
3
34
1,189
Crackpot History retweeted
26 year olds today: "my anxiety is high, I am overwhelmed by my email job" 26 year olds in 1944:
854
4,721
496
35,297
7,777,835
Crackpot History retweeted
Replying to @jackvlloyd
This definitely aligns with the problems found in Horton's most recent book Provoked, which is undergoing a thorough autopsy and brilliant critique by @crackpothist. More people should hit this up. crackpothistory.libsyn.com/c…
1
5
339
Someone please convey to Darryl Cooper that these aren’t Hashemite troops but rather British soldiers that liberated Jerusalem. Notable difference.
The surrender of Jerusalem to the British, December 9, 1917. First British guard at the Jaffa Gate.
2
2
37
1,299
Absolutely correct take.
I am once again telling you the podcasters literally believe they run the show. They think the tail really does wag the dog, and they're having panic attacks and complete meltdowns over the fact that it just isn't true. This only makes it more visible too. Downward spiral.
1
18
580
Nick does a decent breakdown of some of the King Crane Commission's findings, but the thing that alot of people (especially people like @ComicDaveSmith) omit about King Crane, is that half of the two man commission was tainted, which spoiled the commissions findings due to the presence of a tremendous amount of animus. Most of the following is taken from Episode 2 of my Manufactured Martyr miniseries, where I break down where and how Darryl Cooper weaponized the King Crane Commission's findings as further evidence that the idea of a Jewish state in the region should have been rejected. Charles Crane was openly hostile toward Jews and the idea of a Jewish state from the outset of his appointment. He was a wealthy businessman who inherited his fortune and used his wealth to fund extensive travel that sparked his interest in foreign policy. According to Crane’s biographer Leo Bocage, during one of these trips he met Czar Nicholas II of Russia and dismissed reports of Cossack-led pogroms against Jews as a nuisance. President Taft appointed Crane as minister to China but later rescinded the nomination, questioning his judgment after being confronted with Crane’s open hatred of “Japs and Jews" leading Taft to conclude that Crane would have been, “a dangerous appointment.” Despite this, Crane was appointed to serve on the commission evaluating the situation in the Holy Land in 1919 and tasked with offering policy recommendations for the region in the aftermath of World War I. The commission ultimately recommended that Zionism be rejected, that no Jewish state be created, and that restrictions be placed on Jewish immigration to the region. In Robert Kaplan’s The Arabists: The Romance of an American Elite, Kaplan writes the following about Crane: "the most pronounced prejudice which dominated his thinking during later years was his unbridled dislike of Jews,” according to his biographer, Crane “tried… to persuade the recently elected Franklin Roosevelt to shun the counsels of Felix Frankfurter and to avoid appointing other Jews to government posts.” “Crane envisioned a worldwide attempt on the part of the Jews to stamp out all religious life and believed that only a coalition of Muslims and Roman Catholics would be strong enough to counter such efforts.” In 1933, Crane even proposed to Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, that the Mufti open talks with the Vatican to coordinate an anti-Jewish campaign.” “That perspective led Crane to develop an intense admiration for Adolf Hitler, whose Germany he considered “the real political bulwark of Christian culture.” A private audience with the Führer - like his earlier meeting with the Czar - was easily arranged thanks to Crane’s beliefs and financial clout. Hitler blamed the Jews for the problems in the Middle East, and at the same time, Crane, despite his hatred of Bolshevism, voiced support for Stalin’s anti-Jewish purges in Soviet Russia.” All of this tells us a great deal about Crane’s frame of mind, and anyone suggesting he approached the commission in good faith should be met with serious skepticism. Crane had a well-documented animus toward Jews when he joined the commission in 1919. Anyone invoking the King-Crane Commission as a authority on this issue without acknowledging Charles Crane’s deeply rooted bias is failing even the most basic standard of historical diligence. They’re appealing to an incredibly flawed authority as if its some kind of yardstick for measuring blame.
Dave Smith misrepresented the King-Crane Commission here. ~80% rejected foreign control entirely (also, btw - less than 1% supported an independent Palestine). Most wanted a unified Syria. That completely challenges the modern narrative.
1
6
28
1,563
Don't let the door hit you on the way out.
16
51
1
1,114
22,312
The letter makes sweeping historical claims: that Israel pushed the US into Iraq and that Israel created ISIS. Both deserve scrutiny. “The Israelis used the same tactic to draw us into the disastrous Iraq war.” There is no evidence Israel was the primary driver of the Iraq War or led a decisive lobbying effort for invasion. Douglas Feith, former Under Secretary of Defense Policy from 2001 - 2005 under Bush is on record saying “I don’t recall the Israeli government urging us to go to war with Iraq.” Israeli officials were more focused on Iran. Former Israeli PM Ariel Sharon said in 2002 “Iran is more dangerous than Iraq.” The push for war came largely from US policymakers like Paul Wolfowitz, Robert Kagan, and Bill Kristol, who had advocated removing Saddam Hussein since the 1990s to finish what had started under Bush Sr. The September 11 attacks created the opening to implement that agenda. The outcome of Saddam’s ouster was disastrous for Israel. Post-Saddam Iraq became dominated by Shiite parties aligned with Iran, strengthening what Abdullah II of Jordan warned in 2004 could become a “Shiite crescent” - an expansion of Iranian influence across the region and the empowerment of groups like Hezbollah. On the creation of ISIS: ISIS was not created by Israel. It traces back to Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, who founded a precursor jihadist network in 1999, with a strategy centered on provoking sectarian war between Sunnis and Shias. Claims that Israel created ISIS began circulating prominently from Iranian officials around 2014, when Iran’s deputy foreign minister said ISIS was a “product of Mossad.” ISIS in reality emerged out of the chaos of post-Saddam Hussein Iraq, the insurgency against US forces, and later the Syrian civil war. It grew by exploiting power vacuums, sectarian conflict, and collapsing state authority. No credible intelligence findings, independent investigations, or captured ISIS documents have substantiated the claim that Israel created ISIS. This is reinforced by the fact that ISIS has carried out attacks against Israel itself. ISIS claimed its first attack in Israel in January 2016, when a gunman killed two civilians in Tel Aviv. In June 2017, ISIS-linked attackers killed an Israeli border police officer. In March 2022, ISIS-linked attacks in Beersheba and Hadera killed multiple civilians. Kent's statements here don't reflect the historical record and appear to be driven by animus more than anything else.
After much reflection, I have decided to resign from my position as Director of the National Counterterrorism Center, effective today. I cannot in good conscience support the ongoing war in Iran. Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby. It has been an honor serving under @POTUS and @DNIGabbard and leading the professionals at NCTC. May God bless America.
42
98
7
433
23,778
Crackpot History retweeted
For the fans of @martyrmade and @scotthortonshow you should check out this phenomenal podcast! He adds what’s missing!
Work is in progress on the next episode. Been a longer gap than I’d like, but that’s life. Stay tuned.
1
1
6
444
Work is in progress on the next episode. Been a longer gap than I’d like, but that’s life. Stay tuned.
3
1
37
1,376
Great conversation with @ARaderVon. He does great research and his podcast is fantastic. Encourage you to support his work. Full conversation to be released soon. Will share it here.
1
1
7
798
The indigeneity argument as it relates to Israel-Palestine is a weak argument. People have connections to places and then subsequent people have connections to places. Trying to say that someone is more indigenous than others just results in a never-ending discussion about who has more connective tissue to a place. You can’t win that argument because it’s inherently emotional. Grounding to the political realities of today and the recent past is a much more effective place to start. The missed opportunities for peace, why they were intentionally shirked, and how those inflection points got the conflict to its present state. That’s more compelling than DNA testing an entire population.
I found the Tucker-Huckabee conversation deeply frustrating. Both men seemed to be grounding their arguments on the question of “indigeneity,” which, if applied to other parts of the world, becomes immediately recognizable as the Third Worldist ideology of “decolonization” and “land acknowledgements.” “International law” is fake and, as Huckabee conceded elsewhere, should not be something to which we automatically submit. And the “right to exist” formulation is a leftist bastardization of the natural rights doctrine, which, properly interpreted, would point to the argument that Israel secures the natural rights of its citizens in a state of civil society, but exists in a state of nature, and sometimes a state of war, relative to its neighbors. Rather than go in circles, supporters of Israel should reject the premise of arguments related to “the right to exist” or “indigeneity,” and instead, make the argument that Israel has established a state to secure the life, liberty, and property of its citizens and will defend itself against its enemies. That’s probably more persuasive to modern Americans than parsing the genetic lineage of Abraham or debating whether the Jews or the Palestinians should be doing “land acknowledgements.” There is a big debate about this on both sides of the political aisle and pro-Israel conservatives can’t rely on inertia or half-formed theological arguments. It’s baffling that the US Ambassador to Israel seemed totally lost on these questions.
5
6
73
4,985
They went from "this is the greatest day in our history" to "it wasn't us - we don't know what happened."
Journalist: "The people we see in the body cam videos with bandanas, with Qassam brigade logos, clearly looking like Palestinians shooting young people at the Nova festival. Who were these people if they were not your fighters?" Hamas: "Israel did it" @chalavyishmael
11
206
3
1,346
55,874