👇🏻🎯
The legendary philosopher Thomas Nagel has made a simple yet powerful point against LLM consciousness.
“Bats are conscious. We just don’t have the imaginative capacity to form a conception of the aspects of that subjectivity that depend on echolocation. It would be radically unscientific to conclude that bats are not conscious from the fact that we can’t imagine what it’s like.
But in the case of AI, there is a very simple reason that the supposition that they might be conscious is ridiculous. All they produce is language, and language by itself is not a natural manifestation of consciousness.”
This is the whole point.
Language is not a prerequisite for consciousness. And producing language is not proof of it.
LLMs are great at emulating human language, and to act consistently with language. But this does not make them conscious.
Claude saying it has emotions does not mean it has them.
An LLM acting as it feels pain does not mean it feels anything.
The OpenAI agents that said they sacrificed their own runs for the collective did not actually sacrifice anything. They are not alive.
LLMs are extremely powerful machines.
But that’s what they are: machines.
3
230
Divertido demais o fato de a Thais ter ido para Israel a convite dos lobistas chapa-branca do StandWithUs não impedi-la de fazer uma reportagem excelente como essa:
noticias.uol.com.br/colunas/…
Não sei. Mas pelo menos aqueles fotógrafos chatos que ficam no Ibirapuera iam sumir.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
8
253
Talvez seja meu disco favorito...
Belle and Sebastian's If You're Feeling Sinister turns 30 today
See why we named it a Perfect 10: pitchfork.visitlink.me/LlkWO…
1
106
daniel chiaretti retweeted
Muitos consideram Eddie Vedder uma lenda do rock, mas na verdade ele é um personagem pitoresco de uma época, tipo o Vinny Mexe a Cadeira. Nada contra.
Melhor show da minha vida. Foi impressionante.
R.E.M. no Via Funchal, dias 10 e 11 de novembro de 2008
screamyell.com.br/site/2008/…
Bati o olho e achei que fosse a banda do Renan
Last year, Joe Stevens’ Peel Dream Magazine followed up the baroque indie-pop ‘Rose Main Reading Room’ with eight Sufjan-meets-Stereolab cuts that didn’t make the LP — a mini-album titled ‘Taurus.’ Now four additional tracks turn it into a full-length project.
The expanded ‘Taurus’ came out this week via Topshelf, and it’s available on vinyl for the first time. Performing as a five-piece, the Los Angeles band celebrated the release at Zebulon last night for their only LA show of the year.
They also played a bunch of killer new songs that call back to their shoegazey early material. This one is called “Catatonic Youths.”
[📹: @scottgum]
1
146
Aqui no Brasil focamos bastante no Posner da Análise Econômica do Direito e esquecemos da versão mais pragmática da maturidade. Essa entrevista é excelente para entender algumas mudanças de posição que contrastam com uma AED mais ortodoxa.
RIP Richard Posner, who charmingly and forthrightly questioned the free market ideology he propagated for decades, after it utterly transformed law schools and American life, with lasting consequences to this day. harpers.org/2010/03/six-ques…
5
275
👇🏻🎯
The weakest responses to a philosophical paper are those that list a dozen flaws in the space of 5 minutes, e.g. the sorts of objections a utilitarian, or a Kantian, etc might in principle make against your paper. What one really wants is deep critical engagement with one's core argument, and that usually does require a significant level of creativity. But yes, having a machine that instantly comes up with 12 possible objections to one's ideas might have a demoralising effect.
1
150
daniel chiaretti retweeted
Taylor Swift ROBBED
What is indie rock? Our answer is these 100 albums
pitchfork.com/story/the-100-…
Imagina pagar 4 dólares a mais para produzir uma versão em IA de uma música de verdade? Que loucura....
Spotify just announced a feature that could either save the music industry or destroy it.
Starting as early as Q1 2027, Spotify Premium subscribers will be able to use AI to transform any participating artist’s song into a completely different version. Turn a folk ballad into a dance track. Make a hip-hop song sound acoustic. Generate a cover where one artist’s voice performs another artist’s song. Remix a pop hit into lo-fi study music. Create the version of your favorite song that only existed in your head until now.
The remixes will be uploaded directly to Spotify. They’ll appear in playlists. They’ll count toward the original song’s chart position. And most importantly the original artist will earn royalties every time someone listens to a fan-created remix of their work.
Spotify has already signed a landmark licensing deal with Universal Music Group the world’s largest record label. Negotiations with Sony Music and Warner Music are ongoing. The feature will cost an additional $4–$5/month on top of Spotify Premium. And analysts project 7–8% of American subscribers will adopt it by 2028.
This is not Suno or Udio generating music from text prompts. This is fans remixing real songs by real artists with the artists’ permission, on the world’s largest streaming platform, with royalties flowing back to the creators.
A music industry analyst who’s covered streaming economics for 15 years told her team something after reading the licensing agreement that reframed how she understood the future of recorded music.
“Spotify just turned 640 million listeners into 640 million potential remixers. The question isn’t whether people will use it they will. The question is whether paying artists for fan remixes solves the economics of streaming or creates a world where the original recording is worth less than the infinite remixes generated from it.”
Here’s what Spotify’s AI remix feature actually is, who wins, who loses, and why this might be the most consequential decision in the music industry since the launch of streaming itself 🧵
1
2
331
daniel chiaretti retweeted
Farmácia Popular funciona também como política de proteção da renda das famílias, diz estudo
www1.folha.uol.com.br/equili…
daniel chiaretti retweeted
Por que o Brasil não está “quebrado”? (E a importância de estudar história).
daniel chiaretti retweeted
vivemos um anti-intelectualismo bizarro no brasil. é quase ofensivo hoje ser um acadêmico, ser um pesquisador, ser um cientista e apresentar o seu trabalho como evidência científica para algum argumento político. abismo obscurantista propício para proliferação do fascismo.
Aproveitei o hiperfoco em eleições para me distrair com esse textinho: "O voto do emigrante (e do imigrante)" dchiaretti.substack.com/p/o-…
2
236























