John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3) header
John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3) profile picture

Filmmaker, ex-democrat, curious about how power protects itself. Currently convinced that the larger the state, the smaller, more controllable the citizen.

Berlin & London
Joined March 2009
Photo by John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3)Photo by John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3)Photo by John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3)Photo by John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3)Photo by John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3)Photo by John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3)Photo by John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3)Photo by John Dunton-Downer (@doubledee3)
Isn’t this lovely.
The UK has agreed to join EU's more expensive Emissions Trading Scheme. This will push up the cost of UK electricity made using gas. Today, right now, more than half of the electricity generated in the UK comes from gas. 18.4 GW gas 2.3 GW solar 5.3 GW wind 5.1 GW nuclear 2.6 GW Biomass @andyburnham 's Reset will increase electricity prices. National Grid: Live share.google/SrQEhAMwwgDeyPB…
1
7
Fascinating and very illuminating re attitudes about numerous contemporary phenomena… wokeism, COVID restrictions, climate, Islam…
People don't just pretend that the emperor is fully clothed: they will punish dissenters even when they privately know the emperor is naked. Why? Because they want to signal that they are genuine believers, not merely fakers bowing to social pressure. Studies find that people who conform under social pressure will criticize norm-breakers in public, but not in private. This kind of false enforcement creates the illusion of widespread, sincere support for even deeply unpopular norms. The upshot is that it takes only a small number of true fanatics to intimidate an entire group into submission through these cascading effects. journals.uchicago.edu/doi/ab…
1
5
The international press has been shockingly indifferent to this, an intergovernmental scientific scam that history will remember as perhaps the worst of all. Quite the cabal of media and public authorities in the conspirators’ club here; no wonder corruption is the emergent theme and general trust is down all across society:
Full text of article: Jay Bhattacharya, head of the National Institutes of Health, has written to Nature Medicine journal demanding a “formal, independent investigation” into why a key scientific paper misled the world about the virus causing Covid, and concealed the contributions made by three senior scientists to commissioning, reviewing and editing the paper. In a career as a science writer that spans more than four decades, I have never seen an alleged case of scientific malpractice as influential. Like many others I have called for the paper to be retracted. Twice, the editor of the journal, Joao Monteiro, has been sent letters from numerous leading scientists demanding an investigation or retraction of the misleading paper. He has ignored us. I know the paper entitled “Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2” was misleading because I was among those misled. At the time I sat on the science and technology select committee of the House of Lords and we were conducting an inquiry to try to understand this new virus threatening all our lives. The possibility that it had been accidentally released from a laboratory, if true, would have significant implications for the public-health response: a virus marinaded in human tissues in a laboratory for weeks would be far more infectious than one newly arrived from bats. Parliamentary colleagues were asking me what I thought. To my shame, I told them a lab leak could be ruled out. I did so based almost entirely on the authority of this one paper. That very phrase “ruled out” appeared in the press announcement of the paper from the institution where the lead author, Kristian Andersen, worked. The article itself left no room for doubt: “we do not believe that any type of laboratory based scenario is plausible… our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct.” That these words appeared in Nature Medicine gave them a stamp of authority, or so I believed. The paper was subsequently viewed millions of times and cited in thousands of academic papers. The journal and the authors of the paper therefore had a special responsibility not to allow themselves to be misled. Yet we now know that Proximal Origin’s arguments were flawed and released Slack messages and emails show several of its authors were expressing exactly the opposite opinion in private both before, during and after publication. They still thought a lab leak was “friggin likely”, in the words of Andersen. Worse than all that, congressional investigations have uncovered records strongly indicating that three of the most senior medical scientists in the world, Francis Collins (Bhattacharya’s predecessor as head of the National Institutes of Health), Anthony Fauci (head of National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases) and Jeremy Farrar (head of the Wellcome Trust) had not only seen the paper before publication, but – according to a House Select Subcommittee report – had prompted its authors to write it in the first place, had reviewed it and even suggested alterations in wording. Fauci referred to the paper from the White House podium, giving no hint of his own role in it. These men were heads of the bodies that funded the scientists’ work, yet they were not listed as co authors or acknowledged in the paper, despite the journal’s stated policy that authors disclose any funder’s “involvement in the conceptualisation, design, data collection, analysis, and preparation of the paper”. Farrar even suggested a change of wording to strengthen its conclusion: from “unlikely” to “improbable”. Why was he not acknowledged? Robert Garry, one of the authors, wrote to his colleagues: “Jeremy has been an amazing leader – should be author.” Ed Holmes, another author, replied: “I agree, and I offered, but he wants to remain independent.” As we wrote to the journal editor in 2024: “This omission of a significant role played by the head of a funding agency, allegedly to maintain his ‘independence’, represents a serious breach of publishing ethics that completely undermines the credibility of the journal and calls into question the motivation behind the paper.” Answer came there none. It should infuriate the journal’s editor that the paper appears to have been commissioned, designed and intended to shut down all debate about a possible laboratory origin of the most destructive pandemic in a century despite going directly against its authors’ own opinions. For the sake of science’s integrity the journal must act on Dr Bhattacharya’s letter.
9
To me it was no surprise since the whole movement and its adherents seemed always to be more about feelings than facts.
It still amazes me how European energy policy became subservient to the mindless rantings of a teenage girl with absolutely zero qualifications.
1
1
12
The most remarkable thing is how unremarkable he is in his should-be extraordinary behaviour and posture.
John Kerry spent three years as America's climate envoy telling farmers they are a third of the problem, and he is not a serious person. He is a former Secretary of State, a former presidential candidate and, by marriage, attached to the Heinz ketchup fortune. The man who wants your food system reformed lives on the proceeds of 57 varieties of processed tomato. In 2023 he told a summit in Washington that food and farming produce a third of the world's emissions, and that the planet cannot be saved unless agriculture is put front and centre. He said this to a ballroom, and then lunch was served. In 2019 he flew to Iceland by private jet to collect an award for climate leadership. A local reporter asked whether that was quite the thing. He replied that it was "the only choice for somebody like me". His family's Gulfstream went on flying while he held the climate post. It was sold shortly after the newspapers began adding up the trips. At Davos he looked out at a hall of billionaires and told them that people like themselves, gathered to save the planet, were "almost extraterrestrial". He meant it kindly. He once kept his 76-foot yacht moored in the state next door to the one he represented in the Senate, which spared him about half a million dollars in tax. The yacht was built in New Zealand and shipped. So the position, as far as it can be assembled, is that a cow eating grass in Wyoming is an emission that must be accounted for, and a private jet to an awards dinner is a choice nobody else was in a position to make. No rancher with 200 head has ever been flown to Reykjavik and thanked, because somebody would have had to stay behind with the cattle. He has told the world to change what it eats, and he did it from 40,000 feet.
7
Sounds about right.
If there were actually a “climate crisis,” the IPCC wouldn’t be concerned about diversity. Folks, you are being conned. These are deeply unserious people. Just point and laugh at them.
1
8
Is the truth merely elusive to these people or is it actually offensive? There seems a huge, sustained effort to resist it.
Every word is wrong. Britain did not organise the slave trade. Its wealth does not derive from slavery. It was British industrial capitalism that made emancipation feasible. Compensation is a tendentious word: we force-purchased slaves so as to free them: an unambiguous good.
1
18
The pattern of our giving credence to “well-intentioned” but wrong voices is so deep and widespread there should be library shelves devoted to the study of it.
In 1999 we were reliably assured by experts that all coral reefs were on the point of death. After only 400 million years on Earth the last 20 years of climate change was killing them off But today they are doing better than ever! Is it possible the experts were wrong? If so, why did we give them such credence and respect?
6
Nice return to the fixation on vaxxes, even as a metaphor. And these people call their opponents fascist.
This is so dangerous. Implicit in her description is that she and her fellow leaders should be empowered to decree what counts as misinformation.
8
This calm and reasonable argument has been getting made since the last millennium but was drowned out by the Establishment hysteria. At last it’s climbing to dominance, if ever so gradually.
When we look at the debate surrounding carbon dioxide and the climate, it is easy to get lost in technical jargon and alarming headlines. However, when we step back and look at the broader history of our planet, a very different picture emerges — one that suggests our current environment is far more stable, resilient and benign than we are often led to believe. To understand where we are today, we have to look at where the Earth has been. Across the vast timeline of complex life on Earth, our planet has typically been much warmer than it is right now — roughly 9°C warmer on average. Today, we are actually living in a relatively cool interglacial period within a broader ice age. Comparing our mild, predictable modern environment to catastrophic events like the end-Permian extinction simply does not hold up. Life on Earth did not just survive in warmer, higher-CO₂ eras; it thrived. We are thriving today in a world that is it faces climate doom scenario. While carbon dioxide gets almost all the attention, its a minor player in a massive, dynamic system. The world’s oceans hold the overwhelming majority of the Earth’s surface carbon, while the atmosphere holds only a tiny fraction — around one percent. Because of basic physics, as oceans warm and cool, they naturally release and absorb CO₂. More importantly, water vapor is the dominant greenhouse gas in our atmosphere, operating through clouds, storms and ocean currents. Yet in public discussions, the massive role of water vapor is routinely downplayed, while the influence of a trace gas like CO₂ is heavily overstated. Furthermore, because ice cores trap air bubbles slowly over 50 to 100 years, past temperature shifts are often smoothed out, making modern changes look uniquely abrupt when they may not be. Far from causing ecological collapse, modest warming and higher CO₂ levels have visibly benefited plant life. Coming out of the Little Ice Age — the coldest stretch in 10,000 years — the planet has experienced measurable global greening. Plants use CO₂ to grow, and a slightly warmer, CO₂-enriched atmosphere supports greater agricultural yields and healthier forests. Finally, we have to look at who is driving the alarm. Much of the modern 'climate crisis' narrative is promoted by massive, unelected international bureaucracies (the United Nations, for one) and political bodies that benefit from keeping the public in a state of fear. When complex, poorly understood natural systems are reduced to a single variable — human CO₂ emissions — it serves a political agenda rather than an open scientific inquiry. We live in a mild, adaptable world, and our climate policies should reflect reality rather than manufactured panic.
5
Thank you.
I'm going to close the "ecological transition" debate once and for all. Next time someone lectures you about degrowth and "saving the planet", here's the full genealogy. Bookmark this. It starts with the Frankfurt School. Their problem: the Western working class never revolted, because capitalism kept making it richer. So Marcuse and co. changed the target. The enemy was no longer poverty. It was abundance itself. Consumer society. Growth. Add Gramsci's playbook on top: don't seize the factories, seize the culture. Win the schools, the universities, the media, and politics will follow. In 1972, the Club of Rome publishes The Limits to Growth. An MIT computer model telling the world that growth will hit a wall, resources will run out, collapse will follow. Fun detail: the Club was founded by an industrialist and a technocrat, and the study was funded by the Volkswagen Foundation. That's the trick. The anti-growth idea leaves the radical campus and puts on a lab coat and a suit. Same year, the Marxist philosopher André Gorz picks it up and gives it a name: "décroissance". Degrowth. The loop is closed: a Marxist critique of abundance, wrapped in a scientific-looking doom model. Fifty years later, the doom calendar keeps slipping. Extreme poverty has collapsed. Food per capita is up. France, the UK and the US all emit less CO2 than in 2005 with a bigger GDP. So the narrative needed a new face. Enter Greta Thunberg. Not a scientist. Not an engineer. A teenager on a sailboat telling adults "how dare you". You can't debate a crying child. That's the whole point. And here's the core sleight of hand: they welded growth and capitalism to the destruction of the planet. As if the solution was to produce less, consume less, build less, live less. It's exactly backwards. What decarbonized French electricity? Nuclear. A massive engineering project, not a sobriety campaign. What made solar ~90% cheaper in a decade? Markets, scale and innovation. Poor countries burn their forests. Rich countries replant them. Wealth is what pays for a clean environment. Today it's dressed up in Davos language. "Great Reset". "You'll own nothing and be happy". Eat bugs. Fly less, drive less, have fewer kids. Rationing sold as virtue, preached by people who fly private to tell you about it. And it trickles down into French politics. Even the "center" now calls water "the common good of humanity", and the answer to drought is... a new ministry. Always the same reflex: the world is finite, so the State must manage scarcity. Our answer is the opposite. Scarcity is not a law of nature, it's an engineering problem. Abundant energy. Nuclear. Desalination. Space. Degrowth isn't ecology. It's a death drive with a green coat of paint. There is NO limit to growth. 🚀
2
It didn’t take a tree surgeon to predict the obvious outcome of that bill when California announced it. Happens every time. Where’s the learning curve?
California politicians wanted to make sure fast food workers got their “fair share,” and that’s when 557,000 workers across 30,000 restaurants got a very real economic reality check. 📽️: @BessByers @reason
6
Another betrayal. We wonder why our young men today wouldn’t fight to defend this nation…
I honestly don't know whether to laugh or feel furious for British taxpayers after reading what five European governments just announced today. Every single pious excuse Labour used to scrap Britain's border deterrence just collapsed in one afternoon. Germany, Austria, Greece, Denmark, and the Netherlands are unveiling a joint deportation hub in Rwanda for failed asylum seekers. According to reports, they are expected to use the very same empty facilities that Britain handed Kigali £290 million in aid to renovate, as part of a £700 million scheme Labour cancelled the moment they won power in 2024. British workers paid for the infrastructure, Labour walked away from it, and now European governments are moving right in to use it. Remember the endless lectures from Labour ministers and human rights lawyers insisting offshoring to Rwanda was uniquely cruel, unworkable, and impossible under European law? When Britain tried to use that system, the European Court of Human Rights grounded the flight and Labour mocked the entire policy as an immoral gimmick. Yet the moment European capitals realized their own cities couldn't cope, Brussels simply tightened EU migration rules last year and cleared the path to send failed claimants to Kigali. Now look at the sheer audacity of Andy Burnham today. Just last week, the Prime Minister told reporters Britain was watching this European push for return hubs "with interest." Yet tonight in London, he is delivering a speech claiming that Brexit cost Britain control of its borders. Britain didn't lose control of its borders because it left the European Union. Britain lost control because Labour lacked the political spine to use a deterrent that British taxpayers had already spent £700 million building, leaving five EU countries to quietly pick up the keys for free.
1
11
What would be the remedy for this situation? A war on our own soil?
I think about this a lot. The U.S. Navy has operated nuclear-powered aircraft carriers and nuclear-powered submarines. Currently, there are 11 big-deck nuclear-powered aircraft carriers (10 of which are Nimitz class) and 71 submarines in service. And they are primarily operated by 18–30-year-old men. However, climate alarmists and an entire generation of people inflicted with Jane Fonda's China Syndrome will try to convince you that nuclear fission is too dangerous for society to use for baseload power. We are a deeply unserious society.
13
Noted.
In UK we blew up our coal fired stations long ago. We thought we were 'Leading the World' But the world didn't notice. It burnt MORE coal in 2025 than ever before. And we are Goody Two Shoes with the highest electricity prices in the world Moral superiority for egocentric politicians doesn't pay the energy bills for us peasants
1
9
John Dunton-Downer retweeted
I am Muslim, and I ask my fellow Muslims in Britain and around the world. Is Islam so weak that we need to take to the streets every time someone criticizes it? Why are we screaming at the top of our lungs over something some Tom, Dick or Harry said? What exactly are we afraid of? A man in London can say what he thinks about my religion. I can tell him he’s wrong, go home, pray, and sleep just fine. Harman Singh Kapoor is a Sikh restaurant owner in Hammersmith. A crowd outside his business chanted, “Shut them down.” He says his family has received death threats. What do his wife and daughter have to answer for? Disagree with him about Gaza? Tell him why. Want halal food? Eat somewhere that serves it. And if you take to the streets to exercise your freedom of speech, have the decency to defend his freedom to speak, too. I grew up in Pakistan. I know what it feels like to weigh every word about religion before saying it out loud. Britain, is that how you want your children to grow up? Mansoor Laghari #FreedomOfSpeech #Britain #ReligiousFreedom
1,155
2,316
152
13,657
573,728
Probably too deep and too true to be debated in spaces like this one, so it goes under-examined until someone writes a major piece or book on the argument.
The only issue with nuclear fission is that it’s good. And that’s why climate zealots oppose it. It delivers dense, reliable, near-zero-emission power 24/7 with a tiny land footprint. If we cut the bureaucratic red tape to lower costs and standardized reactor designs like China has, it would solve the climate change “issue” overnight. But climate alarmists only want solar and wind, which need endless overbuilding, backup power, and rolling blackouts to keep the electric grid going. Intermittency justifies rationing and state control over how much energy you are allowed to use. If you control energy, you control human behavior. And that's what the climate debate is about. It's not about science. It's not about energy. It's about power, control, and wealth redistribution.
14
Let’s not lose those.
How lovely to see these again
18