dasha retweeted
The Copyright Office's report on generative AI training is superb - thoughtful, thorough, and clear in rejecting the idea that all gen AI training is fair use.
A few things jumped out:
1. A use is less transformative if it ultimately serves the same purpose as the original. 'Transformative', in the context of fair use decisions, doesn't just mean 'something is transformed'. A use is less transformative if it serves essentially the same purpose as the original. They give the example of training audio models on sound recordings: if you do this to create new sound recordings that compete in the same market as the originals, this is clearly less transformative.
2. Being 'transformative' is not enough anyway. Even when AI training is transformative, the market effects on the original can outweigh this in the fair use evaluation.
3. Market dilution by gen AI weighs against fair use.
This is critical. They say: "The speed and scale at which AI systems generate content pose a serious risk of diluting markets for works of the same kind as in their training data. That means more competition for sales of an author’s works and more difficulty for audiences in finding them." They argue that this weighs against a fair use finding, and they remind us that this fourth factor of fair use - the effect on the potential market for or value of the work that's copied - is "undoubtedly the single most important element of fair use", according to the Supreme Court.
Many of us have been saying this for a long time, shouted down by a chorus of AI boosters. It's great to see the US Copyright Office - the government body responsible for providing guidance on copyright law - agreeing.
copyright.gov/ai/Copyright-a…
dasha retweeted
I can respect how far current gen AI has come from a purely technological point of view—credit to the researchers & scientists—but genuinely, what do we need this so badly for, that it would outweigh all the humanity, stories, and history being stripped from our lives?
dasha retweeted
The opposite is true: we need to move a lot of people in low productivity roles (aka 'bullshit jobs') in the private sector into high productivity roles in government (aka 'essential workers')
dasha retweeted
I’m not kidding: those who delegate all their writing, thinking and creative expression to machines are going to wake up one day and discover that they can no longer write or think. You need to make your own art. You need to keep your brain working. You need to stay human.
dasha retweeted
“i just asked chatgpt and…” cool i just lost a significant amount of my respect for you
dasha retweeted
“AI companies present creators as being against change. We’re not. Every artist I know is already engaging with AI…but a distinction needs to be made between AI used in brilliant ways…& AI models where companies are essentially stealing creatives’ work for their own profit.” 🙏🏼
Kate Mosse CBE with a powerful rallying cry in the FT for creators to fight the UK government’s proposals to weaken copyright to benefit AI companies:
- The gen AI training they plan to legalise is theft
- The House of Lords agrees, as demonstrated in their debate this week
- Legalising theft is not the right way to promote AI
- “The time has come to group together and act”
ft.com/content/f26bda64-1237…
dasha retweeted
Today, the UK government announced a proposal to change copyright law - for the benefit of AI companies - that would cause huge, irreversible harm to creators.
More info below, but most importantly here's what you can do (wherever you live):
1. Email your MP. If you're in the UK, here's a template letter you can copy - docs.google.com/document/d/1… - and you can find your local MP's details here - members.parliament.uk/member….
2. If you're a creator, email your representatives. Your publisher, record label, union - whoever represents you. Here's a second template letter you can copy - docs.google.com/document/d/1…. You need to know your representatives are representing your views.
3. Respond to the consultation. You can do so by emailing [email protected]. If possible, write your own response, and go into all the detail you can. Feel free to use info / data I've prepared here - docs.google.com/document/d/1….
4. Share these template letters with anyone you know. The more people get involved, the more the government will get the message that a broad copyright exception is the wrong path to be pursuing.
--
And here's a summary of the government's proposal, and why I think it's so problematic:
- Broad new copyright exception for commercial generative AI training. AI companies will be able to train on British copyrighted work without a licence, even if the AI model is designed to compete with the creators whose work is trained on. This would make the UK one of the most punitive jurisdictions for creators in the world.
- Rights holders can 'reserve their rights', i.e. opt out. But opt-outs don't work (you can't successfully opt out downstream copies of your work), most creators miss the chance to opt-out, doing so is a huge admin burden, etc. AI companies should be getting opt-in consent - it's unfair to shift the burden to creators.
- AI companies must offer some level of transparency over their training data. This would be good if presented on its own, but it's much less helpful if you're packaging it up with a broad copyright exception that lets AI companies train on most of the UK's creative output with impunity.
The consultation on these proposals lasts for 10 weeks. Anyone who cares about this issue should do whatever they can to make their views known to government now - there will only be one chance.
not me probably being in Thailand when this premieres 👀
The official tailer for ‘THE WHITE LOTUS’ Season 3.
Premiering February 16 on Max.. xitter.gq/StreamOnMax/status/186…
1
41
dasha retweeted
Fucking stop using AI
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
1 AI image takes 3 Wh of electricity. arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16863
This takes 1mn in e.g. Midjourney. docs.midjourney.com/docs/fast-relax
Doing this for 24h costs 4.3 kWh. This releases 0.5kg of CO2 (grid.iamkate.com): same as driving 3 miles in your car. gov.uk/government/sta…
Overall, cars emit 10% of world CO2 (ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions-…), and AI 0.04% (data centers emit 1% dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.114… -- 1/25th is AI iea.org/reports/electr…)
dasha retweeted
I'm so serious, if you stop using your creativity, imagination and thinking abilities you will LOSE them. Millions of people willingly giving up their intellects, the very thing that makes them human, is a nightmare straight out of our darkest science-fictions.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
dasha retweeted
I think that between what Spotify has done to music as a full-time job, what streamers did to Hollywood, and what smartphones in general have done to reading, you can argue that the tech economy is basically destructive to American culture.
dasha retweeted
Maybe im stupid (im not) but there is literally not a single thing id need chatgpt for??????????? like does it do the dishes?
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
dasha retweeted
The next time someone in my comments tells me that it’s okay to use it for personal shit, I am throwing this article at them like a frisbee.
dasha retweeted
paraphrased subtitles… why would you do that… why.. why even do the subtitles if you’re not gonna… we need rules in society or everything falls into chaos
dasha retweeted
These people are problematic narcissists. I love tech but I would trade it all for a healthy & equitable world where we live intune with nature.
These people are parasitic, hellbent on consumption & obsessed with a hypothetical future.
Their mindset is a danger to us all.
I understand why customers get late fees for being late to appointments but why doesn't that mean we get discounts if they're late ?
1
35




























