Where is the line for the educators we invite into our living rooms?
Ms. Rachel built an empire on parental trust. But you don’t get to monetize the sanctuary of toddler media by day while using that platform to push one-sided geopolitical activism and blood libels and refuse to condemn Hamas by night.
When preschool educators cross into activist campaigns, corporate partners have a responsibility to act.
We are calling on @Netflix @SpinMaster @Target @Walmart @amazon to enforce basic moral guardrails and reconsider their commercial partnerships.
(Petition link in the reply below 👇)
For the last decade, free-speech advocates, including @AngelEduardo from @TheFIREorg, invoked Karl Popper’s "paradox of tolerance" while collapsing his philosophy into a simple binary: "more speech" vs. physical violence.
That reading leaves out the exact safeguard that keeps a free society intact. 🧵
1
84
Separating First Amendment law from free speech culture is essential. The state shouldn't police hateful speech short of incitement—but civil society must enforce objective behavioral standards, while leaving an open door of grace for ordinary people who make honest mistakes.
1
33
A boundary without consequences is merely a suggestion. If we refuse to enforce basic decency through public pressure today, we are only hastening the day when our arguments are settled by fists, pistols, and the heavy hand of the state.
My latest in @TheWhiteRoseMag: whiterosemagazine.com/reclai…
Erez 🇺🇸 #MakeTaboosTabooAgain 'Holding the Line' retweeted
More than 10,00 want to see Netflix drop Ms. Rachel.
Many more should ask Target and Walmart to do the same.
Sign here:
change.org/p/call-on-netflix…
Erez 🇺🇸 #MakeTaboosTabooAgain 'Holding the Line' retweeted
I’ve had this weight on me for a while and felt the need to share it once and for all.
Years ago, the CEO and co-founder of Semafor, a media publication, approached me. He presumably wanted me to consider investing, because he spent a significant amount of time boasting about all of his supplemental sources of revenue.
I was stunned when he bragged about getting an enormous amount of money from the government of Qatar. The pretense was that he was receiving these funds to “train journalists.” I don’t recall the precise amounts, but recall that he acknowledged that the cost to conduct this “training” was a tiny fraction of what he was getting paid - directionally it was something like getting paid $2mm to conduct a “media training” boot camp that would cost Semafor $50,000 to execute. I pointed out that it sounded like he was being bribed - that nobody with proper intentions would offer to pay something that was 20-100X off market - and no entity pretending to be a journalism outfit should accept stuff like that, as it would compromise him.
He insisted that wouldn’t happen. But over the course of many years, I’ve observed how Semafor continues to receive government sponsorships and perform all sorts of “trainings” and “conferences” in partnership with Qatar, while providing very complementary coverage to the government of Qatar. This is downright unethical - and particularly unbecoming of an outfit pretending to be “training journalists”! The problem doesn’t end with Semafor.
The government of Qatar has been buying off media, education and other groups, with reports of how it deployed billions of dollars in the US higher education system. All of us who care about ethics should demand an investigation into these practices. Regardless of whether legal authorities choose to look into this, we as the people and the consumers should admonish such egregious behavior and ensure we avoid “media” publications that are so compromised.
Countless journalists risk their lives every day to expose abuses in power. Semafor does a disservice to the profession by undermining trust.
@buildersmideast @BuildersMvt
Calling the war in Gaza a "genocide" isn't a human rights critique. It is an ancient, eliminationist blood libel retrofitted in modern legal jargon.
We brought white papers to an unprincipled, demonizing assault. That defensive posture created a permission structure—allowing an existential slander to harden into elite dogma.
Polite debate failed. It’s time to stop explaining and enforce a quarantine.
Shunning genocide accusers must be our last stand.
Full essay link in the replies. 👇
#GenocideBloodLibel #NoDebateOnBloodLibels #HoldingTheLine
Add your name to the petition calling on Ms. Rachel's corporate partners to draw the line against this demonizing blood libel, and then share with your friends: change.org/cut-ties-ms-rache…
15
Add your name to the petition calling on Ms. Rachel's corporate partners to draw the line, and then share with your friends: change.org/cut-ties-ms-rache…
Read the full essay at @TheWhiteRoseMag :
"The Banality of Blood Libel: Why Shunning Genocide Accusers Must Be Our Last Stand" whiterosemagazine.com/the-ba…
The strategy:
An educational off-ramp for naive peers swept up in social contagion.
Zero grace and total professional quarantine for cultural elites laundering the lie.
Pluralism cannot survive if every political and cultural flashpoint gets filtered through our partisan spin machine—making it nearly impossible to introduce the nuanced, principled terms needed to fairly assess and resolve these issues.
The only way we’re going to get through this mess is if we can put aside our tribal loyalties and commit to non-partisan, self-limiting principles.
I know it feels daunting, but it isn’t impossible. The vast majority of Americans do not think or act like hyper-partisans. They sense what’s fair and what’s BS, and most of them are smart or busy enough to steer clear of the circus.
And more importantly, we don’t have a choice. If we keep letting partisans divide our country on every matter, they won’t just tear each other apart. We will all be their collateral damage.
My latest essay for @TheWhiteRoseMag, "Only Principles, Not Tribalism, Can Save Us," makes this case. Link below.
Yes, the Macklemore fiasco brought more attention to him and his views. But what would it have meant if he was not removed? He and countless others would've seen it as a permission structure to bring one-sided, context-free, double-standard, political advocacy into any and all social spaces.
Society has to draw lines. Sometimes drawing those lines has short-term negative consequences. But let's not ignore the counterfactual of what would probably happen otherwise.
Trying to silence controversial speech can have the opposite effect.
@RobbySoave calls Macklemore’s removal from Ed Sheeran’s tour a prime example of the Streisand effect: Trying to suppress a message can end up drawing even more attention to it.
1
145
Illiberalism hurts democracies over the long term and must be resisted at every turn. But immorality—namely tribal, eliminationist hate—can destroy a democracy overnight if it is not promptly contained and shunned out of the mainstream.
Essay in @TheWhiteRoseMag. Link below.
1
1,143
Yes! We must restore a 'moral guilt by association', just like we'd judge anybody who was friends with David Duke. That is how we uphold our universal moral TABOOS against eliminationist hate, ostracizing that hate and all who espouse and launder it out of polite society, so it doesn't normalize and tear apart our social fabric. @jkirchick @nickgillespie
'Piker and Carlson are not the equivalent of your crazy uncle. And El-Sayed and Vance are not regular citizens; they’re political figures whose judgment and choices affect other Americans’ lives. One’s choice of friends is in fact an excellent sign of character, and in this respect, both Vance and El-Sayed have demonstrated a conspicuous lack of it.' @jkirchick theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/0…
149









