Equity Analyst • Footballer & Fan. Finding market inefficiencies by day, and fixing football's broken risk-reward rules by night.
Munich, Germany
Joined May 2012
- Tweets116
- Following132
- Followers75
- Likes314
3 Urgent Rule Changes to Save Modern Football
Here is how we fix the game, protect players, and bring back the entertainment value:
1. Attacking Advantage on Offside We need to give the benefit of the doubt to the attacker. Modifying the offside rule to favor the attack will eradicate "millimeter VAR" rulings and unleash a massive wave of real, beautiful goals.
2. Graded Penalty System 🎯 Soft fouls in the box shouldn't automatically mean a 75% chance of a goal. We need a tier system: soft, non-goal-threatening fouls should result in an indirect free-kick inside the box, saving maximum penalties only for clear, denied goal scoring opportunities.
3. The 10-Minute Sin Bin & Early Yellows Referees must start booking players in the 1st minute for dirty tackles—no more "warning periods." To avoid ruining games with early reds, introduce a 10-minute temporary dismissal. It punishes violent play immediately without completely killing the contest.
Eli Berenshtein retweeted
🚨 3 Urgent Rule Changes to Save Modern Football
Here is how we fix the game, protect players, and bring back the entertainment value:
•1. Attacking Advantage on Offside 📐 We need to give the benefit of the doubt to the attacker. Modifying the offside rule to favor the attack will eradicate "millimeter VAR" rulings and unleash a massive wave of real, beautiful goals.
•2. Graded Penalty System 🎯 Soft fouls in the box shouldn't automatically mean a 75% chance of a goal. We need a tier system: soft, non-goal-threatening fouls should result in an indirect free-kick inside the box, saving maximum penalties only for clear, denied goal scoring opportunities.
•3. The 10-Minute Sin Bin & Early Yellows ⏱️ Referees must start booking players in the 1st minute for dirty tackles—no more "warning periods." To avoid ruining games with early reds, introduce a 10-minute temporary dismissal. It punishes violent play immediately without completely killing the contest.
or give them few red cards and they will learn themselves. let’s promote clean fun attacking football.
@fifa @piersmorgan #var #FootballTickets #football #messi #spain #Argentina #fifa #ifab @FabrizioRomano @TheIFAB @TifoFootball_
1/6 I love Messi, he’s the greatest and cleanest player in history who endured a career of tackles just to show us the beautiful game. But let’s be honest: Argentina plays a dirty, physical game, and FIFA/the referees are enabling it.
2/6 The refereeing was a joke tonight. How does an Argentina player get a first yellow just for throwing his hands up in frustration after a missed foul on Tapia, while actual leg-breaking tackles and intentional obstructions go completely unpunished? It’s all about the ref's ego, not player safety.
3/6 This unwritten rule of "no early bookings for hard fouls" has to stop. If a team comes to destroy the game, book them in the 1st minute. If they end up with 7 players by minute 20, so be it! We tuned in for football, not the UFC.
4/6 It’s no surprise Argentina will finish this match with more fouls committed than minutes of possession. Yes, they have immense heart, soul, and a winning mentality—but today, their entire tactical blueprint was built on disrupting the game through force.
5/6 If FIFA is terrified of ruining matches with early red cards, it's time to adapt. Don't want to send players off? Introduce a 10-minute sin bin (temporary dismissal) as an intermediate punishment. Force teams to play clean, or pay the price.
6/6 Ultimately, football won tonight. The better, cleaner team won the trophy they fully deserved. Lionel Messi deserves every bit of glory in the world, but this version of Argentina absolutely deserved to lose. 🏆
🚨 3 Urgent Rule Changes to Save Modern Football
Here is how we fix the game, protect players, and bring back the entertainment value:
•1. Attacking Advantage on Offside 📐 We need to give the benefit of the doubt to the attacker. Modifying the offside rule to favor the attack will eradicate "millimeter VAR" rulings and unleash a massive wave of real, beautiful goals.
•2. Graded Penalty System 🎯 Soft fouls in the box shouldn't automatically mean a 75% chance of a goal. We need a tier system: soft, non-goal-threatening fouls should result in an indirect free-kick inside the box, saving maximum penalties only for clear, denied goal scoring opportunities.
•3. The 10-Minute Sin Bin & Early Yellows ⏱️ Referees must start booking players in the 1st minute for dirty tackles—no more "warning periods." To avoid ruining games with early reds, introduce a 10-minute temporary dismissal. It punishes violent play immediately without completely killing the contest.
or give them few red cards and they will learn themselves. let’s promote clean fun attacking football.
@fifa @piersmorgan #var #FootballTickets #football #messi #spain #Argentina #fifa #ifab @FabrizioRomano @TheIFAB @TifoFootball_
With a gradual Penalty system, they wouldn't overthink it—meaning we’d actually get more foul calls in the box and more genuine attacking opportunities. The referee didn't want to award a game-deciding penalty here and the rules are ignored more often than not. otherwise there will be 3-5 penalties a game.
Beyond the Messi bias, high-stakes matches always turn into physical battles that ruin technical play and risk injuries.
Refs are terrified of giving early yellows because they fear it’ll force a fast red and ruin the game. So, they just let border-line fouls slide to keep "operational peace."
The solution? A Pink Card (sin-bin) system:
Early yellow for a borderline foul.
Pink Card (10 mins out) for the next borderline foul.
Red card only if you commit another after returning.
Direct reds stay for dangerous plays. Football rules evolve constantly—it's time to bridge this gap!
Bottom line: zero tolerance for violence and constant fouling. Quick yellow, and the next one sends you straight to the bench for a rest. Let’s keep the players safe
What do you think?
England scored one, parked the bus, and stopped playing. Nobody wants to see that kind of football win.
Then, Lionel Messi, at almost 39 years old, delivers two assists—including a second-half beauty with his weaker right foot—to seal the comeback for Argentina. absolute genius!
People always say refs favor Argentina, and honestly, maybe there's some truth to it. But who wouldn't want to favor the GOAT? He’s given us so many moments of pure joy, no matter his age. The undisputed greatest of all time, by a mile. 🐐🇦🇷
In the Spain vs. France match, there was also a clear foul committed right on the penalty box line against a French player.
Under the current dry laws, this is technically a penalty, because the location of the foul determines the outcome, not the position of the ball.
In this case, the referee whistled nothing at all, which unfairly punished France. Yet, had they awarded a penalty, it would have been incredibly harsh—handing out a massive 80% xG gift that severely over-punishes Spain for a non-dangerous situation.
The logical solution, even with the foul occurring inside the box, is to award a direct free-kick just outside the area. This keeps the game balanced: France gets a fair set-piece opportunity, and Spain is held accountable for a clear foul.
It's time to eliminate this extreme all-or-nothing lottery.
Let's adopt a Graded Penalty System to make football fair and proportional! ⚽
Spain hasn’t registered a single shot on target against France, yet they are gifted an 80% xG penalty out of absolutely nothing. It is deciding the game on a non-scoring situation, not to mention a clear handball by Yamal during the buildup to gain control.
This is exactly why football rules are broken. It’s too binary. We need a Graded Penalty System:
1️⃣ Standard Penalty (11m): ONLY if a foul denies a direct, active goal-scoring opportunity (attacker facing goal, in motion to shoot).
2️⃣ Distant Penalty (14-15m): For borderline/reckless fouls that don't deny a 100% clear chance. Gives the GK a fighting chance.
3️⃣ Edge-of-Box Free Kick: For soft fouls or back-to-goal situations. No more free gifts.
And the ultimate balancer: The player fouled must take the kick.
Stop deciding massive tournaments on technicalities. Let the players play!!!
To be clear: Under my proposal, Spain's incident today is a clear Option 3 (Edge-of-Box Free Kick). Furthermore, we must fix the absurd handball rule—any contact that advances an attacker's advantage, even if accidental or close-body, should be penalized.
The current binary penalty rule is completely illogical and should have been scrapped years ago.
Just look at other sports: In basketball, if you foul a player in the paint, they get 2 free throws to potentially score 2 points. It’s proportional. They don’t get awarded 20 free throws just because the foul happened inside the key.
Yet in football, a minor, zero-threat trip at the edge of the box is rewarded with a penalty kick—turning a 3% scoring chance into an 80% free gift. It’s the equivalent of giving a basketball team 15 free throws for a common foul. The punishment is completely disconnected from the crime.
It’s time to bring mathematical proportion and logic back to football
There was another incident with Yamal—a rough push and pull. Under today’s rules, it’s all-or-nothing again. One ref gives a PK, while another thinks: "I already gave them one penalty, a second is overkill
A Graded Penalty system removes this BS. The ref could simply call the foul and award a free-kick, instead of being forced to choose between ignoring a clear foul or ruining the game with an 80% xG gift.
Here is another perfect example to illustrate my point. In the recent France vs. Paraguay match, France played brilliantly but just couldn’t find the back of the net—until they were handed that penalty gift. Let’s be honest, Paraguay's performance was so tough to watch that even half of their own fans probably didn't mind! 😅
But looking at the bigger picture: we have to stop giving away massive gifts for situations with near-zero scoring probability.
Take an attacker with their back to goal, actively trying to dribble out of the box, who gets tripped up. Yes, it’s a foul. But under current rules, it’s an automatic 80% xG penalty. Under my proposal, that’s a clear Option 3: an edge-of-the-box free kick. No more free gifts for non-scoring situations.
What do you guys think?
Should football replace the binary penalty system with a Graded Penalty System (where soft/distant fouls don't get 80% xG gifts)?
43%Yes, rules need to adapt
47%No, it's great as is
11%Not sure, needs thought
860 votes • Final resultsWould love to hear your thoughts on this reform proposal. Is it time for a real change in football?@GaryLineker @piersmorgan @FabrizioRomano @JamesHorncastle @Zonal_Marking @OptaJoe @StatmanDave @TifoFootball_ @SwissRamble @ChristinaUnkel @TheIFAB @markgoldbridge @ESPNFC
Eli Berenshtein retweeted
Alexey Navalny we will never forget you.
As @GadSaad so rightly says in this short podcast: speaking up is never easy. There is always a price to pay. But if we don't speak up - we risk losing our freedom. For ever.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcas…
That's why I am so grateful to Bono of @U2 for speaking up.
@vkaramurza @ekaramurza praying for you.
@navalny Yulia Navalnaya - sending my condolences.
"Putin will never say his name. But we will - ALEXEI NAVALNY “ - @u2 Bono, to his audience last night at a concert in Las Vegas. 🙏🙌🎯
Eli Berenshtein retweeted
The world is thinking of the brave people of Ukraine and their armed forces who are putting up one hell of a fight against the Russian invasion force. The least all of us can do is to make sure Putin and those around him pay the price for their aggression.
Eli Berenshtein retweeted
What a brave, courageous hero Zelensky is.
Puts so many of our leaders: Johnson, Biden, Macron to shame.
I'm grateful that Volymyr is President of #Ukraine
I'm hopeful Alexey Navalny will be President of Russia soon
@navalny
@Ukraine
