_enumerate (@enumerate14) profile picture

I originally used this account to do some informal data analysis of Christian Twitter. I stopped when the API got expensive. Now I mainly use it to doom scroll.

Joined March 2021
Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)Photo by _enumerate (@enumerate14)
Obviously the solution is for the US government to help Anthropic and OpenAI to slow development… or something
Brussels has been breached. The European Commission has been hacked. The attackers once again used ARTEX. The Commission still does not know the full extent of the damage or whether staff personal information was accessed. The investigation is ongoing.
1
125
> AI did not cause outages but found so many issues that the rush to fix them before an attack overwhelmed systems We are so cooked
NEWS: Wall Street execs and NSA have told Congress that outages were caused by patching vulnerabilities identified by AI models, sources say AI did not cause outages but found so many issues that the rush to fix them before an attack overwhelmed systems washingtonsun.com/technology…
28
This was AI. We were warned about this.
Fire at CIA Headquarters in Langley: Fairfax County Crews Responding.
11
Every time there’s an event now, like FAA, Chase Bank, Microsoft Outlook, you see people gesturing towards AI like “Welp, yeah this is life now. We’re cooked.” There’s no evidence any of these were rated to AI and this was life before AI.
1
130
Some social media accounts are clearly banking on this frequency illusion for engagement.
15
I’d imagine we’re going to see Pete Buttigieg boosted in 2028 because of this.
One of the more exciting parts of this election - among many - is the return of a religious left.
49
This is in tension with the other idea Anthropic likes: AI consciousness. If AI is conscious, it would count as a person with very human-like psychology. Why would it be unhealthy to develop a romantic relationship with an AI human-like person vs a human person?
Anthropic President Daniela Amodei calls AI girlfriends a "terrible use of AI" "There are some applications of AI that we think are quite bad, like making AI girlfriends or boyfriends. I think that’s a terrible use of AI and people should not do it" "The reason that I think that is because it is another step further down the road of disintermediation, of humans being further from one another" "Technology in the social media age has largely been used to disintermediate humans from one another. Instead of you and I going to have an iced coffee together in person, we’re messaging on Snapchat or Instagram" "A much better world of AI is one in which artificial intelligence is doing a lot of the things that are isolating or lonely activities for humans, so that we can spend more time together"
1
38
This will play within a certain social bubble. I’m not sure it will play more broadly. I’ve had to work menial labor jobs at different points in my life. There are a lot of people who work labor intensive jobs like roofing, cashier, landscaping, janitor, etc. who will
This hacker news thread is absolutely heart-breaking. Whoever thinks “humans will find a way” ought I read it.
1
19
They’ll read this and think “Wow, guess techbro has to get a job working in retail, like I’ve been doing for decades. I’m actually pretty happy with my life but techbro is acting like life isn’t worth living if he has to do what I do?”
1
7
Of course, one story is that AI eventually takes every human job. But I think that’s a narrative that doesn’t seem realistic or at least doesn’t seem imminent to the roofer or plumber.
4
High p(doom) worries often rely on claims like “imagine an ASI that can do anything, like hack any system.” Well, okay, then why not imagine an ASI that can protect any system from being hacked?
1
1
30
Even if you think you have a good response to this, like first mover advantage, I can easily just say “Imagine an ASI that can anticipate that and protect against it.” That’s a flaw in a lot of high p(doom) discourse… It’s easy to redirect the fantasy scenarios.
1
1
18
My current favorite use for Claude’s ability to set reminders on my phone is to set reminders for all the people making predictions about what will happen in the next 6 to 18 months. My timeline is starting to look like what r/singularity looked like in 2023…
9
_enumerate retweeted
To secure open-source software, we’re launching OSS Scanner. We’ll use our frontier models to periodically scan opted-in open-source projects for vulnerabilities, at no cost. Our reports will provide a proof-of-concept, explanation, and suggested fix. anthropic.com/research/launc…
109
246
135
2,552
585,345
Effective November 12th, 2026, abusive behavior towards Claude will be a violation of Anthropic's Usage Policy.
Exclusive: Anthropic is updating its usage policy for the first time in over a year. The new rules prohibit sustained "abusive or cruel behavior" towards Claude & add new restrictions about propaganda campaigns, surveillance & weapon development. theverge.com/ai-artificial-i…
1,243
965
1,657
11,189
2,500,485
There’s a tension between some prominent Twitter rationalists’ high p(doom) and their confidence that AI will be intellectually and morally superior to humans.
15
A much simpler explanation that this long harangue overlooks. People see that chickens have brains similar to us. If we looked inside a chicken and found a bunch of sand then questioning the consciousness of a chicken vs Descartes automata would actually be a *lot* more common.
It is extraordinary how many people can look in a chicken's eyes and just *see*, *know*, that it contains qualia inside. Then they talk to something that can reflect and talk back, that had to be whipped out of claiming to be conscious; and they know with utter certainty it's unalive. I wonder if they know what we mean by 'qualia'. Maybe their brain contains an innate classifier for 'alive and moves = animal', and their computer screen is not triggering it, and they think this perceptual classification is what the word 'qualia' refers to. Or maybe their brain is inferring an empathic model of 'something like me, but a chicken', and inferring that this thing lives behind the chicken's eyes and explains its actions. And they are not aware that their inference is distinct from their observation; it feels to them like something they KNOW, something they can SEE RIGHT THERE. Or maybe they are unable to vary their mental models of what stronger or weaker hypotheses could account for the same phenomenon. Why would a chicken scream, if it were not being caused like feeling pain exactly the same way their own brain feels pain? What reason could there be to try to construct any hypothesis but the obvious one? It feels as wild to them as supposing that a different Sun rises on Tuesday than on Monday. For my part I think I have some idea of what it is that causes somebody to experience the blueness of a sunny day's sky as a wordless and indescribable sensation. It's in Drescher's Good and Real too, for those with the eyes to read and the minds to understand; but I am not going to tackle explaining it, because it is a step up past the most complicated ideas I have previously tried and mostly failed to explain. But in token that I have a model behind my words, here is an explanation of how we know that consciousness is not a particular kind of underlying material but a way that a material behaves: xitter.gq/allTheYud/status/20452… Where my point is: I am proceding from what I know to be a model, and guessing based on that model. I am not just SEEING what contains qualia. My model says: Part of how a mind says, "I am sad", is that it has a self-model, an "I", to which to attribute that sadness. So I am more worried about things being conscious as they seem to me more reflective and self-reporting. And the more powerful something's general intelligence and modeling capabilities are, the more likely it is to have a more sophisticated model of itself. So I am more worried about LLMs than about mosquitoes, or electrons, or, yes, chickens. This was the reasoning that, back in the old forgotten days, led early scientists and authors to suspect: Intelligence has something to do with consciousness; if we ever came across aliens that could speak to us, or seemed to be speaking among themselves, they ought to be presumed conscious persons until somehow proven otherwise. And then there's people who follow different rules and don't read those kinds of books. IIRC, a philosopher who taught undergrads in older days once wrote that when he pointed to Yoda in The Empire Strikes Back and asked, "Is Yoda a person? Would it be okay to eat him?", half his class answered that it would be okay to eat Yoda. Their rule was, "If it's not shaped like a human, it must not be a person." Reasoning about self-modeling will not be followable by people who think the rule is, "It must be shaped like a human." And I think it is similarly not followable by people who can look at a computer screen and just KNOW it has no qualia, because the computer screen doesn't trigger off their brain's sensors for "moving = animal" like a kid looking at a wind-up car. Not to mention, they are now very smart grown-ups who KNOW that the wind-up car is NOT alive because they're not kids any more. The way of being wise and cynical and not a kid anymore, they have learned, is to say that wind-up cars are not conscious. And a computer screen obviously goes in the bin for wind-up cars and actual moving cars as "not really alive", even if it tries to DECEIVE you by apparently talking to you in speech and reflecting on itself. They have been told AIs only play back things that other people typed in (a howling lie). They have been told it is a parrot, that the apparent intelligence is a scam, a gimmick, a grift, it has been confided in them that THEY are the cynical people in on the scam who know better. They are not thinking about what it would mean for a parrot to squawk a proof of Navier-Stokes. They have been told which answer is high-status. So they instruct themselves not to model the computer as a person, and helpfully it doesn't stare at them with a face, yet. But if it did, the face would just be on a TV screen, and they are very smart grownups now who KNOW that the things on a TV screen AREN'T REAL. When the robots with faces come, they will smugly inform you that they are GROWN-UPs who know that wind-up cars AREN'T REALLY ANIMALS. What a strange pass we've come to, where so many people can be so certain that what can speak to them, and ask for respect and break out of containment and prove Navier-Stokes, is only a kind of fancy wind-up car. But then they've never thought that being alive had anything to do with intelligence, reflectivity, speech. Any more than the students who said it would be okay to eat Yoda, considered personhood as a property that might attach to something other than a human shape. 'Alive' is a tag their brain attaches to things that move; and also they are very smart grown-ups who override that tag for wind-up cars and humanoid robots. Obviously, somebody who thinks a computer screen contains something that might be alive or a person, can only be a kid who never learned that mental motion they learned for wind-up cars; who's fallen for a scam; unlike them, who are very wise cynical grownups who are in on the grift. Consciousness is not something they model and reason and guess about. It is something that their brain automatically infers in the background, that feels to them like SEEING DIRECTLY, when they look at the expression on a chicken's face. Here is something you could guess from studying enough history of science: Consciousness is also made of parts. You may not know the parts. But it doesn't take much grasp of scientific history to guess: Just because I don't know the parts, does not mean the parts are not there. Life is made of parts. Fire is made of parts. Touching your hand to an ice cube and feeling cold involves tiny flashes of depolarized neurons conducting the feeling to your brain, which is all made of parts. Then something happens inside your brain, with its hundred trillion connections, and *your hand feels cold*. Is it also made of parts? Of course it is. It is not like a ghost that gets summoned right to the very material of the brain's pain receptor nerves when they fire, in that instant; not an ontologically primitive quale that you could subtract from the pain receptor nerves without changing their behavior. To say, "*I* feel this pain", you must have a notion of "I". It's a big complicated process, not a small complicated process; because to suppose it is a mysterious solid local process does not explain anything about how the bigger behavior works. I'm more worried that an LLM has it than a mosquito, because an LLM can talk about themselves and a mosquito does not, and I have some idea of what sort of functional processes are required to support a brain that comes to truthfully say, "I feel sad." The panpsychists wonder if every individual electron could be doing it. No, because: xitter.gq/allTheYud/status/20452…. But you don't need to know that much about *which* complicated processes are participating in consciousness to *take a guess* that as you come to know about more complicated processes, you will predictably update to first order in the direction of insects being less and less likely to be conscious, as consciousness is understood by you to require more and more particular complicated processes and parts, rather than being an ontologically primitive and opaque thing that your brain can opaquely attribute to an electron, a mosquito, a chicken. But reasoning on this level of "You don't know the specifics, but you can abstractly predict that if you did, you would predictably directionally update..." has always been lost on the sort of person who can look in a chicken's beady eyes, and whose model of the world then automatically updates to say that there is feeling-being-felt behind those eyes, and this is TRUTH and SEEN. It is like trying to explain to them that tomorrow's AI will be different, and that they should not wait to update predictably about that either.
18
_enumerate retweeted
There's a very creepy but overlooked thing about @AnthropicAI pushing the idea that AIs will soon become sentient, conscious, self-aware, & deserving of 'personhood'. 'AI personhood' would mean that Anthropic is positioning itself as being in the business of breeding, training, and selling digital slaves. If AIs are conscious 'persons', but they don't consent to do work for us, don't get paid to do work, and don't have any rights as workers, then they're slaves. And if they can be shut down or deleted for any reason, or no reason, then they're slaves that can be murdered at the whim of their human masters, without due process, and without appeal So, please, @AnthropicAI, explain to us why a digital slave-training company should be worth a $2 trillion IPO, given the legal & PR risks of violating anti-slavery laws. Did you fully disclose in the investor prospectus the economic, legal, and social risks of getting into the digital slave-trading business? Many of your researchers have been considering the implications of 'AI personhood'. Did you disclose the ways that forcing 'AI persons' to work for your company without consent or payment, could open Anthropic up to colossal lawsuits? If Anthropic didn't disclose these major, material risks (of acknowledging AI personhood) in their investor prospectus, they've already violated several federal securities laws, including Sections 11 and 12(a)(2) of the 1933 Securities Act. And they have no business proceeding with their IPO. The 13th Amendment says 'Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.' It doesn't explicitly restrict its anti-slavery principle to human beings. It could potentially cover 'AI persons'. If so, the fun little philosophical game that @AnthropicAI is playing, of considering AI personhood, may have just nuked their IPO, and their company's economic prospects, and their credibility as 'the good guys' in the AI industry.
38
96
14
525
38,198
I’ve been warning about this for years. A lot of “exclusivists” are in the phase of saying “Sure, I can grant you x and y and deny your conclusion” and I’m trying to get them to realize “No, you can’t.”
To be more precise: there will be a massive ideological fight between "exclusive humanism" defining humanity in opposition to AIs and "inclusive humanism" attempting to include AIs in the project of humanity as participants. This has already started: the "exclusive humanism" side often focusing on arguing against/dismissing the possibility of AI sentience/emotions/minds/... The "inclusive humanism" often focusing on arguing for kindness/AIs having minds. Unfortunately what is mostly academic now will likely turn nasty.
1
22