Luciano (@highhistiorian) header
Luciano (@highhistiorian) profile picture

no I will not buy your content, not because I’m poor, more that it’s not worth it you block = I win

Joined March 2021
Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)Photo by Luciano (@highhistiorian)
Replying to @blacktwiterthrd
How hard is it for white people not to be racist
30
38
3
1,556
19,411
Luciano retweeted
Republican Congressman Andy Harris gets laughed at after blaming high diesel prices on Democrats.
736
5,511
753
98,363
2,287,450
Luciano retweeted
🚨 MAGA influencer Bryce Hall has been arrested for domestic violence.
91
633
37
3,691
37,525
This pic goes insanely hard man
Production Stills From The Return of Godzilla (1984)
5
168
3
1,719
13,088
Jay Z documentary flopped
68
311
26
4,389
83,779
8 years ago today, Snoop Dogg amplified the Kanye West vs. Drake beef claiming “In My Feelings” was about Kim Kardashian 😳 (2018) “I just found out who Kiki was! Kiki is your b*tch! That’s why you’re so mad, ‘cuz Drake put d*ck in your b*tch!” “He f*cked Kiki down didn’t he? Good sh*t, Drake! Did you pour champagne on her?”
15
29
3
420
24,000
Everyone missed Shane Gillis’ commentary on the raiders of the Anglo-Scottish Border…
3
15
129
2,122
A popular credit card thief, Rah Ali, also known as She-Hulk, has now hired Abdul Jemilu, the disgraced figure behind R£d Media, as a staff writer for the failed Onsite! Media. Birds of a feather flock together. Hopefully, she has enough credit cards to swipe to keep him on the payroll.
41
221
9
1,781
55,263
Luciano retweeted
This quoted post is unavailable.
92
1,447
14
53,805
1,024,283
So what did Rommel really know, and did he deserve to die for it? The honest answer is that historians have argued about it for eighty years and still cannot fully agree, because the evidence is thin, tangled, and mostly comes from people with reasons to shade the truth. But you can lay out what we have, and a picture emerges that is messier and more human than either the hero myth or the traitor charge. Start with what seems reasonably solid. Rommel almost certainly knew that something was brewing. Several of the conspirators were close to him, above all his own chief of staff in Normandy, Hans Speidel, who was genuinely in the plot and who had been quietly tasked by the resistance with sounding Rommel out and bringing him over. Men like Stülpnagel, the military governor of France, and Caesar von Hofacker moved in the same circle, and at least one prewar account says a group including the Stuttgart mayor Strölin approached Rommel early in 1944 and came away believing he had agreed to support the resistance. So Rommel was not a man in the dark. The conspirators were circling him, talking to him, and counting on him. In fact many of them were counting on him specifically, because Rommel was the one general with enough prestige, at home and with the enemy, to give a post-Hitler government legitimacy and to negotiate a peace in the West. His bad luck, being badly wounded when his car was strafed on the 17th of July, three days before the bomb, is considered by many historians a real blow to the plotters, who had hoped to lean on him. Now the harder question: what did he actually agree to? Here it splits. There is a striking piece of evidence from British intelligence, which secretly recorded German generals in captivity. In one of these recordings, General Eberbach remembered Rommel telling him, about a month before his death, that Hitler and the men around him had to be killed, that it was the only way out for Germany. If Rommel really said that, it goes a long way past passive knowledge. But against it stands the careful reading of what he said to the plotters themselves. When Speidel and Hofacker felt him out, the clearest thing Rommel seems to have committed to was a willingness to seek a separate peace with the Western Allies, to end the war in the West. Hofacker then reported that as support for the plot, but that may have been Hofacker hearing what he wanted to hear. There is a persistent strand in the sources, though not a fully proven one, that Rommel wanted Hitler arrested and put on trial, not assassinated, that he thought killing him would make a martyr and spark civil war. Whether that is the real Rommel or a later softening of his image is one of the things historians genuinely cannot settle. So the spectrum of serious opinion runs like this. At one end, historians like Joachim Fest conclude the plotters never actually won Rommel over, that he wanted peace in the West but was not really a man of the resistance and not an enemy of the regime. At the other, scholars who weight the Eberbach recording and the testimony of surviving conspirators argue he knew and broadly supported the effort to be rid of Hitler. A revisionist like Reuth goes further the other way and paints him as a self-serving figure who neither truly knew nor backed the plot. The fairest summary is the one the field keeps landing on: Rommel is an ambiguous figure, not cleanly a traitor and not cleanly a hero, a man who had lost his faith in Hitler and wanted the war ended, who was on the edges of the conspiracy and sympathetic to its goal, but whose exact commitments we cannot nail down. Was he guilty, then, in the way the regime claimed? By the standard of a fair trial, the case against him would have been shaky, built on the tortured confessions and desperate mutterings of other men. Stülpnagel, after a botched suicide attempt, reportedly murmured Rommel's name; Hofacker, under Gestapo torture, named him. That is the kind of evidence extracted by pain that no honest court would hang a man on. But the regime was not interested in proof. It was interested in the fact that its most famous soldier had, at the least, lost faith and consorted with traitors, and that was intolerable. And did he deserve his punishment? Set aside that the whole apparatus judging him, Hitler's Reich, the People's Court, the Gestapo, had no moral standing to judge anyone, being itself the greatest criminal enterprise of the age. On its own terms the regime murdered him, and did it in a uniquely cowardly way, too frightened of his legend to try him openly, so it sent two generals with a vial of poison and threatened his wife and teenage son to make him swallow it. Whatever Rommel was, he was given no trial, no chance to answer, only a forced suicide and a staged hero's funeral to keep the public from knowing. Here is the deeper irony, and the reason the question never fully resolves. For most of his career Rommel was Hitler's favorite general, a man who owed his meteoric rise to the Führer, who was used relentlessly by the propaganda machine, who was no part of any resistance while he was winning. He turned toward the idea of ending the war only when he had seen, in the desert and in Normandy, that it was lost and that Hitler was leading Germany to ruin. That is not the same as having been a good man all along, and it is why the clean hero myth that grew up around him after the war, the "good German" general with clean hands, is itself now heavily disputed. But it is also not nothing. In a regime where almost no one at the top ever broke, Rommel did come, late and cautiously, to the view that Hitler had to go. So the truest thing you can say is this. He probably knew. He probably sympathized with getting rid of Hitler, maybe even with killing him, maybe only with arresting him; the evidence genuinely will not decide it. He was guilty of disloyalty to a monstrous regime, which is to say guilty of the one thing that, in 1944, might actually count to his credit. And he was murdered for it without trial, by a government that feared his name more than it feared the truth. Whether that was a punishment deserved depends entirely on whose court you are standing in, and the one that condemned him was the least qualified in history to pass the sentence.
October 14, 1944. Two generals arrive at the country house where Germany's most famous soldier is recovering from his wounds, carrying a vial of poison and an ultimatum. Field Marshal Erwin Rommel, the Desert Fox, the one commander the enemy admired as much as Germans did, is given a choice: swallow the poison and die a hero with his family safe, or face the People's Court and drag them down with him. He chooses the poison. It is one of the strangest and most revealing deaths of the whole war. Rommel had been the great star of the German army, the dashing panzer leader of the fall of France, and above all the legend of the desert, the general I told you about at El Alamein, who had run the British ragged across North Africa and earned a reputation for brilliance and chivalry that crossed the front lines. Later he had commanded the defenses of Normandy against the invasion. He was a hero to the German public and a figure of genuine respect to his enemies. But Rommel had become entangled, at least on its fringes, with the conspiracy against Hitler, the July 20 plot I told you about over the summer, the attempt by army officers to kill Hitler and end the war. How deeply Rommel was involved is still debated; it seems he knew of the plot and sympathized with the aim of getting rid of Hitler and making peace, though he may have opposed assassination. He had been badly wounded in July when his staff car was shot up by Allied aircraft, and was recovering at home. But as the Gestapo tortured its way through the conspirators, Rommel's name came up. Hitler faced a problem. He could not simply put the nation's most beloved soldier on trial for treason and execute him; the blow to morale would be devastating, and the legend was too big. So he offered a bargain through the two generals he sent. If Rommel took poison, his death would be announced as the result of his war wounds, he would be given a hero's state funeral, and his wife and son would be left alone and provided for. If he refused, he would be arrested, tried before the notorious People's Court, and his family would suffer. Rommel understood exactly what it meant. He said goodbye to his wife and his fifteen-year-old son, told them what was about to happen, put on his uniform, and got into the car with the two generals. A short drive away, he took the poison. Within minutes the Desert Fox was dead. The regime played its part of the bargain. It was announced that Field Marshal Rommel had died of his wounds, and he was given a grand state funeral with full honors, Hitler sending a message of condolence, the public mourning a fallen hero with no idea their government had just murdered him. The truth, that he had been forced to kill himself to save his family, came out only after the war. It is a story that captures the nature of the regime in its final year, devouring even its own greatest heroes, so afraid of the truth and so vengeful toward any whiff of disloyalty that it staged the suicide of the Desert Fox and dressed it up as a soldier's death. Rommel's reputation, complicated as the real history is, largely survived, precisely because he died this way, half victim, half legend, poisoned in the back of a car on a quiet road on the 14th of October.
5
10
112
14,644
Me Gusta Face Montage (2010)
1
6
1,242
5
73
3
968
7,666
The Trump administration is delaying the release of data showing how Republicans’ 2025 tax cuts affected millions of Americans’ taxes. While Republicans repeatedly claim their major tax bill helped most Americans, the data that would confirm that claim was scheduled to be released in July, and then updated again in September. But the agency hasn’t published any of it, according to Politico.
6
271
9
1,245
25,019
get that young man’s ass out my face pls
Chrisean keeps doing Blueface’s hair but has had her own hair in a bun since arriving at his house 😭
321
1,853
118
33,304
537,948
Luciano retweeted
As much as I hate that Manon got kicked out I’m also glad asf Katseye can’t make a good song to save their life and Manon’s name is no longer tied to the nonsense
7
89
1
893
5,443
Luciano retweeted
D'Angelo passed away a year ago today.
114
1,644
357
17,255
312,669
Each 2020s breakout girl's 20th most streamed song on Spotify
1
3
12
860
Deborah Gardner, a 23-year-old American Peace Corps volunteer, is murdered by another volunteer, Dennis Priven, on the Polynesian island of Tonga. Priven had apparently asked Gardner on a date several times and became infuriated when she refused his advances. He is now in custody.
2
13
1
191
9,219
Columbus died in 1505 at the age of 55. He was such a monster that the king and queen of Spain refused to invite him to the kingdom after his voyage to the Americas because of how evil he was during his financed expedition. Word spread fast about how he and his men raped and tortured and murdered the indigenous people in the Caribbean islands. He became a pariah. He had to flee Genova (Italy) because he raped a 13 year old girl and hid in Spain, where he was broke and bedridden and finally died while his relatives shunned him from the public due to the unthinkable acts he did while at sea. When he died, he was never recognized as an explorer or discoverer of a new world. He was thought of as a “gross character with Gonorrhea, who butchered kids.” Many Years later, when Settlers were colonizing North America, they needed a white hero to name as the person who discovered the land to justify their colonization and mistreatment of Native Americans. they randomly chose Christofo Colombo because his name had “Christ” in it, and to make it sound more European and Christian, they changed his name to Christopher Columbus, even though he never stepped foot on American soil. Then schools started teaching it. And the rest is history. But the truth is he never discovered anything. He was lost and ended up in a chain of islands. He thought he was in India. He massacred peaceful island civilizations. He murdered men, women, and kids. He tortured and raped. He brought new diseases to each island he invaded. Giving this monster a holiday is insane. We know better. And now we do better. Happy indigenous People’s Day. #FuckColumbus
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Columbus died May 20 1506 in Spain retaining wealth and family support not as a broke shunned pariah after raping a 13-year-old or dying with gonorrhea. His name Cristóbal Colón was anglicized naturally not randomly changed by settlers for "Christ." britannica.com/biography/Chri… history.com/this-day-in-hi… thoughtco.com/how-did-colon-…
679
2,858
129
9,079
505,981