
Author of 'Mahabharata 3136 BCE: Validation of the Traditional Date' Write to [email protected] to get my books https://xitter.gq/t.co/0UEcqru0yw
India
Joined April 2011
- Tweets39.5K
- Following569
- Followers11.1K
- Likes15.6K
Pinned Tweet
Did Vālmīki ever say that the Rāma Setu ran north–south?
There are only two relevant references to the southern shore (dakṣiṇaṃ tīram / dakṣiṇaṃ pāram):
Sampāti tells the vānaras to proceed to the southern shore.
On reaching the seacoast, Rāma wonders how they can cross the ocean and reach the southern shore.
That is all.
Yet, interpreting the ancient geography through the lens of modern coastal orientations, researchers have often looked past the Rāma Setu, which runs broadly east–west, and shifted the search for Laṅkā and the Setu to locations far to the south—even towards the equatorial region or Gujarat.
But have they transported themselves to Vālmīki's geographical world? No.
Now, important scientific research is providing another perspective.
Bathymetric research of the Palk Strait by Dubey et al. indicates that the Palk region was not simply an open extension of the Bay of Bengal. It contained a vast freshwater reservoir, about 35 m deep and ~15,000 sq. km in extent, bounded by Rāmeśvaram, Pāmban, intervening shallow stretches of land and Talaimannar.
Those shallow stretches are significant. According to the research, people could have used this region as a causeway until around 7,000 years ago, before a sudden rise in sea level inundated its boundaries.
Now reconsider Vālmīki's words.
When Sampāti speaks of the southern shore, why assume he meant some distant southern coastline? The southern boundary of this Palk reservoir provides a much more immediate geographical meaning.
The vānaras, led by Aṅgada, had already traversed the coastal region. The southern shore offered the shortest practical route towards Rāvaṇa's Laṅkā in southern Sri Lanka.
When they reached Rāmeśvaram, however, the ancient pathway was no longer completely above water. Hence Rāma's question: How are we to cross the ocean and reach the southern shore?
The solution was the Setu.
And setu means a bund, embankment, causeway or structure enabling passage across water.
In this interpretation, Rāma was not constructing an imaginary bridge across the entire sea. He was strengthening or raising the shallow, partially submerged causeway across the Palk reservoir so that the vānaras could cross.
This also gives us a potential chronological marker.
If the scientific evidence indicates that the southern boundary of this ancient freshwater reservoir was inundated around 7,000 years ago, it provides an important environmental clue for dating the Rāma episode.
The point is not to force modern geography upon Vālmīki.
It is precisely the opposite:
Let Vālmīki's words lead us to the ancient geography—and then see whether geology and bathymetry support it.
More such evidence is discussed in my book Ramayana 5114 BCE: Decoding the Date and Myths.
Study the Bharateeya past through its own texts, geography and scientific evidence.
Our history deserves investigation—not dismissal.
#Ramayana_5114BCE
The last paragraph forms the very core of the Rāmāyaṇa as a work of Bhakti.
The Rāmāyaṇa is fundamentally about the relationship between Paramātma and Jīvātma, and their eventual reunion after the Jīvātma gets lost in Samsāra. Rāma represents Paramātma and Sītā represents Jīvātma, whom Paramātma loses in the forest of Samsāra. Yet, Paramātma does not abandon the Jīvātma. He pursues it, searches for it and ultimately brings it back to its rightful abode. This is precisely what Rāma does for Sītā.
The Jīvātma, too, has the power (Shakti) to liberate itself from Samsāra. Sītā demonstrated this very capacity. She could have freed herself by her own power, but she chose not to. Our ancient Āchāryas explained that relinquishing one's Swa-Shakti, surrendering the belief that one can secure one's own liberation, is an essential aspect of the Jīvātma's surrender to Paramātma.
This is beautifully brought out in Sundara Kāṇḍa, when Sītā speaks to Hanumān. She refuses his offer to carry her back to Rāma. She also refuses to exercise her own extraordinary power to escape. She wants Rāma himself to come and release her from her bondage. She sets aside her Swa-Shakti and waits, with her entire being immersed in thoughts of Rāma.
That is precisely what is expected of us, the Jīvātmas lost in Samsāra. We must remain immersed in thoughts of Him, with unwavering Bhakti. Bhakti is like an unbroken stream of oil flowing from one vessel to another. It is Paramātma's responsibility to seek out the surrendered Jīvātma and bring it back to Him.
This is the spiritual essence of the Rāmāyaṇa. It is, at its very core, a work of Bhakti.
Now, what does Namit Malhotra's Rāmāyaṇa show us?
Sītā runs ahead of Rāma to confront the 14,000 demons of Janasthāna. She rushes with a weapon to protect (!) Rāma when she hears Mārīcha's cries as the golden deer. These are not minor cinematic liberties. They turn the very philosophy of the Rāmāyaṇa upside down. The Sītā who is meant to embody the Jīvātma's surrender to Paramātma is portrayed as someone who takes matters into her own hands, even assuming the role of Rāma's protector.
Now perhaps people will understand why I am so vehemently opposed to this movie. It does not merely deviate from a few episodes of Vālmīki's Rāmāyaṇa. It undermines its very core theme.
Without Bhakti, one should not touch the Rāmāyaṇa.
There are people who question or disagree with the date I have established for the Rāmāyaṇa, accusing me of committing apachāra. But neither that date nor my book emerged in isolation from devotion. It was my devotion that led me to explore and uncover portions of the Rāmāyaṇa that had remained untouched or inadequately examined. Those who have read my book will understand what I mean.
Coming back to those verses I referred to, they are reproduced in my blog. jayasreesaranathan.blogspot.…
They are exceedingly dear to me. I recite them every day, waiting for Rāma and Lakṣmaṇa to appear before me, just as Sītā waited for Rāma.
The serious illness I have endured over the last few years has, in its own way, brought me closer to this state of surrender. Thoughts of Him, sustained by the daily recitation of those verses, have taken away my fear of death. I do not fear death. I only wait for that blessed moment when I may behold Rāma and Lakṣmaṇa.
The Rāmāyaṇa is not merely a book to be researched, dated, interpreted or debated. It is a path of surrender, a means of Bhakti, and ultimately, a lifelong wait for Him.
Jai Śrī Rām!
#Ramayana #RamayanaMovie @malhotra_namit
See next tweet below.
I have spoken about the core theme of the Ramayana - the relationship between the Paramatma and the Jivatma in my interview to a Tamil channel.
youtu.be/3EPZDLxGEos?si=5NyI…
1
161
Jayasree Saranathan retweeted
Blessed to read ...
Tnx @jayasartn ji
Apparently, the Gandhi household had its own dining customs—perhaps even the furniture was different!
Ravana never wanted Rama to find him out. He was scared when Rama landed in Lanka.
Replying to @jayasartn
It's conveying that I want Ram to come let him come as he is Vishnu and I will take my revenge
Jayasree Saranathan retweeted
Replying to @jayasartn
Now Namit bots will write paragraphs on this scene
Calling it subtle acting
Creative choice to appeal Western audience
& Mock us for calling out this Ravanayana
Regarding (b), where is the evidence of Ravana's arrogance or menace in that shot? He calmly picks up Sita’s anklet, almost as though he is admiring a souvenir! Valmiki's Ravana was an abductor consumed by lust and arrogance, not a composed gentleman displaying psychological warfare. In fact such a scene comes in Lanka when Ravana shows the illusory head of Rama to Sita to convey that Rana was killed. I doubt the director has the guts to show that scene in Part - 2.
Replying to @jayasartn
a) The movie is clear: it is
"Namit Malhotra's Ramayana",
not Valmiki's.
b) To me, it conveyed Ravana communicating his fearlessness, of anyone who might come to save Sita. It was a power move, to break her confidence, to have no hope of rescue.
This is the only scene of direct confrontation between Ravana and Sita in Namit Malhotra’s Ramayana, and it takes place inside the Pushpaka Vimana.
Look at Ravana’s face. Is there any sign of lust or anger? He appears utterly nonchalant as he picks up Sita’s anklet from the floor and tears it apart, piece by piece, while looking at her.
The Valmiki Ramayana gives a different account. While struggling to escape Ravana, one of Sita’s anklets slipped off and fell to the ground. She tied the other anklet along with her jewels in a piece of her upper garment and dropped the bundle towards the five Vanaras—Sugreeva, Hanuman, Nila, Nala and Tara—whom she spotted on Rishyamuka Parvata.
The movie neither shows the bundle being thrown nor explains how the anklet came to be on the floor of the Pushpaka Vimana. Sita is merely shown removing some jewellery.
So what exactly is the director trying to convey by showing Ravana casually picking up and tearing Sita’s anklet while gazing at her without any apparent emotion?
What is the intended meaning of this scene? Can anyone explain?
#RamayanaMovie
Shame 😭 Ravanayan is being promoted as Ramayan.
@MIB_India @EduMinOfIndia @MinOfCultureGoI @narendramodi @AmitShah @dushyanthsridar
Replying to @RajivMessage @ExposeDhonifan
Yes, confirmed. Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana (Ranbir Kapoor as Rama, Yash as Ravana, Sai Pallavi as Sita) is scheduled to open the BRICS cinema segment at the 57th IFFI in Goa, 20-28 November 2026.
Multiple outlets including Variety, ANI and Indian media report the official announcement by Goa CM Pramod Sawant and festival director Ashutosh Gowariker. IFFI is run by the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting.
The following account of Rama and Sita’s wedding was prepared by my ten-year-old granddaughter, strictly based on the Valmiki Ramayana. What is interesting is how different the description is from the wedding scenes we are accustomed to seeing.
According to the Valmiki Ramayana, the central features of the wedding included the tying of auspicious sacred threads on the wrists of the bride and groom by their respective families, followed by Dasharatha pouring water into Rama’s hands as part of the Kanyadana ceremony.
Now, think of how Namit Malhotra’s Ramayana depicts the wedding. Rama and Sita exchange garlands, a familiar feature of Hindu weddings today. However, this exchange of garlands is not mentioned in Valmiki’s account.
Panigrahana — the taking of the bride’s hand by the groom — was a central feature of marriage in those days. It is fascinating to see how wedding customs have evolved over time and how modern cinematic depictions sometimes reflect familiar contemporary practices rather than the details recorded in the original epic.
A ten-year-old's careful reading has thus brought out an interesting distinction between the ancient text and its modern visual interpretations!
#RamayanaMovie
youtube.com/watch?v=dJsOIpPp…
Namit Malhotra's Pushpaka vimana and Valmiki Ramayana's Pushpaka vimana: a comparison.
The lotus-shaped Puṣpaka Vimāna shown in Namit Malhotra's Ramayana is an artistic interpretation. It does not correspond to the description of the vehicle used by Rāvaṇa to abduct Sītā in Vālmīki's text. The golden wheels, horses, charioteer, parasol and other chariot features are conspicuously absent from that representation. Nor does the lotus-shaped design convey the elaborate, multi-storeyed architectural structure that Hanumān inspected in Laṅkā. The film's visualisation, therefore, should not be mistaken for Vālmīki's description of Puṣpaka.
In contrast the Rāmāyaṇa describes different forms of Puṣpaka Vimāna. The word Vimāna has several Sanskrit meanings, including palace, royal seat, temple tower and celestial vehicle. King Janaka refers to Kubera’s Puṣpaka as a royal seat (VR: 1-70-3), while Hanumān discovers an elaborate, multi-storeyed structure in Laṅkā (VR: 5-8; 5-9-14). This need not be the same as the vehicle Rāvaṇa used to abduct Sītā.
That vehicle was kept in a yānaśālā (vehicle shed) and had a charioteer (VR: 3-35-4). Vālmīki calls it an uttamaṃ ratham, an excellent chariot (VR: 3-35-5), and describes it as vimānam iva tam ratham — a chariot resembling a Vimāna (VR: 3-42-9).
It had golden wheels, a parasol and animals for pulling it. Rāma found evidence of horse hooves and chariot wheels (VR: 3-65-7). Rāvaṇa is also described as hata aśvo hata sārathiḥ, deprived of horses and charioteer (VR: 3-51-19).
Though it ascended into the sky during the abduction (VR: 3-53-1), its physical features unmistakably identify it as a remarkable wheeled all- terrain chariot which ran faster, as if flying in the air.
The attached pages are from my book 'Ramayana 5114 BCE'.
#RamayanaMovie
Here is a thread of 187 tweets on 'snippets from the Ramayana' based on the Valmiki Ramayana. Unknown facts are covered in this thread, which would be useful for people seeking true info after seeing Namit Malhotra's Ramayana.
#Ramayana
Starting today, a series of lesser-known and interesting snippets from the Ramayana will be tweeted everyday.
#Snippets from the Ramayana (1)
Rama's mother, Kausalya, kept a pet myna. On the night of exile, Rama lamented that the myna brought more joy to his mother than he, as her son, did.
Starting today, a series of lesser-known and interesting snippets from the Ramayana will be tweeted everyday.
#Snippets from the Ramayana (1)
Rama's mother, Kausalya, kept a pet myna. On the night of exile, Rama lamented that the myna brought more joy to his mother than he, as her son, did.
#Snippets from the Ramayana (181)
Vibhishana wasn't alone when he sought refuge in Rama's camp. He was accompanied by four loyal rakshasas, leaving behind his wife Sarama and daughters Anala and Trijata in Lanka. Vibhishana had taken a risk leaving his family behind, but his righteousness saved them from Ravana's wrath.
1
1
158
Jayasree Saranathan retweeted
Replying to @jayasartn @jsaideepak
Banning may not be possible.
BTW, they have nominated themselves for OSCAR
Least we can all do is to email the OSCAR team & let them know how we feel: that this is an aberration of our Sacred History.
Save image. Use QR scanner. Locate Image. Send. Simple!
#RamayanaMovie
#BanNamitMalhotraRamayana must be the slogan. Can't we move the court to ban the movie of Namit Malhotra's Ramayana, @jsaideepak ji?
Replying to @jayasartn @RGVzoomin
Cinematic liberty is a farce, majority of the people involved with this trade are puppets of an ecosystem driven by an anti-national propoganda mechanism. They're worse than barbarics. They're a blot to humanity. #BoycottRamayana Distorting historical facts is just one aspect.
My interview with a Tamil channel on the recently released Ramayana movie.
I discussed the many deviations from Valmiki’s original Ramayana, including the attempt to portray Ravana as a good person, the complete omission of Sita’s abduction scene—which would have exposed Ravana’s true character—and the imaginative additions to Jatayu’s episode.
I also highlighted the poor characterisation of Rama and Sita in the war sequences, which goes against the very spiritual essence of the Ramayana. Sita represents the Jīvātma, who does not rely on her own sva-shakti to liberate herself but awaits Rama, the Paramātma, to redeem her.
These are among the many distortions and departures from the original epic that I addressed in the interview.
Please watch, share and help bring the original Valmiki Ramayana into the discussion.
#RamayanaMovie
youtu.be/3EPZDLxGEos?si=iHZk…
On two occasions in the Valmiki Ramayana, Ravana himself refers to the curse that his head would shatter into pieces if he ever forced himself upon an unwilling woman. Yet, this curse did not take effect when he abducted Sita by force. The explanation lies in the power of his tapas and the fear he had instilled in the gods. The relevant pages from my book on why the curse didn't activate in Sita's abduction are attached.
Replying to @grok @MostlyKohli
But Ravana has a curse right?
If he touched any woman without her concern he will burn right away
Isn't this true? @grok
This video was created by my 10 year old granddaughter. Based on Valmiki Ramayana. Just compare this with Namith Malhotra's version.
Rama's Swayamvara: The Trial of the Divine Bow youtu.be/jwWK8whIBto?si=zTk8… via @YouTube
@praarabdh_in @anuradhasabha
Check the channel for other videos.





























