Pinned Tweet
Have a handful of new followers. In intro to all those who follow for psychotherapy content:
I’m a proudly pro-Israel, anti-Hamas Jew who believes in biological sex and the freedom for women to have single-sex spaces and for children to grow into their bodies into adulthood.
Dr. Mel retweeted
being able to conceive naturally, carry a child full term, give birth naturally, and bring a life into the world that’s healthy with no birth defects is an underrated blessing.
Dr. Mel retweeted
I received many comments about how brave I stood when @MyronGainesX called me a "Jew", and thank you all, but let's set the record straight. 'Jew' is not a dirty word! I am a Jew, a proud Jew. My grandparents didn't survive the Holocaust for me to be ashamed of my identity 🇮🇱✡️💪🏽
Dr. Mel retweeted
If someone invents a machine that makes food 50% cheaper and becomes a billionaire, society hasn't lost a billion dollars.
We've gained cheaper food.
The fact that someone got rich solving a problem doesn't mean the rest of us got poorer.
Wealth creation isn't theft.
Dr. Mel retweeted
BREAKING 🚨: Kmele Foster: “It's one thing to not think capitalism isn't working, ideally. It's another thing entirely to insist that it is oppressive, that it is bound up with white supremacy.”
Jemele Hill: “How is it not?”
Kmele Foster: “I've always preferred Adam Smith's description of capitalism as the natural system of liberty. The idea that people can own property, that they can exchange it freely with one another for profit, that they can find ways to put their resources to good use and profit in a way that is actually beneficial to everyone else, that there can be gains from trade that are mutually beneficial. These are foundational ideas that have created more wealth than any other system in human history. That is what capitalism is. That is not white supremacy.”
Jemele Hill: “Do you think capitalism has always worked that way?”
Kmele Foster: “I’ve actually just described the basic facts of the economics.”
Hill: “That ain't how it's always worked.”
Kmele Foster: “Slavery is an institution that is older than writing. It predates capitalism. The notion that white supremacy and all these other things are bound up with capitalism in an intrinsic and fundamental way is so absurd and laughable, it barely needs to be defended.”
Jemele Hill: “How was it absurd?”
Kmele Foster: “It barely needs to be defended.”
Jemele Hill: “What do you mean it barely needs to be defended?”
Kmele Foster: “You actually have to articulate what the connections is. How are these two things the same? I'm talking about private property, the right to exchange and sell with whomever you like. What does that have to do with white supremacy?… What is the white supremacy dynamic of private property?”
Therapy is a powerful tool with the capacity to be used with care and integrity as well as the capacity to be exploitive. We see vulnerable people in intimate circumstances. To deny therapy’s capacity for harm is dangerous, and to label all therapists exploitative is deceptive.
Jonathan Shedler is a psychoanalytic research scientist in addition to being a practicing psychoanalyst and educator.
He is uniquely qualified to speak on the scientific body of evidence for psychoanalysis.
Replying to @mellodynamic @NickTaber
Psychoanalysis is not science, which is fine, but therapists like him assert it like it is.
Not all psychologists share this “worldview” btw.
Therapy Twitter was engaged today. It was a good day.
And, with few exceptions, it was civil engagement even when we disagreed.
Lets have more of that!
PSA 🚨
Therapy cant fix every problem. Not even every psychological problem.
But it certainly cant fix any problems located outside of yourself.
If you dont accept that your own behaviors might contribute to your distress, dont choose therapy. Therapy is a change process.
I get the reflexive move away from believing that therapists see things that patients cant, but come on. No one can see their own face. A mirror is required for reflection.
Therapists reflect patterns and themes. But ultimately, those patterns need to resonate with the patient.
23
589
Pointing out patterns of repeated behavior is not like interpreting Mona Lisa’s smile. Its saying, “Hey, I notice you keep choosing unavailable men… can we be curious about that?”
The exploration that follows is subjective. But often it’s meaningful TO THE PATIENT.
Amazing how many people uncritically accept this. The therapist isn’t doing any of the things listed here in a literal sense because there is no objective truth here. There are interpretations. Like what the Mona Lisa means or what Jesus was trying to say. The problem is they aren’t aware that this is the nature of what they’re doing, they think it’s objective, and they have institutional expert power as though it is. That’s a great way to ruin people’s lives.
Great reminder why psychotherapy is extremely harmful so often and why pursuing other paths toward healing can be so wise.
Feeling hopeful today because people seem genuinely hungry for deeper understanding of the psychodynamic process and understanding. @JonathanShedler Is the OG of this kind of content. All is not lost.
3
56
1,940
I feel like its important to point out that therapists are just people. Strangers, in fact. We have no way of knowing, at least at first, that you are playing a role or trying to be pleasant. This takes time to notice and understand. Good therapy takes time.
1
32
1,326
If therapy is only understood through the content and not the process, it will often feel useless, and indeed be useless.
But theres a meaningful pattern emerging here. A desire to make things comfortable for others even at the expense of your own discomfort.
Worth exploring.
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
Dr. Mel retweeted
In just the past two weeks, the pro-Palestine movement tried to burn down my neighborhood synagogue and organized a boycott of Jewish-owned businesses in Philadelphia on the eve of Kristalnacht.
So please, spare me the “anti Zionism isn’t antisemitism” nonsense. Yes, it is.
















