
ALT Text: "Near the end of Enzo Paci’s “Towards a New Phenomenology”—a piece that attempts to find a way of thinking through the potentials of Husserl’s late work in relation to critical, Marxist theory in the service of developing the concept of ‘intersocialism’—we find the following curious remark: “Faced with this situation,” that is, the situation of having a mismatch between the ‘popular will’ and a state constitution which is meant to be a reflection of that will, “the popular will must once again perform an epoché and negate the abuse and the transformation of the constitution in a dictatorship” (Paci 1970, 76)."

ALT Text: "This is a surprisingly dense conjunction of philosophical traditions and concepts which pulls from Rousseau’s theory of the popular (or general) will, especially as this concept has been taken up in the Marxist tradition and in relation to revolutionary theory, alongside Husserl’s process of ‘bracketing,’ specifically, for Paci, as this concept is reworked in Husserl’s Crisis and in his late work more broadly. The problem is placed within the framework of a philosophical “negativity,” not in terms of the destruction of a previous state of affairs but as a teasing out of the potentials always left unrealized in any structured experience of the present."
![Text: "This point becomes more tangible when Paci, immediately after the quote above, goes on to associate this form of the phenomenological epoché with the political work of the Soviets, which “came into being when the Russian soldiers in the war asked themselves why they had to die, what was the meaning of the war and, consequently, [when] they re-questioned everything in a radical epoché, including the telos of life and history” (Paci 1970, 76). The idea that a social collective can perform a bracketing of the historical situation they find themselves in towards the end of the revolutionary transformation of society is key for understanding Paci’s emphasis on intersocialism, on the “new phenomenology” as a critical political project, and on the necessity of thinking through Husserl’s “psychological” phenomenology in conjunction with a Marxist critique of political economy (that is, of thinking through psychology and economics in tandem)."](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HXgi1snWkAAOKo4.png?name=small&format=webp)
ALT Text: "This point becomes more tangible when Paci, immediately after the quote above, goes on to associate this form of the phenomenological epoché with the political work of the Soviets, which “came into being when the Russian soldiers in the war asked themselves why they had to die, what was the meaning of the war and, consequently, [when] they re-questioned everything in a radical epoché, including the telos of life and history” (Paci 1970, 76). The idea that a social collective can perform a bracketing of the historical situation they find themselves in towards the end of the revolutionary transformation of society is key for understanding Paci’s emphasis on intersocialism, on the “new phenomenology” as a critical political project, and on the necessity of thinking through Husserl’s “psychological” phenomenology in conjunction with a Marxist critique of political economy (that is, of thinking through psychology and economics in tandem)."

ALT Text: "In this chapter, my intention is to interpret this statement from Paci. To do so, I will first provide an account of the general will by returning to Rousseau’s initial formulation in the Social Contract. By returning to Rousseau’s mature philosophy, I will be able to show that Paci is relying on him more than he indicates, thus providing a means of reading Paci’s own theory of will and need alongside Rousseau’s classic theory, and insisting on the fact that the two figures are more closely aligned than is generally noted. Then, I will move into an account of the “general” or generic character of Paci’s epoché, where the “general will” can roughly be equated with the “will of the people.”"

ALT Text: "I will claim that Paci’s work may best be understood through recent attempts to develop a ‘dialectical voluntarism’ (Hallward 2009) and through a specifically Maoist emphasis on the organizational strategy of the ‘mass line.’ The appeal to a theory of voluntarism will help explain how the disembodied ‘general will’ is able to do something like perform an epoché or determine the limits of a given social situation. Finally, I will briefly look at Paci’s theory of needs in relation to Rousseau’s own theory of such. In doing so, I hope to show that Paci’s account of needs is bound up with his statement about the generic epoché."

ALT Text: "In short, my argument is that the major concepts at play here (will, need, and ‘will of the people’) are necessary for making sense of Paci’s formulation of a ‘new phenomenology’ as a specifically socialist form of phenomenology that is internationalist in character (hence his focus on ‘intersocialism’) and which prioritizes an evaluation of the life-world alongside the traditional ‘economic’ analyses that are generally associated with the Marxist tradition. Although Paci’s statement about the generic epoché is short, my contention is that unpacking this form of the epoché enriches the understanding of Paci’s philosophy more broadly and thus serves as a helpful means of continuing to develop Paci’s thinking in the present and of thinking through Paci’s work in conjunction with contemporary philosophical concerns."

ALT Small section of text that ends before the sentence is completed. It reads: "This means that Paci’s theory of needs and its relationship to the will (including the general will) is essentially diachronic: the “new phenomenologist” is the one who determines, in line with the “dialectical voluntarism” discussed above, the current state..."

ALT Still image from Věra Chytilová's movie Daisies. The scene features the two main characters, Marie 1 and Marie 2, at a giant table filled with the remains of partially eaten food. They are covered in food as well, taking a kind of hedonistic pleasure at being covered in food waste without any care for the world around them. As the characters state at the beginning of the film, the world itself has become spoiled, so they decide to spoil themselves in turn—and this scene shows them at the height of this 'spoiling'.

ALT Excerpt from Kristeva's Powers of Horror: "Food loathing is perhaps the most elementary and most archaic form of abjection. When the eyes see or the lips touch that skin on the surface of milk—harmless, thin as a sheet of cigarette paper, pitiful as a nail paring—I experience a gagging sensation and, still farther down, spasms in the stomach, the belly; and all the organs shrivel up the body, provoke tears and bile, increase heartbeat, cause forehead and hands to perspire. Along with sight-clouding dizziness, *nausea* makes me balk at that milk cream, separates me from the mother and father who proffer it. “I” want none of that element, sign of their desire; “I” do not want to listen, “I” do not assimilate it, “I” expel it. But since the food is not an “other” for “me,” who am only in their desire, I expel *myself*, I spit *myself* out, I abject *myself* within the same motion through which “I” claim to establish *myself*"

ALT Andres Serrano's *Piss Christ* (1987), featuring a photograph of a plastic crucifix that has been submerged in the artist's own sickly, amber-colored urine.

ALT Another excerpt from Kristeva's Powers of Horror, from a section titled "The Horror Within". The excerpt reads: "The body’s inside, in that case, shows up in order to compensate for the collapse of the border between inside and outside. It is as if the skin, a fragile container, no longer guaranteed the integrity of one’s “own and clean self” but, scraped or transparent, invisible or taut, gave way before the dejection of its contents. Urine, blood, sperm, excrement then show up in order to reassure a subject that is lacking its “own and clean self.” The abjection of those flows from within suddenly become the sole “object” of sexual desire—a true “ab-ject” where man, frightened, crosses over the horrors of maternal bowels and, in an immersion that enables him to avoid coming face to face with an other, spares himself the risk of castration."

ALT A poem by Andrew Hudgins titled "Piss Christ" (2000). This is the first stanza (the rest of the poem is in the next photo), which reads: "If we did not know it was cow’s blood and urine, if we did not know that Serrano had for weeks hoarded his urine in a plastic vat, if we did not know the cross was gimcrack plastic, we would assume it was too beautiful. We would assume it was the resurrection, glory, Christ transformed to light by light because the blood and urine burn like a halo, and light, as always, light makes it beautiful."

ALT Hudgins's poem continued: "We are born between the urine and the feces, Augustine says, and so was Christ, if there was a Christ, skidding into this world as we do on a tide of blood and urine. Blood, feces, urine— what the fallen world is made of, and what we make. He peed, ejaculated, shat, wept, bled— bled under Pontius Pilate, and I assume the mutilated god, the criminal, humiliated god, voided himself on the cross and the blood and urine smeared his legs and he ascended bodily unto heaven, and on the third day he rose into glory, which is what we see here, the Piss Christ in glowing blood: the whole irreducible point of the faith, God thrown in human waste, submerged and shining. We have grown used to beauty without horror. We have grown used to useless beauty."








